prose Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 I would assume that your intention was SPECIFICALLY to NOT use the Lord's name in vain... So maybe He is even HAPPIER if you use word like Gosh because it shows others you are serious about not using His name in vain....
TheoGrad07 Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 [quote name='qfnol31' post='1443946' date='Jan 10 2008, 02:42 AM']I listened to a wonderful Protestant speaker talk about how gosh, darn, heck, shoot, and (this was added by a different Protestant) fudge are all said with the same intention and really mean the same thing. You can tell how they come from the same words. Anyways, I actually live by this and by not saying those, never cussing is really easy. And then I knew a Priest who told my friends in Confession to look up the words in their family's original language and use them to get out of cussing. And to answer the original question, I think to use "God forbid" wrongly would be taking His name in vain, though I think you could use it correctly. I think you could use it to describe a person's opinion pretty well, if you actually mean to say that he thinks God does forbid something...Sorry, I'll try to be clearer after a good night's rest. As far as the other words, I think their intention is often the same, which does make an action evil..........[/quote] I agree. I think substituting a "less offensive" word that sounds similar and is used it the manner of a swear word means one is swearing. While the language itself may be "less offensive," I still think the intention appears to be swearing, perhaps "mild swearing" rather than "offensive swearing." Crude language, language not used in the proper sense, should be avoided whether it is more or less offensive. A person who substitutes a "less offensive" word may not offend as gravely as one who uses the more offensive language, but it is still swearing.
goldenchild17 Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 (edited) [quote name='qfnol31' post='1444083' date='Jan 10 2008, 12:47 PM']How come cuss words are swearing?[/quote] I'm not sure they should be considered as such. "N.B. The words "cursing" and "swearing" admit of various meanings. By accusing themselves of these sins penitents sometimes mean a) profanity or the use of sacred names in anger against some creature (venial sin); b) blasphemy, the use of such names in anger against God or in contempt of Him (mortal sin); [b]c) abusive language, [u]which is not a sin against the second commandment [/u]but which may offend against charity or is a sin of anger."[/b] Moral Theology - Fr. Heribert Jone: section 190. In this context I think c would encompass many of the common cuss words. My opinion is that even the real cuss words are not that big of a deal if they are not words of holy import. They may be less refined and profane (hence: profanity), but if used when not in a state of anger or in a place where another might be scandalized, is not a sin at all. To me, these words are just words, unless a malicious intent is placed upon them. Edited January 10, 2008 by goldenchild17
TheoGrad07 Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 [quote name='prose' post='1444101' date='Jan 10 2008, 03:17 PM']I would assume that your intention was SPECIFICALLY to NOT use the Lord's name in vain... So maybe He is even HAPPIER if you use word like Gosh because it shows others you are serious about not using His name in vain....[/quote] Well, He may be "less upset" but I wouldn't say "happier" ... I think not sinning at all shows greater love for God than committing little sins instead of big ones. If words are used as "mild" replacements for the original word, it's a lesser failing, not a virtue. Such expletives, mild or otherwise, are not necessary.
goldenchild17 Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 I think the question is if some words are sins at all. I would say something like OMG is probably sinful to a degree, but are other words which have no sacred affiliation sinful if not used out of anger or cause scandal? I'm open to the contrary, but for now I would have to say that they're not. In which case I don't see why would be either happy or sad about a word that has no intention either way, good or bad.
qfnol31 Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 [quote name='prose' post='1444101' date='Jan 10 2008, 02:17 PM']I would assume that your intention was SPECIFICALLY to NOT use the Lord's name in vain... So maybe He is even HAPPIER if you use word like Gosh because it shows others you are serious about not using His name in vain....[/quote] I would agree that context makes a big difference. Last week at work, a homeless man in the bathroom was cussing up a storm and a boy about 3 years old (with his dad) walks in. The first man continued his vulgarity. Would it had made a difference if he had used the words I mentioned above? Absolutely! Context can change the nature of an act. Saying something vulgar (in my opinion) is much worse in front of a child. Of course, I would argue it's wrong anytime, just worse at other times. However, intention can make a big difference. If a person uses "gosh" merely to avoid God's name, but perhaps thinks God or intends gosh the same way as God, then he is following the letter of the law without the spirit of the law. If the intention is still the same, then the act is in my opinion still evil, even if not to as great a degree. As for your last question, if I may use hyperbole to respond. A man was wronged by his brother. He decided to stab his brother to death. Right before he sticks the knife in he decides to just hurt him bad. Now, granted, the act is completely different. It's not nearly as bad, but would you say that because he didn't kill his brother the act was now a good act? I don't mean to sound harsh or scrupulous about gosh, and can't remember telling anyone not to use the way I would when someone says "God" out of context, other than a recommendation on how not to use "God" wrongly. I just wanted to illustrate that just because a person isn't doing the worst possible thing doesn't mean he isn't doing something wrong. The flip side of this is I don't know if I would say using gosh is wrong.
Ash Wednesday Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 My personal favorite is [size=5][b]"BOB SAGET!"[/b][/size]
allis-challmers Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 [quote]The answer is yes if the comment is not a prayer. The meaning of Vain is "having no real value". If the comment is not a prayer and directed to God, it would be taking the Lord's name in vain. Because it would have no real value it would be vain. This post has been edited by KnightofChrist: Jan 5 2008, 05:34 P[/quote] I recently listened to a cd that said that the offhanded way that we use god's name is a direct violation of the second commandment. In the old testoment you would have been stoned for using the expression Oh My God. the only time that you should use the lords name is when you mean to
prose Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 I think swearing is really black and white. You have sworn or you haven't. But that is just me.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now