Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

I am sorry to admit that I am totally baffled by Phatmass. When I look at the forum, I see a subforum for "whatever you want to talk about"...and then the debate tables, where many of the threads turn into arguments between either Catholics and Catholics, or Catholics and Non-Catholics; and then the election section, where tensions seem to run equally as high. The stuff that is actually more Catholic related is kind of pushed towards the bottom.

Is this really what the Catholic faith is about? Arguing, lack of charity towards others, snide comments? That is all I have seen in my short time here. I came here because someone else recommended it, and I am having a lot of trouble faithwise. I was hoping to find some inspiration or encouragement of some kind and see charity and kindness being practiced among the forum. I am sad to say that my faith has diminished further as a result of using this forum.

I don't know if you all know the vibe you're sending out, but I don't think it is a good one. I don't know if it is just me who feels this way.

Edited by Kitty
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Kitty' post='1565979' date='Jun 10 2008, 12:16 AM']I am sorry to admit that I am totally baffled by Phatmass. When I look at the forum, I see a subforum for "whatever you want to talk about"...and then the debate tables, where many of the threads turn into arguments between either Catholics and Catholics, or Catholics and Non-Catholics; and then the election section, where tensions seem to run equally as high. The stuff that is actually more Catholic related is kind of pushed towards the bottom.

Is this really what the Catholic faith is about? Arguing, lack of charity towards others, snide comments? That is all I have seen in my short time here. I came here because someone else recommended it, and I am having a lot of trouble faithwise. I was hoping to find some inspiration or encouragement of some kind and see charity and kindness being practiced among the forum. I am sad to say that my faith has diminished further as a result of using this forum.

I don't know if you all know the vibe you're sending out, but I don't think it is a good one. I don't know if it is just me who feels this way.[/quote]

I am sorry if I have in any way contributed to your feelings about Phatmass. :console:

This was actually brought up not too long ago by another member and pretty much got brushed aside. Maybe now it will be taken more seriously.

Edited by Alycin
HisChildForever
Posted

Phatmass is set up as a very personal community - in my opinion, anyway - and like any family, there will be tension, arguing, bickering, etc. Of course that doesn't justify it, but that's the sense that I make of it.

I get a different vibe, but it's not really anyone's fault, it just...is. There are regulars here, and a lot of them know each other in person (from what I've gathered), and while "clique" isn't the right word to use, it's difficult to feel completely welcome (again, maybe that isn't the right word) sometimes. But of course, this happens whenever you start a new job and go to a new school, too. Just an observation.

Posted

I'm a moderate in most things. I believe in social justice, fighting for the vulnerable and marginalized. I like the modern post Vatican II church, new music, and lively masses in English. I try to defend faithfully all the teachings of the Magisterium, Sacred Scripture, and the Traditions of the church. I believe in fighting for life from conception to a natural death. I also prefer to deal with other Christian denominations or other faiths communities with tolerance. I know that my stance on modern music, the Novus Ordo mass, and my opposition to the death penalty, will get me stomped on occasionally here. I know that there is a valid argument that Catholics are allowed to believe in the death penalty, but I just can't. I don't think other people are wrong for their belief, I just prefer Pope John Paul's teaching on the matter.

When I get attacked for holding beliefs that are allowed by the church, I used to get very upset. Now I just have my say, and pull out of the discussion when it gets nasty. It is hard when being attacked for holding valid beliefs, but the debate can be worth something. It's good for me to practice my tolerance with those who do hold opposing view points, and many times, I do learn something that I didn't know before. It's okay to have an open mind in a debate even when those you are debating do not have theirs open. There is also charity in understanding that some people are so rigid in their beliefs, that they are incapable of hearing anything that contradicts them. It's kind of like television. If the picture offends me, I just change the channel.

Posted (edited)

well, as a non catholic with opposing views on handgun control, gay marriage and the attitude towards gay people, the death penalty and a whole lot more topics, i tend to either get ignored by people too caught up in themselves to recognize statements that they don't believe in, or get shut out like an annoying child and occasionally personally attacked.

not everyone does this, several people coming from both sides are kind and well mannered on this board and they make it all worth it. the above posters Alycin, and CatherineM come to mind, along with many of the regulars on the lame board. after idly chatting with the people here and learning that they are all kind hearted people, it makes it harder to treat each other as "the faceless enemy"

Edited by Jesus_lol
Posted

[quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1566315' date='Jun 10 2008, 02:02 AM']......................[/quote]


:):):)

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1566315' date='Jun 10 2008, 03:02 AM']well, as a non catholic with opposing views on handgun control, gay marriage and the attitude towards gay people, the death penalty and a whole lot more topics, i tend to either get ignored by people too caught up in themselves to recognize statements that they don't believe in, or get shut out like an annoying child and occasionally personally attacked.

not everyone does this, several people coming from both sides are kind and well mannered on this board and they make it all worth it. the above posters Alycin, and CatherineM come to mind, along with many of the regulars on the lame board. after idly chatting with the people here and learning that they are all kind hearted people, it makes it harder to treat each other as "the faceless enemy"[/quote]

I hope I am not considered one of your "faceless enemies."

