T-Bone _ Posted February 20, 2008 Posted February 20, 2008 [quote name='mommas_boy' post='1466091' date='Feb 20 2008, 06:30 AM']Whether Al Gore is personally irresponsible in regards to his own energy use is irrelevant to the argument at hand, namely, whether global warming is indeed a phenomenon to be worried about. This is an [i]ad hominem[/i] argument, literally from the latin: [i]against the man[/i], and is generally considered to be fallacious in the realms of philosophy, argumentation, and debate. Please stay on topic.[/quote] Actually, the lifestyle of one of the biggest proponents of this farce is relevant. If he actually believed the propaganda he spews forth, he would be one of the first to significantly alter his decedent lifestyle.
T-Bone _ Posted February 20, 2008 Posted February 20, 2008 [quote name='mommas_boy' post='1466091' date='Feb 20 2008, 06:30 AM']Three points: (1) Assuming that you like I have an average American lifestyle, our lifestyle is such that if everyone were to live as we do, we would need 4 worlds. Yet, it is required of us as Catholics to "live simply". An arrogant refusal to not change your lifestyle to better suit the needs of others and of the planet which God has entrusted to us is most certainly a sin, and one bordering on mortal sin (assuming the usual three conditions are met).[/quote] You're pretty judgmental of my lifestyle, without even having ever met me. [quote](2) Your soliloquy about freezing to death is hyperbole -- nothing more than an exaggeration.[/quote] I never mentioned freezing to death. Please read what I actually post. [quote](3) The Pope and his advisors have been looking into this specific issue more closely over recent years. While I can do nothing to predict His Holiness' intentions, I expect a statement from the Vatican in the coming years.[/quote] If you have no clue what the Pope is going to say, why bring it up?
Church Punk Posted February 20, 2008 Posted February 20, 2008 The way I see it, we have a couple options when it comes to global warming and the environmental crises we face. We can sit here and pretend nothing is wrong, or if anything is wrong it is supposed to happen that way, after all could this be the apocalypse? Don't worry our blind faith in this will save us. Or we can wake up and realize how bad of stewards we as humans are. We have not done a good job taking care of our home as God instructed us to and try to make a difference and make our home a better place to live and to be healthy if not for you at least for your children. We are cutting down precious forest and tropical rain forest at a rate of 2.47 acres per second! Over half of the rain forest in the world are now lost. Many animals and ecosystems have been destroyed. Many rivers and lakes have all but lost their fish and wildlife. Go outside in any major city, do you prefer the smog to nice crisp fresh air? These are facts, some you can know just by looking around you! So do we approach the coming years and generations, basing our actions off of facts? or by simple blind faith that if we keep doing what we are doing it will be OK? I know that the government offers mostly lip service, and teaching global warming as 100% our fault may not be accurate, however, the facts that we are destroying much of the environment speak for themselves, whether or not global warming is human caused or natural, the Earth is in big doo doo if we keep on the path that we are on, destroy and never give back. We need to take responsibility for our actions. Perhaps if we all did this, it would solve a lot of our other issues too.
MC IMaGiNaZUN Posted February 20, 2008 Posted February 20, 2008 I lived in Los Angeles all my life, its easy to believe in global warming when it gets to 110 degrees in August. I am living in Chicago now. Its hard to believe in global warming when it gets below Zero in February. SHALOM Bro Mark
MC IMaGiNaZUN Posted February 20, 2008 Posted February 20, 2008 Usually the global warming arguement also contains this. We are using so much of the earth's resources like coal and gas, if we switched over to naturally renewable resources like electricity (for cars and heating systems) and solar power, we would not waste the earth's resources. (but of course solar power doesn't work everywhere in this country, wind power is another alternative)
MissScripture Posted February 20, 2008 Posted February 20, 2008 [quote name='mommas_boy' post='1466091' date='Feb 20 2008, 08:30 AM'](2) Your soliloquy about freezing to death is hyperbole -- nothing more than an exaggeration.[/quote] A) He never mentioned freezing to death. B) If you're where I am, freezing to death is a very real possibility if something goes wrong.
