aalpha1989 Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Lil Red' post='1546607' date='May 28 2008, 03:30 PM']+J.M.J.+ and honestly, if we apply to politicians, then we have to apply it to everyone. [/quote] Everyone who is a public figure. Not everyone is, and not everyone creates scandal by cohabitation or even by pro-choice sentiments. There IS a difference. Edited May 28, 2008 by aalpha1989
StColette Posted May 28, 2008 Author Posted May 28, 2008 I've looked through the entire Sacrament of Penance section of Canon Law, nothing there.
StColette Posted May 28, 2008 Author Posted May 28, 2008 Section on DELICTS AGAINST HUMAN LIFE AND FREEDOM nothing there either
Lil Red Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 +J.M.J.+ [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1546603' date='May 28 2008, 01:29 PM']Your sin did not cause 'public scandal' or at least not the level of 'public scandal' which is caused when an elected leader who claims to be catholic supports something counter to catholic teaching.[/quote] being as i'm a youth minister at a large parish, i would argue that my sin could have caused public scandal. not on the level as a politician, but still. [quote name='aalpha1989' post='1546604' date='May 28 2008, 01:29 PM']The difference is that masturbation causes no scandle. It is hte scandle which makes her public repentance necessary.[/quote]agreed, i was mostly talking about the effects of such a hidden sin. mostly theorizing aloud. [quote name='aalpha1989' post='1546604' date='May 28 2008, 01:29 PM']I do think that she should be admitted to Communion after she has been to Confession, however, whether she has publicly repented or not. I just think that public repentance is something she should do, not something that is strictly required. Personally I think I would still feel the guilt on my conscience after confession if I had not apologized directly to the people I had wronged (even though I had been technically forgiven).[/quote] agreed, though she might not feel the same.
StColette Posted May 28, 2008 Author Posted May 28, 2008 (edited) Only thing about pulic officials so far Can. 1369 A person who in a public show or speech, in published writing, or in other uses of the instruments of social communication utters blasphemy, gravely injures good morals, expresses insults, or excites hatred or contempt against religion or the Church is to be punished with a just penalty. not sure if this fits in anywhere Can. 1399 In addition to the cases established here or in other laws, the external violation of a divine or canonical law can be punished by a just penalty only when the special gravity of the violation demands punishment and there is an urgent need to prevent or repair scandals. Can. 1315 §1. A person who has legislative power can also issue penal laws; within the limits of his competence by reason of territory or of persons, moreover, he can by his own laws also strengthen with an appropriate penalty a divine law or an ecclesiastical law issued by a higher authority. Edited May 28, 2008 by StColette
Lil Red Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 [quote name='aalpha1989' post='1546618' date='May 28 2008, 01:34 PM']Everyone who is a public figure. Not everyone is, and not everyone creates scandal by cohabitation or even by pro-choice sentiments. There IS a difference.[/quote] +J.M.J.+ i don't agree. and St.Colette, i talked with my priest friend (orthodox guy), and he says he is pretty sure there is no such thing in Canon Law simply because of the fact that it is such a complicated issue. (he said a lot more, but i'm uncomfortable posting his thoughts here unless he'd like to come and do so).
Lil Red Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1546637' date='May 28 2008, 01:42 PM']Only thing about pulic officials so far Can. 1369 A person who in a public show or speech, in published writing, or in other uses of the instruments of social communication utters blasphemy, gravely injures good morals, expresses insults, or excites hatred or contempt against religion or the Church is [u]to be punished with a just penalty.[/u][/quote] +J.M.J.+ which is up to the confessor.
Lil Red Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 [quote name='aalpha1989' post='1546618' date='May 28 2008, 01:34 PM']Everyone who is a public figure. Not everyone is, and not everyone creates scandal by cohabitation or even by pro-choice sentiments. There IS a difference.[/quote] +J.M.J.+ and i'll tell you why i disagree. because anyone who's sin is public like advocacy for abortion, divorced & remarried without annulment, gay marriage proponents, those who flaunt the 'rules' on homosexuality, cohabitators, etc. all those [b]are[/b] public sins. and [b]do[/b] cause scandal to those around them. maybe it isn't on the level of a politician, but it is public, and it is scandalous. btw, nice avatar.
aalpha1989 Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1546653' date='May 28 2008, 03:46 PM']+J.M.J.+ and i'll tell you why i disagree. because anyone who's sin is public like advocacy for abortion, divorced & remarried without annulment, gay marriage proponents, those who flaunt the 'rules' on homosexuality, cohabitators, etc. all those [b]are[/b] public sins. and [b]do[/b] cause scandal to those around them. maybe it isn't on the level of a politician, but it is public, and it is scandalous. btw, nice avatar. [/quote] I guess that's true. How would an everyday Joe publicly repent, though? Send a letter to the editor of the newspaper? Write letters to everyone he knows? Maybe just an explanation to close friends/family... do you think that would do it? I guess that sounds pretty good to me. Thanks, I like yours, too. It actually reminds me of mozilla firefox's logo.