Edited by kujo
Posted

hardly, kujo. you are a nice guy as far as i know. no, i dont think i consider anyone here a faceless enemy. what we see of each other here is only the tip of the iceberg, and i try and remember that when dealing with others.

Posted

Thanks JL. You rock.

Posted

+J.M.J.+
i'd just like to add, that, we're not saints. we're sinners. i'm a sinner, for sure. so if you've come here looking for saints, they're not here. should we do our best to exhibit Christian charity, humility, and love? :) of course, but with as many members as we have, someone is always going to be having a bad day. i try to stay off the boards if i'm cranky, but i don't always have that option. :hehe:

PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

Kitty, Welcome

I don't think I've run across you on any of the thread yet. Give Transmundane Lane a try. There generally seems to be a little less bickering there. Q&A is really good if you have specific questions. The other boards for me really just looking for some fun stuff for the most part, and light hearted conversation. With the exception of Debate. I try to remember that not everyone is schooled in the art of debate and formulation of good arguments, sometimmes it is easy for someone to misconcieve an attack on someone's beliefs as not being an attack on them. I hope your experience gets more enjoyable, and a reminder of the need for Christian charity and love is never a bad thing.

Thanks. :cool:

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Kitty' post='1565979' date='Jun 10 2008, 01:16 AM']I am sorry to admit that I am totally baffled by Phatmass. When I look at the forum, I see a subforum for "whatever you want to talk about"...and then the debate tables, where many of the threads turn into arguments between either Catholics and Catholics, or Catholics and Non-Catholics; and then the election section, where tensions seem to run equally as high. The stuff that is actually more Catholic related is kind of pushed towards the bottom.[/quote]

I've never noticed that. Most of the time, I check Open Mic, Debate, Transmundane, and occasionally Vocation Station. Having been around a number of forums, I've learned that the trolls are going to show up on every site, along with the people who don't know how to debate, people who refuse to listen, etc. The Internet just brings out the worst in people, plain and simple.

[quote name='Kitty' post='1565979' date='Jun 10 2008, 01:16 AM']Is this really what the Catholic faith is about? Arguing, lack of charity towards others, snide comments? That is all I have seen in my short time here. I came here because someone else recommended it, and I am having a lot of trouble faithwise. I was hoping to find some inspiration or encouragement of some kind and see charity and kindness being practiced among the forum. I am sad to say that my faith has diminished further as a result of using this forum.[/quote]

Then I'd encourage you to read the Transmundante, Prayer, Lame, and Open Mic areas. Debate and political discussion are never going to be friendly ground no matter what web site you're on. Maybe they should be moved lower down on the main phorum page to avoid the implication that they're a higher priority than serious spirituality and prayer... guess that would be dust (the ultra-handsome)'s call.

Posted

[quote name='Kitty' post='1565979' date='Jun 10 2008, 01:16 AM']I am sorry to admit that I am totally baffled by Phatmass. When I look at the forum, I see a subforum for "whatever you want to talk about"...and then the debate tables, where many of the threads turn into arguments between either Catholics and Catholics, or Catholics and Non-Catholics; and then the election section, where tensions seem to run equally as high. The stuff that is actually more Catholic related is kind of pushed towards the bottom.

Is this really what the Catholic faith is about? Arguing, lack of charity towards others, snide comments? That is all I have seen in my short time here. I came here because someone else recommended it, and I am having a lot of trouble faithwise. I was hoping to find some inspiration or encouragement of some kind and see charity and kindness being practiced among the forum. I am sad to say that my faith has diminished further as a result of using this forum.

I don't know if you all know the vibe you're sending out, but I don't think it is a good one. I don't know if it is just me who feels this way.[/quote]

Me personally, I don't share the same vibe. I can see how the Debate Table and the Election Section can become pretty heated at times, but those subjects naturally can arise emotions to begin with (it's not an excuse, but it's predictable. I'm guilty of this). Out of the countless forum communities (Christian and secular) I've posted or browsed, Phatmass is one of the most chartiable [b]and[/b] genuine message boards that I've ever witnessed. I've been a member on a handful of other Christian forums (both Catholic and non-Catholic), and unfortunately it seems some of them (predominately the Protestant ones) are so afraid of conflict with one another, that they are 'too happy' to the point where it seems fake. Some people, including myself, do not like fake people. If I want to talk to somebody about a subject, I want their [b]real opinion[/b], not some politically-correct, nicey nice answer that masks their true feelings. When I'm dealing with fake personalities it does me an injustice, because those people are not being truthful to me; and in many cases, are probally talking bad behind my back. You can be charitable but also honest, and unfortunately it's very common for someone to read inbetween the words and receive a different emotional tone than what the author originally intended. It's hard to read peoples' emotions through simple text, not impossible, but still hard.

Though at the sametime, there have been phases on Phatmass where the overall mood may sway into a more negative direction, while others seems more positive. With that, I can say this through personal account: [b]almost every forum community experiences the same 'mood swings'[/b]. Does this mean we should be complacent and just continue any uncharitable behavior? No. We should always strive to better ourselves, and also realize at the sametime that we are imperfect, we are sinners, we are human.

