Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1457451' date='Feb 8 2008, 02:15 AM']I figure that purgatory is the best I can hope for, so I hope it is tolerable. My dad used to say he didn't mind going there because he figured that's where all his friends would be anyway.[/quote]
And you might be right. Just don't aim for purgatory, if you know what I mean. If you aim for purgatory, you just might miss.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='XIX' post='1457512' date='Feb 8 2008, 10:12 AM']And you might be right. Just don't aim for purgatory, if you know what I mean. If you aim for purgatory, you just might miss.[/quote]
Excellent observation. Be humble enough to admit that without God's grace, you deserve hell, trusting enough that with God's grace you will be happy to be admitted to purgatory, and courageous enough to hope for heaven after leaving this life behind.

Posted

Sometimes I seriously doubt the existence of Purgatory. Didn't Jesus tell the hanged thief that he will be with him in heaven on that same day? :unsure:

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='dandy777' post='1457531' date='Feb 8 2008, 10:42 AM']Sometimes I seriously doubt the existence of Purgatory. Didn't Jesus tell the hanged thief that he will be with him in heaven on that same day? :unsure:[/quote]
Yes, but it would seem to me that if the Church can grant plenary indulgences and apostolic pardons, then surely Christ, faced with the total repentance of a contrite sinner, can allow him immediate access to paradise.

Anyway, the point is more on the coming of the Kingdom and God's mercy in and through the Kingdom than about literally saying the thief he would be in heaven immediately after death.

Posted

[quote name='rkwright' post='1456700' date='Feb 6 2008, 07:58 PM']Prose, I'm reading a set of books by "Anne". She is a current catholic writer, wife, and mother, and has had some amazing visions during the past 5 years or so. Her writings are being 'monitored' (poor choice of a word, I really don't know what to call it...she has submitted all of her writings to a bishop and the vatican for their approval) and it is definitely a private revelation, so take it or leave it. The first book I read was called 'Climbing the Mountain' and had her dairies of her visions of heaven. They are amazing! She talks about conversing with the saints, being able to re-visit Christ's passion, talking with the Blessed Mother, seeing souls honor Mary on a feast day, seeing the intercession of the saints working first hand... Its amazing because it is so Catholic and very inspirational.

Anyways, the second book I have from her, 'Mist of Mercy' is her experiences and visions of purgatory. Again they are just amazing. They talk about the souls there, the pains they feel, and how they move through purgatory based on intercessions and their own purification.

She never mentioned fire in her visions, rather it was very isolated, you were not aware of those around you, you were alone. The souls were in this 'mist' and would move through it. There were some that had converted on their deathbed, some that she said had done terrible things but converted at the last second... they were the farthest in the Mist, and very isolated. She mentioned that they were simply praying for God to have mercy on them non-stop and somewhat reliving their sins and seeing how they affected those around them.

She mentions that the biggest difference between her visions of hell and purgatory were that the souls in purgatory were 'safe' they needn't fear about being attacked by demons or other souls.

Anyways, they're great books, easy reads, very inspiring. Just some insight, again it is private revelation so take it or leave it...

I'd just like to quote one part, just because I know some people might think this is all wacky being private revelations. The first thing in the book says "Direction for Our Times wishes to manifest its complete obedience and submission of mind and heart to the final and definitive judgement of the magisterium of the Catholic Church and the local Ordinary regarding the supernatural character of the messages received by Anne, a lay apostle."[/quote]

I read all of Anne's Volumes, the two books and the small message books. They are pretty incredible. I don't know what to believe but, it sure would be nice to think that Jesus is gathering his army and preparing us for his return. I got a lot of solace out of the messages myself.

Archaeology cat
Posted

While we're talking about Purgatory, anyone have a good way of explaining it? I'm trying to explain it to my sister (from a southern baptist background), b/c she thinks it takes away from Christ's sacrifice. Any suggestions would be helpful.

Posted

The way I used to explain it to Baptists is that after a fancy dinner party, you don't put the dirty china away without cleaning them first. Heaven is perfect, and only those who are cleansed should be allowed in. Some stains won't come out, and those plates get discarded, but the ones that come clean can be put back in the cabinet.

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1457594' date='Feb 8 2008, 06:43 PM']The way I used to explain it to Baptists is that after a fancy dinner party, you don't put the dirty china away without cleaning them first. Heaven is perfect, and only those who are cleansed should be allowed in. Some stains won't come out, and those plates get discarded, but the ones that come clean can be put back in the cabinet.[/quote]

Thanks! I'd given the example of a child breaking something. While the child is forgiven, they still need to fix the item. Maybe he'll relate to your example more. Oh, and she's also in a Methodist seminary.

