cappie Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 A Peruvian cardinal has banned the practice of receiving Communion in the hand in his diocese to guard against devaluing the Eucharist, an Italian website has reported. Opus Dei Cardinal Juan Luis Cipriani Thorne told Petrus: "I maintain that the best way to administer Communion is on the tongue, so much so that in my diocese I have forbidden the host in the hand." The cardinal, who is Archbishop of Lima and a member of the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, said that "the relaxed attitude of many priests" was to blame for a decline in reverence for the Eucharist among the faithful. "In Masses with great attendance, in the past we even found hosts thrown on to the pavement of the church," he added. A missionary priest working in Lima told The Tablet the ban "would only apply to his jurisdiction of the Archdiocese of Lima". "The remainder of the dioceses around Lima would not go for such a practice," he said. [url="http://thetablet.co.uk/articles/11362/"]http://thetablet.co.uk/articles/11362/[/url]
Deus te Amat Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 I wish MY diocese would do that. Receiving on the tongue is so much more personal.
Lil Red Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 [quote name='Deus_te_Amat' post='1511908' date='Apr 27 2008, 04:48 PM'] I wish MY diocese would do that. Receiving on the tongue is so much more personal.[/quote] +J.M.J.+ and yet it is still allowed, according to the USCCB and the GIRM.
Deus te Amat Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 Yeah well, there are reasons why opinions are just that... opinions.
Lil Red Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 (edited) +J.M.J.+ ever heard the one about opinions and well, never mind Edited April 27, 2008 by Lil Red
Deus te Amat Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 Um... I think that receiving on the tongue should be encouraged and more widely used. However, I don't really think that people should be forced to do so. --Just clarifying my initial comment.
CatherineM Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 St. Cyril talked about receiving the Eucharist on the hand back in the 300's, and I'm pretty sure the Apostles handled the first Eucharist with their hands too. I don't believe that receiving it on my hand makes me any less reverent. If he's concerned that his priests aren't being reverent enough, then he has a whole different set of problems.
Deus te Amat Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 I grew up receiving on the hand, and I still do so when I am sick. However, I think that receiving on the tongue should be more encouraged. I didnt even know people received on the tongue until a few years ago.
Laudate_Dominum Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1511910' date='Apr 27 2008, 05:49 PM']+J.M.J.+ and yet it is still allowed, according to the USCCB and the GIRM. [/quote] It isn't up to the USCCB, it is up to the individual bishop to permit or prohibit the practice. Communion on the tongue on the other hand is always permitted and cannot be prohibited by a bishop. The Communion on the hand agenda is a disgrace.
Laudate_Dominum Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1511934' date='Apr 27 2008, 06:14 PM']St. Cyril talked about receiving the Eucharist on the hand back in the 300's, and I'm pretty sure the Apostles handled the first Eucharist with their hands too. I don't believe that receiving it on my hand makes me any less reverent. If he's concerned that his priests aren't being reverent enough, then he has a whole different set of problems.[/quote] What St. Cyril describes is not the same as modern Communion on the hand and this is not exactly relevant to the modern issues anyway. The fact that x, y or z happened in the early Church is not the reason why we have such things today. Women were bound to cover their heads in church up until 1983 and yet I doubt you would accept this fact as a compelling reason why we should revive this practice today. Similarly, in St. Cyril's time men and women were separated at the liturgy but if I were to invoke this historical fact I do not think that this alone would convince you of the wisdom or necessity of such a practice today. If one were to desire including a drink of milk and honey at Communion I suppose a show of antiquarian enthusiasm would be insufficient in demonstrating the appropriateness of such a revival in our time. But again, modern Communion on the hand follows the Protestant pattern and not that which St. Cyril and others describe (St. Cyril was not even a Roman Christian btw). If being more like the early Church was really important we would have more fasting after Vatican II and not virtually none. The early sources on Roman liturgy indicate a number of things such as the congregation kneeling during baptisms and the like which would be cool. Also the early baptismal rites include very strong prayers of exorcism and yet the "modern" rite has almost done away with the exorcism entirely. My point is that time and time again the changes in the so-called "modern" Church have very little to do with early Church practice and a lot more to do with Protestantism and modernism. There are countless examples and it is simply dead obvious upon even a superficial analysis. According to Pope Benedict many of the people who spearheaded the liturgical changes following the Council were essentially Protestant in their thinking (I would add liberal Protestant) and were explicitly going against the theology of Trent. The contemporary Catholic practice of Communion on the hand is the result of the heterodoxy and dissent of the early 1970's. That bishop has made an excellent decision in forbidding this infamous practice which is an embarrassment and a scandal as far as I'm concerned. The reign of liberal Protestants within the Church has done enough damage in the past 40 years and I am thankful for this recent example of basic Catholic common sense. Btw, the archaeologist or antiquarian arguments are not as effective as they were in the 60's and 70's, you'll have to do better than that if you really hope to justify the continued existence of this asinine fad.