Comparing some of the forums I've either registered or browsed, this place most certainly has charity.


[quote name='CatherineM' post='1566061' date='Jun 10 2008, 01:42 AM']I'm a moderate in most things. I believe in social justice, fighting for the vulnerable and marginalized. I like the modern post Vatican II church, new music, and lively masses in English. I try to defend faithfully all the teachings of the Magisterium, Sacred Scripture, and the Traditions of the church. I believe in fighting for life from conception to a natural death. I also prefer to deal with other Christian denominations or other faiths communities with tolerance. I know that my stance on modern music, the Novus Ordo mass, and my opposition to the death penalty, will get me stomped on occasionally here. I know that there is a valid argument that Catholics are allowed to believe in the death penalty, but I just can't. I don't think other people are wrong for their belief, I just prefer Pope John Paul's teaching on the matter.

When I get attacked for holding beliefs that are allowed by the church, I used to get very upset. Now I just have my say, and pull out of the discussion when it gets nasty. It is hard when being attacked for holding valid beliefs, but the debate can be worth something. It's good for me to practice my tolerance with those who do hold opposing view points, and many times, I do learn something that I didn't know before. It's okay to have an open mind in a debate even when those you are debating do not have theirs open. There is also charity in understanding that some people are so rigid in their beliefs, that they are incapable of hearing anything that contradicts them. It's kind of like television. If the picture offends me, I just change the channel.[/quote]

At times, some members of Phatmass seem to develop an attituide that anything pre-Vatican II was superior to post-Vatican II, while still being loyal to the current Magisterium. I agree with many of the examples you just listed, and they are just as Catholic as someone who may have a different (yet valid) approach. I'm orthodox in my faith, and I'm assuming you are as well. It doesn't make us any less Catholic or devout, we just have a different viewpoint that in no way diminishes the Sacredness of the Faith. I don't care if a fellow Catholic prefers the Tridentine Mass over the Novus Ordo Mass, what I find most important is their stances are on the core beliefs and issues of the Catholic faith. Everything else, in the big scheme of things, is trivial. If one starts to nitpick at every little detail, then that individual is prone to develop a pharisaical approach to one's spiritual journey with Christ. (I have a feeling my statement will be interpreted in the wrong way, as to identify my viewpoint as one who has a relativistic outlook on the rubics, traditions, and customs of the Catholic Mass and of the Faith in general).


[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1566519' date='Jun 10 2008, 11:27 AM']I've never noticed that. Most of the time, I check Open Mic, Debate, Transmundane, and occasionally Vocation Station. Having been around a number of forums, I've learned that the trolls are going to show up on every site, along with the people who don't know how to debate, people who refuse to listen, etc. The Internet just brings out the worst in people, plain and simple.[/quote]

Unfortunately, this is a sad reality. I laughed so hard when I was watching a Canadian news broadcast, they were covering a story about "Internet" when it was first released to the public (it was a 1993 broadcast), and one of the users commented how friendly, tolerant, and charitable Internet was, and how there was no cursing, flames, or aggressive behavior. :lol:

Boy, has "Internet" changed since then. :lol:


[quote]Then I'd encourage you to read the Transmundante, Prayer, Lame, and Open Mic areas. Debate and political discussion are never going to be friendly ground no matter what web site you're on. Maybe they should be moved lower down on the main phorum page to avoid the implication that they're a higher priority than serious spirituality and prayer... guess that would be dust (the ultra-handsome) (the ultra-handsome)'s call.[/quote]

I could be wrong, but I believe the Prayer section used to be at the very top of the forum. I wouldn't mind having it relocated back up there again.

Posted (edited)

Double post.

Edited by Paladin D
Posted (edited)

Triple post.

Edited by Paladin D
PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

good post PaladinD

dominicansoul
Posted

I've been on here since February of this year. I don't know anybody. But I do believe you can not truly share your thoughts here without having them kaboshed and badly judged by certain individuals. There is no true "intelligent" debate...it seems that one side or the other turn against one another so quickly, and things can get ugly fast.

I think the favorite place for me is the Lame Board, because there, we just seem to have a lot of fun with one another. I laugh so much at what you guys post there....and it's there in that board where I feel we are the most Catholic with one another. You can really feel the love on that board....I wish we could be like this on the other boards.

Posted

I have been on here for six months. When I first came on I would get very upset very quickly with people because they were so convinced that everything they said was the only way to think. It took a while but, I started to realize, I was just as adament about some of my beliefs. I try to temper myself and just enjoy the difference of opinion.

Yes, there are people on here who profess to be Catholic or Christian and their posting manner does not show that at all.

What I have discovered is that there are some incredible people here. People who are kind and caring and loving and open and expressive. I do gravitate to the lame board because it always makes me laugh. I also love reading some of the other threads that I don't contribute to, just to get information.
I have learned so much about my faith just by looking topics up so I can debate them.

I say give it some time. I love it!!

Posted

*Seconds what Deb said*

Posted

[quote name='PadrePioOfPietrelcino' post='1566681' date='Jun 10 2008, 02:22 PM']good post PaladinD[/quote]

Thanks [b]PPoP[/b]. :lol:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...