Jaime Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 I'm seeing statements like "pro-life doesn't equal conservative" floating around and it intrigues me. I agree that the pro-life position is not a "conservative only" position anymore. (which I think we should take as good news folks) However, I've been trying to engage people on this on various threads to no avail. So I'm just going to point blank ask Which is more important, voting conservative or voting for what's best for the pro-life movement?
CatherineM Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 Remember also that pro-life isn't just about abortion. It is about conception to a natural death. That includes issues like the death penalty, euthanasia, treatment of the disabled and elderly, and treatment of the most vulnerable, those people that were a focus of Christ's ministry while on Earth.
goldenchild17 Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 Voting pro-life is more important definitely. But one also has to consider (in my opinion) the long-term vs. short. Are we willing to concede a likely long-term defeat to the pro-choice movement in exchange for a very very slim chance at a minimal pro-life victory/stale-mate for the next 4-8 years? You might not see a long-term loss as likely. That's fine. I, on the other hand, don't see a McCain presidency to be beneficial to the pro-life movement either in the short or long-term. I have my reasons, and I'm sure you have yours. You might not see it this way, but I do believe both perspectives, both sides, are truly trying to vote pro-life the best way they see fit. I respect your position on this as a valid one. It would be nice if in turn our position wasn't looked down upon as a conservative vs. pro-life one, when in turn it is a pro-life one that we believe is best remedied by a strong conservative policy.
goldenchild17 Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1472864' date='Mar 3 2008, 09:53 AM']Remember also that pro-life isn't just about abortion. It is about conception to a natural death. That includes issues like the death penalty, euthanasia, treatment of the disabled and elderly, and treatment of the most vulnerable, those people that were a focus of Christ's ministry while on Earth.[/quote] Supporting the death penalty is fully within a Catholic's rights. You may be against it, but its certainly not fair to include that in the list of non-negotiables like abortion, contraception, euthanasia or stem-cell stuff etc.
Lounge Daddy Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 (edited) Of course life is the most important. To state the obvious, liberty and property don't mean jack-carp without life. I have been finding it intriguing when I hear people imply or assume that particular candidates are Conservatives simply because they are pro-life and Christian. Huckabee being a recent example. Is conservatism today now defined on only those principles? I understand that there is a younger generation of voters now who never really knew Reagan and Goldwater and the like, and I get that. But in recent years Christianity isn't a defining characteristic of a political Conservative. Reagan was very much a believing and sincere Christian, but I have heard Michael Reagan talk on his radio program about how his dad didn't go to church. I have heard Goldwater's faith questioned, and I have seen him listed among historical American atheists. Faith has been a defining characteristic in modern Conservatism. But not exclusively Christian faith. It could be faith in the individual; and thus, rejection of collectivism on the grounds that it denies the individual. A good friend of mine has always been very much a Conservative and very much pro-life -- and he is very much an atheist. Life is an important part of Conservatism, because the government is supposed to defend the individual from violence. But if Conservative is now becoming defined as simply pro-life and Christian, then I will stop calling myself a conservative. Not because I am not pro-life (I am), and not because I am not a Christian (I am); but because totalitarianism can deliver a Christian and pro-life government too. That's the kind of government that candidates like Huckabee promise. Ah well. At one time "Liberalism" meant defending life, individual liberty, property rights, and all the tax reduction and government reduction and pro business policies that went along with that. That's why Libertarians sometimes call themselves "classical liberals." Edited March 3, 2008 by Lounge Daddy
cmotherofpirl Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1472864' date='Mar 3 2008, 11:53 AM']Remember also that pro-life isn't just about abortion. It is about conception to a natural death. That includes issues like the death penalty, euthanasia, treatment of the disabled and elderly, and treatment of the most vulnerable, those people that were a focus of Christ's ministry while on Earth.[/quote] Abortion and euthenasia are not negotiable. The death penalty does not fall intop that category.
Fidei Defensor Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 I think for a person to be truly responsible, they ought not to vote "liberal" or "conservative" but on an issue by issue basis. Granted, I'll let you have your "non-negotiables" like abortion, but other than that, I think one ought to consider all other things equally and vote based on how each candidate best displays the values and policies that they believe in.
XIX Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 [quote name='hot stuff' post='1472838' date='Mar 3 2008, 10:37 AM']I'm seeing statements like "pro-life doesn't equal conservative" floating around and it intrigues me. I agree that the pro-life position is not a "conservative only" position anymore. (which I think we should take as good news folks) However, I've been trying to engage people on this on various threads to no avail. So I'm just going to point blank ask Which is more important, voting conservative or voting for what's best for the pro-life movement?[/quote] I vote B.
mommas_boy Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 [quote name='goldenchild17' post='1472917' date='Mar 3 2008, 12:43 PM']Supporting the death penalty is fully within a Catholic's rights. You may be against it, but its certainly not fair to include that in the list of non-negotiables like abortion, contraception, euthanasia or stem-cell stuff etc.[/quote] While the death penalty might not be a "non-negotiable" in regards to elections, the Catholic Church is still very clear on Her teaching regarding its application: While the death penalty is not intrinsically wrong, its application must be limited to "cases of extreme gravity" (CCC 2266). Further, all other options of containing a prisoner without bloodshed must be exhausted before the death penalty is applied: "If bloodless means are sufficient to defend human lives against an aggressor and to protect public order and the safety of person, public authority should limit itself to such means, because they better correspond to the concrete conditions of the common good and are more in conformity to the dignity of the human person." (CCC 2267). Here in America, the only permissible reasons to impose the death penalty on a prisoner would be if their containment and thus the protection of the public was not physically or financially possible. Note that society also has the responsibility to protect those in the prison where the criminal is kept, including both guards and other prisoners.
