Treehugger Posted July 17, 2008 Posted July 17, 2008 [quote name='M.SIGGA' post='123942' date='Feb 20 2004, 02:25 AM']Like the Rosary for example; I wouldn't break into "Our God is an Awesome God" after completing each Mystery. The reason why is the Rosary isn't supposed to be prayed that way.[/quote] I have read what others have been posting regarding "Praise and Worship" music in the liturgy. Many say that it does not fit and that it takes away from the tradtion element that is so valuable. I attend a Lifeteen parish where contemporary Christian music is played throughout the mass. Everyone in the church is participates with such "full, active, concious participation." The music selected is also carefully chosen to reflect the liturgical year. It is difficult to see issues with liturgical correctness when the church is full or people joyfully singing our parish mission statement of "Becoming a joyful, Catholic community of spirit-filled disciples worsjipping the Risen Lord!" It's interesting to think of where the balance would be. Prayer is prayer and there are so many different ways. Why would such ways be unsuitable for the liturgy. Really, I don't know that much about this genre of music in the liturgy so please let me know! Also, the comment about the Rosary not supposed to be prayed certain ways...I find this difficult to follow. I pray many audio versions of the Rosary. (I have them on my iPod.) There are so many CDs with the Rosary these days. Some with religious sisters singing, other with a contemporary feel, and still others in more of a rap genre. (Joe Melendrez!) Why are other creative ways of praying the same prayer and reflecting on the mysteries less "correct?"
Guest KevinSymonds Posted July 17, 2008 Posted July 17, 2008 The musical style known as 'praise and worship' (P&W) is actually a punch to the face of Catholicism. [b]So Gregorian Chant and Sacred Polyphony are not for the praise and worship of the Almighty Triune God?[/b] This is a rather emotional topic for me so I will leave the above question for everyone to think about. The answers are out there. A lot depends upon how far the person is willing to go in pursuit of the truth. -KJS
jeffpugh Posted July 17, 2008 Posted July 17, 2008 [quote name='johnnydigit' post='1588097' date='Jul 1 2008, 06:25 AM']Christian Praise&Worship/Contemporary/Gospel/Rock/Country/Pop/Rap/Alternative/Metal(i dunno about heavy metal though) is freaking awesome! ..outside of Mass. (mods, time to join threads?)[/quote] No you di'n't! [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1588470' date='Jul 1 2008, 04:49 PM']For Byzantine Catholics this is a non-issue, because that type of music is not allowed in the divine liturgy.[/quote] You're moving me closer to wanting to become Byzantine... but... not right now... [quote name='aalpha1989' post='1588917' date='Jul 2 2008, 02:58 AM']sooo jealous.... of course it's not technically allowed in ours, either, but let's not get into that, I've made enough people mad lately...[/quote] Hehe... not like it's possible to not offend anyone anyways... [quote name='Jenny Yay' post='1589225' date='Jul 2 2008, 02:24 PM']I would much rather hear Gregorian chant (even though I've never heard it in a church). It sounds more "otherworldly", so to speak, and holy. The times I've heard Gregorian chant (my mother has a Christmass CD with some on it), it makes me think of how the angels would have sung "Glory to God in the highest" when they appeared to the shepherds when Christ was born.[/quote] Look up "ave maria gregorian chant" on youtube. Nice examples there too. [quote name='Jenny Yay' post='1589225' date='Jul 2 2008, 02:24 PM']Praise and worship music is too insipid for my tastes.[/quote] Ice burn
pan!c139 Posted July 17, 2008 Posted July 17, 2008 UGH! I hate when it's a rock concert at MASS!!!! Reserve that kind of music for a youth meeting, but use proper music at Mass.
salterrae Posted July 17, 2008 Posted July 17, 2008 JM + JT I had a short conversation about this with the friend I was traveling to and from ND Vision with. He was totally for P&W at Mass and I was more with the "it depends" opinion. The 5 PM Mass at my parish is the teen mass, so they usually have P&W type songs which I don't see any problem with. Mass doesn't end up feeling like a rock concert even with the drums. Is it mostly teens that are "pushing" for more P&W in Mass? I enjoy a lot of Christian rock/ whatever songs (they fill my iPod), but I don't see the need to scatter them throughout the Mass. I'd prefer the more solemn kind of music like Gregorian Chant which I have yet to see at Mass. If anything, I'd think P&W could be used during Adoration (for teens, at least) - with times for silent prayer, of course (sometimes they forget those parts ). So yeah, I too don't see why there should be argument over this. Just make sure it's appropriate and not more like a concert and it should be fine.
Noel's angel Posted July 17, 2008 Posted July 17, 2008 No drums in Mass! Even if people are gonna pull the 'well no one says you can't play guitar at Mass' line, you can't get away with that for the drums. They're expressly forbidden. P+W shouldn't be used for Adoration either. How can it be Adoration if you're busy singing P+w music? Adoration should be silent time, spent before the Lord, contemplating.
