prose Posted February 6, 2008 Posted February 6, 2008 I remember when purgatory was taught to be like standing on the edge of Hell. That the suffering and torment were horrific. I remember one priest during a homily saying it was more than the worst pain we would have on earth because we couldn't turn our brains off in purgatory. We won't pass out from pain. We are forced to endure it. Pain. Suffering. Torture. Tongues burnt. Eyes pierced. Purified like silver in fire. Now, the rare time I hear about purgatory, it sounds almost pleasant. Like a "place of purification". Like we know we are going to heaven, so any pain that may be involved it not so bad. That it is simply another step on our faith journey. Like it is the runway to our takeoff. Now, have theologians changed their opinion on purgatory? Has the Church began to water it down for some reason? What are your opinions about this??
HeavenlyCalling Posted February 6, 2008 Posted February 6, 2008 I have always imagined that purgatory would be horribly painful because you are separated from God. I believe the Church has and continues to define it as a "pain of the senses" I dont really know what that means, to be honest, but there is hope because you know you will go to heaven. So there is some relief there. Hope it helps
Lil Red Posted February 6, 2008 Posted February 6, 2008 i still think of it as a place of purification, but i don't think of it as torture.
goldenchild17 Posted February 6, 2008 Posted February 6, 2008 (edited) [quote name='prose' post='1456430' date='Feb 6 2008, 12:36 PM']I remember when purgatory was taught to be like standing on the edge of Hell. That the suffering and torment were horrific. I remember one priest during a homily saying it was more than the worst pain we would have on earth because we couldn't turn our brains off in purgatory. We won't pass out from pain. We are forced to endure it. Pain. Suffering. Torture. Tongues burnt. Eyes pierced. Purified like silver in fire. Now, the rare time I hear about purgatory, it sounds almost pleasant. Like a "place of purification". Like we know we are going to heaven, so any pain that may be involved it not so bad. That it is simply another step on our faith journey. Like it is the runway to our takeoff. Now, have theologians changed their opinion on purgatory? Has the Church began to water it down for some reason? What are your opinions about this??[/quote] I believe that the pain suffered in purgatory is comparable to that suffered in hell and I think this is in accordance with the traditional understanding of Purgatory. I’m sure you are all well versed enough in the CCC so you can compare this with whatever is taught now: “The sufferings in purgatory include exclusion from the vision of God and other great pains. Hence the prayer: ‘Grant rest to the souls of the faithful departed and let perpetual light shine upon them.’ When we burn candles by the coffins or on the graves of the dead, we pray that the poor souls may be admitted to the sight of God. Apart from the duration[b], there is no distinction between the torments of hell and those of purgatory (St. Thomas). ‘The same fire,’ says St. Augustine, ‘burns the lost and the saved.’ Hence we see why the Church, in the Requiem Mass, prays God to deliver the souls from the pains of hell (Benedict XIV.). St. Augustine tells us that the pains of purgatory are greater than the sufferings of all the martyrs; and St. Thomas teaches that the least pain in purgatory is greater than the greatest on earth. ‘All the tortures that one can conceive of I this world are,’ says St. Cyril of Alexandria, ‘refreshing, compared to the least pain of purgatory.’ [/b] The greatness and duration of the sufferings in purgatory vary according to the gravity of the sins. St. Augustine tells us that those are longer in the purging fire who have been more attached to the goods of this world; that those who have grown old in sin take longer to pass through the cleansing stream. The foundation Masses going on for centuries, lead to suppose that some souls have to suffer through many generations of men; were this impossible the Church would have abolished such Masses. Catherine Emmerich, in her revelations, says that Our Lord descends into purgatory every Good Friday, and frees one or more souls of those who had been witnesses of His Passion. Eve where the punishment has lasted only an hour, we are told by St. Bridget, that it appears intolerably long. Those who wear the scapular are assured of a considerable shortening of their sufferings…” p. 265 “The Catechism Explained” Spirago-Clarke copyright 1899. Edited February 6, 2008 by goldenchild17
jeffpugh Posted February 6, 2008 Posted February 6, 2008 Fr. Groechel Says he looks forward to purgatory, too... But then, it's nothing compared to the Eternity of Bliss that is promised after the "cleansing" in the agonizing flames...
