RandomProddy Posted April 3, 2008 Posted April 3, 2008 [quote name='dust (the ultra-handsome' post='1491210' date='Apr 2 2008, 08:09 PM']Has anybody else's diocese been through this, and if so, what was the general feeling around that?[/quote] My diocese lost it's right to have a standing army at the end of the middle ages, which smells of elderberries
LouisvilleFan Posted April 3, 2008 Posted April 3, 2008 [quote name='MissyP89' post='1491205' date='Apr 2 2008, 03:04 PM']Have any of you gone through this in your own diocese? I'm sure the adjustment period is going to be very hard on everyone, but it will be better for us in the end. It's waiting it out that will be difficult...[/quote] The Archdiocese of Louisville had a lot of mergers and reconfigurations 10-15 years ago and is now going through another phase of it, but I think most of it in the urban area where parishes were/are somewhat overbuilt. My parish is one of three that's merging, and these are three of the oldest in the diocese, so that's just a big mess that I prefer to avoid. In another neighborhood, five parishes are merging into one! [quote name='Brother Adam' post='1491301' date='Apr 2 2008, 04:48 PM']Yes, the Diocese of Steubenville just went through it. They closed all abut 2 parishes and are building a new Cathedral.[/quote] Are you saying the Diocese of Steubenville has only two parishes plus the cathedral??? With the university there, you'd think they'd be growing. [quote name='prose' post='1491328' date='Apr 2 2008, 05:21 PM']We don't really have any "cathedrals" per se around here, but the new church build for one of our mergers is gorgeous and traditional.[/quote] Without a cathedral, where's the bishop gonna sit? Anybody here from the Diocese of Kansas City? I remember looking up some statistics where they especially stood out in conversions, with by far the highest growth rate in parishioners through their RCIA. I've never met anyone from there or heard much from that area, but figure they must be doing something right.
prose Posted April 3, 2008 Posted April 3, 2008 We have one main basillica, but that is pretty well the extent of it. Edmonton is basically surrounded by tonnes of rural community, so most churches are wooden (attempts at being traditional with what they ahd to work with) or modern (rural Churches built as Edmonton grew. Many of our rural churches are closing as priests are, understandably, finding it hard to do Masses in churches that are an hour or more apart, so we are starting to be more condensed into the rural, more modern Churches. Not to say they are all like that, but that just seems to be how it is working. Like I said earlier, it is unfortunate though, that several seniors from rural communities are starting to be in a situation where they can no longer attend Mass. They just don't have the ability (or resources) to travel an hour to an urban center for Mass, so they are the ones (I think) being hurt the most from this.
MissyP89 Posted April 3, 2008 Author Posted April 3, 2008 Well, 24 parishes are closing, and there are a whole mess of mergers going on, according to local news. The trouble is that the diocese website apparently couldn't handle the increased traffic and has been crashed for most of the day. Looks like I'm going to be waiting it out...
Andrea348 Posted April 3, 2008 Posted April 3, 2008 [quote name='MissyP89' post='1492111' date='Apr 3 2008, 06:18 PM']Well, 24 parishes are closing, and there are a whole mess of mergers going on, according to local news. The trouble is that the diocese website apparently couldn't handle the increased traffic and has been crashed for most of the day. Looks like I'm going to be waiting it out...[/quote] I read about it on the web of the local newspaper. My parish is going to merge with a mission church (not surprised) and another large parish once they build a new church. They were just created in 2000 and only have a rectory and parish center. My church is a smaller old building, but we were approved by the diocese to build a new church. I guess the new church will be a new church for the merged parish at the site of the new one. The part that stinks the most is during the capital campaign we exceeded the financial goal, which is great, but I think a lot of people will take back what they are donating since it will be a merged church. I could definitely see my grandparents go that way.
MissyP89 Posted April 3, 2008 Author Posted April 3, 2008 [quote name='Andrea348' post='1492213' date='Apr 3 2008, 08:49 PM']I read about it on the web of the local newspaper. My parish is going to merge with a mission church (not surprised) and another large parish once they build a new church. They were just created in 2000 and only have a rectory and parish center. My church is a smaller old building, but we were approved by the diocese to build a new church. I guess the new church will be a new church for the merged parish at the site of the new one. The part that stinks the most is during the capital campaign we exceeded the financial goal, which is great, but I think a lot of people will take back what they are donating since it will be a merged church. I could definitely see my grandparents go that way.[/quote] We are merging with an older parish, with most of the activity going on at my parish, which was built in the 60s. Andrea, check your private messages.
mortify Posted April 4, 2008 Posted April 4, 2008 What's scary is that there may come a time where receiving the sacraments will mean relocating.
