Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

KnightofChrist
Posted

[url="http://insidecatholic.com/Joomla/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=2155&Itemid=48"]The Great Lie: Pope Benedict XVI On Socialism[/url]
by Rev. Robert Sirico


One doesn't usually expect a thorough-going reconstruction of the history of socialism in the late 19th century from the pope, but Benedict XVI has delivered to us a wonderful -- and oh-so-needed -- reminder of what socialism was (and is), and why it went wrong. One can't but marvel at his intellectual power: He has discerned the essential problem that has evaded vast numbers of academics for 100 years.

What's more, he has done this in a time when socialism as an ideology seems to have been unfazed by the collapse of the communist experiment. Visit the philosophy and English departments on most college campuses, and you will still find intellectuals waxing eloquent on the glories of socialist theory. Students are still encouraged to imagine that it could work.

What about the Soviet Union? We are told that this wasn't really socialism. And what about Nazism -- the German word for national socialism? Oh, that's not socialism either. What about the growing impoverishment in once-rich countries with social democratic governments? The failure of micro-socialism in the United States, where entire communities have lived on government subsidies and are plagued with frightening levels of social pathology? They say that this is not socialism either.

Large swaths of American academia are in denial. So too are major parts of the American and European clerical class, which is still under the impression that socialism represents a gospel ideal that has yet to be tried. One suspects that the entire history of the 20th century passed them by, for they have learned nothing from the poverty, despotism, and vast suffering wrought by the socialist ideology.

Not Benedict. He wants to talk about it. It fits his message of hope precisely...

[url="http://insidecatholic.com/Joomla/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=2155&Itemid=48"]continued... [/url]

Posted

Dude, I'm just throwin' this out there....our Pope is THAT MAN!!!!

I'm taking an African Politics class right now and the material seems to be very pro-socialism/anti-capitalism. I am, admittedly, intellectually unarmed when it comes to the topic of socialism. But I'm glad that I can start quoting Papa Benny in discussions.

B-16!!!!

Posted

[quote]History is strewn with intellectuals who imagined that they could save the world -- and created hell on earth as a result. The pope counts the socialists among them, and Karl Marx in particular. Here was an intellectual who imagined that salvation could occur without God, and that something approximating the Kingdom of God on earth could be created by adjusting the material conditions of man.[/quote]

I have already stressed this countless times. My arguments for a type of democratic socialism are not incompatible with the God of Christianity, much less with the teachings of the Church which I do hold dear.

[quote]Socialism fails for a precise and practical reason: It has no system for pricing factors of production to make economic calculation possible. Prices come from the exchange of the very private property with which socialism dispenses.[/quote]

but what happens when we do not abolish private property as I have already posited in another thread?

This article seems to re-direct BXVI's explanation of the Materialism of Karl Marx and his belief in a Utopia and use it against all of the ideas that Socialism brings to the table.

In fact, Fr. Sirico never seems to continue discussing this, which I would have really wanted to hear:

[quote]What about the Soviet Union? We are told that this wasn't really socialism. And what about Nazism -- the German word for national socialism? Oh, that's not socialism either. What about the growing impoverishment in once-rich countries with social democratic governments? The failure of micro-socialism in the United States, where entire communities have lived on government subsidies and are plagued with frightening levels of social pathology? They say that this is not socialism either.[/quote]

This is quite similar to what I have said (emphasis on similar :D ) and he doesnt seem to have answered it.

I do encourage everyone to read the posted response at the bottom of the second page in the link. It really hits the nail on the head:
[quote]I concur with the critique of Socialism- the State controlling every aspect of the economy is an obvious mistake- especially when the typical socialist recipe is an agnostic or even atheistic in philosophic underpinning. But socialism is hardly the fear here in the U.S., we are the great exporter of the "American Consensus" neoliberalism applied to global economics. What are the fruits? What is the relationship to Magisterium teachings? These topics seem pretty much off-limits in so-called "conservative" circles. I would love to have a serious self-proclaimed "conservative" intellectual deal honestly with Pope John Paul II's encyclical "On Social Concern" written back in 1987 in the heat of the Cold War, he offered a stunning critique of the East and West- why is all the focus of his teachings only on his fight against atheistic socialism/communism? He has plenty to say about the ideologies related to consumerism and the neo-colonialism inherent in the Western prescriptions for the developing world. The "Washington Consensus" and the "IMF Conditionalities" seem to create or at least maintain horrible conditions of life for the majority of people in the Third World. The fact is that the Catholic teaching is that the political authorities must be the guarantor of the common good, the economy must serve the people- not the other way around. To simply allow capital and corporation to move freely around the globe in search of speculative bubbles or the cheapest available labor and/or least restrictive environmental regulations, while keeping labor (actual people) trapped behind borders with walls and police- well this seems more than a little problematic.

