Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Malachi Crunch' post='1533645' date='May 19 2008, 02:51 PM']I would like to hear both sides of the stroy as newspaper articles rarely capture the entire lanscape of a story.

The priest certainly has to right to protect his flock, even if that means he is protecting the flock [i]from [/i]the flock. But the priest has no right to deny the boy mass or the eucharist. It sounds as if some options have been presented to the parents, but without any results.[/quote]

he absolutely has the right to deny the boy Eucharist if he isn't understanding of its nature.

praying4carmel
Posted

[quote name='Alycin' post='1533614' date='May 19 2008, 04:34 PM']I think there ought to be a "cry room" in every church so that people can still be there, but without disturbing others.[/quote]

We Have a Cry Room at St Thomas Aquinas..Will anybody use it?? NO. Yesterday when Msgr Lifted the Host and said "Do this in Rememberance of Me"..before the bells rang a little voice said loudly "YEAH"!!! it was quite funny.. however she then screamed thru the much of the service. My Father Hates this, that's why he goes to 8AM Mass. I guess I just don't understand why people won't use it and most of all why the Ushers won't make them...

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='Alycin' post='1533614' date='May 19 2008, 07:34 PM']I think there ought to be a "cry room" in every church so that people can still be there, but without disturbing others.[/quote]
Not all parishes have a cry room, or have room for one, my parish being one of those. Our priest has offered to let me take Kieran into the hall that connects the church with the rectory, though, if needed. I will take Kieran out if he's inconsolable/screaming, but not for minor cries (I know that probably isn't what you're referring to, though). It really isn't a problem at my parish, though (there are around 3-4 babies, so not a whole lot, and no one minds if they fuss a little, as babies do).

let_go_let_God
Posted

Some times it is nice to hear the fuzz of little ones, but if cry rooms are like that of what I've seen many times, someone like the young man in reference here, could easily break the glass. This would leave a mess of the church and potentially harm more than just him.

I do however think that there could be a better solution than getting a restraining order.

God bless-
LGLG

Posted

This sounds like a lot more than a child fussing or crying. The child is 6 feet tall and 225 pounds. The article stated that the pastor had been working through several agencies and the parents to resolve this but, had to end up getting the restraining order.

This child is the size of a very large grown man and it sounds like his actions disrupt the entire mass. How could it not bring it to a halt? How frightening is that to the other children that are in the church?

I feel for the parents as they have a very hard job but, even if it is church, if the child cannot be controlled, he should not be there.

Posted

I guess I just can't see Jesus stopping in the middle of preaching with an annoyed look on his face and telling the parents of "disturbing" little kids to leave.

:unsure:

When danger comes into play, things change a bit.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' post='1533380' date='May 19 2008, 09:35 AM']After warning, family of autistic teen attends different church[/quote]

Oh dear. I think this is what we call a rock and a hard place. Very difficult for everyone involved and no one to really blame.

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' post='1533651' date='May 19 2008, 01:57 PM']he absolutely has the right to deny the boy Eucharist if he isn't understanding of its nature.[/quote]

yeah I think you're right.

let_go_let_God
Posted

Priests do not have to give the Eucharist to anyone that they know do not have an understanding of the meaning of the Eucharist.

God bless-
LGLG

Posted

[quote name='praying4carmel' post='1533652' date='May 19 2008, 02:58 PM']We Have a Cry Room at St Thomas Aquinas..Will anybody use it?? NO. Yesterday when Msgr Lifted the Host and said "Do this in Rememberance of Me"..before the bells rang a little voice said loudly "YEAH"!!! it was quite funny.. however she then screamed thru the much of the service. My Father Hates this, that's why he goes to 8AM Mass. I guess I just don't understand why people won't use it and most of all why the Ushers won't make them...[/quote]

I TOTALLY disagree with cry rooms. We are one big family and we should be included together.

When I was little if I threw a fit in Church, Dad would take me out to the car. We learned very quickly that we were to behave in Church.

From what I have seen (and this does not apply everywhere), cry rooms breed undiscipline. It would be different if the parents cared but when they are in the cry room it is "ok" to misbehave. I think that children can be taught better if they are in the Church. However, it also has to do with the parents. If the parents allow a behavior then the child will misbehave anywhere. I am just saying that cry rooms give more encourage to misbehaving.

If a child screams during a service, I think that the parents should take them to the vestibule. There is nothing wrong with that. There was one Church that I visited that have the vestibule and Church separated with a piece of glass that went from ceiling to floor. I think that was an excellent idea. The people in the vestibule were still part of the Mass.

I misread the article. I didn't know he was that big of a boy...13 and already 6ft? However, I wonder how much of it is true and how much is exaggerated.

meg

praying4carmel
Posted

[quote name='picchick' post='1533709' date='May 19 2008, 05:34 PM']I TOTALLY disagree with cry rooms. We are one big family and we should be included together.

When I was little if I threw a fit in Church, Dad would take me out to the car. We learned very quickly that we were to behave in Church.

