Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

CatherineM
Posted

I live in a very multicultural neighborhood. Our condo has 12 units, and there are people from 9 different countries living here. I love it. The problem comes when people use the word multiculturalism to mean everything is allowed except Christianity because we are the oppressors. That's when things go wacko.

Posted

[quote]In my experience, relativism has affected education, at least indirectly. I'm an English major, and I don't like when teachers just leave interpretations to the individual, and say that there is no right interpretation. Classes become about nothing more than feelings and personal opinion. To a certain degree, I am not against interpretation. We all have different perspectives on literature. But I think teachers should teach more with facts, and challenge more with sound, scholarly, and traditional interpretations. They don't necessarily have to tell the student, "This is what the text means." But I think a teacher has to lead them in the right direction, and that requires the teacher to assert himself into the discussion. A teacher cannot just be a facilitator. He has to encourage thinking, but he also has to give students the basic foundation on which to think, and this requires him to be grounded in the truth.[/quote]

All of this fine in the practice of a multiculturalism in the classroom, as long as the teacher identifies the perspectives that they bring to the classroom, and this is my point.

If you are Catholic you can say, I believe in an absolute truth as long as you identify that it is because you are Catholic. The conflict with critical multiculturalism only comes if and when you say this is truth - because it just is, because a school should be a place for critical thought and the student is not subjected to your belief as fact (even if Era and FreeSoul know this to BE fact). In other words - where there is a difference of belief - it is good to acknowledge, included and respect its place in curriculum- even if not agreed with. No - this is not always easy!

[quote]In America, for example, sometimes Hispanic or Native American writers express disregard for Christianity in favor of the pagan religions of their ancestors.[/quote]

But can't we see why? African and Indigenous cultures were nearly obliterated by European settlers and so it is natural that people look back to where they came from in order to understand who they are! We understand that the english language is often the 'language of commerce' although, if it was forced on a group of people, and then that same group of people was systemically denied access to equal education for decades would they not want to bastardize it?? If we acknowledge peoples histories, political and spiritual - then we can reconcile them (and I do not use the word reconcile lightly!)

mommas_boy
Posted

[quote name='FreeSoul' post='1549791' date='May 30 2008, 05:49 PM']I think that would depend on the context, because in practice a multicultural school that shaped curriculum around moral relativism or any other ideology [b]without critiquing itself would be at odds with its own purpose[/b].[/quote]

I teach science. Believe me, we'll be doing a lot of that in my classroom. :D

[quote]I think the important factor here would be to investigate prior to teaching if that is in fact the case at the school, rather than throwing the baby out with the bath water, because in my opinion Toronto is a fantastic city, and I my Catholic life has not been threatened, and also we do not have nearly the same forms of racism (although I am not ignorant - we have a significant amount) as that which exists in regions of the United States. This is almost exclusively due to the policy of multiculturalism and the institutions which protect it (i.e. the Ontario Human Rights Tribunal)[/quote]

Don't get me wrong; I'm still going to apply there. To be absolutely honest, I think that it is my first choice school for the fall. I [b]know[/b] that I am called to be a public school teacher here in Chicago, and the thing about this school that I don't feel from others is that there is an incredible sense of commitment and spirit in a small-school setting. The principal has vision and drive, and really works with the teachers, and the school has a strong emphasis on [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Critical_pedagogy"]critical pedagogy[/url], which, in my experience, is all but required to reach students in an urban setting such as this. One may even use the same pedagogy to teach students about the dangers of contraception as an injustice. Talk about being a subversive!

Mostly, my question was in regards to what were some of the [b]potential[/b] theological dangers of the issue, so that I may inform my own conscience, and so that I know what aspects of the philosophy to avoid should I decide to work there. [b]From what I understand about multiculturalism, it is not the spirit of multiculturalism that we should be concerned with, as this spirit is based on the legitimate desire to include others. Instead, what gives cause to worry about multiculturalism is the unintended byproduct in the culture of relativism that it can sometimes create[/b].

Posted

Sorry sorry....didn't mean to tangent there....I just got all fired up about multiculturalism...oooooooooooops :doh:

Winchester
Posted

Didn't multiculturalism destroy the Roman Empire?

mommas_boy
Posted

[quote name='Winchester' post='1549849' date='May 30 2008, 06:38 PM']Didn't multiculturalism destroy the Roman Empire?[/quote]

If by "multiculturalism" you mean us Catholics, then yes! :lol:

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='FreeSoul' post='1549773' date='May 30 2008, 05:36 PM']I forgot to address this part.

Slavery was the result of imperialism, in other words ... [i]the complete opposite of multiculturalism. [/i] The slaves were not Christians but were [b]forced [/b]to be Christians.[/quote]
Actually, that's inaccurate. Many slave-traders and slave-holders considered the slaves to be unworthy (or incapable) of accepting Christianity. It was often they who wanted to be Christian because they saw a life of hope in Christian belief, and it was Pope Gregory XVI who ardently supported the rights of slaves to become Christians (and supported the need to evangelize them in the midst of many who said they should not be evangelized). It was also Gregory XVI who placed automatic excommunication on anyone involved in the slave trade in the Canary Islands.

