Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

  

21 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

The five non-negotiables according to the USCCB are as follows:
1. Abortion
2. Euthanasia
3. Embryonic Stem Cell Research
4. Human Cloning
5. Homosexual Marriage

My questions pertain to the fact that for the most part, these 5 platforms align with one of the two main political parties in America, while omitting crucial quality of life issues that this party has time and time again failed to address.

One more thought to consider while responding: Does the Church specify which of the five non-negotiables is the most important? If there is in fact more of moral imperative to one of the five than another, than why does this list not also include other crucial issues, such as that of the injustices brought about through uninhibited free trade?

CatherineM
Posted

I'd guess if they are non-negotiable, then they are fairly equal, but they did put them in a numerical rather than alphabetical order. They were probably only dealing with issues in the US, and except for human trafficking issues, there aren't that many sweatshops within the jurisdiction of the USCCB.

Posted

good point. but what [i]is[/i] within the jurisdiction of the USCCB are many of the corporations and private individuals who contribute to the poor quality of life within the free trade zone factories and the sweatshops that produce for U.S. companies.

CatherineM
Posted

Sometimes a room is so dirty that trying to clean the whole thing is overwhelming. You have to focus on individual piles one at a time.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

1. Abortion
2. Euthanasia
3. Embryonic Stem Cell Research

I would say that these three are worse than the other two. The result of all these actions is murder. The scenarios in the poll are important to consider, but I would still think that murder is worse than poor work conditions. Maybe thats just me... :idontknow:

Posted

I voted yes to the first question because you said "or innocent"... an an unborn child is more innocent than anyone past the age of reason :cyclops:... I suppose I missed the point of the question though.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Didymus' post='1529494' date='May 15 2008, 02:13 PM']The five non-negotiables according to the USCCB are as follows:
1. Abortion
2. Euthanasia
3. Embryonic Stem Cell Research
4. Human Cloning
5. Homosexual Marriage

My questions pertain to the fact that for the most part, these 5 platforms align with one of the two main political parties in America, while omitting crucial quality of life issues that this party has time and time again failed to address.

One more thought to consider while responding: Does the Church specify which of the five non-negotiables is the most important? If there is in fact more of moral imperative to one of the five than another, than why does this list not also include other crucial issues, such as that of the injustices brought about through uninhibited free trade?[/quote]
Abortion is the #1 because it is premeditated murder of an innocent human being.

Posted

[quote name='Didymus' post='1529494' date='May 15 2008, 12:13 PM']The five non-negotiables according to the USCCB are as follows:
1. Abortion
2. Euthanasia
3. Embryonic Stem Cell Research
4. Human Cloning
5. Homosexual Marriage

My questions pertain to the fact that for the most part, these 5 platforms align with one of the two main political parties in America, while omitting crucial quality of life issues that this party has time and time again failed to address.[/quote]
OK, I didn't vote in your poll because the wording was so blatantly slanted and skewed toward your agenda, but I'll start out by pointing out that you've got the idea back-assward here:
The Catholic five non-negotiables don't align with the Republican or any political party; rather the Republican Party (at least in principle) aligns with these principles more than the Democratic party does.
If that fact is inconvenient to your political agenda, perhaps it's you, not the Church, that needs to change here.

The five non-negotiables are based on the Church's unchanging moral teachings, not some political platform.
And if you're trying to insinuate that the U.S. bishops are the lackey of the G.O.P., you couldn't be more wrong; if anything the USCCB is known as tending towards political liberalism, and has never been shy on speaking out on "social justice" issues.

For starters, [b]life itself[/b] [i]always[/i] trumps "quality of life" as a moral issue. If an innocent person is murdered (as by abortion or euthanasia), "quality of life" issues become meaningless. The Fifth Commandment, after all, is "Thou Shalt Not Kill."

[quote]One more thought to consider while responding: Does the Church specify which of the five non-negotiables is the most important? If there is in fact more of moral imperative to one of the five than another, than why does this list not also include other crucial issues, such as that of the injustices brought about through uninhibited free trade?[/quote]

The list is basically in descending order of importance. Abortion and euthanasia are at the top, as they involve the deliberate taking of innocent human life - the most serious moral offense against another human being. Embryonic stem-cell research is wrong because it involves abortion. Cloning is an extremely grave violation of the sacredness of human reproduction, and lastly "homosexual unions" violate the sacredness of marriage, and encourage a grave sin against nature.