[b][i]The Church calls for freedom in the marketplace, but not absolute or total freedom- there must a framework of laws and regulations the underpin every economy to ensure outcomes that fit with the universal common good. The universal destination of goods principle calls into question unbridled capitalism, and the principle of subsidiarity should lead us to question the power of the WTO, NAFTA et al which give multinational corporations more power than local communities could ever seriously challenge.[/i][/b][/quote]
[emphasis added]

CatherineM
Posted

I just find it so refreshing to have leaders who are actually learned. The knowledge and wisdom shown by our popes, cardinals and bishops unfortunately reminds me of how our elected officials often fall short.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1536604' date='May 21 2008, 07:15 PM']I just find it so refreshing to have leaders who are actually learned. The knowledge and wisdom shown by our popes, cardinals and bishops unfortunately reminds me of how our elected officials often fall short.[/quote]

true that... the pope anyways. too many off our elected officials seem to just have more money than intelligence and wisdom.

Posted

The Holy Father is indeed awesome. I hope he speaks out more frequently regarding socialism. I suspect Putin may have a lot to do with his belief for this need.

Posted

Definitely agree with you here, Justin.

Lounge Daddy
Posted (edited)

This is fantastic! Very very timely material from Pope Ben :cool:

Just to digress from the main subject slightly:
And I see that Father Sirico penned the article. [url="http://www.acton.org/"]His Acton Institute is truly wonderful[/url]. I have gone to a few of their noontime lectures, because I am fortunate enough to be going to a college that is just a block away from the Acton Institute main offices. They do very good work to expose the dangers of this current socialist trend and its growing popularity, and they work hard in spreading the message of authentic freedom and liberty. Acton's work is also very timely.

Edited by Lounge Daddy
KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote name='Didymus' post='1536592' date='May 21 2008, 06:02 PM']I have already stressed this countless times. My arguments for a type of democratic socialism are not incompatible with the God of Christianity, much less with the teachings of the Church which I do hold dear.
but what happens when we do not abolish private property as I have already posited in another thread?

This article seems to re-direct BXVI's explanation of the Materialism of Karl Marx and his belief in a Utopia and use it against all of the ideas that Socialism brings to the table.

In fact, Fr. Sirico never seems to continue discussing this, which I would have really wanted to hear:
This is quite similar to what I have said (emphasis on similar :D ) and he doesnt seem to have answered it.[/quote]

What do you mean that you have also argued that Nazi Germany and Communist Russia where not true socialist governments? Because Fr. Sirico is saying they where true socialist governments. I dont understand why you do not understand, the church has for some 100 yrs condemned all types of socialism. Yours would be no different.

Lounge Daddy
Posted

The recent book [url="http://www.amazon.com/Liberal-Fascism-American-Mussolini-Politics/dp/0385511841"][u]Liberal Fascism[/u][/url] covers a lot of this issue of the popularization and acceptance of socialism, historic and current. I picked it up a month ago and it's in line on my personal reading list. The author did a great hour on Glenn Beck's CNN Headline Prime program, and some of it [url="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1aStUHvmDb4"]can be seen on You Tube[/url] and [url="http://www.videosift.com/video/Jonah-Goldberg-discusses-LIberal-Fascism-with-Glenn-Beck"]elsewhere[/url]. They covered the very real danger of the current spread and acceptance of socialism in the USA. A [url="http://www.glennbeck.com/content/articles/article/196/4199/"]transcript of a brief interview[/url] from the radio program is at Beck's website.

KnightofChrist
Posted

I'll have to check that out. :cool:

Posted

[quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1537484' date='May 22 2008, 03:05 PM']What do you mean that you have also argued that Nazi Germany and Communist Russia where not true socialist governments? Because Fr. Sirico is saying they where true socialist governments. I dont understand why you do not understand, the church has for some 100 yrs condemned all types of socialism. Yours would be no different.[/quote]


Communist Russia was not Communism ala Karl Marx and Freidrich Engels. It was an attempt, but a poor one at that. But that is a totally different matter.

What I am advocating are only some of the ideas that run from a Socialist economy, and I have yet to be shown why this runs contrary to Church teaching.

You seem to be only condemning me because you hear the word Socialism, and then you quote the Magisterium without explanation...

It is not that I don't understand. I understand why the Church is opposed to Marxism and some of the ideas proposed in Communist Manifesto, but no one has yet explained to me why the Church would be opposed to a democratized regulated economy rather than a focus on making the market 'free' for corporations, many of which outsource labor and exploit the people of Latin and South America...

[quote name='Didymus' post='1536258' date='May 21 2008, 02:17 PM']What I want you to do... is show me how [i]I[/i] am on the wrong path and straying from the fold by merely finding an attraction to the belief in a market that focuses more on need then on profit, to the belief that outsourcing and free trade should always be accompanied by a respect for fair wage negotiations and labor unions, and to the belief that even the poorest of Americans ought to have an actual say in our democratic republic, and not just rely on the false and empty promises of the politicians who only serve those who had the money and the power to put them in office, often times themselves.[/quote]

KnightofChrist
Posted

Sorry I just dont understand why the last 100 yrs of commendation of all socialism by the Church is not good enough. Every type of socialism tried look just as good on paper but in practice it was a big delivery of epic fail.

