Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Which way will you vote  

49 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='slywakka250' post='1474610' date='Mar 9 2008, 02:48 PM']I said conservative, because I believe that if you are conservative, then you have to be pro-life.[/quote]

Two words: Barry Goldwater.

Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' post='1472838' date='Mar 3 2008, 09:37 AM']I'm seeing statements like "pro-life doesn't equal conservative" floating around and it intrigues me. I agree that the pro-life position is not a "conservative only" position anymore. (which I think we should take as good news folks) However, I've been trying to engage people on this on various threads to no avail. So I'm just going to point blank ask

Which is more important, voting conservative or voting for what's best for the pro-life movement?[/quote]
I voted "pro-life," though I'm really not sure what the point is here.
I certainly do not see conservatism and being pro-life as being opposed to one another, but rather I see the pro-life position as being part of true conservatism. By and large, it has been conservatism which upholds the sanctity of human life by opposing abortion, while the move to legalize abortion, and the "pro-choice" position have been causes of the Left.
This is in line with conservatism's philosophy of preserving traditional morality vs. liberalism's tendency to oppose traditional morality and promote a philosophy of moral relativism. The modern Democratic Party, with its embrace of "abortion rights" and "gay rights," is the Party of the Sexual Revolution.

According to Russell Kirk, an intellectual founder of the American conservative movement, belief in an "enduring moral order" is the first principle of conservatism:[quote]First, the conservative believes that there exists an enduring moral order. That order is made for man, and man is made for it: human nature is a constant, and moral truths are permanent.[/quote]
[url="http://www.kirkcenter.org/kirk/ten-principles.html#one"](Read more here.)[/url]

I'm not sure exactly what you're "trying to engage people on" here, as nobody's pitting conservatism against the pro-life cause.
It's not like we actually have pro-abortion conservatives running against pro-life liberals. And I haven't seen any conservatives here actually support abortion or pro-abortion candidates.

I've actually seen a lot more on here of liberals who put their liberalism above pro-life principles by insisting on supporting blatantly pro-abortion candidates like Obama.

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1474764' date='Mar 9 2008, 10:50 PM']I voted "pro-life," though I'm really not sure what the point is here.
I certainly do not see conservatism and being pro-life as being opposed to one another, but rather I see the pro-life position as being part of true conservatism. By and large, it has been conservatism which upholds the sanctity of human life by opposing abortion, while the move to legalize abortion, and the "pro-choice" position have been causes of the Left.
This is in line with conservatism's philosophy of preserving traditional morality vs. liberalism's tendency to oppose traditional morality and promote a philosophy of moral relativism. The modern Democratic Party, with its embrace of "abortion rights" and "gay rights," is the Party of the Sexual Revolution.

According to Russell Kirk, an intellectual founder of the American conservative movement, belief in an "enduring moral order" is the first principle of conservatism:
[url="http://www.kirkcenter.org/kirk/ten-principles.html#one"](Read more here.)[/url]

I'm not sure exactly what you're "trying to engage people on" here, as nobody's pitting conservatism against the pro-life cause.
It's not like we actually have pro-abortion conservatives running against pro-life liberals. And I haven't seen any conservatives here actually support abortion or pro-abortion candidates.

I've actually seen a lot more on here of liberals who put their liberalism above pro-life principles by insisting on supporting blatantly pro-abortion candidates like Obama.[/quote]


Well its pretty simple Soc so I'm not sure what you're not getting.

We will have one of two 100% prochoice candidates on the democratic side.

We will have John McCain who has a zero NARAL rating on the republican side and he's not conservative enough for conservatives.

We have a liberal SCJ that will either retire or die during the next presidency. We have four legitimately conservative justices now. One more tips the balance.

Bush's approval ratings make it even easier for a democrat to win this presidential campaign.

So quite literally, voting "conservative" (i.e. third party) is voting contrary to pro-life.


[quote]And I haven't seen any conservatives here actually support abortion or pro-abortion candidates.[/quote]

well then you have a problem with short term memory. Dismas had a thread (which you posted on) where he admits to voting for Hilary. Al and Dismas has a plethora of threads on how he's advocating for a democratic presidency (so the country can be left in ruins) which will bring "a true conservative".

So the question is which is more important? Conservatism or pro-life?

Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' post='1474908' date='Mar 10 2008, 08:31 AM']Well its pretty simple Soc so I'm not sure what you're not getting.

We will have one of two 100% prochoice candidates on the democratic side.

We will have John McCain who has a zero NARAL rating on the republican side and he's not conservative enough for conservatives.

We have a liberal SCJ that will either retire or die during the next presidency. We have four legitimately conservative justices now. One more tips the balance.

Bush's approval ratings make it even easier for a democrat to win this presidential campaign.