CatherineM Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 I guess I just got the wrong idea about the death penalty. I thought we were supposed to be against it because every time one was scheduled Pope John Paul would send a letter asking the governor to please commute the sentences. I guess that term paper I wrote on Evangelium Vitae was just a waste of time.
rkwright Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1473095' date='Mar 3 2008, 05:07 PM']I guess I just got the wrong idea about the death penalty. I thought we were supposed to be against it because every time one was scheduled Pope John Paul would send a letter asking the governor to please commute the sentences. I guess that term paper I wrote on Evangelium Vitae was just a waste of time.[/quote] I waste of time because of what you wrote on? Or just a waste of time as most term papers are?
mommas_boy Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1473095' date='Mar 3 2008, 05:07 PM']I guess I just got the wrong idea about the death penalty. I thought we were supposed to be against it because every time one was scheduled Pope John Paul would send a letter asking the governor to please commute the sentences. I guess that term paper I wrote on Evangelium Vitae was just a waste of time.[/quote] What's important is WHY the death penalty is wrong. For instance, the Church has always recognized that killing in the name of self-defense is permissible. Similarly, the death penalty is permissible only when its imposition defends others' lives. The reason why the popes have condemned the death penalty, and why it is wrong, is not because this theology has changed, but rather because the ability to punish a prisoner and protect the rest of society from them has increased. Thus, since we can hold a prisoner, we have less reason to fear for the safety of society, and thus there is no reason to execute them.
Jaime Posted March 3, 2008 Author Posted March 3, 2008 you people getting off topic and hijacking the thread is not helpful
goldenchild17 Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 hot stuff's right. We can't really discuss the death penalty fairly anyways since we are both coming from different aspects. I don't accept anything after Vatican II so nothing said since then that criticizes the death penalty will hold any water with me.
mommas_boy Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 [quote name='hot stuff' post='1473115' date='Mar 3 2008, 05:39 PM']you people getting off topic and hijacking the thread is not helpful[/quote] Sorry. Was just explaining ...
Carnanc Posted March 9, 2008 Posted March 9, 2008 I said conservative, because I believe that if you are conservative, then you have to be pro-life. the reverse is not always true, and thats a good thing like you said. in a November 14th, 2007 townhall interview with William F. Buckley, when asked what the most general definition of conservatism was, Buckley said, "Conservatism aims to maintain in working order the loyalties of the community to perceived truths and also to those truths which in their judgment have earned universal recognition. Now this leaves room, of course, for deposition, and there is deposition -- the Civil War being the most monstrous account. But it also urges a kind of loyalty that breeds a devotion to those ideals sufficient to surmount the current crisis. When the Soviet Union challenged America and our set of loyalties, it did so at gunpoint. It became necessary at a certain point to show them our clenched fist and advise them that we were not going to deal lightly with our primal commitment to preserve those loyalties. " I like this definition, and as I read it, the same thing that he said of the Soviet Union in this quote may be true of the culture of death as we experience it today. in other words, I think the average American believes in the cause of life, and understands that the right to life is part of the founding of this country, and that once more people come to understand that we will see a change away from the culture of death to a culture of life. That is, We need to educate people in conservative principles, perhaps most basically that morals matter, and that America should be strong in the world, and that the basic principles are country was built on are relevant today. Basically, I feel a conservative leader, who as I said is necessarily pro-life, will do the most by his personal character, and understanding of the greatness of this country, to advance the pro-life cause...
Jaime Posted March 9, 2008 Author Posted March 9, 2008 But you don't have a conservative to vote for this time around
Carnanc Posted March 9, 2008 Posted March 9, 2008 [quote name='hot stuff' post='1474619' date='Mar 9 2008, 03:21 PM']But you don't have a conservative to vote for this time around[/quote] no kidding...but the conservative movement is not dead; I'm going to concentrate on working some of the local congressional and senate races. just because conservatives lose the presidency this year, doesn't mean we should just throw everything away..
dairygirl4u2c Posted March 9, 2008 Posted March 9, 2008 we've tried getting them to admit they have to vote mccain, but they will simply rationalize that he's bent on keeping roe even though he's said otherwise, and everything else he's done, as for voting 115 out 120 prolife, is negligble. if they think it's a mortal sin to not vote prolife all the time as they often said in 2000 etc, they are voting themselves into damnation. we wouldn't be having this convo if romney won, evne though he was militant pro choice but two years ago. the media isn't telling them not to vote for him, so they don't dispute whether they have to. people who said that stuff back then but have changed, unless they admitt heir inconsistentcy, are jokes.
Carnanc Posted March 9, 2008 Posted March 9, 2008 about McCain, I'm sure you have all heard the list of conservative disagreements against him a thousand times by now, so I won't repeat it..is McCain pro-life?? to be honest, I have not come to a solid conclusion on that. I read that his decision to support embryonic stem cell research was a very difficult one, and I am pretty sure he does oppose abortion for the most part. I think its fair to say he is considerably more pro-life than Hillary or Obama, however. will I vote for McCain? probably, relunctanty yes, as long has he doesn't run too far to the left now that the primaries are over...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now