KnightofChrist Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 (edited) [quote name='aalpha1989' post='1546872' date='May 28 2008, 03:52 PM']It specifies the excommunicated. As of now, The governor is not.[/quote] Yes the excommunicated, but also the interdicted and the manifestly infamous. Edited May 28, 2008 by KnightofChrist
StColette Posted May 28, 2008 Author Posted May 28, 2008 (edited) [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1546863' date='May 28 2008, 04:51 PM']There seems to be a basis in Can.855 §I . The publicly unworthy, who are the excommunicated, the interdicted and the manifestly infamous, unless their penance and conversion have been established and they [i]will have first made up for the public scandal[/i], are to be excluded from the Eucharist.[/quote] to make up for the public scandal can be handle in different ways, it doesn't necessarily mean with public repudation. I believe there is a stronger case with Can. 1369 A person who in a public show or speech, in published writing, or in other uses of the instruments of social communication utters blasphemy, gravely injures good morals, expresses insults, or excites hatred or contempt against religion or the Church [i]is to be punished with a just penalty.[/i] which would come down to the authority and decision of the confessor. Edited May 28, 2008 by StColette
StColette Posted May 28, 2008 Author Posted May 28, 2008 (edited) [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1546876' date='May 28 2008, 04:54 PM']Yes the excommunicated, but also the interdicted and the manifestly infamous.[/quote] the Canon is not saying excommunicated, interdicted, and manifestly infamous. It is defining the public unworthy as such. The grammar in the Canon is precise and is not making a list of who's but is rather defining who is the publicly unworthy. Those who are exommunicated are the interdicted and manifestly infamous. Edited May 28, 2008 by StColette
Lil Red Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 +J.M.J.+ [quote name='StColette' post='1546887' date='May 28 2008, 02:59 PM']to make up for the public scandal can be handle in different ways, it doesn't necessarily mean with public repudation. I believe there is a stronger case with Can. 1369 A person who in a public show or speech, in published writing, or in other uses of the instruments of social communication utters blasphemy, gravely injures good morals, expresses insults, or excites hatred or contempt against religion or the Church [i]is to be punished with a just penalty.[/i] which would come down to the authority and decision of the confessor.[/quote] agreed. [quote name='StColette' post='1546889' date='May 28 2008, 03:01 PM']the Canon is not saying excommunicated, interdicted, and manifestly infamous. It is defining the public unworthy as such. The grammar in the Canon is precise and is not making a list of who's but is rather defining who is the publicly unworthy. Those who are exommunicated are the interdicted and manifestly infamous.[/quote] thanks for the help on that.
StColette Posted May 28, 2008 Author Posted May 28, 2008 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1546896' date='May 28 2008, 05:03 PM']+J.M.J.+ thanks for the help on that. [/quote] yw lol I miss working on or with Theology on a daily basis.
StColette Posted May 28, 2008 Author Posted May 28, 2008 [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1546863' date='May 28 2008, 04:51 PM']There seems to be a basis in Can.855 §I[/quote] according to Holy See's website version of the Code of Canon Law. Can. 855 is something totally different then what was posted. Can. 855 Parents, sponsors, and the pastor are to take care that a name foreign to Christian sensibility is not given.
KnightofChrist Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1546954' date='May 28 2008, 04:27 PM']according to Holy See's website version of the Code of Canon Law. Can. 855 is something totally different then what was posted. Can. 855 Parents, sponsors, and the pastor are to take care that a name foreign to Christian sensibility is not given.[/quote] I got it from here so it can't be wrong, probably just a different Canon... [url="http://www.therealpresence.org/eucharst/holycom/denial.htm"][center]PERIODICA DE RE CANONICAvol. 96 (2007) pag. 3-58The Discipline Regarding the Denial of HolyCommunion to Those Obstinately Perseveringin Manifest Grave SinR. L. BURKE[/center][/url]
Thy Geekdom Come Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1546969' date='May 28 2008, 05:31 PM']I got it from here so it can't be wrong, probably just a different Canon... [url="http://www.therealpresence.org/eucharst/holycom/denial.htm"][center]PERIODICA DE RE CANONICAvol. 96 (2007) pag. 3-58The Discipline Regarding the Denial of HolyCommunion to Those Obstinately Perseveringin Manifest Grave SinR. L. BURKE[/center][/url][/quote] This is why those who haven't studied canon law make poor canon lawyers. You're referring to canon 855 of the [b]1917[/b] code of canon law. From the same document you linked to: "The question of those to be excluded from the reception of Most Holy Communion is treated in can. 855 of the 1917 Code of Canon Law."
StColette Posted May 28, 2008 Author Posted May 28, 2008 Micah's correct canon 855 in the 1917 Canon refers to those who hold political office. The one I was using is the 1983 copyright, I believe that's the one on the Vatican's website.
CatherineM Posted May 29, 2008 Posted May 29, 2008 I took Canon Law in '87, and we definitely used the '83 text.