jeffpugh Posted February 20, 2008 Posted February 20, 2008 [quote name='Dismas' post='1465872' date='Feb 19 2008, 08:08 PM']Please shut up and burn some oil right now! I'm freezing here![/quote] Yeah, chilleh where you are too? I hear ya. [quote name='T-Bone _' post='1465942' date='Feb 19 2008, 11:24 PM']Go ahead and shiver in the dark, walk 20 miles to work in the snow, and be a feel-good do-nothing hippie if you want, but I'm not going to significantly alter my lifestyle to the negative based on speculation by people that can't even predict the weather three days ahead of time.[/quote] Hehehe... [quote name='notardillacid' post='1465959' date='Feb 20 2008, 12:14 AM']HEY, just because his home uses 12 times the energy the average American uses, and flies around the world in his private jet doesn't mean he isn't going to save us! lol Well that's an intelligent argument if I've ever seen one.[/quote] lawl [quote name='notardillacid' post='1465960' date='Feb 20 2008, 12:15 AM']Double post.[/quote] Double post almost ruins the credibility of the last one [quote name='MissScripture' post='1466291' date='Feb 20 2008, 03:20 PM']A) He never mentioned freezing to death. B) If you're where I am, freezing to death is a very real possibility if something goes wrong.[/quote] Yeah, same here.
Mr.Cat Posted February 20, 2008 Posted February 20, 2008 [quote][b]Homily from Pope Benedict the Sixteenth[/b] [[i]Excerpts[/i]] [b]Sunday, September 2, 2007 AD[/b] "Do not be afraid, dear friends, to prefer the "alternative" routes pointed out by true love: a modest and sound lifestyle; sincere and pure emotional relationships; honest commitment in studies and work; deep concern for the common good. Do not be afraid of seeming different and being criticized for what might seem to be losing or out of fashion; your peers but adults too, especially those who seem more distant from the mindset and values of the Gospel, are crying out to see someone who dares to live according to the fullness of humanity revealed by Jesus Christ." "There is no doubt that one of the fields in which it seems urgent to take action is that of safeguarding creation. The future of the planet is entrusted to the new generations, in which there are evident signs of a development that has not always been able to protect the delicate balances of nature. Before it is too late, it is necessary to make courageous decisions that can recreate a strong alliance between humankind and the earth. A decisive "yes" is needed to protect creation and also a strong commitment to invert those trends which risk leading to irreversibly degrading situations." [url="http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/benedict_xvi/homilies/2007/documents/hf_ben-xvi_hom_20070902_loreto_en.html"]http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/benedict..._loreto_en.html[/url][/quote]Global Warming and Global Climate Change are two serious issues that must be addressed by not only individuals but by the whole of humanity. We ought not to be fooled by those who desire to take advantage of ignorance and fear in theses matters. However this does not negate our responsibility in being good stewards of creation. The wasteful and inconsiderate lifestyles that have developed must be corrected, for some people this could be the selection of what ones eats to turning lights off.[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1465105' date='Feb 18 2008, 11:29 AM']not surprising. It'll become commonly accepted in society just like any of the recent major theories of evolution or geocentrism.[/quote]Presumably one intended to propose “[url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heliocentrism"]Heliocentrism[/url]” as a modern and major theory of the solar system, opposed to “[url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geocentrism"]Geocentrism[/url]”. Heliocentrism in astronomy is the theory that the Sun is at the center of the Solar System/Universe. Geocentrism in astronomy is the theory that the Earth is the center of the Solar System/Universe, which has been generally rejected by the modern scientific community.
