Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

KnightofChrist
Posted

Well, then it maybe how it ties it together, but I am curious could you explain your understanding now that it is clearer? :bigthink:

Posted (edited)

Well I read the transcript of the first audio, and I think principals 6 and 7 are referring to the morality of legislating anti-abortion laws. People might say 'even if you prove its a human, you can't push your morality on everyone else'. 6 says that morality is based on metaphysical realities, so what is right and wrong is based on the fetus being in reality a person. 7 I feel is kinda a rehash of 6, refuting the claim we can only have opinions on morality, not a true morality.

I gathered that from the following in the transcription (note it might not be the best, and I could be wrong on this, but it seems like this is where he is applying 6 and 7)
[quote]The conclusion of this argument is, of course, that if it's always wrong to deliberately kill an innocent person, and if abortion deliberately kills an innocent person, then abortion is always wrong. Always. Just as rape is always wrong. There's an addition to the argument, a third premise that you can add, that brings it into the social, political, and legal area. Some people will say, "There's nothing wrong with this argument, but I still don't want to legally force my views on people who don't agree with me. I'm personally opposed to abortion, but I wouldn't make it illegal."

So, why do I also believe not only that it is immoral, but that it ought to be illegal? Not everything that's immoral ought to be illegal. The structure of legal reasoning has a moral premise, but then it has a legal premise. If a thing is not morally bad, we don't want to prohibit it by law. But some things are morally bad that we don't want to prohibit by law. Maybe smoking is morally bad, maybe it's irresponsible. I don't think there should be a law against smoking. Maybe not wearing a seatbelt is bad, irresponsible. I don't know whether it's a good idea or not, but I'm sympathetic to those that say there shouldn't be a law about seatbelts. I don't think smoking marijuana's a good idea, but I'm not sure whether illegalizing it is a good idea or not; maybe so, maybe not.

So, you have to add a legal premise to the moral premise, to get a conclusion that this thing that is morally ought also to be legally prohibited. All right, so what's the purpose of law? Law is to protect people. If law doesn't do that minimal job, it's not doing anything. Law has to at least protect the innocent and weak against the guilty and strong. Nobody seriously maintains that there shouldn't be laws against theft, rape, or slavery, because those are clearly cases of misusing human beings, oppression. Well, the legal premise that can be added to this argument is that the law must protect the rights of the innocent and weak against the powerful and strong. Well, if abortion is killing a person, and if that person is innocent and weak, shouldn't he be protected?[/quote]

I personally think the transcription is a better version of the same argument.

Edited by rkwright
Posted

In the second audio file, he explains it similarly; even if the fetus is a person, you still have to prove morality of protecting it. Morality is based in metaphysical reality, so then the morality of protecting the fetus comes from the fetus actually being a human.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...