Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

In my class's discussion of Roe v. Wade, a girl (somewhat a friend of mine) mentioned that she is Catholic, but her morality shouldn't be put on others - women still have a right to choose.

Should I talk to her about this? What should I say?

GuyWithAFoil
Posted

I think you should talk to her about it. I do not think morality is a matter of opinion, but rather what is right and wrong. The taking of a life, born or unborn, is wrong. That is the issue. There are many secular scientific studies that show human life beginning at conception. I think anyone who believes abortion is "okay" is simply in denial.

so does this mean women have no choice? no, of course not. But the choice was made long before the question of abortion comes into play. The choice was made when the child was conceived.

Posted

Explain to her that abortion is not a matter of morality. It is a matter of science. Once the science is there, it simply becomes a matter of murder.

Don't bring it up in a way that is attacking. Just being it up that what she said was really interesting to you.

filiusInFilio
Posted (edited)

read Peter Kreeft's apple argument...........you could print it out and give it to her or email it to her.....the comments above are good too

i think peter kreeft's argument is the best pro-life argument i've ever heard/read though

Edited by filiusInFilio
Posted

[quote name='filiusInFilio' post='1475715' date='Mar 11 2008, 12:11 PM']read Peter Kreeft's apple argument...........you could print it out and give it to her or email it to her.....the comments above are good too

i think peter kreeft's argument is the best pro-life argument i've ever heard/read though[/quote]

What is this argument?

Posted

[quote name='rkwright' post='1475683' date='Mar 11 2008, 08:52 AM']In my class's discussion of Roe v. Wade, a girl (somewhat a friend of mine) mentioned that she is Catholic, but her morality shouldn't be put on others - women still have a right to choose.

Should I talk to her about this? What should I say?[/quote]
show her this article: [url="http://ncregister.com/site/article/13870"]http://ncregister.com/site/article/13870[/url]

specifically:
[quote]The annual CBS News opinion poll on the legality of abortion gives people the following choices:

1. It should be permitted in all cases.

2. It should be permitted, but subject to greater restrictions than it is now.

3. It should be permitted only in such cases as rape, incest and to save the woman’s life.

4. It should only be permitted to save the woman’s life.

5. It never should be permitted.

For the last three years, 70% of people chose answers 2 through 5. That means 70% of Americans disagree with Roe v. Wade.

Under Roe, abortion cannot be prohibited or limited to cases of rape, incest, or life endangerment. And for those who want “greater restrictions” on abortion, Roe v. Wade stands in their way...[/quote]

Posted

[quote name='filiusInFilio' post='1475715' date='Mar 11 2008, 12:11 PM']read Peter Kreeft's apple argument...........you could print it out and give it to her or email it to her.....the comments above are good too

i think peter kreeft's argument is the best pro-life argument i've ever heard/read though[/quote]

Ok so I searched this argument... this is an incredible one!

But I might be missing something. It seems to me that it really boils down to, we know what humans are, humans have rights simply because we're human :. fetus has rights b\c its human.

But how do you respond to 'We don't know when the fetus is a human?' Is his response that we really know what humans are, just as we know what apples are?

BTW for anyone else thats never read the argument... here it is... by far the most 'air-tight' argument I've ever read!
[url="http://www.peterkreeft.com/topics-more/personhood_apple.htm"]http://www.peterkreeft.com/topics-more/personhood_apple.htm[/url]

Posted

Thanks for the replies, but some of them might be misplaced. This person is a catholic and does believe abortion is wrong, but doesn't believe it should be made illegal. So proving abortion is wrong isn't really the issue, its more about proving that the government should say its wrong.

This all sounds really dumb to me honestly, but I think this is the position of some of our Catholic politicians.

filiusInFilio
Posted

[quote name='rkwright' post='1475779' date='Mar 11 2008, 04:16 PM']Ok so I searched this argument... this is an incredible one!

But I might be missing something. It seems to me that it really boils down to, we know what humans are, humans have rights simply because we're human :. fetus has rights b\c its human.