"Non-negotiable" means always wrong under any circumstance, no questions asked. These are things which morally can never be supported.
"Free trade" is a vague term, and is not quite as black-and-white and issue. (And yes, I acknowledge that there are problems inherent in unrestricted free trade, and think some tariffs should be imposed on imports from other countries - but that's another debate.) However, I think most of the problems with free trade involve the loss of American jobs to cheap foreign labor - simply ending "free trade" would not in itself do nothing to make the Chinese or Vietnamese sweat-shop worker any less poor or oppressed - she would likely remain poor and oppressed - just without American money. In fact, trade with America has overall increased the wealth and standard of living in countries like China and India.

There's a lot that can be debated there, but my point is that something like "free trade" cannot in itself be put morally on par with issues like abortion and euthanasia as a non-negotiable.

As Cardinal Ratzinger (now His Holiness Pope Benedict XVI) explained regarding worthiness to receive communion:[quote][b]Not all moral issues have the same moral weight as abortion and euthanasia.[/b] For example, if a Catholic were to be at odds with the Holy Father on the application of capital punishment or on the decision to wage war, he would not for that reason be considered unworthy to present himself to receive Holy Communion. While the Church exhorts civil authorities to seek peace, not war, and to exercise discretion and mercy in imposing punishment on criminals, it may still be permissible to take up arms to repel an aggressor or to have recourse to capital punishment.[b] There may be a legitimate diversity of opinion even among Catholics about waging war and applying the death penalty, but not however with regard to abortion and euthanasia.[/b][/quote]
If there can be a legitimate diversity of opinion about waging war and applying the death penalty, there can certainly be a legitimate diversity regarding economic issues, and "free trade" most certainly does not have the same moral weight as abortion and euthanasia.

And I don't think you can convincingly say that the Holy Father is a pawn of the American political right.

You need to get your thinking in line with that of the Church, not vice-versa.

CatherineM
Posted

Socrates-as you know, I always disagree with you about capital punishment, but your post was so encompassing in explaining the list from the USCCB, why things are on it, and why some things are not on it, that I just have to tip my hat to you. I'm still against capital punishment, but I do understand that not everyone is, and the Church is okay with that.

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1529991' date='May 15 2008, 10:20 PM']If there can be a legitimate diversity of opinion about waging war and applying the death penalty, there can certainly be a legitimate diversity regarding economic issues, and "free trade" most certainly does not have the same moral weight as abortion and euthanasia.

And I don't think you can convincingly say that the Holy Father is a pawn of the American political right.

You need to get your thinking in line with that of the Church, not vice-versa.[/quote]


Just because I have questions doesn't mean I'm wrong. Sometimes I only want to know [i]why[/i]

Thank you for responding. I have a couple other comments on your response, but I haven't the time right now. Be back later!

Posted

I think JP2 said that, aside from salvation itself, the most important issue of our time is the destruction of babies in the womb.

Posted

Okay let's start with this:

First of all, I have no agenda, unless the attainment of knowledge and wisdom are an agenda. In that case, I'm guilty as charged. I want to see this all layed out rationally and logically, and I have yet to see it done, so that is why I have turned to all of you on Phatmass. The poll is actually of little importance, it is just some thoughts I have from reflecting ont his issue and learning more about what goes on in some of the free trade zones in Latin America.

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1529934' date='May 15 2008, 09:37 PM']Abortion is the #1 because it is premeditated murder of an innocent human being.[/quote]

[quote name='Socrates' post='1529991' date='May 15 2008, 10:20 PM']If an innocent person is murdered (as by abortion or euthanasia), "quality of life" issues become meaningless.[/quote]

Let's come to an agreement on here. Which one of you is right? Is abortion #1 or is euthanasia #1? Or are they both #1? I guess it all depends on how you define "innocence." Because in that case, why is not embryonic stem cell research #1 as well? Is is not as much the "premeditated murder of an innocent human being"?

I need this broken down further.

[quote name='Socrates' post='1529991' date='May 15 2008, 10:20 PM']The list is basically in descending order of importance.[/quote]

[quote name='Socrates' post='1529991' date='May 15 2008, 10:20 PM']For starters, [b]life itself[/b] [i]always[/i] trumps "quality of life" as a moral issue. If an innocent person is murdered (as by abortion or euthanasia), "quality of life" issues become meaningless. The Fifth Commandment, after all, is "Thou Shalt Not Kill."[/quote]

so the unjust taking of a life in some foreign country would be a greater injustice than homosexual marriage in this country, no? or how am I wrong?