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1457547' date='Feb 8 2008, 11:41 AM']Yes, but it would seem to me that if the Church can grant plenary indulgences and apostolic pardons, then surely Christ, faced with the total repentance of a contrite sinner, can allow him immediate access to paradise.

Anyway, the point is more on the coming of the Kingdom and God's mercy in and through the Kingdom than about literally saying the thief he would be in heaven immediately after death.[/quote]
Yes, but wouldn't the theif be still attached to sin? or was his purgatory suffered on the cross during his 3+ hours hanging there?

[quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1457575' date='Feb 8 2008, 01:12 PM']While we're talking about Purgatory, anyone have a good way of explaining it? I'm trying to explain it to my sister (from a southern baptist background), b/c she thinks it takes away from Christ's sacrifice. Any suggestions would be helpful.[/quote]
Better quote revelations: "nothing unclean may enter [the New Jerusalem]"

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1457623' date='Feb 8 2008, 07:19 PM']Yes, but wouldn't the theif be still attached to sin? or was his purgatory suffered on the cross during his 3+ hours hanging there?
Better quote revelations: "nothing unclean may enter [the New Jerusalem]"[/quote]

I hadn't thought about that one. Thanks. I did give her a link for Scripture Catholic on it, but she pretty much dismissed it. So I'll keep praying. :)

Posted

I think it is safe to say that if the pain in Purgatory (whatever form it takes) is greater than here on earth, then so is the joy. We are joyful in suffering on earth because we know we are on pilgrimage, that we have here no lasting home. The souls in purgatory not only know that they are being perfected for Heaven, but they are no longer tempted and can never sin again. Maybe that is one of the ways they are purified. They know that they will never offend God again, so they are able to see clearly their past offenses, and their contrition is made perfect.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='dandy777' post='1457531' date='Feb 8 2008, 11:42 AM']Sometimes I seriously doubt the existence of Purgatory. Didn't Jesus tell the hanged thief that he will be with him in heaven on that same day? :unsure:[/quote]

That's the argument Charles Spurgeon used against purgatory. However, there is no time after we die, and Jesus most likely wasn't speaking in the sense of a 24-hour day. When someone says "back in my day," they aren't referring to a single day.

Plus, the thief could well have been completely detached from this world. For one, he had admitted that he and the other thief were getting the punishment they deserved while attesting to Jesus' innocence. And I imagine if I were hanging half-dead on a cross, I wouldn't care much for this world either.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='XIX' post='1457512' date='Feb 8 2008, 11:12 AM']And you might be right. Just don't aim for purgatory, if you know what I mean. If you aim for purgatory, you just might miss.[/quote]

That doesn't make any sense at all to me. How do you aim for purgatory? Just aim for Christ.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='rkwright' post='1456700' date='Feb 6 2008, 08:58 PM']Prose, I'm reading a set of books by "Anne". She is a current catholic writer, wife, and mother, and has had some amazing visions during the past 5 years or so. Her writings are being 'monitored' (poor choice of a word, I really don't know what to call it...she has submitted all of her writings to a bishop and the vatican for their approval) and it is definitely a private revelation, so take it or leave it. The first book I read was called 'Climbing the Mountain' and had her dairies of her visions of heaven. They are amazing! She talks about conversing with the saints, being able to re-visit Christ's passion, talking with the Blessed Mother, seeing souls honor Mary on a feast day, seeing the intercession of the saints working first hand... Its amazing because it is so Catholic and very inspirational.[/quote]

Unfortunately, it seems that she's been exposed as a fraud. She's apparently divorced, remarried, and advocated sterilization in her friend (which her friend did, and eventually divorced). She also apparently wrote a book under her real name called "The Breakable Vow," which referred to marriage. All while receiving the alleged messages, she worked for an organization that advocated divorce and remarriage under circumstances not necessarily cohesive with the Church's teachings. She mentions Medjugorje at the beginning of her volumes, a place of apparitions that has been called into question by many and put a tiny red flag up in my mind. But I still gave her the benefit of the doubt and read some of her stuff....

Anyway, I wish this wasn't the case because I'm all about getting inspiration from private revelations, but she and her website have a very fishy past...