God bless,

Micah

Posted (edited)

I am specifically addressing the comment about american slaves, after they were socialized out of their traditional cultures. They were allowed to have churches, but they had to be separate. The Catholic Church usually had a very different stance on slavery and colonialism, partially due to dogma, and partially their political competition with other european countries.

------

also, slaves in Africa typically were transients who were being adopted into a different tribe, but could assimilate and work their way up in society or buy their way into freedom.

When the trans-atlantic slave trade began, this ended and the slaves were given new names and forced to adopt another identity, but denied the ability to participate in the greater culture (no voting, no schools, no church) because they were not seen as human beings (if that is what you mean by 'unworthy'. So the statement about Africans wanting to be Christian is a half-truth, it was as much about becoming politically salient in a monolithic culture as the desire to achieve salvation.

Edited by FreeSoul
Galloglasses
Posted (edited)

[quote name='mommas_boy' post='1549728' date='May 30 2008, 03:44 PM'][1]Please define your understanding of "critical multiculturalism" so that we all know that we are talking about the same thing. Also, I'm not so certain that my understanding of the term is as advanced as I would like, and so the discussion should be helpful.[/quote]
Critical Multiculturalism=Criticise Traditional/Dominent/National/Social/Religious to your fullest extent while promoting the good aspects of every other culture possible. Include others, exclude your own. Basically what England did in regards to multiculturalism, in seeking to reconcile all cultures, they sacrificed their own and are slowly becoming cultureless.

[quote][2]Please list any strengths that you are familiar with in regards to the term.[/quote]
Strengths: Helps students of different backgrounds, especially if such students are in the minority in the classroom, feel included and more secure in their identity.

[quote][1]Please list any weaknesses / areas of worry that you are aware of.[/quote]
Weaknesses: Sours opinion of said Traditional/Dominent/National/Social/Religious Culture in the majority of the classroom and many Students of said culture become dissillusioned and more or less dislike or even hate (don't hate, appreciate) the culture they came from. Look what happens to students in Berkely.

Not a very detailed reply, but its half 2 in the morning here, may reply again later.

Edited by Galloglasses
mommas_boy
Posted

[quote name='Galloglasses' post='1550038' date='May 30 2008, 09:25 PM']Critical Multiculturalism=Criticise Traditional/Dominent/National/Social/Religious to your fullest extent while promoting the good aspects of every other culture possible. Include others, exclude your own. Basically what England did in regards to multiculturalism, in seeking to reconcile all cultures, they sacrificed their own and are slowly becoming cultureless.
Strengths: Helps students of different backgrounds, especially if such students are in the minority in the classroom, feel included and more secure in their identity.
Weaknesses: Sours opinion of said Traditional/Dominent/National/Social/Religious Culture in the majority of the classroom and many Students of said culture become dissillusioned and more or less dislike or even hate (don't hate, appreciate) (don't hate (don't hate, appreciate), appreciate) the culture they came from. Look what happens to students in Berkely.

Not a very detailed reply, but its half 2 in the morning here, may reply again later.[/quote]

Interesting replies, and thank you for them. I agree with you that concerns that you listed are legitimate dangers, but I believe that none of them are impossible to recover from, if the teacher is skilled at this. For instance, I can be critical of American culture and slavery as is being discussed elsewhere in this thread, but still not hate (don't hate, appreciate) and loathe my culture. I believe that any failure in this regard is not the fault of the pedagogy, but is instead the failure of the teacher to temper their efforts. Still, as the teacher who would be responsible for this task, it is good to that we discuss them. So, what ideas might you have to counter-act this side-effect?

Posted

[quote name='FreeSoul' post='1549761' date='May 30 2008, 05:21 PM']No it is not a mask for relativism.

Relativism is when you say that all beliefs are right/wrong.

Multiculturalism is when we say that all CULTURES are respected in a society. Cultures are more than beliefs - which are just one part of a culture which is made up of traditions, sexual and gender roles, artistic endeavours. concepts of beauty, diets, entertainments anything.

Mistaking culture for truth is simplistic and dangerous. More to come...[/quote]

+

With all due respect, I see problems in the argument above. Certain cultures incorporate infanticide, abortion, child-molestation, genital-mutilation, pornography, polygamy, and cannibalism just to name a few in their beliefs and practices. Therefore, it seems that the argument/definition for "multi-culturalism" above is reductio ad absurdum.

Allow me to elaborate: Why would we "respect" a culture that is founded on these beliefs and principles? We may respect individuals, but that does not mean we ought or need to respect their particular beliefs, even if we recognize their right to have them -but not act on them. But perhaps, we need to define "respect"? Does it mean "to honor" to "give recognition" to "allow"? These are very different things with different implications.

