Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1544134' date='May 26 2008, 09:32 PM']It was Didy who initially identified himself as a "democratic socialist," even at one point using the profile title "Pro-life Socialist."

Sorry, but if one doesn't want to be criticized for being socialist, he shouldn't identify himself as one.[/quote]

but instead of using your brain and your God-given gift of reason, you resorted to pope quotes and encyclicals to condemn what I was saying instead of acknowledging the good things I was alluding to as well. I brought up a lot of different points and it seems as though all you saw was 'socialism.' I shouldn't have even implied i had an attraction to some of the ideas of socialism, since it seems from then on you and KoC just focused on the word and not behind the ideas I was focusing on, and even now you refuse to actually answer the question I asked.

Posted

[quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1544159' date='May 26 2008, 09:51 PM']Exactly words have meanings and definitions.[/quote]

and you saw one word - out of everything I said... one word.

Posted

[quote name='Didymus' post='1544272' date='May 26 2008, 09:42 PM']but instead of using your brain and your God-given gift of reason, you resorted to pope quotes and encyclicals to condemn what I was saying instead of acknowledging the good things I was alluding to as well. I brought up a lot of different points and it seems as though all you saw was 'socialism.' I shouldn't have even implied i had an attraction to some of the ideas of socialism, since it seems from then on you and KoC just focused on the word and not behind the ideas I was focusing on, and even now you refuse to actually answer the question I asked.[/quote]
So now we're not to "resort to" quoting papal encyclicals on a Catholic message board? I'd hope, as a Catholic, they'd carry some weight with you, but perhaps I'm wrong.

Our point is that socialism is wrong, and you are wrong to espouse it, regardless what other ideas you may have.

I answered you on the thread in the Debate Table.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Socrates' post='1544300' date='May 26 2008, 10:54 PM']So now we're not to "resort to" quoting papal encyclicals on a Catholic message board? I'd hope, as a Catholic, they'd carry some weight with you, but perhaps I'm wrong.[/quote]

as Catholics, we resort to faith [i]and[/i] reason. If you cannot do more than just quote a few popes and summarize what they say without explaining and understanding [i]why[/i] they say it, then you might as well be protestant... you and KoC never once did what Aloysius did. He actually broke it down and saw the property rights issue as separate from the free market issue. It helped me a lot.

[quote name='Socrates' post='1544300' date='May 26 2008, 10:54 PM']Our point is that socialism is wrong, and you are wrong to espouse it, regardless what other ideas you may have.[/quote]

I saw a lot of this kind of attitude in the seminary, mostly from guys who couldn't actually argue efficiently for the Truth, but rather could only regurgitated what the Popes have said. I have no problem with this in and of itself, except when they could not rationalize to the same answer that they saw the Church had given them.

Someone could easily show how the Church cannot allow women to be ordained, but when they cannot explain [i]why[/i] women cannot be ordained, then what good are they doing for the cause of evangelization?

Edited by Didymus
  • 4 weeks later...
Galloglasses
Posted

Here's an odd annomaly. Here in Ireland, during the war of Independence, the IRA was nomily a Socialist organisation. Socialism is fundamentally opposed to Nationalism, which is usally, by naturally Right winged. After the civil war, the Irish Constitution and the subsequent Irish Government was, by nature, Nationalistic and Right winged. (Some would call Ireland outrightly fascist if it wasn't for the fact the had genuine Democracy that worked for a change), and later at the beginning of the troubles, the IRA, which had degenerated into outright Marxism, was at a crossroads, the leadership didn't want to get involved because they veiwed defending Nationalists in Northen Ireland as 'Sectarianism' were as the 'traditionalists' In the IRA veiwed it as their duty to defend the 'grass roots' from violence, (this was before the ensuing attrocities of the Troubles in Ireland), and more or less a military coup and subsequent split of the organisation followed. How can socialism be that great if it not only caused trouble in Ireland, but actually created the OPPOSITE of what it was intended to. (Instead of a socialist government, they got a nationalist Government), not only that, but it caused its own organisations to split, not once, but twice?

Lounge Daddy
Posted

Wow, Gallow, what an interesting observation. And I just learned something about Ireland. Thank you.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I'm sure someone's said it already, but I'd just like to throw this in the pot:

THANK YOU POPE BENEDICT.

Someone needs to say this.

Galloglasses
Posted

[quote name='Lounge Daddy' post='1578145' date='Jun 20 2008, 10:52 PM']Wow, Gallow, what an interesting observation. And I just learned something about Ireland. Thank you.[/quote]
You're welcome. By the by, I'd advise not making an assumption about Irish politics, like, ever. Not becuase you're likely to offend someone but because, as the saying goes, "Nothing is happening in Ireland that didn't start 800 years ago", so almost all of the time you're likely to be generalising or getting it completely off the mark without knowing the whole story. Most Irish people make that mistake. (It may also explain why there is an astounding degree of political literacy among the population. That is, of course, until alot of southerners got corrupted and were willing to vote away their sovereignty after 800 years of fighting to get it. Morons.)

Posted

Socialism stinks and I really don't understand how anyone would ever advocate for any system that stifles and punishes ambition and hard work. It's a nice idea to help people, but it ain't gonna work because it don't make any sense.

Posted

the way I see it though, is that (the evils of property abolition aside) there are many ideas incorporated into Socialism that would be very beneficial to society.

the lower/middle class could make the exact same 'stifling' argument about unbridled capitalism, especially if they're coming from the experience of benefiting from a more socialized state.

Galloglasses
Posted

The attractiveness of Socialism is what makes countries still strive for it. Ideas=Good, Reality=Unworkable. Every failed attempt at socialism thus far has just been labelled, 'Not-Socialism', instead of 'failed attempt at socialism' Capitalism, with its obvious and sometimes 'glaring-you-in-the-face' difficulties, is in my eyes, preferable.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...