Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Hi, pham--

If you'd all keep the diocese of Camden, NJ in your prayers in the coming days, I think we could all use it. Tomorrow, the bishop is announcing his final decisions about the future of the Church in South Jersey. Parishes will be merging, reconfiguring, and closing. Priests are going to be reassigned...people are going to switch parishes.

This has been a very in-depth, detailed process that involved the laity as well as clergy. It's taken a year and a half, so I can only hope that things resolve as they're best able.

I got all my Sacraments except for baptism with my parish, and returned last year after a long time away from God. It's hard to think of possibly losing my parish, or worse, my priests--either one of them, but my confessor particularly.

Have any of you gone through this in your own diocese? I'm sure the adjustment period is going to be very hard on everyone, but it will be better for us in the end. It's waiting it out that will be difficult...

Please pray it goes over with as little turbulence as possible. :)

Thanks, all!
Pax Christi,
Melissa

Edited by MissyP89
Posted

Hmm...

I wonder what the trend is as far as keeping the older traditional buildings as opposed to the more modern style buildings. I would hope that they take this into consideration when deciding which parishes will close or merge.

Has anybody else's diocese been through this, and if so, what was the general feeling around that?

farglefeezlebut
Posted

*Prayers*

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='dust (the ultra-handsome' post='1491210' date='Apr 2 2008, 05:09 PM']Hmm...

I wonder what the trend is as far as keeping the older traditional buildings as opposed to the more modern style buildings. I would hope that they take this into consideration when deciding which parishes will close or merge.

Has anybody else's diocese been through this, and if so, what was the general feeling around that?[/quote]

Yes, the Diocese of Steubenville just went through it. They closed all abut 2 parishes and are building a new Cathedral. They left St. Peter's open which still has a high altar and communion rails. It is very beautiful and where most of us who could not go to the TLM worship. They also left one of the newer parishes, Holy Family open, but it is by no means an "ugly" parish. Its a bit too modern for my tastes, but you still felt like you were in a Catholic parish.

Our Catholic Diocese of Lansing is going through the process now. We are a very large diocese though, so closings are going to depend primarily on the populations of different cities and different needs based on the number of priests we have.

Posted

Our Archdiocese has been closing and merging like crazy.

Basically it goes like this:

Churches, frankly, need to be closed or merged for whatever reason.
Announcement.
Lots of people protest and complain.
Church is closed.

On merges it usually angers people because they have to travel a bit further to a central church.

We don't really have any "cathedrals" per se around here, but the new church build for one of our mergers is gorgeous and traditional.

It is sad, but it is what needs to be done. From what I see the people who are harmed the most are seniors who can't travel to make it to the new parishes. That is super sad to see.

Posted

Is the main problem a financial one?

Posted

The plan is for our parish to absorb two others, one east and one west of us. The one to the west is in a really bad area. People don't like going there because homeless sleep on the grounds. The one to the east is newer, but smaller than ours. I was told the decision to keep ours open was because it had a bigger hall, and had an elevator added to make it completely accessible. This plan has been in place for many years. They even combined our women's group with the one to the east to make the transition easier. I was told they were going to let the two elderly priests at those parishes to stay until retirement, and when they did, that would be when the parish was closed. Well, nothing has happened. Our women's group finally split back off and rechartered this year.

I don't know it they are going ahead with the plan, or have changed their mind. It seems as if all three churches are limping along. We don't even have enough money in the budget to pay organists, so we have to have amateur fill ins, and the music ministry is frustratingly bad at times. We have plywood covering one of the windows. Our new pastor is from India, and while a great guy, he is scheduled to return to India in 3 years, so that doesn't sound too stable either. I just wish that the powers that be would be plain, and concise on what is going to happen, why it is happening, and exactly when to expect it. It is really hard to plan long term otherwise.

Theologian in Training
Posted

The problem stems from two things:

Finances and the fact that there were a lot of parishes founded based on culture, that is, there would be an "Irish" parish an "Italian" parish and a "Polish" parish two blocks away from each other. In this day and age, it is not practical to do that type of thing.

But, the biggest problem is always finances...if the parish does not make money, or draw people, then it becomes "irrelevant," sadly.

Autumn Dusk
Posted

This is an issue especally in the northeast where people had parishes based on ethnicity.

In my friend's dioceses there are alot of refigurations going on. One is in a parish where there are polish and Italians. The italians hated the polish so much when a polish priest was assigned to their church the italians asked the dioceses to remove him. Those churches are now being combined b/c the bishop sais he will not allow such goings on in his dioceses.