KnightofChrist Posted May 29, 2008 Posted May 29, 2008 "It is fitting that one who has given public scandal, and especially one of some standing in the community, should in some way publicly acknowledge his wrongdoing and his sincere intention to better his life." [url="http://www.alibris.com/search/books/isbn/0787640042"] Scandal - The New Catholic Encyclopedia[/url]
IrishSalesian Posted May 29, 2008 Posted May 29, 2008 [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1547418' date='May 28 2008, 11:06 PM']"It is fitting that one who has given public scandal, and especially one of some standing in the community, should in some way publicly acknowledge his wrongdoing and his sincere intention to better his life." [url="http://www.alibris.com/search/books/isbn/0787640042"] Scandal - The New Catholic Encyclopedia[/url][/quote] I agree with you Knight. The Governor is a person of high stature in the community, and is usually respected by most. If the Archbishop is asking for public reparation, then public reparation is necessary because of obedience. Even if you are not bound by vows of obedience, you are to listen to your bishop. Unless of course the bishop asks you to do something immoral or sinful. If the bishop asks you not to present yourself for the reception of Holy Communion, then do not present yourself, and if you continue to ignore the bishop's request, then you will probably be excommunicated. This goes to show you that the governor does not take the bishop seriously. Also, if your job causes you to sin mortally, support abortion through legislation, then you should resign. Im surprised that the bishop has not yet asked that. But I also recognize why he has not.
StColette Posted May 29, 2008 Author Posted May 29, 2008 [quote name='IrishSalesian' post='1547481' date='May 28 2008, 10:35 PM']I agree with you Knight. The Governor is a person of high stature in the community, and is usually respected by most. If the Archbishop is asking for public reparation, then public reparation is necessary because of obedience. Even if you are not bound by vows of obedience, you are to listen to your bishop. Unless of course the bishop asks you to do something immoral or sinful. If the bishop asks you not to present yourself for the reception of Holy Communion, then do not present yourself, and if you continue to ignore the bishop's request, then you will probably be excommunicated. This goes to show you that the governor does not take the bishop seriously. Also, if your job causes you to sin mortally, support abortion through legislation, then you should resign. Im surprised that the bishop has not yet asked that. But I also recognize why he has not.[/quote] We all are in agreement that if the Archbishop asks it of her then she should. But what we are looking for is if Code of Canon Law or some authoritative text from the Holy See says that all public official if they cause public scandal are [b]required[/b] by Church Law or authority to make public reparation. If your Bishop tells you to do something, and it being moral of course, then you do it. We just want to know if it is [b]required[/b] of all public officials who cause public scandal. We have yet to find anything in Code of Canon Law or another authoritative text that comes right out and says that they are [b]required[/b] to do so.
KnightofChrist Posted May 29, 2008 Posted May 29, 2008 (edited) "Reparation for Scandal. As to the duty of making reparation for having given scandal,[b] it would seem clear[/b] that if, by his words or actions, one has led others into serious temptation or sin, he [b]should[/b] do what he can to undo the wrong. At the very least, he [b]should[/b] offset the bad example previously given by the good example that he now strives to offer. Generally, indeed, the reparation that is demonstrated by a [b]visible and outward[/b] change of life will be the best way to make reparation. It is fitting that one who has given public scandal, and especially one of some standing in the community, [b]should[/b] in some way publicly acknowledge his wrongdoing and his sincere intention to better his life. It is fitting that one who has given public scandal, and especially one of some standing in the community, should in some way publicly acknowledge his wrongdoing and his sincere intention to better his life." [url="http://www.alibris.com/search/books/isbn/0787640042"] Scandal - The New Catholic Encyclopedia[/url] Edited May 29, 2008 by KnightofChrist
IrishSalesian Posted May 29, 2008 Posted May 29, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1547503' date='May 28 2008, 11:44 PM']We all are in agreement that if the Archbishop asks it of her then she should. But what we are looking for is if Code of Canon Law or some authoritative text from the Holy See says that all public official if they cause public scandal are [b]required[/b] by Church Law or authority to make public reparation. If your Bishop tells you to do something, and it being moral of course, then you do it. We just want to know if it is [b]required[/b] of all public officials who cause public scandal. We have yet to find anything in Code of Canon Law or another authoritative text that comes right out and says that they are [b]required[/b] to do so.[/quote] OK, i do not believe that it is required by cannon law. I think all this is now is a matter of obedience. Or lack there of.
KnightofChrist Posted May 29, 2008 Posted May 29, 2008 Is the New Catholic Encyclopedia article on scandal not authoritative text?
StColette Posted May 29, 2008 Author Posted May 29, 2008 [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1547532' date='May 28 2008, 10:53 PM']Is the New Catholic Encyclopedia article on scandal not authoritative text?[/quote] No, an authoritative text is something that is written by the magisterium.
IrishSalesian Posted May 29, 2008 Posted May 29, 2008 [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1547532' date='May 28 2008, 11:53 PM']Is the New Catholic Encyclopedia article on scandal not authoritative text?[/quote] Is there a source given in the encyclopedia? If not then the excerpt is purely academic, not authoritative.
CatherineM Posted May 29, 2008 Posted May 29, 2008 If you can't find one, it may just be that is considered an area at the discretion of her confessor. I can't image a confessor not making some kind of public pronouncement in her case a part of her penance.
IrishSalesian Posted May 29, 2008 Posted May 29, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1547631' date='May 29 2008, 12:10 AM']If you can't find one, it may just be that is considered an area at the discretion of her confessor. I can't image a confessor not making some kind of public pronouncement in her case a part of her penance.[/quote] The Bishop can reserve the right to be the only one that is to absolve this sin for this person. So the pastor of this lady, may not be able to absolve her from this sin. This is the big IF i think.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now