dominicansoul Posted June 10, 2008 Posted June 10, 2008 I do believe there is a lot of truth in your concerns, Kitty. I do think that what happens, is that we all have a real problem "listening" to one another....or "reading" one another's points. I think a lot of times, people don't really understand fully what another is trying to express, and therefore, (and this really shouldn't happen, but it does...) they can be quite judgemental in their replies. This is why a dear friend of mine left this website a few months ago. And she is a Nun. I have to agree, I do have much of the same concerns you do.... ...but I don't have any personal hard feelings for anyone here, as I hope no one does for me, either. We aren't perfect people, we are struggling sinners... I contemplate not coming on here much anymore, but hey, I'm leaving to enter the convent very soon, and I'm sure a lot of what happens on these boards is happening there too! It's all a part of growing in virtue! We all help one another out to be the best we can be.... humility...humility....humility....
Paladin D Posted June 10, 2008 Posted June 10, 2008 In response to [b]dominicansoul[/b] and [b]Deb[/b]'s posts: I'm afraid there are times that people are quick to judge. Of course we cannot confuse judgement with correction, because the "don't judge lest ye be judge" phrase is overused to death that it has lost it's true meaning in society. I'm glad you guys realize that not everyone acts in this matter, and nor the ones who do are always like that. Sometimes we may have a bad day, log on, and just snap at someone over something simple. Though I do want to make something clear: [b]You will rarely find an actual forum debate where both sides think they aren't right[/b]. What I mean is, both parties that are debating a particular issue will always have a level of stubbornness and a sense that they truely are right and that you are wrong (in one way or more). This doesn't necessarily mean that there is hard feelings attached (though in cases they can develop). I used to debate almost every, single, day on more than one message board, which would take literally hours out of my day. Though since then, my schedule has become increasingly demanding and whatever "free time" I have, I'm either busy working on a project or just relaxing and enjoying the company of family and friends. I suppose I'm just used to how debating usually is, even the more professional debates I've witnessed have a level of tension and stubbornness. So it doesn't really bother me. If you want to discuss about matters of the Faith, that are not open for debate, that is why we have the [b]Transmundane Lane (serious spirituality)[/b] section.
Deus te Amat Posted June 10, 2008 Posted June 10, 2008 I love this phorum. It has been a support to me in my faith when I receive no support at home. I have met wonderful people here, and I've enjoyed myself in the process. That isn't to say that I've not gotten frustrated with members or upset at antics. I've left twice for periods of time because of that frustration, and I came back willing to reconcile differences. I am now good friends with one of those frustrating persons. The problem is a lack of understanding the other person, in some cases, or in obstinate souls in others. I tend to stay away from the debate table, because some of those obstinate souls tend to stay there. This forum, as others have said, is like one giant family. My family in particular has struggled with differences and conflicts. This forum functions better than my own family, with more charity shown. I also came here from another forum, and I must say that I prefer it here. The people are intelligent, mature, and know when to have a good time. It may seem cliquish at first, but that is because relationships have developed over time, and as a member here just over a year, I can say honestly that it is possible to be welcomed into that family. Kitty, you have valid statements, but you are seeing what is on the surface. People here have hearts and souls, senses of humor, and depth. Come join us on the lame board... We may be classified as "lame" but I have seen so much support and depth of thought from some of its regulars. I will pray for you and I hope to see you around. Pax Christi, DtA
StColette Posted June 10, 2008 Posted June 10, 2008 I'm going to come to the defense of the debate table. lol I'm a stickler for charity, most on here know that lol. As for the arguing that seems to be taking place in the debate table it's really nothing new. I would not say that it's Catholic on Catholic debate, which is not allowed in the Debate Table or anywhere on Phatmass. Catholics are going to disagree on matters that aren't dogmas or doctrines of the Church. I believe those subjects are open for debate. The Catholic vs Non-Catholic debates are what the debate table is generally for. These should not turn into bashing threads by any means. But as Catholics its our job to spread the truth of the faith and sometimes that involves debate. Now I don't approve of any type of snide remarks, which I find very childish and often prove the person making the comment is not mature enough to be in the debate table. I don't approve of lack of charity either. The way to spread the Gospel is through charity. Name calling, personal attacks, or bashing of any kind is what I would call lack of charity. Calling someone on the fact that they are wrong about a Church teaching etc. is not wrong, which I've often seen reported as uncharitable. Father Groeschel makes the point that we must be very careful when it comes to debate. Charity is of great importance, but this doesn't mean sugar coated gum drops of a response. Debate Table isn't for everyone. Some people are more sensitive to debate or disagreement than others, which I believe can have an influence on how they view even the most gentle of debates. If you want more Theological discussion or reflection without debate I would visit Transmundane Lane or if you have a particular question use the Q&A section.