prose Posted February 6, 2008 Author Posted February 6, 2008 Question: Are we separated from God here on Earth? Like, for instance, some people do not "Feel" God or have His comfort... Would that be comparable? And do people in purgatory KNOW they are there? Or do they think they are in Hell because they are separated from God and he can't tell them?
cefrybar Posted February 6, 2008 Posted February 6, 2008 I think people who don't 'feel God or his comfort' are more likely experiencing what's known as the dark night of the soul. Mother Theresa said that she felt like that for half her life. I think that's completely different than purgatory. There's a difference between not feeling God's comfort and the agonizing albeit purging fires of purgatory...
Era Might Posted February 6, 2008 Posted February 6, 2008 This is from the old Catholic Encylopedia entry on "Purgatory": [quote]At the Council of Florence, Bessarion argued against the existence of real purgatorial fire, and the Greeks were assured that the Roman Church had never issued any dogmatic decree on this subject. In the West the belief in the existence of real fire is common. ...How this fire affects the souls of the departed the Doctors do not know, and in such matters it is well to heed the warning of the Council of Trent when it commands the bishops "to exclude from their preaching difficult and subtle questions which tend not to edification, and from the discussion of which there is no increase either in piety or devotion."[/quote] A lot of the specifics that we believe about Purgatory is theological speculation and/or pious belief, not Catholic doctrine. It is certain dogma, however, that there is a purgation after death (for those who die in God's grace but are still imperfect), and that our prayers can assist them.
premed_jakey Posted February 6, 2008 Posted February 6, 2008 I was always taught that it was painful in a "physical" sense of course, but the worst pain of it was that you were seperated from God for a short time. Its always been very confusing, but some of these posts definetly help define it a bit better.
rkwright Posted February 7, 2008 Posted February 7, 2008 Prose, I'm reading a set of books by "Anne". She is a current catholic writer, wife, and mother, and has had some amazing visions during the past 5 years or so. Her writings are being 'monitored' (poor choice of a word, I really don't know what to call it...she has submitted all of her writings to a bishop and the vatican for their approval) and it is definitely a private revelation, so take it or leave it. The first book I read was called 'Climbing the Mountain' and had her dairies of her visions of heaven. They are amazing! She talks about conversing with the saints, being able to re-visit Christ's passion, talking with the Blessed Mother, seeing souls honor Mary on a feast day, seeing the intercession of the saints working first hand... Its amazing because it is so Catholic and very inspirational. Anyways, the second book I have from her, 'Mist of Mercy' is her experiences and visions of purgatory. Again they are just amazing. They talk about the souls there, the pains they feel, and how they move through purgatory based on intercessions and their own purification. She never mentioned fire in her visions, rather it was very isolated, you were not aware of those around you, you were alone. The souls were in this 'mist' and would move through it. There were some that had converted on their deathbed, some that she said had done terrible things but converted at the last second... they were the farthest in the Mist, and very isolated. She mentioned that they were simply praying for God to have mercy on them non-stop and somewhat reliving their sins and seeing how they affected those around them. She mentions that the biggest difference between her visions of hell and purgatory were that the souls in purgatory were 'safe' they needn't fear about being attacked by demons or other souls. Anyways, they're great books, easy reads, very inspiring. Just some insight, again it is private revelation so take it or leave it... I'd just like to quote one part, just because I know some people might think this is all wacky being private revelations. The first thing in the book says "Direction for Our Times wishes to manifest its complete obedience and submission of mind and heart to the final and definitive judgement of the magisterium of the Catholic Church and the local Ordinary regarding the supernatural character of the messages received by Anne, a lay apostle."