[url="http://www.unitypublishing.com/Apparitions/anna'name.htm"]http://www.unitypublishing.com/Apparitions/anna'name.htm[/url]

Edited by lilac_angel
Excelsior1027
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1457575' date='Feb 8 2008, 01:12 PM']While we're talking about Purgatory, anyone have a good way of explaining it? I'm trying to explain it to my sister (from a southern baptist background), b/c she thinks it takes away from Christ's sacrifice. Any suggestions would be helpful.[/quote]
I just found this video of Fr. Benedict Groeschel the other day and I had thought it would be good for Protestants who are wondering about Purgatory (being a former Protestant, I tend to notice things like that, haha). He just seems to have a manner about him that I think would be good for explaining Catholic beliefs to Protestants and others. He also specifically mentions that we do not 'earn' anything in Purgatory, and that it is only through Christ that we are saved. Yes, just as others have mentioned in this thread, Fr. Benedict is more of the persuasion that Purgatory isn't [i]all[/i] that bad, and that comes through in this video; but he's not necessarily wrong since we don't really know for sure what it's like. I always thought I could just explain to a Protestant that through the ages there have been different ideas about Purgatory as to the details of the suffering that goes on there, but the main point is that [i]some[/i] kind of 'purging' [i]does[/i] take place. That should be enough for us to want to avoid it. Anyway, I digress, here's the link to the video. :)

[url="http://franciscanfriars.com/gallery/holy_souls.htm"]http://franciscanfriars.com/gallery/holy_souls.htm[/url]

Edited by Excelsior1027
Posted

[quote name='lilac_angel' post='1461971' date='Feb 14 2008, 12:01 AM']Unfortunately, it seems that she's been exposed as a fraud. She's apparently divorced, remarried, and advocated sterilization in her friend (which her friend did, and eventually divorced). She also apparently wrote a book under her real name called "The Breakable Vow," which referred to marriage. All while receiving the alleged messages, she worked for an organization that advocated divorce and remarriage under circumstances not necessarily cohesive with the Church's teachings. She mentions Medjugorje at the beginning of her volumes, a place of apparitions that has been called into question by many and put a tiny red flag up in my mind. But I still gave her the benefit of the doubt and read some of her stuff....

Anyway, I wish this wasn't the case because I'm all about getting inspiration from private revelations, but she and her website have a very fishy past...

[url="http://www.unitypublishing.com/Apparitions/anna'name.htm"]http://www.unitypublishing.com/Apparitions/anna'name.htm[/url][/quote]

Wow I hadn't heard any of that... it makes me a bit sad actually...

She does write that she is divorced and remarried, she cites abuse. I didn't know about her advocating any other causes. The thing that most concerns her is the lack of validation of the Imprimatur.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='rkwright' post='1462017' date='Feb 14 2008, 02:39 AM']Wow I hadn't heard any of that... it makes me a bit sad actually...

She does write that she is divorced and remarried, she cites abuse. I didn't know about her advocating any other causes. The thing that most concerns her is the lack of validation of the Imprimatur.[/quote]

It makes me sad, too... I had been looking forward to reading the rest of her messages because many of the things she said seemed like good, reassuring, and helpful advice that any Catholic would benefit from. :( But I guess that could have just been a tactic to sneak in bits of her agenda here and there... *sigh* :unsure:

Edited by lilac_angel
Posted

[quote name='lilac_angel' post='1462032' date='Feb 14 2008, 03:03 AM']It makes me sad, too... I had been looking forward to reading the rest of her messages because many of the things she said seemed like good, reassuring, and helpful advice that any Catholic would benefit from. :( But I guess that could have just been a tactic to sneak in bits of her agenda here and there... *sigh* :unsure:[/quote]

Well one more point, I haven't outright dismissed her books yet. That was one website, and the only one I could find out there. The website seemed somewhat like a Catholic conspiracy website too... I dunno I'll check into it a bit more.

Posted (edited)

There was a lot of discussion back on the Catholic Answers forum a few years back regarding the site too, when they didn't offer the books for free online which made it seem like they just wanted to make a profit. A lot of people seemed skeptical about it. Eventually, they offered the material for download and then eventually got non-profit status, but they're still selling things on the site which makes me wonder a little. Something also just looks a little artificial about that website to me, but I guess the majority of what I've read so far (except for making divorce in general seem like no big deal and defensive "messages" said to be from God about how relatives shouldn't give the divorced a hard time.. which seems like it could just be motivated by her own private life, rather than a directive from divinity) didn't seem to go against the Church.

I haven't read her stuff on Purgatory, though. I've read a lot of different things about that, some from visionary saints, ranging from it being just as painful as hell, yet temporary, to... well that's about all that sticks out in my mind :)

Edited by lilac_angel
Posted

If you learn\hear anymore on this, please send me a PM or post it! I'd like to know!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...