From what I have seen (and this does not apply everywhere), cry rooms breed undiscipline. It would be different if the parents cared but when they are in the cry room it is "ok" to misbehave. I think that children can be taught better if they are in the Church. However, it also has to do with the parents. If the parents allow a behavior then the child will misbehave anywhere. I am just saying that cry rooms give more encourage to misbehaving.

If a child screams during a service, I think that the parents should take them to the vestibule. There is nothing wrong with that. There was one Church that I visited that have the vestibule and Church separated with a piece of glass that went from ceiling to floor. I think that was an excellent idea. The people in the vestibule were still part of the Mass.

meg[/quote]

We also have our vestibule like that too, Still the parents won't take them out...I can see your point on that, about cry rooms..I think the ushers could do more there...A Little noise.. after all they are Kids..does not bother me but screaming and the parents ignoring it does bother me too after awhile..

I do feel sorry for this boy and His Parents.

Posted

[quote name='picchick' post='1533709' date='May 19 2008, 03:34 PM']If a child screams during a service, I think that the parents should take them to the vestibule. There is nothing wrong with that. There was one Church that I visited that have the vestibule and Church separated with a piece of glass that went from ceiling to floor. I think that was an excellent idea. The people in the vestibule were still part of the Mass.[/quote]

Cry rooms are there for babies so that crying babies don't prevent the parents from being able to attend church. I don't think people should begin in the cry room and stay there the whole time, but I think they're appropriate when needed.


And what you just described is what any cry room I've ever seen looks like...

MissScripture
Posted

[quote name='let_go_let_God' post='1533707' date='May 19 2008, 02:34 PM']Priests do not have to give the Eucharist to anyone that they know do not have an understanding of the meaning of the Eucharist.

God bless-
LGLG[/quote]
But how can the priest know if non-speaking person with autism does not understand?

rhetoricfemme
Posted

[quote name='picchick' post='1533709' date='May 19 2008, 01:34 PM']I TOTALLY disagree with cry rooms. We are one big family and we should be included together.

When I was little if I threw a fit in Church, Dad would take me out to the car. We learned very quickly that we were to behave in Church.[/quote]

I agree with you, Meg. The church I used to attend would often have services sprinkled with crying infants or fretful children, but it was always handled with such grace by service-goers. If it got too loud, parents would take their children to the lobby. We were fortunate enough to also have large glass windows, keeping everyone in the service together.

There was also a mentally disabled woman, who would occasionally let out a moan or something during service, but no one ever minded. And she received Communion each week, as well.


I don't know, I find it charming to hear the occasional cry, cough or whatever during service. It reminds me of our frailty and that I'm not the only one with needs.

-Christina.

Posted

[quote name='MissScripture' post='1533736' date='May 19 2008, 03:48 PM']But how can the priest know if non-speaking person with autism does not understand?[/quote]

I'm going to guess that at certain levels of severity of autism, Eucharist is not an option.

MissScripture
Posted

[quote name='Alycin' post='1533729' date='May 19 2008, 02:43 PM']Cry rooms are there for babies so that crying babies don't prevent the parents from being able to attend church. I don't think people should begin in the cry room and stay there the whole time, but I think they're appropriate when needed.
And what you just described is what any cry room I've ever seen looks like...[/quote]
Yeah...I don't know what other cry rooms look like...the only ones I've ever seen have glass windows to watch the Mass. I wasn't aware there were any that were different than that.

Autumn Dusk
Posted

I fear that the boy will be welcome at a church, while he behaves, for an indefinate amount of time. Then he spits, hits, screams uncontrollably and the church will ask he leaves. It will happen again. He probably is quite well behaved 80% of the time.

Thing is that the mother, especially since she home schools, should know when her child has reached his threashold and NOT take him to Mass or out of the house at all. I'm not saying confine him at all times or that she could predict his behavior at all times, but there has to be some sort of boundary. Sure, church can be calming but it isn't therapy.

It sounds like this priest worked very hard to aid this family and they refused to cooperate on grounds the priest "didn't understand". However, it seems that the family had more than enough chance to get through to this priest. As a pastor he has a right to protect his flock. And in this day in age where lawsuits are rampant I honestly can't blame the priest for making the final decision when he was left with no more choices.

let_go_let_God
Posted

There are many "non-speaking" autistics that can communicate well in other forms such as writing or sign language. They can prove their level of knowledge with many other forms than speaking.

God bless-
LGLG

goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

also if that weren't an option, I'd think if one doesn't have the ability to attain the understanding of at least a 6-7 year old (usually an average age requirement for recieving Eucharist) then it can be reasonably determined that one doesn't have the reason necessary to understand what the Eucharist really is.

Edited by goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='praying4carmel' post='1533724' date='May 19 2008, 03:41 PM']We also have our vestibule like that too, Still the parents won't take them out...I can see your point on that, about cry rooms..I think the ushers could do more there...A Little noise.. after all they are Kids..does not bother me but screaming and the parents ignoring it does bother me too after awhile..

I do feel sorry for this boy and His Parents.[/quote]

Then it is the parents responisbility. Not the ushers. I too would be bothered if that happened. I like your vestibule though. I think that children should be taken out until they settled down and then brought back to the Church.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...