Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

  

21 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Didymus' post='1530262' date='May 16 2008, 10:06 AM']I need to try to find where I heard it, but in some of these free trade zone factories, the women workers must take contraceptive pills and if they fail they must take an abortifacient shot. This is so as to make it so that their employers do not have to suffer a reduction in output, and they do not have to support pregnancies amongst their employees.[/quote]This happens outside of "free trade zones" as well. The female residents (doctors in training) at some Mexican hospitals where I worked were not allowed to get pregnant. I never learned how this rule was enforced... I didn't want to. If this was an accepted practice among educated professionals, I'm guessing it's not uncommon in other segments of society as well. There is a huge deficiency in respect for life.

I have a difficult time ranking the list. I think they all feed each other.

Posted

[quote name='tgoldson' post='1531550' date='May 17 2008, 02:21 PM']This happens outside of "free trade zones" as well. The female residents (doctors in training) at some Mexican hospitals where I worked were not allowed to get pregnant. I never learned how this rule was enforced... I didn't want to. If this was an accepted practice among educated professionals, I'm guessing it's not uncommon in other segments of society as well. There is a huge deficiency in respect for life.[/quote]

yikes... thats not pro-life [i]or[/i] pro-choice!

Posted

[quote name='Didymus' post='1530257' date='May 16 2008, 10:01 AM']Okay let's start with this:

First of all, I have no agenda, unless the attainment of knowledge and wisdom are an agenda. In that case, I'm guilty as charged. I want to see this all layed out rationally and logically, and I have yet to see it done, so that is why I have turned to all of you on Phatmass. The poll is actually of little importance, it is just some thoughts I have from reflecting ont his issue and learning more about what goes on in some of the free trade zones in Latin America.[/quote]
Your poll fails to mention that we are comparing life itself vs "quality of life" - directly sanctioning murder vs. allowing with people with highly questionable ethics.
While you raise some legit issues, you're also failing to make important distinctions. The non-negotiables are intrinsically evil and may never be supported, while "free trade" is more ambiguous and even hard to define.

I think it can be compared with giving my girlfriend money to get an abortion, and buying a pair of sneakers made in some sweatshop in China.
There may be good reason not to buy stuff made in China (I try to avoid when I reasonably can - increasingly hard to do), but it's not the same as directly sanctioning the evil they do.

And while you may have completely different intentions, almost invariably when I see someone trying to equate things like free trade or excesses of capitalism, poverty, etc. with abortion, euthanasia et., it is to justify voting for the leftist pro-abortion, pro-homosexual political candidate of one's choice.

[quote]Let's come to an agreement on here. Which one of you is right? Is abortion #1 or is euthanasia #1? Or are they both #1? I guess it all depends on how you define "innocence." Because in that case, why is not embryonic stem cell research #1 as well? Is is not as much the "premeditated murder of an innocent human being"?
I need this broken down further.[/quote]
Really, does it matter? Both abortion and human euthanasia are extremely grave evils - willful murder of helpless human beings, and are at least at a similar level of evil. I think abortion is at the top of the list mainly because its currently more widespread and accepted than euthanasia.
Embryonic Stem research is further down the list because the research is reaping from murder, rather than murder itself (abortion).
I honestly find your quibbling here really bizarre.
All the things on the list are non-negotiable and gravely evil.

[quote]so the unjust taking of a life in some foreign country would be a greater injustice than homosexual marriage in this country, no? or how am I wrong?[/quote]
Directly sanctioning the murder of someone anywhere would be a greater evil, but no one is advocating that. Trading with people is not the same as deliberately promoting murder. By that logic, it would be intrinsically evil to trade with the U.S. because of all the abortions committed here.

[quote name='Didymus' post='1530354' date='May 16 2008, 11:48 AM']So innocence directly equates to any actual sin? So then is it less of an abomination to euthanize an elderly person (since they have lived out a life and have experienced sin) than it is to kill an unborn child?

Right now there are so many definitions of "innocence" in this thread, it'll make your head spin. :wacko:[/quote]
More senseless and silly quibbling. Killing [i]either[/i] is an abomination. (Though I agree with Al that there is something especially evil about killing a perfectly innocent baby.)
Since [b]both[/b] are non-negotiable, what is the issue here?

"Innocent" is used here traditionally in the broader sense of someone who is not a criminal being executed for his crimes, a combatant in war, or an attacker being defended against.
(As in the phrase "killing innocent bystanders," even though the bystanders in question may be guilty of sin.)

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1534215' date='May 19 2008, 10:33 PM']There may be good reason not to buy stuff made in China (I try to avoid when I reasonably can - increasingly hard to do),[/quote]

HORRAY!!! :clap: I am not the only one!!!

CatherineM
Posted

We were watching Back to the Future yesterday, and in part II the 1955 Doc Brown said that no wonder something didn't work because it said made in Japan on it. Marty then said that all the best stuff is made in Japan. It sounded so strange. Everything today seems to be made in China, but I remember when that wasn't so. When did this happen? When did we stop making our own things. I guess about the time we quit repairing things and started just throwing broken stuff out and buying newer cheaper stuff.

goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

[quote name='picchick' post='1534333' date='May 19 2008, 10:56 PM']HORRAY!!! :clap: I am not the only one!!![/quote]

true that, but it does get a little tiring sometimes to pick up the 99% of items in a store, check the label see that it is from China, then put it back and keep looking... :rolleyes: :smokey:

Edited by goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1534215' date='May 19 2008, 10:33 PM']"Innocent" is used here traditionally in the broader sense of someone who is not a criminal being executed for his crimes, a combatant in war, or an attacker being defended against.
(As in the phrase "killing innocent bystanders," even though the bystanders in question may be guilty of sin.)[/quote]

thank you

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Socrates' post='1534215' date='May 19 2008, 10:33 PM']Your poll fails to mention that we are comparing life itself vs "quality of life" - directly sanctioning murder vs. allowing with people with highly questionable ethics.
While you raise some legit issues, you're also failing to make important distinctions. The non-negotiables are intrinsically evil and may never be supported, while "free trade" is more ambiguous and even hard to define.[/quote]

My problem does have to do with life in a way, since most of these factories in the free trade zones force women to be on birth control and threaten with abortifacients should they conceive. If we are pro-life, then should we not be pro all life? I know thats cliche-ic, but its how I feel after hearing about the atrocities brought about by these zones in Latin/South America.

But where does quality of life stand with regards to homosexual marriage?

[quote name='Socrates' post='1534215' date='May 19 2008, 10:33 PM']And while you may have completely different intentions, almost invariably when I see someone trying to equate things like free trade or excesses of capitalism, poverty, etc. with abortion, euthanasia et., it is to justify voting for the leftist pro-abortion, pro-homosexual political candidate of one's choice.[/quote]

Thank you for understanding this. I refuse to vote for any pro-choice candidate. I am not necessarily leftist, except perhaps on the economical issues, but never do I find any merit in any of the liberal candidates around today. When I 'complain' about many of these issues, its more or less because it seems to many times as if folks like to overlook the injustices that are brought about by policies often deemed "conservative" just because conservatism supposedly supports family values and life from conception. I apologize if ever my posts sound aimless, and I will try to work on providing more construction to my criticism.

and i noticed your quote from Pius XI, so I want to clarify that I doubt I am a "true socialist" as Pius XI would call it, as I am merely attracted to some of the framework of socialism as it applies to the economy and the free market, not to mention the fact that I don't believe that we should ever rid ourselves of capitalism, but merely regulate it more.

Edited by Didymus

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...