StColette Posted May 28, 2008 Author Posted May 28, 2008 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1546640' date='May 28 2008, 03:42 PM']+J.M.J.+ i don't agree. and St.Colette, i talked with my priest friend (orthodox guy), and he says he is pretty sure there is no such thing in Canon Law simply because of the fact that it is such a complicated issue. (he said a lot more, but i'm uncomfortable posting his thoughts here unless he'd like to come and do so).[/quote] I asked one of the Deacons who is pretty familiar with Canon Law and he said it isn't in there either.
Lil Red Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 [quote name='aalpha1989' post='1546671' date='May 28 2008, 01:50 PM']I guess that's true. How would an everyday Joe publicly repent, though? Send a letter to the editor of the newspaper? Write letters to everyone he knows? Maybe just an explanation to close friends/family... do you think that would do it? I guess that sounds pretty good to me. Thanks, I like yours, too. It actually reminds me of mozilla firefox's logo.[/quote] +J.M.J.+ yeah, see that's where public repudiation gets tricky. and interesting. never thought of that. [quote name='StColette' post='1546699' date='May 28 2008, 01:56 PM']I asked one of the Deacons who is pretty familiar with Canon Law and he said it isn't in there either.[/quote] interesting.
StColette Posted May 28, 2008 Author Posted May 28, 2008 (edited) If we sin against someone aren't we supposed to make reparation toward them? Like say we sin against our spouse or parents in some way. Aren't we supposed to make reparation toward them? Would that be considered public repudation? Edited May 28, 2008 by StColette
aalpha1989 Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1546736' date='May 28 2008, 04:06 PM']If we sin against someone aren't we supposed to make reparation toward them? Like say we sin against our spouse or parents in some way. Aren't we supposed to make reparation toward them? Would that be considered public repudation?[/quote] Yeah... there's that part of the gospel where Jesus tells his disciples that if they sin against their brother they should make peace with him before they go to the altar of God. could that be interpreted as apologize to someone before you confess the sin, or does it matter whether it is before or after? or is it strictly that one must go to confession before one receives the Eucharist (after a mortal sin)?
Lil Red Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1546736' date='May 28 2008, 02:06 PM']If we sin against someone aren't we supposed to make reparation toward them? Like say we sin against our spouse or parents in some way. Aren't we supposed to make reparation toward them? Would that be considered public repudation?[/quote] +J.M.J.+ i'm not sure. i've never been told to in confession to make reparation.
StColette Posted May 28, 2008 Author Posted May 28, 2008 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1546745' date='May 28 2008, 04:09 PM']+J.M.J.+ i'm not sure. i've never been told to in confession to make reparation.[/quote] I have, espcially if it was a sin against someone.
Lil Red Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1546736' date='May 28 2008, 02:06 PM']If we sin against someone aren't we supposed to make reparation toward them? Like say we sin against our spouse or parents in some way. Aren't we supposed to make reparation toward them? Would that be considered public repudation?[/quote] +J.M.J.+ [u][b]from my priest:[/b][/u] as a matter of justice, yes, you could be required to. in the case of stealing, you would have to in some way return what was stolen. but our sin always effects the community in some way. even in a matter of justice, a matter of anonymity must be retained. there is not always a way to restore what was taken or what was done without revealing all that happened. for example, if you had an affair against your spouse, the priest cannot require you (by withholding absolution) to reveal that to your spouse. and in a way, there are some sins you could never reparate for, especially if you met the person only once.
StColette Posted May 28, 2008 Author Posted May 28, 2008 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1546757' date='May 28 2008, 04:15 PM']+J.M.J.+ [u][b]from my priest:[/b][/u] as a matter of justice, yes, you could be required to. in the case of stealing, you would have to in some way return what was stolen. but our sin always effects the community in some way. even in a matter of justice, a matter of anonymity must be retained. there is not always a way to restore what was taken or what was done without revealing all that happened. for example, if you had an affair against your spouse, the priest cannot require you (by withholding absolution) to reveal that to your spouse. and in a way, there are some sins you could never reparate for, especially if you met the person only once.[/quote] very cool! It's so helpful having priests handy lol
Lil Red Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1546763' date='May 28 2008, 02:19 PM']very cool! It's so helpful having priests handy lol[/quote] +J.M.J.+ no kidding. i emailed him this thread, i'm hoping he responds.
KnightofChrist Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 There seems to be a basis in Can.855 §I . The publicly unworthy, who are the excommunicated, the interdicted and the manifestly infamous, unless their penance and conversion have been established and they [i]will have first made up for the public scandal[/i], are to be excluded from the Eucharist. Or in other words... "When public figures create public scandal, they must make public reparation before they may return to the sacraments. [i]The reparation must be proportionate to the scandal.[/i]" But I am awaiting word back from Fr. Z. and Fr. R., so that they may provide sounder proof.
aalpha1989 Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1546863' date='May 28 2008, 04:51 PM']There seems to be a basis in Can.855 §I . The publicly unworthy, who are the excommunicated, the interdicted and the manifestly infamous, unless their penance and conversion have been established and they [i]will have first made up for the public scandal[/i], are to be excluded from the Eucharist. Or in other words... "When public figures create public scandal, they must make public reparation before they may return to the sacraments. [i]The reparation must be proportionate to the scandal.[/i]" But I am awaiting word back from Fr. Z. and Fr. R., so that they may provide sounder proof.[/quote] It specifies the excommunicated. As of now, The governor is not.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now