Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

praying4carmel
Posted

Thanks to our previous thread, I now receive on the tongue, Unless I am receiving from a Eucharistic Minister, in which case I use my hands.

From a Priest or Deacon always.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='XIX' post='1512388' date='Apr 28 2008, 10:11 AM']I respect the fact that communion in the hand is permitted in most places, and basically every Novus Ordo Mass I've ever been to. However, I do suspect that the church wants to move back towards communion on the tongue, only.
I will say that I absolutely do not understand the argument that "I am not worthy to touch Jesus with my hands." True, we aren't, but that's not really a reason. We aren't worthy to touch Him with our tongues, either. Or the roofs of our mouths, or out teeth, or out throats, or anywhere else for that matter. We certainly are not worthy to have Jesus present in our hearts the way He is in the precious few moments after communion.

Either way, I am starting to think that communion in the hand is paving the way towards abuses of the Eucharist (receiving unworthily, receiving carelessly, etc.)[/quote]

I don't understand the argument either. What we say with our mouths is just as sinful as what we do with our hands. Though I can understand how easily it would be for abuses to occur by receiving in the hand (i.e., stealing).

I prefer receiving on the tongue, I feel more comfortable that way. I don't look down on anyone who takes it on the hand, just as long as they are reverent, believe in the Real Presence, and are in the state of grace (which we all should be). :)

Edited by Paladin D
Posted (edited)

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1511934' date='Apr 27 2008, 07:14 PM']St. Cyril talked about receiving the Eucharist on the hand back in the 300's, and I'm pretty sure the Apostles handled the first Eucharist with their hands too. I don't believe that receiving it on my hand makes me any less reverent. If he's concerned that his priests aren't being reverent enough, then he has a whole different set of problems.[/quote]
I think in the early church they received on the hand quite differently... I read somewhere on PM, I think it was transmundane lane, that the Eucharist was placed on the palm of the hand, and was not to be touched by the communicant's finger tips at all. They were to receive from their palm, then have their hand purified. It was pretty intense.

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1511950' date='Apr 27 2008, 07:38 PM']What St. Cyril describes is not the same as modern Communion on the hand and this is not exactly relevant to the modern issues anyway. The fact that x, y or z happened in the early Church is not the reason why we have such things today. Women were bound to cover their heads in church up until 1983 and yet I doubt you would accept this fact as a compelling reason why we should revive this practice today. Similarly, in St. Cyril's time men and women were separated at the liturgy but if I were to invoke this historical fact I do not think that this alone would convince you of the wisdom or necessity of such a practice today. If one were to desire including a drink of milk and honey at Communion I suppose a show of antiquarian enthusiasm would be insufficient in demonstrating the appropriateness of such a revival in our time. But again, modern Communion on the hand follows the Protestant pattern and not that which St. Cyril and others describe (St. Cyril was not even a Roman Christian btw).

If being more like the early Church was really important we would have more fasting after Vatican II and not virtually none. The early sources on Roman liturgy indicate a number of things such as the congregation kneeling during baptisms and the like which would be cool. Also the early baptismal rites include very strong prayers of exorcism and yet the "modern" rite has almost done away with the exorcism entirely. My point is that time and time again the changes in the so-called "modern" Church have very little to do with early Church practice and a lot more to do with Protestantism and modernism. There are countless examples and it is simply dead obvious upon even a superficial analysis. According to Pope Benedict many of the people who spearheaded the liturgical changes following the Council were essentially Protestant in their thinking (I would add liberal Protestant) and were explicitly going against the theology of Trent.

The contemporary Catholic practice of Communion on the hand is the result of the heterodoxy and dissent of the early 1970's. That bishop has made an excellent decision in forbidding this infamous practice which is an embarrassment and a scandal as far as I'm concerned.
The reign of liberal Protestants within the Church has done enough damage in the past 40 years and I am thankful for this recent example of basic Catholic common sense. Btw, the archaeologist or antiquarian arguments are not as effective as they were in the 60's and 70's, you'll have to do better than that if you really hope to justify the continued existence of this asinine fad.[/quote]
Great post! Is the milk and honey reference to (the new) Jerusalem?

[quote name='CrossCuT' post='1512042' date='Apr 27 2008, 08:42 PM'][size=1]My parish doesnt allow communion on the hand.
Everyone kneels on a kneeler and receives on the tongue.
[/size][/quote]
Whoa... sweet. :mellow:

[quote name='Innocent' post='1512348' date='Apr 28 2008, 07:06 AM']You mean, in your churches, there are no separate halves of the church for men and women to sit? :blink:[/quote]

Welcome to America :mellow: :rolleyes:

Seriously, we don't separate men and women here... very few women even wear veils. Different kind of society here.

[edit]
I should add, that's pretty interesting that the bishop had the chutzpa to do that. It' pretty exciting, I think. In saying all this, I only receive on the tongue now. I used to receive on the hand, but I decided to switch over as a gesture of reverence toward Our Lord.

Edited by Sacred Music Man
fides quarens intellectum
Posted

[quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1513059' date='Apr 28 2008, 06:35 PM']Welcome to America :mellow: :rolleyes:

Seriously, we don't separate men and women here... very few women even wear veils. Different kind of society here.[/quote]



Did you move?
:unsure:

Posted

no... what I mean is, welcome to North America...