CatherineM Posted April 28, 2008 Posted April 28, 2008 Yes, I was reading Irenaeus yesterday and was fascinated by the reference to Eucharistic ministers distributing water and milk along with the wine. I think asinine is a bit harsh of a word to use for a practice that is approved by the Vatican, and my Archbishop, and I find to be a comforting part of my spirituality. Being able to hold the Body of Christ in my hand is important to me, but I will certainly yield to your superior knowledge on the subject. My field is Moral/Spiritual, not Systematic Theology.
Proud2BCatholic139 Posted April 28, 2008 Posted April 28, 2008 I always recieve on the tongue. I am not worthy to touch God with my own two hands. Now, I kneel while recieving the Eucharist. Everyone thinks I am strange. But, go to St. Agnus and you will feel much welcomed.
CrossCuT Posted April 28, 2008 Posted April 28, 2008 [size=1]My parish doesnt allow communion on the hand. Everyone kneels on a kneeler and receives on the tongue. [/size]
mortify Posted April 28, 2008 Posted April 28, 2008 LD that was an excellent post (as usual.) I believe the Cardinal moved in the right direction and hopefully in time kneeling and receiving on the tongue will be the only acceptable forms.
Laudate_Dominum Posted April 28, 2008 Posted April 28, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1511990' date='Apr 27 2008, 07:17 PM']Yes, I was reading Irenaeus yesterday and was fascinated by the reference to Eucharistic ministers distributing water and milk along with the wine. I think asinine is a bit harsh of a word to use for a practice that is approved by the Vatican, and my Archbishop, and I find to be a comforting part of my spirituality. Being able to hold the Body of Christ in my hand is important to me, but I will certainly yield to your superior knowledge on the subject. My field is Moral/Spiritual, not Systematic Theology.[/quote] True enough, my apologies. But I should say that what I had in mind as 'asinine' was more the early agenda that emerged in the 1970's. I respect the fact that this practice is approved in many dioceses and that Catholics exercise this option. No problem there. I just find it unfortunate that this practice was able to spread in the first place. I have a few books by some of the folks that were in some ways responsible for this fad and I have no problem describing their agenda as asinine. haha. Faithful Catholics who prefer to receive on the hand in dioceses where this is permitted do not offend me at all and I wouldn't presume to condemn them by any means! Sorry if I offended you.