Paladin D Posted June 10, 2008 Posted June 10, 2008 [quote name='dominicansoul' post='1566779' date='Jun 10 2008, 03:23 PM']I do think that what happens, is that we all have a real problem "listening" to one another....or "reading" one another's points. I think a lot of times, people don't really understand fully what another is trying to express, and therefore, (and this really shouldn't happen, but it does...) they can be quite judgemental in their replies.[/quote] I would agree with this. It's also makes it more difficult to try and understand the emotional tone behind the plain text, because someone may interpret the intent the wrong way as well. Which means, we should be even more prudent in how we word things. [quote]...but I don't have any personal hard feelings for anyone here, as I hope no one does for me, either. We aren't perfect people, we are struggling sinners... I contemplate not coming on here much anymore, but hey, I'm leaving to enter the convent very soon, and I'm sure a lot of what happens on these boards is happening there too! It's all a part of growing in virtue! We all help one another out to be the best we can be.... humility...humility....humility.... [/quote] Glad you don't, and you are good in my book. God bless you on your journey into entering the convent, may God give you whatever graces you need.
rachael Posted June 10, 2008 Posted June 10, 2008 [quote name='Paladin D' post='1566638' date='Jun 10 2008, 12:17 PM']Me personally, I don't share the same vibe. I can see how the Debate Table and the Election Section can become pretty heated at times, but those subjects naturally can arise emotions to begin with (it's not an excuse, but it's predictable. I'm guilty of this). Out of the countless forum communities (Christian and secular) I've posted or browsed, Phatmass is one of the most chartiable [b]and[/b] genuine message boards that I've ever witnessed. I've been a member on a handful of other Christian forums (both Catholic and non-Catholic), and unfortunately it seems some of them (predominately the Protestant ones) are so afraid of conflict with one another, that they are 'too happy' to the point where it seems fake. Some people, including myself, do not like fake people. If I want to talk to somebody about a subject, I want their [b]real opinion[/b], not some politically-correct, nicey nice answer that masks their true feelings. When I'm dealing with fake personalities it does me an injustice, because those people are not being truthful to me; and in many cases, are probally talking bad behind my back. You can be charitable but also honest, and unfortunately it's very common for someone to read inbetween the words and receive a different emotional tone than what the author originally intended. It's hard to read peoples' emotions through simple text, not impossible, but still hard.[/quote] And, in my opinion, it can be kind of funny when things get heated on here.
Paladin D Posted June 10, 2008 Posted June 10, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1566803' date='Jun 10 2008, 03:35 PM']Debate Table isn't for everyone. Some people are more sensitive to debate or disagreement than others, which I believe can have an influence on how they view even the most gentle of debates. If you want more Theological discussion or reflection without debate I would visit Transmundane Lane or if you have a particular question use the Q&A section.[/quote] Exactly. Debating is simply not for everyone. Doesn't mean one is a panzy or that one is weak, it's just that people have different personalities, some are more suited for heated debates while others are not. Doesn't make one inferior, nor superior, just different.
picchick Posted June 10, 2008 Posted June 10, 2008 [quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1566315' date='Jun 10 2008, 02:02 AM']well, as a non catholic with opposing views on handgun control, gay marriage and the attitude towards gay people, the death penalty and a whole lot more topics, i tend to either get ignored by people too caught up in themselves to recognize statements that they don't believe in, or get shut out like an annoying child and occasionally personally attacked. not everyone does this, several people coming from both sides are kind and well mannered on this board and they make it all worth it. the above posters Alycin, and CatherineM come to mind, along with many of the regulars on the lame board. after idly chatting with the people here and learning that they are all kind hearted people, it makes it harder to treat each other as "the faceless enemy"[/quote] I will proudly admit that I, Meg Picchick, is a faceless enemy dun dun duuuuuuuuuun Jennie and Pal D: Yes the debate table is not for everyone. However there is a way to debate and some people do not follow that way to debate. Jabs are not part of debating. I can take jabs directed to me pretty well but I can not stand them directed towards others. I believe that people who do not belong in the debate table are not necessarily the "more sensitive" (although I agree with you). But also those who do not debate but give flat answers with no explanations to their argument. Furthermore, those who believe that the way to "win" is to tear down the others in the threads. I think I agree with Kitty's point of setting an example of a Catholic Forum. However, I know that we are all human and some things get misunderstood due to the nature that this is all over the internet. But I think above everything we must try to strive towards charity and fairness to others no matter what are difference on opinion God Bless us Everyone! Meg