Then their is my parish, its being combined with two others and we're getting a new church. Its REALLY good because one church is old and way, WAY too tiny, the other is post vatican II and really poorly designed, and the third is o.k. but needs many fixes.

While a building does mean alot its best in many cases if churches are combined. Extra-large churchs are not very "green" and smaller parishes just aren't big enough.

Posted

The problem in my diocese, Richmond Va, is the severe shortage of priests. Our priest has 3 parishes he is responsible for. He is never available, always on the road. A very diffiicult situation. Now they are talking about reorganizing again, so we may have even less priestly coverage. Very sad indeed, as there are no religioius in this area either. I feel so cut off from my religion.

Posted

wow. I will pray for your diocese. I can't even imagine this happening. The growth down here is amazing. Our diocese is expandind and the Churched are trying to figure out how to fit more people in. Sorry to hear that about your home parish.

Posted

I have heard that maintaining the older buildings is very expensive. But some these modern churches really leave a lot to be desired.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='alicemary' post='1491389' date='Apr 2 2008, 07:09 PM']The problem in my diocese, Richmond Va, is the severe shortage of priests. Our priest has 3 parishes he is responsible for. He is never available, always on the road. A very diffiicult situation. Now they are talking about reorganizing again, so we may have even less priestly coverage. Very sad indeed, as there are no religioius in this area either. I feel so cut off from my religion.[/quote]

The Diocese of Richmond is definately in need of priests, already they're talking about merging a couple parishes in the western part of my county and the neighboring one, due primarily to the lack of priests. Our parish priest operates two parishes, which are a 45 minute drive apart from one another [b]and he does daily Mass for both of them[/b]. Same can be said for the east neighboring county, where another priest is faced with an almost identical situation.

[b]Almost forgot:[/b] There's a parish in this part of the state, that does not even have a [b]regularly scheduled visiting priest![/b] Once in a great while they have a priest visit to say Mass, but they usually conduct communion services throughout most of the year, if that... :( . Other than that, the parish is practically dead.

Edited by Paladin D
Posted

Why do you suppose people aren't going to mass?

Posted

[quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1491343' date='Apr 2 2008, 04:53 PM']there were a lot of parishes founded based on culture, that is, there would be an "Irish" parish an "Italian" parish and a "Polish" parish two blocks away from each other. In this day and age, it is not practical to do that type of thing.[/quote]
Yah, my hometown is only 2.5 square miles, and it had four parishes, one French, another Polish, and the other two more general, but one of them now has a large Hispanic and Asian community. The French parish was closed a few years ago. The Polish parish is still alive, but it's probably the smallest of the three remaining parishes. But they each have their own Priest, so we are fortunate.

Posted (edited)

No idea how my diocese is doing... I think things are still hanging on... we're getting vocations, that's for sure.

We'll have 9 seminarians in September, unless some are getting ordained :cool:

Edited by Sacred Music Man
Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1491335' date='Apr 2 2008, 04:35 PM']Is the main problem a financial one?[/quote]

This is my diocese too. The main problem is the priest shortage.

"The diocese projects that by 2015 there will be half the 171 diocesan priests the diocese had in ministry in the diocese in 2005. Last month the diocese reported that there are 162 diocesan priests now in ministry."

I cannot imagine my parish being closed. If anything, someone will merge with us. We just had a capital campaign to build a new church.

Posted

[quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1491343' date='Apr 2 2008, 05:53 PM']The problem stems from two things:

Finances and the fact that there were a lot of parishes founded based on culture, that is, there would be an "Irish" parish an "Italian" parish and a "Polish" parish two blocks away from each other. In this day and age, it is not practical to do that type of thing.

But, the biggest problem is always finances...if the parish does not make money, or draw people, then it becomes "irrelevant," sadly.[/quote]

I know that's the situation here basically. There used to be Italian parishes, Irish parishes, and a Polish parish. However as things grew tighter financially, and with the priest shortage, they went merger happy over the last half century or so.

johnnydigit
Posted

prayers. just remember, the source and summit of our faith is the Eucharist. so whatever the trial and wherever you end up, just remember you're there for the Eucharist, and it helps to keep in mind those who barely even have a church to go to.

[img]http://defiant.corban.edu/gtipton/net-fun/maz-poor.JPG[/img]

Posted

Milwaukee is doing it too. From what I've heard they're working on linking all the parishes. We're going to be linked with another parish, sharing a pastor and an associate and a parish council.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...