CatherineM Posted June 3, 2008 Posted June 3, 2008 Congratulations on the job. Teaching is a great calling.
mommas_boy Posted June 4, 2008 Author Posted June 4, 2008 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1556300' date='Jun 3 2008, 04:50 PM']I am glad you got the job and I am sure you will do well in it.[/quote] Thank you! [quote]Back to your original discussion, my problem with this topic is two-fold. [b]Sometimes[/b] its simply a mask for teaching [b]victimhood[/b] like Rev Wright does.[/quote] A good point. I do want to make issue of this word, "sometimes", as well as "victimhood". I believe that focusing on illegitimate victimhood is unjust. However, focusing on legitimate victimhood is required. Being an urban educator, my eyes are opened every day to the latter. Being a scientist, and therefore pragmatist, I am constantly questioning the former. I try very hard to incorporate issues of social justice into my chemistry curriculum. There are very many issues that are relevant: lower scores of minorities in the sciences in America are just one. Others are issues of environmental import: the power plant just down the street from the school where I student taught spits out 170 lbs of mercury into the air every year, adversely affecting one in six pregnancies. There are still a great deal of lead pipes in the Chicago water system. Superfund sites. Etc. And then there are injustices that are wrought because of strains of poverty that have nothing to do with science or student achievement in them. I don't want to discount the legitimacy of these issues. On the other hand, it is very important to avoid sensationalism. I am reminded of the high school teacher favorite: exploring the dangers of [url="http://www.dhmo.org"]dihydrogen monoxide[/url]. Check out the website: the facts are all true: inhalation of DMHO will cause death; it is a greenhouse gas; it is caustic, and contributes to the formation of acid rain; and is the single greatest factor contributing to natural disasters such as tsunamis and hurricanes. The issue is so serious that the California municipality of Alisa Viejo nearly voted to outlaw the chemical. The problem is, this dangerous chemical is nothing other than water: H2O (dihydrogen monoxide is an IUPAC name for water). The website, [url="http://www.dhmo.org"]www.dhmo.org[/url], was created not with the purpose of being a clever prank, but rather satire in order to demonstrate a very important point: one may tell a lie by saying nothing but the truth. We must be ever on guard against sensationalism. Further, even in the case of legitimate victimhood, a teacher that focuses solely on the negative nature of that victimhood rather than providing their students with a means of escape or correcting an injustice visited upon them could be argued as causing more harm than good. Then again, there is some benefit to merely raising awareness, but these kids need to feel that THEY are in control for once, and not merely on board for the ride. [quote]Second not all cultures are equal as pointed out, and while you can support people, as a catholic you cannot support all cultures.[/quote] An interesting point. I will think on this further.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now