But how do you respond to 'We don't know when the fetus is a human?' Is his response that we really know what humans are, just as we know what apples are?

BTW for anyone else thats never read the argument... here it is... by far the most 'air-tight' argument I've ever read!
[url="http://www.peterkreeft.com/topics-more/personhood_apple.htm"]http://www.peterkreeft.com/topics-more/personhood_apple.htm[/url][/quote]

yeah thats the way i understood it, we know what humans/fetuses are because we know what apples are....and its supported by the argument from skepticism giving the 4 cases of abortion...

GuyWithAFoil
Posted

[quote name='rkwright' post='1475829' date='Mar 11 2008, 06:51 PM']Thanks for the replies, but some of them might be misplaced. This person is a catholic and does believe abortion is wrong, but doesn't believe it should be made illegal. So proving abortion is wrong isn't really the issue, its more about proving that the government should say its wrong.

This all sounds really dumb to me honestly, but I think this is the position of some of our Catholic politicians.[/quote]

That is a more difficult argument. But if she believes that abortion is wrong, that doesn't it make sense for her to support her beliefs? I think that to say "abortion is wrong but the government shouldn't stop it" is weak. we know that murder is wrong, aren't we glad that murder is illegal?

Posted

Civilization is based on people recognizing that some things are right and wrong, and so we write laws to govern that. There are times when we mature as a society that we change what we consider to be wrong, but murder is one of the first we recognized. Our ideas about what constitute a murder have changed over time. Every change has happened by a group of people standing up to witness to it. I guess what I would tell your friend that it is a shame that someone with so much promise isn't willing to stand up for her morals. When people of good conscience do nothing, we are all lessened.

filiusInFilio
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1475887' date='Mar 11 2008, 09:24 PM']Civilization is based on people recognizing that some things are right and wrong, and so we write laws to govern that. There are times when we mature as a society that we change what we consider to be wrong, but murder is one of the first we recognized. Our ideas about what constitute a murder have changed over time. Every change has happened by a group of people standing up to witness to it. I guess what I would tell your friend that it is a shame that someone with so much promise isn't willing to stand up for her morals. When people of good conscience do nothing, we are all lessened.[/quote]


The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing.
-Edumund Burke

Posted

[quote name='rkwright' post='1475779' date='Mar 11 2008, 03:16 PM']Ok so I searched this argument... this is an incredible one!

But I might be missing something. It seems to me that it really boils down to, we know what humans are, humans have rights simply because we're human :. fetus has rights b\c its human.

But how do you respond to 'We don't know when the fetus is a human?' Is his response that we really know what humans are, just as we know what apples are?

BTW for anyone else thats never read the argument... here it is... by far the most 'air-tight' argument I've ever read!
[url="http://www.peterkreeft.com/topics-more/personhood_apple.htm"]http://www.peterkreeft.com/topics-more/personhood_apple.htm[/url][/quote]
Yeah. Peter Kreeft is 1337. I love his works.

[quote name='rkwright' post='1475829' date='Mar 11 2008, 05:51 PM']Thanks for the replies, but some of them might be misplaced. This person is a catholic and does believe abortion is wrong, but doesn't believe it should be made illegal. So proving abortion is wrong isn't really the issue, its more about proving that the government should say its wrong.

This all sounds really dumb to me honestly, but I think this is the position of some of our Catholic politicians.[/quote]
Get her to read the argument. Seriously. He talks about the duty of law in it... maybe her own convictions need re-affirming.

[quote name='filiusInFilio' post='1475902' date='Mar 11 2008, 08:54 PM']The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing.
-Edumund Burke[/quote]

:cool: RK, she needs to read it for the Edumund Burke quote.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='rkwright' post='1475829' date='Mar 11 2008, 04:51 PM']Thanks for the replies, but some of them might be misplaced. This person is a catholic and does believe abortion is wrong, but doesn't believe it should be made illegal. So proving abortion is wrong isn't really the issue, its more about proving that the government should say its wrong.