cmotherofpirl Posted February 20, 2008 Posted February 20, 2008 How times change.... in the seventies scientists predicted we would all die of global cooling, in fact I remember the winter where we had temps of below zero for days on end. I remember seeing the rivers frozen solid for months. So pardon my scepticism of the current scientific fad. Is the earth changing ? of course! is it something new? duh, of course NOT. The only fallacy is that the earth is a static entity. Can we take better care of the planet- absolutely. But we are called as catholics to do that ANYWAY. Jumping on fad solutions to fad disasters is not only foolish, but downright dangerous. We can take care of the earth but we need to use data carefully and plan thoughtfully, and avoid the "chicken little" approach of todays politicians.
mommas_boy Posted February 20, 2008 Posted February 20, 2008 Most important thing first: [quote name='T-Bone _' post='1466101' date='Feb 20 2008, 08:48 AM']You're pretty judgmental of my lifestyle, without even having ever met me.[/quote] Dear friend in Christ, I never meant to be judgmental about your lifestyle. Having re-read my post, I believe that I didn't take the necessary precautions to make sure that my post was not taken as being uncharitable, and that's my fault. Please forgive me. Rather, I was asserting the simple fact that collectively we (you, me, and the rest of the western countries/states) as Westerners live beyond the means of the entire world to live as we do. I quoted the figure that if everyone on earth were to live as the average Westerner does, we would need four worlds to sustain all of us. Other figures abound, as well. What I was definitely not doing was taking a personal stab at you. What I was doing was taking the figures for the lifestyle of the average westerner and applying them to you the same that they apply to me. Living this way now is not a problem, but very soon, we will need to practice social justice and make a change in our lives to live more simply. Sin enters with a refusal to make this adjustment. [quote name='T-Bone _' post='1466093' date='Feb 20 2008, 08:39 AM']Actually, the lifestyle of one of the biggest proponents of this farce is relevant. If he actually believed the propaganda he spews forth, he would be one of the first to significantly alter his decedent lifestyle.[/quote] Reduccio ad absurdum: The Devil most certainly believes in Christ. The Devil even believes that Christ died for him, and that no matter what he does, Christ will still reign victoriously over him. Even so, despite this belief (or really rather, certain knowledge), the Devil does chose to rebel. Further, assume that the Devil does NOT believe in Christ (this is false, by the way), even if he doesn't, simply him having this belief does not invalidate the truth of Christ's existence. In other words, just because Al Gore does not practice what he preaches does not mean that he doesn't believe it. Further, even if Al Gore were to believe/disbelieve his own statements, his own belief/disbelief doesn't change whether or not those statements are objectively true pieces of information. The only way to determine the truth of the statements is to evaluate them based upon the data that they present, rather than upon the actions/beliefs of the (wo)man presenting them. Again, this is an ad hominem argument. [quote name='T-Bone _' post='1466101' date='Feb 20 2008, 08:48 AM']I never mentioned freezing to death. Please read what I actually post.[/quote] No, you never mentioned specifically freezing to death. Still, you presented an exaggerated false problem. Yes, freezing to death is a very really problem for many people. Simply being cold and NOT freezing to death is an even bigger reality. I do not believe that sacrifices that we will have to make will necessitate even "being cold and shivering" will be a problem. The problem is not THAT we are producing energy/heat to survive, but rather the WAY that this energy is produced, as well as the PRECAUTIONS to reduce emissions that aren't being taken, and finally the AMOUNT of energy consumed. It's a multidimensional problem, rather than a simple hot or cold, yes or no. [quote name='T-Bone _' post='1466101' date='Feb 20 2008, 08:48 AM']If you have no clue what the Pope is going to say, why bring it up?[/quote] I can have a clue about what the Pope will say based simply upon sacred Tradition. The Pope will essentially reaffirm the need for all peoples to be stewards of the Earth as one of our collective Vocations, (cf. Gen 2); that much is very certain. I can be all BUT certain that the Pope WILL NOT provide a definitive answer as to whether or not global warming is happening, not because the Pope is certain or uncertain that there is a pending crisis, but rather because His Holiness understands that this decision is not one of the Church but is rather one of science. The wording of this statement will, however, be very cautionary in tone so as to encourage people to take action NOW.
