Lounge Daddy Posted February 18, 2008 Posted February 18, 2008 Yup, government schools in California will be teaching global warming as a matter of fact if a pending piece of legislation gets passed. Think the government-run schools will also be teaching children that government is the solution to the 'problem' of global warming? You bet! From [url="http://www.mercurynews.com/education/ci_8269190"]Mercury News[/url]: [quote]Reading, writing and . . . global warming? A Silicon Valley lawmaker is gaining momentum with a bill that would require "climate change" to be among the science topics that all California public school students are taught. The measure, by state Sen. Joe Simitian, D-Palo Alto, also would mandate that future science textbooks approved for California public schools include climate change. "You can't have a science curriculum that is relevant and current if it doesn't deal with the science behind climate change," Simitian said. "This is a phenomenon of global importance and our kids ought to understand the science behind that phenomenon." The state Senate approved the bill, SB 908, Jan. 30 by a 26-13 vote. It heads now to the state Assembly. Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger has taken numerous actions to reduce global warming, but he has yet to weigh in on Simitian's bill. Other Republicans in the Capitol, however, are not happy about the proposal. Some say the science on global warming isn't clear, while others worry the bill would inject environmental propaganda into classrooms. "I find it disturbing that this mandate to teach this theory is not accompanied by a requirement that the discussion be science-based and include a critical analysis of all sides of the subject," said Sen. Tom McClintock, R-Thousand Oaks, during the Senate debate.[/quote]
goldenchild17 Posted February 18, 2008 Posted February 18, 2008 not surprising. It'll become commonly accepted in society just like any of the recent major theories of evolution or geocentrism.
mommas_boy Posted February 18, 2008 Posted February 18, 2008 Ok, please let's review: [list] [*]We know that the earth is warming. This does not imply in and of itself that humans are to blame, and could simply be a natural process. [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming#Temperature_changes"]Link[/url] [*]We know that carbon dioxide levels are rising. This leaves two questions: (1) this could somehow be natural, and (2) carbon dioxide might not cause temperature change. [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:Mauna_Loa_Carbon_Dioxide.png"]Mona Lau[/url] [*]We know that carbon dioxide does in fact contribute to a greenhouse effect. The total list is: water vapor, which causes about 36–70% of the greenhouse effect (not including clouds); carbon dioxide, which causes 9–26%; methane (CH4), which causes 4–9%; and ozone, which causes 3–7% [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming#Greenhouse_gases_in_the_amosphere"]Link[/url] [*]We know that burning fossil fuels contributes to an atmospheric increase of not only carbon dioxide, but also of water (burning gasoline produces approximately 8 CO2 molecules for every 9 H2O molecules). This is assuming that the fuel burns completely. For an incomplete burn (which is more common), we will also produce methane and ozone, which are also greenhouse gases as mentioned above. [*]Since the mid-1700s, CO2 has increased by 31%. Of this increase, 75% is attributed to fossil fuel burning in the last 20 years. Thus, we have an increase of 23.25% CO2 since the mid-1700s which is directly attributable to fossil fuel burning. [*]With this 23.25% increase, the amount of the greenhouse effect that is directly attributable to fossil fuel burning in just the last 20 years is 2.1% (using the conservative 9% value for CO2 contribution to global warming). That's 2.1% that God didn't intend. [*]The entire green house effect is approximately 33* C (59* F). Thus, there is an increase of 0.69* C (1.24* F) is directly attributable to CO2 released by burning fossil fuels in the last 20 years. Another question: that's not a lot of an increase, or is it? [*]CO2 levels are continuing to rise, according to the Mona Lau data. [*]We know that an increase of just 5* C (9* F) in global annual average temperature is enough of a change to increase the rate of rock weathering by 400% [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming#Pre-human_climate_variations"]Link[/url]. This could have several unwanted effects: increasing silt in river streams, adversely affecting fish by clogging their gills or inhibiting spawning or hunting; increasing water salinity or density. [*]There are likely other effects that we aren't aware of as well. [*]Climate model predictions project an increase of 1.1 to 6.4* C by the end of this century. That's scary quick. But considering my back-of-the-envelope calculation yielding a conservative estimate of 0.69* C in just 20 years, this would put us on track to reach an increase of 3.45* C in 100 years, assuming that the temperature increase stays linear (temperature and CO2 charts show that gains have been accelerating, however, so this linear estimate is likely a low one, still). [/list] Please, let's quit arguing and just be stewards of what God has given us.