So quite literally, voting "conservative" (i.e. third party) is voting contrary to pro-life.
well then you have a problem with short term memory. Dismas had a thread (which you posted on) where he admits to voting for Hilary. Al and Dismas has a plethora of threads on how he's advocating for a democratic presidency (so the country can be left in ruins) which will bring "a true conservative".

So the question is which is more important? Conservatism or pro-life?[/quote]
Lord have mercy!

First of all, by your own admission, you yourself voted for Peroutka (a conservative third-party candidate) in the 2004 presidential election, rather than vote for Bush (and attacked those who did vote for Bush). That's all fine and well, except this year you are attacking people for doing the exact same thing you did.

So, in 2004, were you "voting contrary to pro-life," as you accuse conservative third-party voters of doing this year??
The situation this year is substantially no different.
Either your views on this matter have taken a 180 degree turn since 2004, or you are a hypocrite. Which is it?

It's really starting to look like you have no consistant principles, but just want to pick fights with PM conservatives, and attack them at every turn.

Dismas in the thread you speak of was not supporting Hillary for president, but for the Dem nominee, seeking to help sabatage the Party of Death by having them elect the less-electible of two pro-abort candidates. (If you want to argue that further, go to that thread)

And from what I've seen, neither Al nor Dismas advocated supporting Hillary or Obama for president - they were simply explaining why they thought a McCain presidency might not be the best thing for the pro-life movement ultimately.
And a large part of the concern is that McCain would not actually nominate pro-life justices in the face of Dem opposition.
Whether they are right or wrong, you are twisting their position.

I voted for Paul in my state primaries, but I may yet grit my teeth and vote McCain against Hillary Obama in the presidential election - I'll have to see how things shape up.

But in the mean-time I've had enough of your childish games, distortions, and out-and-out hypocrisy on these boards.

Lounge Daddy
Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' post='1474619' date='Mar 9 2008, 03:21 PM']But you don't have a conservative to vote for this time around[/quote]
Sure there are. Just not within the Democrat and Republican parties.

Lounge Daddy
Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1475376' date='Mar 10 2008, 10:24 PM']Lord have mercy!

First of all, by your own admission, you yourself voted for Peroutka (a conservative third-party candidate) in the 2004 presidential election, rather than vote for Bush (and attacked those who did vote for Bush). That's all fine and well, except this year you are attacking people for doing the exact same thing you did.

So, in 2004, were you "voting contrary to pro-life," as you accuse conservative third-party voters of doing this year??
The situation this year is substantially no different.
Either your views on this matter have taken a 180 degree turn since 2004, or you are a hypocrite. Which is it?

It's really starting to look like you have no consistant principles, but just want to pick fights with PM conservatives, and attack them at every turn.

Dismas in the thread you speak of was not supporting Hillary for president, but for the Dem nominee, seeking to help sabatage the Party of Death by having them elect the less-electible of two pro-abort candidates. (If you want to argue that further, go to that thread)

And from what I've seen, neither Al nor Dismas advocated supporting Hillary or Obama for president - they were simply explaining why they thought a McCain presidency might not be the best thing for the pro-life movement ultimately.
And a large part of the concern is that McCain would not actually nominate pro-life justices in the face of Dem opposition.
Whether they are right or wrong, you are twisting their position.

I voted for Paul in my state primaries, but I may yet grit my teeth and vote McCain against Hillary Obama in the presidential election - I'll have to see how things shape up.

But in the mean-time I've had enough of your childish games, distortions, and out-and-out hypocrisy on these boards.[/quote]

:shock: ooooooooooooogh! Nice points.

Posted

$10 says hot stuff is baiting you guys, and eventually he will come out and say he is voting some 3rd party candidate.


lol

Posted

it is very interesting just how many people have made 180 degree turns in their opinions on third party voting since the 2004 election... myself included... :popcorn:

Lounge Daddy
Posted

[quote name='notardillacid' post='1475723' date='Mar 11 2008, 01:42 PM']$10 says hot stuff is baiting you guys, and eventually he will come out and say he is voting some 3rd party candidate.
lol[/quote]

Bah, I think he's just sore that McCain lost to Bush for the nomination way back then and he grew to like Bush even less by 2004. So now hot stuff sees that McCain has another shot.

But I love that hot stuff. Maybe we can get together and buy him a McCain 2008 coffee mug or somethin' :)

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

I say vote your conscience. Integrity is more important than strategy, in my book.

Posted

I voted pro-life, and i assume now would be a good time to explain the change I myself have gone through in the past couple months.

I really don't understand why conservativism and the GOP claims the "pro-life" stance, when the Democratic party has always claimed to have been the party for the little guy, the helpless, and the lower class. It would seem as though the parties have for some reason switched roles when it comes to abortion.