Posted

[quote name='XIX' post='1530224' date='May 16 2008, 10:05 AM']I think JP2 said that, aside from salvation itself, the most important issue of our time is the destruction of babies in the womb.[/quote]

I need to try to find where I heard it, but in some of these free trade zone factories, the women workers must take contraceptive pills and if they fail they must take an abortifacient shot. This is so as to make it so that their employers do not have to suffer a reduction in output, and they do not have to support pregnancies amongst their employees.

I will definitely try to find a source, as Socrates will probably accuse me of evil anti-conservative propaganda now. Oh Socrates :rolleyes:

Posted (edited)

[quote]Is the life of a child in the womb any more sacred, or innocent, than the life of the worker in a free trade zone in Latin America?[/quote]
An unborn baby is more innocent than anyone because they have not experienced life as we know it yet alone sinned.

[quote]Is homosexual marriage more important of an issue than the quality of life of those who work in oppressive conditions to make products for the American economy?[/quote]
I think that the latter is more important than the former. I am not saying the homosexual marriage is not important. However, the living conditions of the people the situations described are horrendeous. They are subhuman conditions. I am wondering if the "quality of life" issue can be grouped loosely under euthanasia considering that many people die from such conditions.

Above all, I believe that respecting life from the beginning (conception) to the end (natural death) is more important than anything. Human beings are human being regardless of their state of life presently. Abortion, euthanasia, and the like are more important issues.l However, like a baby I think that the people who work in forced labor or sweat shops are made extremely vulnerable. Therefore we must also include them into our life issues. They maybe not be high on the priority list but they must be included. They are human beings as well as being such have the basic right to shelter, clothing and food.


[quote]For starters, life itself always trumps "quality of life" as a moral issue.[/quote]
This is not directed towards anyone in particular ;) I agree considering that a person cannot have a quailty of life without being alive then life always is above quality of life. However, quailty of life is still important and needs to be discussed.
Edit: I want to add that I think if you look at the places like the Honduras where America basically raped the land and the people are living in horrible horrible conditions it can be considered a moral issue. But again, not as important as the killing of innocent human beings.

Edited by picchick
Posted (edited)

[quote name='picchick' post='1530278' date='May 16 2008, 11:22 AM']An unborn baby is more innocent than anyone because they have not experienced life as we know it yet alone sinned.[/quote]

So innocence directly equates to any actual sin? So then is it less of an abomination to euthanize an elderly person (since they have lived out a life and have experienced sin) than it is to kill an unborn child?

Right now there are so many definitions of "innocence" in this thread, it'll make your head spin. :wacko:

Edited by Didymus
Posted

it is in fact less evil to kill an elderly person than it is to kill an infant in the womb.

that doesn't mean both aren't terrible terrible evils, just that one is worse than the other. if you had a choice between them, you could choose neither, but one is definitely less evil than the other.

this only works in the extreme comparison between killing someone prior to the age of reason and killing someone who is after the age of reason, because after the age of reason it is impossible for us to know who is "more innocent" and thus every murder is equal. but killing someone who has not yet reached the age of reason is definitely MORE evil than killing someone after they have reached it. that doesn't justify anything, it's just an objective fact.

it is not more sacred, but it is more innocent.

Posted

but when we are referring to death, and the taking of a life, is there really a grade in the innocence of a person? Can someone really be [i]more[/i] innocent? or [i]more[/i] deserving of death?

Posted

[quote name='Didymus' post='1530396' date='May 16 2008, 01:33 PM']but when we are referring to death, and the taking of a life, is there really a grade in the innocence of a person? Can someone really be [i]more[/i] innocent? or [i]more[/i] deserving of death?[/quote]

Someone can be more innocent yet no one is more deserving of death.

Posted

[quote name='picchick' post='1530482' date='May 16 2008, 02:13 PM']Someone can be more innocent yet no one is more deserving of death.[/quote]

I need to add. I feel that innocence can also be applied to the elderly.

If someone has dementia and are being euthanized, I think that it falls under innocence. What is the difference between them and a baby? They are all-trusting, they rely on others.

It is different to if I am walking down the street and someone shoots me because I wearing red shoes because I am not innocent.

Maybe I am confusing myself now...

Posted

If the right to life is abrogated, all other human rights are endangered.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...