jeffpugh Posted February 7, 2008 Posted February 7, 2008 I think the biggest message about purgatory is that it's a state of improvement and that the souls are SAFE. They cannot sin because they no longer live as we do, but they're not pure enough for heaven, so Christ's grace pours out on them so they may progress in whatever fashion to become spotless. The worldly attachments are lost here and the Godly ones are gained here.
kafka Posted February 7, 2008 Posted February 7, 2008 I wrote an article about Purgatory. It goes into some interesting ideas such as Is Purgatory a Place? Do the souls in Purgatory gradually ascend to Heaven. Is Purgatory a midpoint between Heaven and Earth? Is their time in Purgatory? Anyone interested? One thing about Purgatory is that the holy souls undergo change and become more like Christ. Change hurts and so does the Crucifixion which each Christian must relive in some way. If not on Earth then in Purgatory. Pain in Purgatory is of the soul since no one in Purgatory has a body. The worst pain is the full realization of the true extent of their own sinfulness in offending God, and secondly, of the harm done by their sins to their neighbor Another thing about Purgatory is that the holy souls have a clearer understanding. They long to see God who is Eternity and be with Him, but they are still stuck in Time. BTW one of the biggest tortures of Hell is that the damned will always be stuck in some form Time.
prose Posted February 7, 2008 Author Posted February 7, 2008 I thought the Great Divorce by CS Lewis explained purgatory better than I had ever heard before. I loved it. It is so interesting to hear people's thoughts and opinions on this topic. Keep it coming!
jeffpugh Posted February 7, 2008 Posted February 7, 2008 [quote name='kafka' post='1457066' date='Feb 7 2008, 02:08 PM']I wrote an article about Purgatory. It goes into some interesting ideas such as Is Purgatory a Place? Do the souls in Purgatory gradually ascend to Heaven. Is Purgatory a midpoint between Heaven and Earth? Is their time in Purgatory? Anyone interested? One thing about Purgatory is that the holy souls undergo change and become more like Christ. Change hurts and so does the Crucifixion which each Christian must relive in some way. If not on Earth then in Purgatory. Pain in Purgatory is of the soul since no one in Purgatory has a body. The worst pain is the full realization of the true extent of their own sinfulness in offending God, and secondly, of the harm done by their sins to their neighbor Another thing about Purgatory is that the holy souls have a clearer understanding. They long to see God who is Eternity and be with Him, but they are still stuck in Time. BTW one of the biggest tortures of Hell is that the damned will always be stuck in some form Time.[/quote] Great insight. Especially the last line.
icelandic_iceskater Posted February 7, 2008 Posted February 7, 2008 [quote name='Premed_Jakey' post='1456649' date='Feb 6 2008, 07:50 PM']I was always taught that[b] it was painful in a "physical" sense of course,[/b] but the worst pain of it was that you were seperated from God for a short time. Its always been very confusing, but some of these posts definetly help define it a bit better.[/quote] How can it be painful in a "physical sense" if our bodies are buried 6 feet under?
Dismas Posted February 8, 2008 Posted February 8, 2008 [quote name='cefrybar' post='1456533' date='Feb 6 2008, 03:41 PM']I think people who don't 'feel God or his comfort' are more likely experiencing what's known as the dark night of the soul. Mother Theresa said that she felt like that for half her life. I think that's completely different than purgatory. There's a difference between not feeling God's comfort and the agonizing albeit purging fires of purgatory...[/quote] That is a definite possibility. On the other hand, the spiritual death of mortal sin is also quite deadening of our senses of God.