I have many a time tried to defend conservativism as being the solution to the abortion crisis, but I no longer believe it is the case at all. I was wrong to have believed so.

I really think that the main argument between the Republicans and the Democrats is ALWAYS the economy. If abortion rights were not part of the party platforms, then pro-life vote would be for the Democratic party. All these other issues that the GOP throw into their stance are just to pad the party, and to gain votes, save perhaps a big, powerful military. There is no way the republicans would always be getting as many votes as they do if it weren't for a "pro-life" party stance. I put pro-life in quotations because I really don't think most of the republican scumbags who claim to be pro-life really are, because once they're in office they don't give a hang about the unborn, or the women who may feel pressured to procure an abortion.

I'm not saying that the democrats are inherently any better now - I think that a politician is a politician. But what's the difference between voting for a pro-choice democrat, and voting for a nominally pro-life republican? I'll tell you: the democrat will push for more of the social policies that will take pressure off of the woman who doesnt believe she can have her baby...

I'm not advocating a pro-choice vote. I refuse to vote pro-choice. I'm just sayin that we need to open our eyes.

And another thing. When we say "pro-life" are we referring to the "Catholic pro-life" or the "all-encompassing pro-life?" Because to be Catholic, you do not have to be against the death penalty, but I believe that to be fully pro-life, you [i]must[/i] oppose it in this day and age - especially in America. The pro-life criteria falls within Catholic teachings, but who's to say it cannot go the extra mile beyond what is asked by the Church?

I thought it would be the right time to let yall know that I am no longer a Republican, and no longer a conservative. I have given up on those principles, because in the end they only support the rich and those with a powerful lobby. But maybe I never believed in them in the first place. Maybe catholicinsd was always right. Maybe I was just drinkin the koolaid.

I can't wait to see how pleasantly suprised some of you are to hear all this ;)
sorry if my argument is all over the place, i had a lot to say and maybe i didnt use enough words to say it.

Posted

I have to agree with Didymus.

I am tired of being placed in groups that somehow are realted to other groups.

Although what I say is not as eloquently put as Didymus:
Being pro-life means you're conservative. Being conservative means that you vote Republican. Voting Republican means you are for the war. At least to the general public. This is not so. Someone can be pro-life and not be conservative. I am a nothing when it comes to political parties. Of course I always vote pro-life first. However, as Didymus says, those politicians who are "pro-life" are not really pro-life. They are either "the better of the two evils" or they are only half-way pro-lifers. Once in office, they do not care. They just want votes. I have seen enough in the debates to make me sick of politicans and their "stances".

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Didymus' post='1484663' date='Mar 26 2008, 09:52 AM']I voted pro-life, and i assume now would be a good time to explain the change I myself have gone through in the past couple months.

I really don't understand why conservativism and the GOP claims the "pro-life" stance, when the Democratic party has always claimed to have been the party for the little guy, the helpless, and the lower class. It would seem as though the parties have for some reason switched roles when it comes to abortion.

I have many a time tried to defend conservativism as being the solution to the abortion crisis, but I no longer believe it is the case at all. I was wrong to have believed so.[/quote]
First of all, as this debate and others should have made clear, the GOP and conservative principles are not always identical. McCain may be the GOP presidential nominee, yet I don't consider him a real conservative (though he is less liberal than Obama and Hillary).

The pro-life position is conservative because true conservatism defends moral principles, while liberalism tends to actively fight against "traditional morality" and has long promoted moral relativism and moral license (support of abortion, "gay rights," etc., etc.)

According to conservative philosopher Russell Kirk, belief in an "enduring moral order" is the first principle of conservatism.
[quote]First, the conservative believes that there exists an enduring moral order. That order is made for man, and man is made for it: human nature is a constant, and moral truths are permanent.[/quote]

[quote]I really think that the main argument between the Republicans and the Democrats is ALWAYS the economy. If abortion rights were not part of the party platforms, then pro-life vote would be for the Democratic party. All these other issues that the GOP throw into their stance are just to pad the party, and to gain votes, save perhaps a big, powerful military. There is no way the republicans would always be getting as many votes as they do if it weren't for a "pro-life" party stance. I put pro-life in quotations because I really don't think most of the republican scumbags who claim to be pro-life really are, because once they're in office they don't give a hang about the unborn, or the women who may feel pressured to procure an abortion.

I'm not saying that the democrats are inherently any better now - I think that a politician is a politician. But what's the difference between voting for a pro-choice democrat, and voting for a nominally pro-life republican? I'll tell you: the democrat will push for more of the social policies that will take pressure off of the woman who doesnt believe she can have her baby...