dairygirl4u2c Posted February 18, 2008 Posted February 18, 2008 way to lay the smack down. at a certain point, it's no longer scientifically sound to reserve judgment and ignore acting on the data. just saying.
mommas_boy Posted February 18, 2008 Posted February 18, 2008 [quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1465251' date='Feb 18 2008, 03:53 PM']at a certain point, it's no longer scientifically sound to reserve judgment and ignore acting on the data. just saying.[/quote] This is also a good point. 100% certainty is not required to necessitate action in this matter.
ardillacid Posted February 18, 2008 Posted February 18, 2008 I submit that you should stop breathing so much because you are putting out dangerous amounts of carbon dioxide and water vapor when you do this 'necessary' activity. lol
Apotheoun Posted February 18, 2008 Posted February 18, 2008 The production of vast new numbers of textbooks will only add to the increase in global temperature. What a waste of money and resources.
mommas_boy Posted February 18, 2008 Posted February 18, 2008 [quote name='notardillacid' post='1465287' date='Feb 18 2008, 04:52 PM']I submit that you should stop breathing so much because you are putting out dangerous amounts of carbon dioxide and water vapor when you do this 'necessary' activity. lol[/quote] I know that you were joking, but let's assume that you are serious for a moment because it brings up some good points that are often misunderstood: Where does the carbon for the carbon dioxide come from? We get it from the food that we eat: plants and animals. Even the animals that we eat ultimately get the carbon from plants. The process of changing this carbon that we eat into carbon dioxide is what provides us with the energy that we need to function. We breath out all of the carbon dioxide, which is then consumed by the plants that we eat. Thus, our breathing is part of a closed-loop system, and doesn't introduce any [b]new[/b] carbon into the system. On a similar note, biofuels get their carbon directly from plants. This carbon is burned, becoming atmospheric carbon dioxide again. This carbon dioxide is then reabsorbed by plants -- the same thing that are producing the fuel. This carbon is also part of a closed-loop system -- no net new carbon. The problem with fossil fuels is that they contain carbon that was taken outside of that loop and stored in the fossils. Yes, the plants are able to absorb it, but it's carbon that wasn't in the cycle before, and so they can't keep up and fall behind.
Mercy me Posted February 19, 2008 Posted February 19, 2008 Seems so simple but it leaves out so much. Please account for the climatic shifts that have occurred throughout Earth's history. Looked at from a historical perspective, this is but another fluctuation. Greenland is called Greenland because it used to be green. It has been covered in ice for a few hundred years. Look at the crops produced around the world a few hundred years ago versus what was growing a few thousand years ago. Of course the climate is changing, it has always changed. What is different is that humans know that they are in control now. To me it is secular humanism taken to its logical conclusion.
mommas_boy Posted February 19, 2008 Posted February 19, 2008 [quote name='Mercy me' post='1465436' date='Feb 18 2008, 09:41 PM']Seems so simple but it leaves out so much.[/quote] Indeed. I tried to keep it as simple as possible so that it could be followed. [quote]Please account for the climatic shifts that have occurred throughout Earth's history. Looked at from a historical perspective, this is but another fluctuation ... Look at the crops produced around the world a few hundred years ago versus what was growing a few thousand years ago. Of course the climate is changing, it has always changed. What is different is that humans know that they are in control now. To me it is secular humanism taken to its logical conclusion.[/quote] As a science teacher (or at least student teacher), I will definitely look into these things for you. Unfortunately, I need to exercise prudence and get back to those lesson plans. When I have more time, I will try to resurrect this thread. You may PM me, too, to remind me around, say, Thursday when the week starts to cool down. I will say, in a sense more related to these matters, my response may be something to the effect that yes, climate change is happening naturally, but that it is happening concurrent with a human-caused change such that the two are having a reinforcing effect on one-another. I believe that data support the conclusion that an almost-rhythmic global warming trend can be seen in time. I also believe that the previous warm period wasn't as warm as the current period, and so this natural warming theory can't explain the entirety of the current effect. I'm Catholic, and therefore both-and. In a general sense and unrelated to these specific matters, we can also be certain that the things that we are doing to the environment are far from good, even if they cannot be directly attributable to something as colossal and wide-sweeping as global climate change. Regardless of attribution, I believe that you would agree with me that we ought to do something about wide-spread industrial pollution, superfund sites, and the like, especially when these seem to hit God's poor the hardest. [quote]Greenland is called Greenland because it used to be green. It has been covered in ice for a few hundred years.[/quote] I'm not familiar with that. I had heard, in grade school at least, that it was a ruse thought up by the Vikings to keep their native Iceland (which was green), safe from invaders. Blessings!