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Innocent' post='1512348' date='Apr 28 2008, 06:06 AM']You mean, in your churches, there are no separate halves of the church for men and women to sit? :blink:[/quote]
Not in this country. I'm sure if one were to suggest such a thing they'd be lynched by feminists since everything involving gender distinction is interpreted as sexism around here. hehe.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1513059' date='Apr 28 2008, 06:35 PM']Is the milk and honey reference to (the new) Jerusalem?[/quote]
There is certainly a good bit of variety based on the extant evidence but there are a few particularly interesting patristic elucidations of the practice that come to mind. In essence it is a reminder of God's promise to the Israelites and a sign of our liberation as Christians in the new covenant of Jesus Christ. I suppose that the Church of Christ in the Holy Spirit is the promised land and if one has a deeply eschatological understanding of the Church it is all the better. The Eucharistic Sacrifice is the pinnacle so I suppose drinking of the milk and honey after receiving Holy Communion was a meaningful symbol for some Catholics of that time. There are other neat little traditions from the early centuries that we don't hear much about. There is an ancient holy water type thing with a quasi-Eucharistic context, there were sacred meals involving non-Eucharistic bread and wine with solemn blessings that could be shared by catechumens (at least in some cases), there were solemn blessings for olives, coagulated milk, oil, various fruits, et cetera which were either part of solemn Christian meals or even somewhat connected with the Eucharist itself. Many of the specifics are quite debatable since the sources are often ambiguous or dubious but I still think it is a cool thing to read about.

Posted (edited)

[quote][quote]I will say that I absolutely do not understand the argument that "I am not worthy to touch Jesus with my hands." True, we aren't, but that's not really a reason. We aren't worthy to touch Him with our tongues, either. Or the roofs of our mouths, or out teeth, or out throats, or anywhere else for that matter. We certainly are not worthy to have Jesus present in our hearts the way He is in the precious few moments after communion.[/quote]

I agree, I've never really gotten that argument. Both can be done reverentially, I think. I've seen some abuses with receiving in the hand, but then I've been around that the most. I certainly wouldn't mind a return to communion rails, though I know there are those who cannot kneel (I didn't used to be able to kneel, actually).[/quote]

For one thing each Host possesses the Totality of our Lord, and therefore each particle, [b]no matter how small[/b], also possesses the Totality of our Lord. To protect our Lord in even these minuscule particles, the administration of His Body is limited to the most suitable person who naturally ought to be a consecrated individual (the priest.) If you ever attend a Latin Mass, you'll notice the Priest only uses his thumb and forefinger to hold the Host, and even after consuming the Host he does not allow his fingers to separate (not even when he holds the Chalice or brings his hands to prayer) until they have been properly washed and consumed (that is, that which is used to cleanse is consumed), and this is precisely to prevent loss of even the smallest Particle.

This great care for the transmission of our Lord in the Blessed Sacrament can only be understood from a clear and fervent belief in the Transubstantiation and Totality. Departure from these venerable disciplines not only weakens this belief, but it allows disregard to our Lord in these small particles and therefore is rather irreverent.

Edited by mortify
Posted (edited)

An addendum to my previous post:

Note how the Priest keeps his forefinger and thumb clasped even while holding the Chalice. This is out of reverence to the Host and protects any loss of Particles. The ball at the center of the Chalice's neck helps facilitate this grasp.

[img]http://tomorrowstrust.ca/wp-content/uploads/2007/08/23-the-little-elevationtt.jpg[/img]


Once again notice the clasped fingers even in modes of prayer:

[img]http://tomorrowstrust.ca/wp-content/uploads/2007/08/22-commemoration-of-the-de.jpg[/img]

[img]http://tomorrowstrust.ca/wp-content/uploads/2007/08/24-the-pater-nostertt.jpg[/img]

Edited by mortify
Laudate_Dominum
Posted

Oh wow, is that Archbishop Fulton Sheen? :cool:

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1513607' date='Apr 28 2008, 09:58 PM']Oh wow, is that Archbishop Fulton Sheen? :cool:[/quote]
+J.M.J.+
he's the man. :cool:

Posted

Yes I believe it is Archbishop Fulton Sheen.

Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1513477' date='Apr 28 2008, 10:41 PM']I agree, I've never really gotten that argument. Both can be done reverentially, I think. I've seen some abuses with receiving in the hand, but then I've been around that the most. I certainly wouldn't mind a return to communion rails, though I know there are those who cannot kneel (I didn't used to be able to kneel, actually).

For one thing each Host possesses the Totality of our Lord, and therefore each particle, [b]no matter how small[/b], also possesses the Totality of our Lord. To protect our Lord in even these minuscule particles, the administration of His Body is limited to the most suitable person who naturally ought to be a consecrated individual (the priest.) If you ever attend a Latin Mass, you'll notice the Priest only uses his thumb and forefinger to hold the Host, and even after consuming the Host he does not allow his fingers to separate (not even when he holds the Chalice or brings his hands to prayer) until they have been properly washed and consumed (that is, that which is used to cleanse is consumed), and this is precisely to prevent loss of even the smallest Particle.

This great care for the transmission of our Lord in the Blessed Sacrament can only be understood from a clear and fervent belief in the Transubstantiation and Totality. Departure from these venerable disciplines not only weakens this belief, but it allows disregard to our Lord in these small particles and therefore is rather irreverent.[/quote]

That is why I receive on the tongue now. I used to receive in the hand, until the above started really sinking in, and I found myself licking my hands after communion (interestingly, some time later, I saw another person do the same).

CatholicCid
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Norseman82' post='1514444' date='Apr 29 2008, 06:22 PM']That is why I receive on the tongue now. I used to receive in the hand, until the above started really sinking in, and I found myself licking my hands after communion (interestingly, some time later, I saw another person do the same).[/quote]
A friend of mine kisses his palms afterwards. I must admit, the trait has rubbed off on me as well. If recieving in the hands, I just clasp my thumb and forefinger in my left palm afterwards so I might inspect it for particles of our Lord. I'll recieve either way really, I suppose it just depends where I am.

I'd bet Priests would have to practice really hard, as I'd be afraid of dropping the chalice.

Edited by CatholicCid

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...