I'm not advocating a pro-choice vote. I refuse to vote pro-choice. I'm just sayin that we need to open our eyes.[/quote]
So what [i]are[/i] you advocating?

I know, politics and politicians generally smell of elderberries. Also in the news: the sun rose in the east this morning, and water has been linked to wetness.
There are plenty of no-good pols in both parties, but there are some pro-life statesmen with genuine principles, and these should be supported. Pro-life efforts often fail due to opposition from liberal Dems and unprincipled "moderate" Republicans.
And Republicans have certainly done more for the pro-life movement than have Democrats, who oppose any and all restrictions on abortion.
You're not offering anything constructive here, merely bitching and moaning.

And more government spending on "social programs" is not going to end abortion. Abortions have skyrocketed in this country since the government began vastly increasing spending on these programs since the mid-sixties.

[quote]And another thing. When we say "pro-life" are we referring to the "Catholic pro-life" or the "all-encompassing pro-life?" Because to be Catholic, you do not have to be against the death penalty, but I believe that to be fully pro-life, you [i]must[/i] oppose it in this day and age - especially in America. The pro-life criteria falls within Catholic teachings, but who's to say it cannot go the extra mile beyond what is asked by the Church?[/quote]
Your point being?

[quote]I thought it would be the right time to let yall know that I am no longer a Republican, and no longer a conservative. I have given up on those principles, because in the end they only support the rich and those with a powerful lobby. But maybe I never believed in them in the first place. Maybe catholicinsd was always right. Maybe I was just drinkin the koolaid.

I can't wait to see how pleasantly suprised some of you are to hear all this ;)
sorry if my argument is all over the place, i had a lot to say and maybe i didnt use enough words to say it.[/quote]
So do you have an argument? Sounds more like a rant with a lot of words but very little to say.

You've not really addressed conservative principles here at all, merely attacked the shortcomings of politicians, and spouted liberal slogans ("they only support the rich and those with a powerful lobby.")
I'm neither rich nor part of a powerful lobby, yet I fully support conservative principles. I believe in limited, constitutional government, the support of moral principles, and the preservation of what made our country great.

If you're really interested in learning about actual conservative principles (rather than a liberal caricature ), I'd suggest you read up on Russell Kirk's [url="http://www.kirkcenter.org/kirk/ten-principles.html"]Ten Conservative Principles[/url].

Edited by Socrates
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Didymus' post='1484663' date='Mar 26 2008, 10:52 AM']I voted pro-life, and i assume now would be a good time to explain the change I myself have gone through in the past couple months.

I really don't understand why conservativism and the GOP claims the "pro-life" stance, when the Democratic party has always claimed to have been the party for the little guy, the helpless, and the lower class. It would seem as though the parties have for some reason switched roles when it comes to abortion.

I have many a time tried to defend conservativism as being the solution to the abortion crisis, but I no longer believe it is the case at all. I was wrong to have believed so.

I really think that the main argument between the Republicans and the Democrats is ALWAYS the economy. If abortion rights were not part of the party platforms, then pro-life vote would be for the Democratic party. All these other issues that the GOP throw into their stance are just to pad the party, and to gain votes, save perhaps a big, powerful military. There is no way the republicans would always be getting as many votes as they do if it weren't for a "pro-life" party stance. I put pro-life in quotations because I really don't think most of the republican scumbags who claim to be pro-life really are, because once they're in office they don't give a hang about the unborn, or the women who may feel pressured to procure an abortion.

I'm not saying that the democrats are inherently any better now - I think that a politician is a politician. But what's the difference between voting for a pro-choice democrat, and voting for a nominally pro-life republican? I'll tell you: the democrat will push for more of the social policies that will take pressure off of the woman who doesnt believe she can have her baby...

I'm not advocating a pro-choice vote. I refuse to vote pro-choice. I'm just sayin that we need to open our eyes.

And another thing. When we say "pro-life" are we referring to the "Catholic pro-life" or the "all-encompassing pro-life?" Because to be Catholic, you do not have to be against the death penalty, but I believe that to be fully pro-life, you [i]must[/i] oppose it in this day and age - especially in America. The pro-life criteria falls within Catholic teachings, but who's to say it cannot go the extra mile beyond what is asked by the Church?

I thought it would be the right time to let yall know that I am no longer a Republican, and no longer a conservative. I have given up on those principles, because in the end they only support the rich and those with a powerful lobby. But maybe I never believed in them in the first place. [b]Maybe catholicinsd was always right. Maybe I was just drinkin the koolaid.[/b]

I can't wait to see how pleasantly suprised some of you are to hear all this ;)
sorry if my argument is all over the place, i had a lot to say and maybe i didnt use enough words to say it.[/quote]
April 1st isn't for a couple days still ;)

Edited by notardillacid

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...