[img]http://tn3-2.deviantart.com/fs13/300W/f/2007/042/e/d/Socialism_by_miniamericanflags.jpg[/img]

For your answers to your questions go here.

[url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=80497"]Can One Be A Sincere Catholic And A True Socialist?, (Continued from "Election Section")[/url]

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Didymus' post='1536592' date='May 21 2008, 06:02 PM']I have already stressed this countless times. My arguments for a type of democratic socialism are not incompatible with the God of Christianity, much less with the teachings of the Church which I do hold dear.
but what happens when we do not abolish private property as I have already posited in another thread?[/quote]
Please see the thread I started in the debate table entitled [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=80497"]"Can One be a Sincere Catholic and a True Socialist?"[/url]

As Pius XI states:[quote][b]Whether considered as a doctrine, or an historical fact, or a movement, Socialism, if it remains truly Socialism, even after it has yielded to truth and justice on the points which we have mentioned, cannot be reconciled with the teachings of the Catholic Church because its concept of society itself is utterly foreign to Christian truth.[/b][/quote]

[quote]This article seems to re-direct BXVI's explanation of the Materialism of Karl Marx and his belief in a Utopia and use it against all of the ideas that Socialism brings to the table.[/quote]
The Popes have clearly condemned socialism in all its forms, not just dogmatic Marxist Communism, but "moderate" forms as well. Again, see my extensive quotes in my thread linked to above.

[quote]In fact, Fr. Sirico never seems to continue discussing this, which I would have really wanted to hear:
This is quite similar to what I have said (emphasis on similar :D ) and he doesnt seem to have answered it.[/quote]
The truth is that whenever and wherever put into practice in the real world, socialism has proven disastrous - at best a miserable failure, and at worst leading to every type of atrocity and tyranny.

Rather than claiming that socialism will work if only "done right" by the "right people," maybe it's time to face the reality that socialism is a failure built on falsehoods, and never has and never will "work" in reality.

And claiming that none of the various historical and existing forms of socialism are "true socialism" still does not get around the fact that "true socialism" has been in fact solemnly condemned by the Church as incompatible with Christian truth.

It's time to abandon your fantasy and wake up to reality (and Catholic Truth).

Edited by Socrates
Posted

I like the new bumper sticker I just saw today, it said:

Vote for McCain
at least he's not a socialist

CatherineM
Posted

I'm trying to remember how it was defined to me as a kid. Socialism is where they take a cow from one neighbor who has two, and gives it to the neighbor that has none. Communism is where the government takes the cow, but gives you some of the milk. Fascism is where you keep the cows, and give the milk to the government who then sells it to you at a high rate. Nazism is where the government takes the cows and then shoots you. Pure Democracy is where your neighbors decide who gets your cow's milk, and Representative Democracy is where your neighbors pick who decides who gets your milk.

Posted

KoC and Socrates:

[quote name='Didymus' post='1536258' date='May 21 2008, 02:17 PM']What I want you to do... is show me how [i]I[/i] am on the wrong path and straying from the fold by merely finding an attraction to the belief in a market that focuses more on need then on profit, to the belief that outsourcing and free trade should always be accompanied by a respect for fair wage negotiations and labor unions, and to the belief that even the poorest of Americans ought to have an actual say in our democratic republic, and not just rely on the false and empty promises of the politicians who only serve those who had the money and the power to put them in office, often times themselves.[/quote]

I did not receive an answer, but only this:
[quote name='Socrates' post='1536874' date='May 21 2008, 11:32 PM']Socialism is not the answer, as the Church repeatedly makes clear.
If you believe in socialism, you are indeed on the wrong path. If not, then you should disassociate yourself from this movement.[/quote]

Posted

I agree with Didy (at least when he says that you didn't give him a real answer). Conservative hardliners on this board throw the s-word around way too much.

If you think a particular policy is socialist, at least try to show why it's socialist instead of assuming we should be able to figure it out on our own. Because call me crazy, but I'm not ready to to look at every deviation from conservative fiscal policy as "socialist." Yet you work under the [i]presupposition[/i] that such a deviation is, by definition, socialist.

Posted

[quote name='XIX' post='1543564' date='May 26 2008, 03:41 PM']I agree with Didy (at least when he says that you didn't give him a real answer). Conservative hardliners on this board throw the s-word around way too much.

If you think a particular policy is socialist, at least try to show why it's socialist instead of assuming we should be able to figure it out on our own. Because call me crazy, but I'm not ready to to look at every deviation from conservative fiscal policy as "socialist." Yet you work under the [i]presupposition[/i] that such a deviation is, by definition, socialist.[/quote]
It was Didy who initially identified himself as a "democratic socialist," even at one point using the profile title "Pro-life Socialist."

Sorry, but if one doesn't want to be criticized for being socialist, he shouldn't identify himself as one.

KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1544134' date='May 26 2008, 08:32 PM']It was Didy who initially identified himself as a "democratic socialist," even at one point using the profile title "Pro-life Socialist."

Sorry, but if one doesn't want to be criticized for being socialist, he shouldn't identify himself as one.[/quote]

Exactly words have meanings and definitions.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...