ardillacid Posted February 20, 2008 Posted February 20, 2008 [quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1466311' date='Feb 20 2008, 03:53 PM']Double post almost ruins the credibility of the last one [/quote] You mean I had credibility before?
cmotherofpirl Posted February 20, 2008 Posted February 20, 2008 [quote name='MC IMaGiNaZUN' post='1466265' date='Feb 20 2008, 03:39 PM']Usually the global warming arguement also contains this. We are using so much of the earth's resources like coal and gas, if we switched over to naturally renewable resources like electricity (for cars and heating systems) and solar power, we would not waste the earth's resources. (but of course solar power doesn't work everywhere in this country, wind power is another alternative)[/quote] We NEED the coal to make the electricity...what do you propose for places with little sun and no wind?
Dismas Posted February 21, 2008 Posted February 21, 2008 [quote name='mommas_boy' post='1465481' date='Feb 18 2008, 10:34 PM']I'm not familiar with that. I had heard, in grade school at least, that it was a ruse thought up by the Vikings to keep their native Iceland (which was green), safe from invaders. Blessings![/quote] There were a number of news articles of glaciers retreating in Greenland, revealing the ruins of villages, even medieval churches that were previously buried beneath the ice. The Vikings mainly abandoned Greenland during the "mini ice age".
Church Punk Posted February 22, 2008 Posted February 22, 2008 (edited) [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1466405' date='Feb 20 2008, 07:41 PM']We NEED the coal to make the electricity...what do you propose for places with little sun and no wind?[/quote] COAL is by far the dirtiest most inefficient form of energy. We don't need coal. There are many other ways to produce energy very efficiently. Nuclear power is far more clean than coal is, so long as it is taken good care of and the waste is contained properly. There is natural gas that can be used instead of coal which burns cleaner and more efficiently. And depending where you are located geographically there are plenty of alternatives that are Green and these should be saught after first because they are sustainable, they will produce and give us the energy we need at a much smaller cost to the envirnoment. There is geothermal, tidal, hydro electric just to name a few. This we NEED coal, just like we NEED SUVs, we NEED cheap gas, we NEED to keep our house ACed to 10° in the summer and heated to 30°C in the winter mentallity has got to go. What we NEED is to start thinking outside the box and stop being so selfish!!! Edited February 22, 2008 by Church Punk
cmotherofpirl Posted February 22, 2008 Posted February 22, 2008 [quote name='Church Punk' post='1467081' date='Feb 22 2008, 01:34 AM']COAL is by far the dirtiest most inefficient form of energy. We don't need coal. There are many other ways to produce energy very efficiently. Nuclear power is far more clean than coal is, so long as it is taken good care of and the waste is contained properly. There is natural gas that can be used instead of coal which burns cleaner and more efficiently. And depending where you are located geographically there are plenty of alternatives that are Green and these should be saught after first because they are sustainable, they will produce and give us the energy we need at a much smaller cost to the envirnoment. There is geothermal, tidal, hydro electric just to name a few. This we NEED coal, just like we NEED SUVs, we NEED cheap gas, we NEED to keep our house ACed to 10° in the summer and heated to 30°C in the winter mentallity has got to go. What we NEED is to start thinking outside the box and stop being so selfish!!![/quote] How long does it take to build a nuclear power plant? What do you do with the waste products that last 10,000 years? I am in PA and remember 3 Mile Island quite well, when the bishops gave us general absolution in case we all died rather suddenly. I am within the kill range now of nuclear power. We have over 200 cloudy or overcast days a year, and do not have a steady breeze. We don't have geothermal, tidal or hydroelectric here, we have coal. The coal is cheap and shipped by barge which is cheap, so our electricity prices have actually dropped, which is a good thing when you have the second largest population of elderly people on social security outside of Florida. Don't have an SUV, kid drives a Honda, don't have air-conditioning and the house is kept between 50-62* in winter.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now