Pontifex Posted April 28, 2008 Posted April 28, 2008 I think the key here is "reverence" and "respect" for the Eucharist. I do think that people who receive on the tongue, do so out of a sense of deep reverence. For that reason I prefer that people receive on the tongue. I find that irreverence and a casual reception happens more readily when people receive in the hand, however I see some beautiful reverence and respect from others who receive in the hand. I blame my brother priest for the lack of reverence and respect in the Eucharist. We have priests that tell their people that receiving on the tongue is "pre vatican". We have priests, dre's and 2nd grade teachers who do not even offer the option for the new communicant to receive on the tongue. I always make sure they know they have that option and I teach my 7th grade Church history class that they can receive on the tongue. I try very hard to celebrate the mass with a sense of deep respect and awareness for the real presence of Jesus and it is amazing how many people have switched from receiving in the hand to the tongue without me ever mentioning it. If we, priests, communicate a deep reverence and respect for Jesus in the Eucharist the people will respond. If we are over casual the people will be casual. Peace, Fr. Pontifex
Era Might Posted April 28, 2008 Posted April 28, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1511990' date='Apr 27 2008, 08:17 PM']Being able to hold the Body of Christ in my hand is important to me[/quote] There is a nice story in the diary of St. Faustina about this: [quote]When I was about to receive Holy Communion, a second Host fell onto the priest's sleeve, and I did not know which host I was to receive. After I had hesitated for a moment, the priest made an impatient gesture with his hand to tell me I should receive the Host. When I took the Host he gave me, the other one fell onto my hands. The priest went along the altar rail to distribute Communion, and I held the Lord Jesus in my hands all that time. When the priest approached me again, I raised the Host for him to put it back into the chalice, because when I had first received Jesus I could not speak before consuming the Host, and so could not tell him that the other had fallen. But while I was holding the Host in my hand, I felt such a power of love that for the rest of the day I could neither eat nor come to my senses. I heard these words from the Host: [b]"I desired to rest in your hands, not only in your heart."[/b] And at that moment I saw the little Jesus. But when the priest approached, I saw once again only the Host.[/quote] In the early Church, I believe only Catholics were allowed to be present at Mass. Even catechumens were not allowed during the consecration. The symbolism of receiving in the hand would have been understood, and would not have led to any confusion. But today, anyone can attend Mass (or even watch on television). While receiving in the hand is not intrinsically wrong (it does express our intimacy with the Lord), I think we should consider whether the practice today strengthens or weakens our sense of the Real Presence (not just our individual sense, but the general sense of those who are present at Mass, both Catholics and non-Catholics). Receiving in the hand is seen in our culture as something casual. That's how we eat common food, with our hands. The danger is that receiving in the hand leads others to see the Holy Eucharist as common bread. However, when we receive on the tongue, it is clear to others that we are not eating common bread, because nobody eats regular food by being fed by another person. Rather, we are receiving Our Lord, who is "the true bread from Heaven." He feeds us (through the Priest), we do not feed ourselves.
Deb Posted April 28, 2008 Posted April 28, 2008 I think receiving in the hand is just very wrong. I don't get why it is done. I was taught as a child to receive it by mouth (we had kneelers back then too) When I returned to the church people were being handed it, people in jeans were giving it out!!! No kneelers. I would never touch it. My sister who is eight years younger than me and came into the church seven years ago, had no idea you had a choice. When she actually noticed someone opening their mouth for it, she was horrified. I noticed in mass today, we had 22 at the one of three first communion masses. Every child went up and put their hands out to receive the host. I was really surprised because my priest is so Eucharist centered in everything he does that I thought maybe the youngsters would be taught differently from the start. Who knows? i would love to see it banned everywhere and go back to the way it should be.
CatherineM Posted April 28, 2008 Posted April 28, 2008 I think my biggest fear in a return to communion rails is that I spent 8 years in a wheelchair. Before then, I had been a cantor. My chair would not allow me to sing in church anymore. In Florida, there was only one church I could use my wheelchair in to go to confession, the cathedral. It only had one wheelchair accessible entrance, that they refused to open on Saturday during confession for security reasons. Yes, I could easily go to confession in my pastor's office, or in the parking lot, but I wanted to be treated like any other parishioner. I've been walking for just over 3 years now. That wasn't an easy task. I am still physically incapable of kneeling. I'm finally able to sing in church again, and it may seem like a small thing, but it was so very important to me to do one thing that made me feel normal again. Putting up a rail, an obstacle will just single me out again. I remember in my canon law classes discussing about things that were "objects of curiosity to children." I don't want to be that object that in any way takes people's attention off the Eucharist.
Lil Red Posted April 28, 2008 Posted April 28, 2008 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1512056' date='Apr 27 2008, 06:52 PM']Faithful Catholics who prefer to receive on the hand in dioceses where this is permitted do not offend me at all and I wouldn't presume to condemn them by any means! Sorry if I offended you.[/quote] +J.M.J.+ thank you for clearing that up, your OP certainly was offensive to me.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now