StColette Posted June 10, 2008 Posted June 10, 2008 [quote name='picchick' post='1566842' date='Jun 10 2008, 02:53 PM']Yes the debate table is not for everyone. However there is a way to debate and some people do not follow that way to debate. Jabs are not part of debating. I can take jabs directed to me pretty well but I can not stand them directed towards others.[/quote] Which is why I said [quote]Now I don't approve of any type of snide remarks, which I find very childish and often prove the person making the comment is not mature enough to be in the debate table. I don't approve of lack of charity either. The way to spread the Gospel is through charity. Name calling, personal attacks, or bashing of any kind is what I would call lack of charity. Calling someone on the fact that they are wrong about a Church teaching etc. is not wrong, which I've often seen reported as uncharitable. Father Groeschel makes the point that we must be very careful when it comes to debate. Charity is of great importance, but this doesn't mean sugar coated gum drops of a response.[/quote] [quote]I believe that people who do not belong in the debate table are not necessarily the "more sensitive" (although I agree with you). But also those who do not debate but give flat answers with no explanations to their argument. Furthermore, those who believe that the way to "win" is to tear down the others in the threads.[/[/quote] Completely agree
Paladin D Posted June 10, 2008 Posted June 10, 2008 [quote name='picchick' post='1566842' date='Jun 10 2008, 03:53 PM']I will proudly admit that I, Meg Picchick, is a faceless enemy dun dun duuuuuuuuuun Jennie and Pal D: Yes the debate table is not for everyone. However there is a way to debate and some people do not follow that way to debate. Jabs are not part of debating. I can take jabs directed to me pretty well but I can not stand them directed towards others. I believe that people who do not belong in the debate table are not necessarily the "more sensitive" (although I agree with you). But also those who do not debate but give flat answers with no explanations to their argument. Furthermore, those who believe that the way to "win" is to tear down the others in the threads.[/quote] I've been guilty of making jabs in the past (most recently towards Budge, but we all know her past and how she still acts today). Overall, I'm more on the fence on this whole issue. I do see Kitty's point, but I also do see the other point of view. Maybe I'm a moderate on this issue? I agree though, usually if an explanation is given to one's argument, it does sometimes bring a better understanding and helps ease the tension a little instead of "I'm right, you're wrong, the end." Not everyone follows the rules of debate all the time, it's disappointing, but just gotta keep reminding people I guess.
picchick Posted June 10, 2008 Posted June 10, 2008 [quote name='Paladin D' post='1566870' date='Jun 10 2008, 03:02 PM']I've been guilty of making jabs in the past (most recently towards Budge, but we all know her past and how she still acts today). Overall, I'm more on the fence on this whole issue. I do see Kitty's point, but I also do see the other point of view. Maybe I'm a moderate on this issue? I agree though, usually if an explanation is given to one's argument, it does sometimes bring a better understanding and helps ease the tension a little instead of "I'm right, you're wrong, the end." Not everyone follows the rules of debate all the time, it's disappointing, but just gotta keep reminding people I guess.[/quote] SHAME ON YOU! I am kidding. Even if someone acts towards us in a mean way, does not mean we can jab back. the temptation is so hard sometimes...so sometimes I will just say it to my computer screen...take a breath...and then type. Yeppers to the last part.
LouisvilleFan Posted June 11, 2008 Posted June 11, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1566803' date='Jun 10 2008, 03:35 PM']Debate Table isn't for everyone. Some people are more sensitive to debate or disagreement than others, which I believe can have an influence on how they view even the most gentle of debates. If you want more Theological discussion or reflection without debate I would visit Transmundane Lane or if you have a particular question use the Q&A section.[/quote] I [b]love[/b] debating Sometimes I disagree with someone just to get something started or explore the topic, not necessarily because I actually disagree. Fact of the matter is, if you want answers, it's much more effective to feign disagreement than to put forth a polite inquiry. The latter will go mostly ignored with a big ol' yawn, but the prospect of a good quarrel draws attention and brings out the big guns from whomever you're challenging. Maybe I shoulda been a lawyer...
CatherineM Posted June 11, 2008 Posted June 11, 2008 I found the best part of being a lawyer is the cross-examination. I loved that. It could be a bit like playing poker. Once you see they have a tell, you know right where to pounce. The biggest problem I had was that after going at them in the deposition, they always wanted to settle. It's no fun without getting to do it in front of an audience.
jeffpugh Posted June 11, 2008 Posted June 11, 2008 [quote name='rachael' post='1566818' date='Jun 10 2008, 02:42 PM'] And, in my opinion, it can be kind of funny when things get heated on here.[/quote] Yes, indeed. We've shared many a bag of popcorn over these disputes. Personally, I don't find it that bad. Sure, people can get a bit ad hominum in approach sometimes, but like people have said, not everyone's versed in debating, and we have concupiscence. Plus, some people take things as offencive when they're not. Ive said this before: "they're just words". Sometimes we make up the tone.
kafka Posted June 11, 2008 Posted June 11, 2008 [quote name='rachael' post='1568625' date='Jun 11 2008, 06:20 PM']hooray[/quote] little gtalk Rache?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now