T-Bone _ Posted February 19, 2008 Posted February 19, 2008 (edited) If there was a single iota of truth in [i]An Inconvenient Truth[/i], Al Gore would fly coach. That being said, we still need to be good stewards. Let's just not go overboard and decrease every one's quality of life the world over. Edited February 19, 2008 by T-Bone _
Mercy me Posted February 19, 2008 Posted February 19, 2008 [quote name='mommas_boy' post='1465481' date='Feb 18 2008, 11:34 PM']In a general sense and unrelated to these specific matters, we can also be certain that the things that we are doing to the environment are far from good, even if they cannot be directly attributable to something as colossal and wide-sweeping as global climate change. Regardless of attribution, I believe that you would agree with me that we ought to do something about wide-spread industrial pollution, superfund sites, and the like, especially when these seem to hit God's poor the hardest.[/quote] Amen! I have always been taught and have tried to live by the rule that you leave a place better than you found it. I am absolutely in favor of reducing emissions and cleaning up the environment that we share.
Fidei Defensor Posted February 19, 2008 Posted February 19, 2008 Leave the science to the scientists. I hardly believe any of you are qualified to decide whether or not global warming in happening. But in the meantime, are you willing to risk your future and your planet? Well, if you believe God will magically save you... go ahead and destory the planet.
Dismas Posted February 20, 2008 Posted February 20, 2008 [quote name='fidei defensor' post='1465849' date='Feb 19 2008, 06:30 PM']Leave the science to the scientists. I hardly believe any of you are qualified to decide whether or not global warming in happening. But in the meantime, are you willing to risk your future and your planet? Well, if you believe God will magically save you... go ahead and destory the planet.[/quote] Please shut up and burn some oil right now! I'm freezing here!
Alycin Posted February 20, 2008 Posted February 20, 2008 I don't think global warming, as in, "We're all going to die because the planet will be destroyed in 100 years" should be taught.... but all the factors that contribute to the theory of it? That stuff is somewhat important... and it wouldn't hurt for people to be more environtmentally conscientious... but being scared to death about it... not necessary, IMHO.
T-Bone _ Posted February 20, 2008 Posted February 20, 2008 [quote name='fidei defensor' post='1465849' date='Feb 19 2008, 04:30 PM']Leave the science to the scientists. I hardly believe any of you are qualified to decide whether or not global warming in happening. But in the meantime, are you willing to risk your future and your planet? Well, if you believe God will magically save you... go ahead and destory the planet.[/quote] Go ahead and shiver in the dark, walk 20 miles to work in the snow, and be a feel-good do-nothing hippie if you want, but I'm not going to significantly alter my lifestyle to the negative based on speculation by people that can't even predict the weather three days ahead of time.
T-Bone _ Posted February 20, 2008 Posted February 20, 2008 [quote name='fidei defensor' post='1465849' date='Feb 19 2008, 04:30 PM']Leave the science to the scientists. I hardly believe any of you are qualified to decide whether or not global warming in happening. But in the meantime, are you willing to risk your future and your planet? Well, if you believe God will magically save you... go ahead and destory the planet.[/quote] Go ahead and shiver in the dark, walk 20 miles to work in the snow, and be a feel-good do-nothing hippie if you want, but I'm not going to significantly alter my lifestyle to the negative based on speculation by people that can't even predict the weather three days ahead of time.