LouisvilleFan Posted February 8, 2008 Posted February 8, 2008 [quote name='goldenchild17' post='1456486' date='Feb 6 2008, 03:22 PM']I believe that the pain suffered in purgatory is comparable to that suffered in hell and I think this is in accordance with the traditional understanding of Purgatory. I’m sure you are all well versed enough in the CCC so you can compare this with whatever is taught now: “The sufferings in purgatory include exclusion from the vision of God and other great pains. Hence the prayer: ‘Grant rest to the souls of the faithful departed and let perpetual light shine upon them.’ When we burn candles by the coffins or on the graves of the dead, we pray that the poor souls may be admitted to the sight of God. Apart from the duration[b], there is no distinction between the torments of hell and those of purgatory (St. Thomas). ‘The same fire,’ says St. Augustine, ‘burns the lost and the saved.’ Hence we see why the Church, in the Requiem Mass, prays God to deliver the souls from the pains of hell (Benedict XIV.). St. Augustine tells us that the pains of purgatory are greater than the sufferings of all the martyrs; and St. Thomas teaches that the least pain in purgatory is greater than the greatest on earth. ‘All the tortures that one can conceive of I this world are,’ says St. Cyril of Alexandria, ‘refreshing, compared to the least pain of purgatory.’ [/b][/quote] I'm curious to know where they got their information? I've heard of some saints having visions of purgatory, yet they can still misinterpret the purpose of those visions or the violent nature of them may have been more relevant in their time. After all, the Catechism doesn't say much about purgatory (nor heaven or hell, for that matter). As I tell my Protestant friends, if you aren't perfect when you die, Christ makes you perfect... and that's purgatory. And, yes, it'll hurt like hell (to use the phrase), but pain suffered under the hands of a doctor is a far cry from pain suffered under the hands of a torturer. [quote name='icelandic_iceskater' post='1457115' date='Feb 7 2008, 04:24 PM']How can it be painful in a "physical sense" if our bodies are buried 6 feet under? [/quote] Because that's the kind of pain we most easily relate to. However, I think the pain of losing someone you love (especially a breakup or divorce/annulment, where you have to deal with outright rejection) is closer to the pain of purgatory. You can even physically hurt from emotional pain, and about the only way to relate the pain of heartbreak to someone who's never suffered a broken heart is to describe it in physical terms.
XIX Posted February 8, 2008 Posted February 8, 2008 I think of the most excruciating romantic heartbreak I have ever experienced and I imagine that purgatory will be something like that. Similarities: Punishment that is not physical (I don't believe Purgatory is physical punishment, since we aren't reunited with our bodies until the end of time). Punishment that is still quite excruciating. Probably the worst part is being separated from someone you love. It's not forever, so there's always hope. And you know this pain will lead to joy in the future, when you gain what you once lacked. The spirit is far stronger than the body IMHO. That's my thoughts. Anyways, the teachings on purgatory have not changed in the least. The speculations, maybe. Not the teachings.
CatherineM Posted February 8, 2008 Posted February 8, 2008 I figure that purgatory is the best I can hope for, so I hope it is tolerable. My dad used to say he didn't mind going there because he figured that's where all his friends would be anyway.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted February 8, 2008 Posted February 8, 2008 Purgatory is a place of hopeful cleansing, to the extent that we are being prepared for our Lord. It is a place of pain and torment to the extent that we are attached to our sins. I liken the pain to the pain you might have recovering from a very intense surgery...it hurts, but it is a pain you gladly endure because you know things will get better. Also, it is not the pain of punishment, but the pain of healing, because God is not meaning for us to be in pain as retribution, but God is meaning to detach us from our sins and sinful desires, which is, by its nature, painful to the soul. Yet the more the soul undergoes the pain, the more it is detached, and the more it loves God, and after some time, the soul is so focused on God that the pain feels as if it was a distant memory, and the soul is enveloped in the love of the Holy Trinity, never to feel the pain of being apart from God again. We are tried in fire. The fire of God's love removes our impurities, and this hurts, but that same fire sets our souls aflame for love of God and makes us glow with His glory. This is more or less the view the pope mentioned in Spe Salvi.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now