salterrae Posted July 17, 2008 Posted July 17, 2008 (edited) JM + JT I never said that I agreed with the use of the drums, just that they were at least not used in a "rock concert" sort of way. And regarding P&W at adoration, I do not mean at perpetual adoration or all adoration "services" or whatever the correct term is. I honestly don't see why some singing would not be OK at say adoration at a high school retreat. I do not mean hands waving, dancing, drums and bongos, but singing and possibly guitars ever few mintues or so with silent prayer and contemplation in between. Why can't you praise and worship the Lord who is revealed right before you? Edited July 17, 2008 by salterrae
jeffpugh Posted July 17, 2008 Posted July 17, 2008 [quote name='salterrae' post='1601926' date='Jul 17 2008, 01:32 PM']JM + JT I had a short conversation about this with the friend I was traveling to and from ND Vision with. He was totally for P&W at Mass and I was more with the "it depends" opinion. The 5 PM Mass at my parish is the teen mass, so they usually have P&W type songs which I don't see any problem with. Mass doesn't end up feeling like a rock concert even with the drums. Is it mostly teens that are "pushing" for more P&W in Mass? I enjoy a lot of Christian rock/ whatever songs (they fill my iPod), but I don't see the need to scatter them throughout the Mass. [b]I'd prefer the more solemn kind of music like Gregorian Chant which I have yet to see at Mass.[/b] If anything, I'd think P&W could be used during Adoration (for teens, at least) - with times for silent prayer, of course (sometimes they forget those parts ). So yeah, I too don't see why there should be argument over this. Just make sure it's appropriate and not more like a concert and it should be fine. [/quote] Emphasis mine. Srsly, how can people be hatin on it when they haven't tried it. That's one of my side comments about this music controversy. [quote name='salterrae' post='1602176' date='Jul 17 2008, 05:09 PM']JM + JT I never said that I agreed with the use of the drums, just that they were at least not used in a "rock concert" sort of way. And regarding P&W at adoration, I do not mean at perpetual adoration or all adoration "services" or whatever the correct term is. I honestly don't see why some singing would not be OK at say adoration at a high school retreat. I do not mean hands waving, dancing, drums and bongos, but singing and possibly guitars ever few mintues or so with silent prayer and contemplation in between. Why can't you praise and worship the Lord who is revealed right before you?[/quote] Ahem... the correct term is "djimbai". Who uses bongos
salterrae Posted July 17, 2008 Posted July 17, 2008 (edited) JM + JT I was hatin' in your emphases? I don't like bongos, or djembai or whatever, but mentioned it to add to the mental picture I wanted to create. They use 'em at the Spanish masses sometimes as a background sound - nothing too loud to get themselves kicked out. Oh, and I Googled djimbai - apparently it's [i]djembai[/i]. Edited July 17, 2008 by salterrae
pan!c139 Posted July 17, 2008 Posted July 17, 2008 I dunno...I just prefer the traditional music at Mass, minus the drums and guitars and whatnot. No fighting kids, emphasis belongs to everyone. ;-)
Apotheoun Posted July 17, 2008 Posted July 17, 2008 The Byzantine Churches do not use musical instruments during the liturgy.
salterrae Posted July 17, 2008 Posted July 17, 2008 (edited) JM + JT I really think it depends on the circumstances. On any given normal Sunday Mass, solemn music such as Gregorian Chant or any other approved and preferred music should be used. But, say, at a teen Mass, I think music more familiar to teens should be used - obviously with some restrictions and toning down so as not to forget or even ruin the sacredness of what is occuring. Now, I'm not saying that teens won't like Gregorian Chant, etc., as I myself would love to see it used at my own parish and school, but I think it unfair to say or insinuate that 99% of all P&W songs are inappropriate for use in Mass. Sure, there are some with lyrics not in line with Catholic teaching, so those can obviously be placed on the "no-no" list, but there are others that are either in-line or indifferent yet still appropriate. Just because we might have our own preferences and pet peeves towards other kinds of music doesn't give us the right to make another form of music almost blasphemous. I actually find it funny that I'm sort of backing (some) use of P&W in the Mass since I've always preferred more solemn and prayerful music (not to say that P&W styled music can't be prayerful. I've had many a good prayers while listening and contemplating on the words of P&W songs.). Edited July 17, 2008 by salterrae
pan!c139 Posted July 17, 2008 Posted July 17, 2008 Ya same here... Still.... I'd rather have that for Adoration and have Mass music just be traditional. Not to bash it tho, it's still good stuff.
salterrae Posted July 17, 2008 Posted July 17, 2008 JM + JT [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1602211' date='Jul 17 2008, 05:55 PM']The Byzantine Churches do not use musical instruments during the liturgy.[/quote] I knew I forgot to mention something. This is actually what I would personally prefer for Mass - the use of the natural instruments God gave us: our voices. This would include Gregorian Chant, no?
pan!c139 Posted July 17, 2008 Posted July 17, 2008 Indeed it would. Wonderful conclusion. I think we should start a petition to bring Gregorian Chant into Mass again.
salterrae Posted July 17, 2008 Posted July 17, 2008 (edited) JM + JT There's no need to petition, at least not in the signature and protest kind of way. Maybe a simple conversation with the pastor and the director of music would be the most charitable and quickest route? Now, how does one kindly tell the drummer at that teen Mass that the Lord would like him to use his gift elsewhere? (Which reminds me that I want to see if I can get the new priest at my school to celebrate - at least daily Mass - [i]ad orientem[/i], but let's attempt to keep this thread on-topic ) Edited July 17, 2008 by salterrae
pan!c139 Posted July 17, 2008 Posted July 17, 2008 Haha... (The petition was a joke!!!!) I dunno either just tell him to his face or kindly avoid the subject till it comes up with the rest of the band (or choir) after Mass or sumsing.
salterrae Posted July 17, 2008 Posted July 17, 2008 JM + JT [quote name='pan!c139' post='1602228' date='Jul 17 2008, 06:09 PM']Haha... (The petition was a joke!!!!)[/quote] Duh. [quote name='pan!c139' post='1602228' date='Jul 17 2008, 06:09 PM']I dunno either just tell him to his face or kindly avoid the subject till it comes up with the rest of the band (or choir) after Mass or sumsing.[/quote] Well, I'm not in the "band" that plays. I wonder, I wonder... You think Msgr. Marini would like to pay our parish and visit and MC a mass and leave them an example to follow? (Can you tell who my hero is? )
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now