ardillacid Posted February 20, 2008 Posted February 20, 2008 [quote name='T-Bone _' post='1465482' date='Feb 18 2008, 10:34 PM']If there was a single iota of truth in [i]An Inconvenient Truth[/i], Al Gore would fly coach. That being said, we still need to be good stewards. Let's just not go overboard and decrease every one's quality of life the world over.[/quote] HEY, just because his home uses 12 times the energy the average American uses, and flies around the world in his private jet doesn't mean he isn't going to save us! lol [quote name='fidei defensor' post='1465849' date='Feb 19 2008, 06:30 PM']Well, if you believe God will magically save you... go ahead and destory the planet.[/quote] Well that's an intelligent argument if I've ever seen one.
ardillacid Posted February 20, 2008 Posted February 20, 2008 (edited) Double post. Edited February 20, 2008 by notardillacid
mommas_boy Posted February 20, 2008 Posted February 20, 2008 (edited) [quote name='mommas_boy' post='1465481' date='Feb 18 2008, 10:34 PM']When I have more time, I will try to resurrect this thread. You may PM me, too, to remind me around, say, Thursday when the week starts to cool down.[/quote] Ok. I went to a science-teacher convention last night, and they told me that there is a big global warming summit at Fermilab in Chicagoland next week. I am going to the meeting on Thursday 28th. More details can be found at www.gwsummit.org if you're interested in going. That said, I will save my comments until after that meeting. [quote name='T-Bone _' post='1465482' date='Feb 18 2008, 10:34 PM']If there was a single iota of truth in [i]An Inconvenient Truth[/i], Al Gore would fly coach.[/quote] [quote name='notardillacid' post='1465959' date='Feb 20 2008, 12:14 AM']HEY, just because his home uses 12 times the energy the average American uses, and flies around the world in his private jet doesn't mean he isn't going to save us! lol[/quote] Whether Al Gore is personally irresponsible in regards to his own energy use is irrelevant to the argument at hand, namely, whether global warming is indeed a phenomenon to be worried about. This is an [i]ad hominem[/i] argument, literally from the latin: [i]against the man[/i], and is generally considered to be fallacious in the realms of philosophy, argumentation, and debate. Please stay on topic. [quote name='notardillacid' post='1465959' date='Feb 20 2008, 12:14 AM'][quote name='fidei defensor' post='1465849' date='Feb 19 2008, 06:30 PM'] Well, if you believe God will magically save you... go ahead and destory the planet.[/quote] Well that's an intelligent argument if I've ever seen one. [/quote] Actually, it's not too bad of one. [quote name='fidei defensor' post='1465849' date='Feb 19 2008, 06:30 PM']Leave the science to the scientists. I hardly believe any of you are qualified to decide whether or not global warming in happening. But in the meantime, are you willing to risk your future and your planet?[/quote] This is good advice. This is a topic for scientists and data, not conjecture based upon personal philosophies and emotions over the issue. [quote name='Mercy me' post='1465436' date='Feb 18 2008, 09:41 PM']To me it is secular humanism taken to its logical conclusion.[/quote] Whether or not the [b]heresy[/b] of secular humanism is responsible for prompting this line of research, the scientific facts gained by said research are not diminished by the heresy. [quote name='T-Bone _' post='1465942' date='Feb 19 2008, 11:24 PM']Go ahead and shiver in the dark, walk 20 miles to work in the snow, and be a feel-good do-nothing hippie if you want, but I'm not going to significantly alter my lifestyle to the negative based on speculation by people that can't even predict the weather three days ahead of time.[/quote] Three points: (1) Assuming that you like I have an average American lifestyle, our lifestyle is such that if everyone were to live as we do, we would need 4 worlds. Yet, it is required of us as Catholics to "live simply". An arrogant refusal to not change your lifestyle to better suit the needs of others and of the planet which God has entrusted to us is most certainly a sin, and one bordering on mortal sin (assuming the usual three conditions are met). (2) Your soliloquy about freezing to death is hyperbole -- nothing more than an exaggeration. (3) The Pope and his advisors have been looking into this specific issue more closely over recent years. While I can do nothing to predict His Holiness' intentions, I expect a statement from the Vatican in the coming years. I will revive this thread after attending that conference I mentioned. Blessings to all! Edited February 20, 2008 by mommas_boy
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now