The Holy Fathers JPII and Benedict XVI have written on the interplay of rights, freedom, and responsibilities unceasingly over the last 30 years. I'm not able to sound-bite them here, but I think that's the best place to start in your research for a firm guiding principle in your paper Momma's Boy. Try the encyclicals of JPII for one e.g. Splendour Veritatis.

Thanks for the discussion, friends.
V

Posted

+

Hmm... slaves the result of imperialism? One does wonder about the pre-colonial, hindu-based caste society of India fitting into this paradigm. Of course, there were slaves all over the east in communities, which would not generally be considered "imperialist".

Slavery, of course, we see in reverse of a black on white when the Egyptians held the Jews captive for centuries (even longer than the North American Experience) before the time of Christ as recounted in the Hebrew Scriptures.

Galloglasses
Posted (edited)

[quote name='mommas_boy' post='1550315' date='May 31 2008, 01:07 AM']Interesting replies, and thank you for them. I agree with you that concerns that you listed are legitimate dangers, but I believe that none of them are impossible to recover from, if the teacher is skilled at this. For instance, I can be critical of American culture and slavery as is being discussed elsewhere in this thread, but still not hate (don't hate, appreciate) (don't hate (don't hate, appreciate), appreciate) (don't hate (don't hate, appreciate) (don't hate (don't hate, appreciate), appreciate), appreciate) and loathe my culture. I believe that any failure in this regard is not the fault of the pedagogy, but is instead the failure of the teacher to temper their efforts. Still, as the teacher who would be responsible for this task, it is good to that we discuss them. So, what ideas might you have to counter-act this side-effect?[/quote]
I would seriously consider, when criticising American Culture, focus on the bad things first, then hit them very heavily with the good things. This way you can prove you are not witholding or reserving opinion or pushing your own, while making sure that the students see the bad of their culture and past of America, while keeping an image ofthe good in their minds. IE: Slavery, yet the American President Abraham Lincon was willing to go to war to abolish it. Slap the bad with one hand, punch the good with the other.

When argueing with other cultures, in practice focus with the good first, then hit with the bad, the reverse of what you do with American Culture. This is a subtle method, on the outside you can be seen as criticsing ALL cultures and traditions, when in reality, the way you word it and the way you handle the class, you can influence your own ideas and opinions on your students while educating them about the world and other cultures. This may seem underhanded, but in reality it isn't, its political. This way you can spread the faith and Catholic social teaching, which is 'right-wing' by most leftist opinions, without overtly attacking the students or shoving it down their throats... Or letting your superiors know what you are doing.

I devleope these sort of ideas when I study Political Science and English literature, it is so unbelieveably easy to manipulate the opinions of people in singles or in crowds it is absolutely scary. The only hope we can have in such regards that orators and teachers will Teach and Tell them the truth. Because if they don't, someone else will teach them a lie.

Edited by Galloglasses
mommas_boy
Posted

Hi guys. Just an update.

I taught my lesson today at the school, and it went exceptionally well. One girl did call me a bad name in Spanish, to which I and the other students told her, "Mira la boca!", but I've had MUCH worse in my student teaching stints here in Chicago. I had her laughing and enjoying the lesson soon after that, though.

Anyhow, I was offered the job after the lesson, and I accepted! This is my first real teaching job, and I am incredibly excited. The principal interviewed me on Friday, and he grilled me very hard. Compare this to other schools where I interviewed; they were simply looking to fill the position, and didn't really care so long as I had a teaching certificate and was endorsed to teach chemistry. There are so many other things going on at this school that tell me that this is a very special place where I will receive the kind of mentorship that I need in order to really grow as a teacher. Plus, they are going to pay me an extra $10K to teach there, as part of their mentorship program!

Anyway, I really need your prayers right now that the job goes through. The teaching position is a brand new one, because the school is growing and they need another teacher. That said, there is a chance that the funding might not go through. I am still interviewing at other schools just in case, but this is really where I want to be.

Thanks again, guys, for all of your help!

Galloglasses
Posted

You're welcome and prayers

Archaeology cat
Posted

Awesome! And will continue to pray. :pray:

cmotherofpirl
Posted

I am glad you got the job and I am sure you will do well in it.
Back to your original discussion, my problem with this topic is two-fold. Sometimes its simply a mask for teaching victimhood like Rev Wright does. Second not all cultures are equal as pointed out, and while you can support people, as a catholic you cannot support all cultures.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1549767' date='May 30 2008, 05:28 PM']Fr. Pacwa from EWTN has a CD called "Relativism and Her Three Ugly Sisters." The three ugly sisters are individualism, pluralism, and multiculturalism.[/quote]
:o I was just at a conference where Fr. Pacwa gave that exact talk!

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1556308' date='Jun 3 2008, 05:56 PM']:o I was just at a conference where Fr. Pacwa gave that exact talk![/quote]
Do tell!

homeschoolmom
Posted

It was really good. However, it took me awhile to figure out where he was going with his talk because he was supposed to be talking on discerning God's will for your life... he... um... didn't read his schedule carefully....

He was supposed to give both talks at the conference, just in the other order.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...