Autumn Dusk Posted April 4, 2008 Posted April 4, 2008 [quote name='mortify' post='1492277' date='Apr 3 2008, 10:47 PM']What's scary is that there may come a time where receiving the sacraments will mean relocating.[/quote] My good friend, a priest named Padre, laughs when this is suggested. He cares for two parishes and when people ask him what gives him the stamina he sais the faithful in Africa and South America who have only one priest for upwards of 10,000 people over distances of a hundred miles. If anything, we'll get more roving priests. Americans were very spoiled by the influx of priests with Irish, Italian, Polish and German immigration. They were then spoiled by drive for vocations that these churches produced, weither they be true vocations or not. This drive for vocations, in my opinion, allowed for the scandals that marred us less than 10 years ago. That, and the baby-boom has somewhat aided in the church's not re-configuring earlier. The spread of parishes also has to do with de-urbanization, eg, the suburbs and "country" sprawl. People are now less likely to live in big cities, or even any cities, especially when raising a family. So they start to sprawl out over many miles. Churches in cities are taking big hits because of decentralized population...people may work in a city but they don't want to go back into a city on a Sunday for Mass. If they go to church at all they want it in their suburb. And suburbs are strange places of homes and grocers and de-centralized sprawls have even less well-defined boundaries. Plus, is it really right for the catholic church to have 8 churches in a 4.5 mile radius? This is common in some smaller, legacy cities. For both ethnic and social class reasons. It really doesn't seem like good stewardship to me. And while these parishes now double up on priest thats using 4 priests, plus 5 or 6 retired, thats [b]10 priests [/b] (albeit most are retired) [b] for an area less than 5 miles wide!!!![/b] If reduced to even 2 parishes alot of burden could be taken off the priests. Then you have truly rural parishes with one priest for 25+ miles. This priest is almost always alone and dosn't have the benefit of living with another priest, or even being a reasonable distance from one, and as priests age this really is a sad thing. I'm against ethnic parishes, more than parishes split by music tastes. I'm not against a mass being said in spanish, or french or italian, but these populations hold on to an ethnic identity and so defend it they are not really open to the faith. I'm actually glad to see some churches "reconfigured" Of course in rural areas it hurts those who have to drive farther, but as my mom pointed out we already drive 8 miles to mass, three more won't hurt us.
prose Posted April 4, 2008 Posted April 4, 2008 [quote]My good friend, a priest named Padre, laughs when this is suggested. He cares for two parishes and when people ask him what gives him the stamina he sais the faithful in Africa and South America who have only one priest for upwards of 10,000 people over distances of a hundred miles. If anything, we'll get more roving priests.[/quote] I think you are wrong. Priests here do not want to travel. They simply close churches that are too far away. They simply are unable to do that much travelling, so they choose the most central and urban Church and close the rural ones. That is where we are taking the most closures. "Farm" Churches. Do some priests travel lots and cater to many Churches? Sure. But not all priests are capable of that. In the end, people, ESPECIALLY seniors, are simply not getting their sacraments. Even at the retirement home that my grandmother was in, pastoral care was not bringing her the Eucharist because it was too far away. And she isn't the only one. I can't imagine having more than one priest. We have a large parish (2400+ families), and we have one priest. No deacon. We also have another retired priest that helps with Masses, but that is it. I can think of only one Church in our city area that has more than one priest.
Lil Red Posted April 4, 2008 Posted April 4, 2008 [quote name='alicemary' post='1491389' date='Apr 2 2008, 04:09 PM']The problem in my diocese, Richmond Va, is the severe shortage of priests. Our priest has 3 parishes he is responsible for. He is never available, always on the road. A very diffiicult situation. Now they are talking about reorganizing again, so we may have even less priestly coverage. Very sad indeed, as there are no religioius in this area either. I feel so cut off from my religion.[/quote] +J.M.J.+ in the rural areas of my state, each priest has at least 2 parishes, and 2 mission churches. and a 45 minute drive between them is a short drive. they're looking at more like a 1 1/2 to 3 hour drive. but the priests in my diocese are still willing to do it because there are still faithful people who want Mass.
Deo Iuvente Posted April 5, 2008 Posted April 5, 2008 I lost my old parish in 2005. It was merged with a parish a few blocks away, then that new parish was taken over by Franciscans. I moved a few blocks away, and now I have another new parish, it's doing well, (Producing vocations, and still growing.) so I doubt we'll be closing, thanks be to God. We just started out capital campaign a few months ago, to restore the convent, and fix the windows (The church is over 100 years old) I can only think of one reason why a parish in the middle of inner city Philadelphia would be growing.(Liturgy) There are some parishes that I can really see need to be closed, but for some reason have not.
Autumn Dusk Posted April 5, 2008 Posted April 5, 2008 [quote name='prose' post='1492475' date='Apr 4 2008, 11:55 AM']I think you are wrong. Priests here do not want to travel. They simply close churches that are too far away. They simply are unable to do that much travelling, so they choose the most central and urban Church and close the rural ones. That is where we are taking the most closures. "Farm" Churches. Do some priests travel lots and cater to many Churches? Sure. But not all priests are capable of that. In the end, people, ESPECIALLY seniors, are simply not getting their sacraments. Even at the retirement home that my grandmother was in, pastoral care was not bringing her the Eucharist because it was too far away. And she isn't the only one. I can't imagine having more than one priest. We have a large parish (2400+ families), and we have one priest. No deacon. We also have another retired priest that helps with Masses, but that is it. I can think of only one Church in our city area that has more than one priest.[/quote] Point is, Americans are spoiled. Sure, priests don't want to travel, but thats becuase of the historic influx and how priests are accustomed to living in America.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now