This all sounds really dumb to me honestly, but I think this is the position of some of our Catholic politicians.[/quote]
It's the typical liberal copout - trying to play both sides of the fence.

If the law does not protect innocent human life, it is worthless.
"I believe abortion is wrong, but the government shouldn't take away a woman's right to choose."
"I believe murder is wrong, but the government shouldn't take away a person's right to choose."
"I believe theft is wrong, but the government shouldn't take away a thief's right to choose."
"I believe rape is wrong, but the government shouldn't take away a rapist's right to choose."

Some choices are heinous crimes.

The only logically consistant conclusion of the "right to choose" or "we must not enforce our morality" argument is total anarchy.
Ironically, many liberals who hold the "right to choose" abortion to be inalienable, have no problem with laws restricting people's right to choose what they do with their money, to buy guns, to smoke, what to eat, etc., etc.

Edited by Socrates
KnightofChrist
Posted

[url="http://www.peterkreeft.com/audio/19_prolife-philosophy.htm"]http://www.peterkreeft.com/audio/19_prolife-philosophy.htm[/url]

Perhaps the same argument in audio form. The 2nd has better audio quality...

Posted

On Kreeft's argument, can anyone explain to me where lines #6 and 7 fit into the proof and what they're saying? Maybe I missing something, but they don't seem to be necessary for the proof?

KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

I am a bit confused as to which 6 and 7 lines you mean...

[i]Preaching to the choir is a legitimate enterprise. Scripture calls it [/i]

or

[i]only philosophers, scholars, "experts," media mavens, professors, journalists, and mind-molders dare to claim that we do not know what an apple is.[/i]

or have I misunderstood completely?

Edited by KnightofChrist
Posted

Sorry, further down in the proof.

6. Morality Is Based on Metaphysics

7. Moral Arguments Presuppose Metaphysical Principles


I understand these principals, but I don't see how they fit in the argument as a whole.

KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

I believe he makes this clearer in the audio I linked. 6 If we know that the child is real, a real child then that child has rights, not to be kill or hurt. But if we know the fetus is not a child, not human it does not have rights, and can be done away with, but in the audio he seems to ask how do we "know" have we seen an abortion to know that fetus is not a child? 7 But if we do not know what the reality is we can not kill or do away with the child, in the audio he uses a story of a insect extinguisher about to flood a building with toxic gas, but does not know if anyone is left in the building yet goes ahead. He also uses a story of a hunter blindly shooting something behind a bush, but doesn't know if it is a deer or not.

He also ties this in with a SCOTUS ruling I forget which, which stated basicly since we dont know when life begins abortion is ok. Which is ridiculous, as Mr Kreeft points out.

If I dont make any sense try and listen to the audio

[url="http://www.peterkreeft.com/audio/19_prolife-philosophy.htm"]http://www.peterkreeft.com/audio/19_prolife-philosophy.htm[/url]

Edited by KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1476000' date='Mar 11 2008, 10:41 PM']I believe he makes this clearer in the audio I linked. 6 If we know that the child is real, a real child then that child has rights, not to be kill or hurt. But if we know the fetus is not a child, not human it does not have rights, and can be done away with, but in the audio he seems to ask how do we "know" have we seen an abortion to know that fetus is not a child? 7 But if we do not know what the reality is we can not kill or do away with the child, in the audio he uses a story of a insect extinguisher about to flood a building with toxic gas, but does not know if anyone is left in the building yet goes ahead. He also uses a story of a hunter blindly shooting something behind a bush, but doesn't know if it is a deer or not.

He also ties this in with a SCOTUS ruling I forget which, which stated basicly since we dont know when life begins abortion is ok. Which is ridiculous, as Mr Kreeft points out.

If I dont make any sense try and listen to the audio

[url="http://www.peterkreeft.com/audio/19_prolife-philosophy.htm"]http://www.peterkreeft.com/audio/19_prolife-philosophy.htm[/url][/quote]

That case is Roe v. Wade actually.

I think those examples are talking more about his principal 13. But I did listen to the audio and got a better understanding of.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...