pan!c139 Posted July 17, 2008 Posted July 17, 2008 Hahaha I like your thinking! Very nice, yeah tell the Msgr. to MC the Mass! The band needs a break anyways.
Noel's angel Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 I have a question. Well, two actually. !. Why should we have different music for 'teen' Masses? 2. Why do we even need 'teen' Masses? I don't want some baloney about making teens feel welcome in the Church etc.
salterrae Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 JM + JT It's nothing about the feeling of being welcome. Why [i]not[/i] have a teen Mass? The youth group meeting follows, so why not start it off with a Mass? And it isn't like the ushers check the ages of those entering to make sure they aren't passed their teenage years. The lectors are still adults, the only difference is that the youth group band handles the music.
XIX Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 I know, right? We don't need young adult Masses, or newlywed Masses, or senior citizen Masses, or Masses geared towards toddlers, or grade school Masses, or midlife crisis Masses. Why are teens (or the "youth") the only ones age group singled out as needing their own special liturgy and music? And I find it ridiculous when people insinuate that young people have an easier time relating to P&W. Where does that presupposition even come from? Is it because the music is relatively new? By that logic, you could say that only 1500 year old people like the Gregorian Chant. And I've been to lots of "youth Masses" and there generally aren't any more young people there than there are at any other Mass. I don't really understand what is so special about the P&W genre that makes it geared towards the youth. On a side note, it's kinda tragic that people refer to the Breaking Bread series is "traditional music." "Come dance in the forest come play in the fields" is not traditional music (it sounds a bit like a rejected Barney song actually). Tantum Egro Sacramentum is traditional. Salve Regina is traditional.
salterrae Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 JM + JT So new forms of prayer can't be formed? New forms of musical prayer can't be created and used? Is traditional the only way? And teen Masses can do a lot of good. I see most of my friends from school at the teen Mass and I meet new friends my age after seeing them Sunday after Sunday and at youth group after. My parish doesn't put on the bulletin: 5 PM - Teen Mass but the fact that we're more involved in the Mass with just the music so far does make it more of a teen Mass. What's so wrong about teens gathering together at the same Mass? Supporting eachother even by just merely being there. Singing music that sounds more familiar but still speaks the message that the more traditional and old songs do. Sure, some go too far, sure some songs and instruments don't belong, but that doesn't automatically make other kinds of P&W type music totally unacceptable for Mass. What happened to the moving of the Spirit to help the Church grow? It isn't like P&W will push out the use of more traditional songs. Tradition and growth/change can be balanced.
Noel's angel Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 (edited) Liturgical music is liturgical music and the wealth of wonderful music already held within the Church should be used at ALL Masses. Now, it would be wonderful if young people were encouraged to compose beautiful liturgical music, so that we could have 'contemporary-tradition'. But unfortunately, Catholics are drawing from their Protestant counter-parts and introducing what I would regard as unworthy music into the Liturgy. We have enough beautiful Catholic hymns to do us...why use anything else? Growth should only take place organically, and shouldn't deviate from the original essence. Edited July 18, 2008 by Noel's angel
salterrae Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 JM + JT Please do correct me if I'm wrong, but I feel some sort of biased coming from a lot of the posts going against pretty much all kinds of what has been called "Praise and Worship" music. You all seem to be so attached to the kind of music that has been used for so long - which I see nothing wrong with - but you take it as far to say that that all other kinds are "unworthy music [for] the Liturgy." I am not saying that we should throw out the old music for this newer kind, but it seems as though you're saying that if it isn't in the Hymn books it shouldn't be used. Why does praise have to be only with violins or acapelo? Quiet and soothing? Where's the happiness and joy during the Sunday celebration of the Resurrection? And I do understand that sometimes this familiar music can sort of take away the focus from the Sacrifice to this familiarity, but, if the right kind of music with the right lyrics is chosen it will remind those participating that the focus IS on the Sacrifice, the Lord, prayer, etc etc.
Noel's angel Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 I never said all contemporary music was unworthy. If you can find beautiful (in the true sense of beauty), liturgical music (in the true sense of liturgical), by all means use it. But, from what I have heard in my years of choir, there are far more modern hymns that shouldn't be brought near a church, than beautiful hymns. In matters of Liturgical music, I always turn to Pope Benedict for guidance: "There is light music which does not wish to say anything but only to break up the burden of silence. There is rationalistic music in which the tones serve only rational constructions but in which no real penetration of spirit and sensibility results. One would have to include many sterile catechism songs and modern hymns constructed under commission here. The music that corresponds to the liturgy of the incarnate Christ raised up on the cross lives from another, greater and broader synthesis of spirit, intuition, and sensuous sound. One can say that Western music, from Gregorian chant through the cathedral music and the great polyphony, through the renaissance and baroque music up until Bruckner and beyond, has come from the inner wealth of this synthesis and developed it in the fullness of its possibilities." “In the course of her two-thousand-year history, the Church has created, and still creates, music and songs which represent a rich patrimony of faith and love. This heritage must not be lost. Certainly as far as the liturgy is concerned, we cannot say that one song is as good as another.”
Guest KevinSymonds Posted July 19, 2008 Posted July 19, 2008 The so-called 'P&W' genre is completely inappropriate for the Roman Liturgy. There is no Magisterial document that says otherwise but there are documents that point to Gregorian Chant and Sacred Polyphony. I have also heard an argument along the lines of, "There is no Magisterial document specifying P&W music is wrong for the Mass". Such is bad logic. It is much like the rubrics in the Roman Missal. They are there for reason. For instance, just because the rubrics don't say we [i]can't[/i] raise our hands at Mass does not mean we [i]can[/i]. Say the [b][color="#000000"]black[/color][/b], do the [b][color="#FF0000"]red[/color][/b]. It's just that simple. Why must people feel this need to innovate the Liturgy? It is a sin to tinker with it! Peace! -KJS
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now