mortify Posted June 15, 2008 Posted June 15, 2008 (edited) If original sin is passed on via generation, why do we baptize children born of Catholic parents? Shouldnt such children already be born in a state of grace? Edited June 15, 2008 by mortify
Thy Geekdom Come Posted June 15, 2008 Posted June 15, 2008 Good question Mortify. Someone asked the same question in the Q&A not long ago. Here is the link [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=81042"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=81042[/url] It may give you the answer you are looking for.
mortify Posted June 15, 2008 Author Posted June 15, 2008 Thank you for the link Raphael, St Colette did a good job though I do have one question on what she said, and unfortunately I can't respond in that thread. She said: [quote]Original sin is transmitted through human nature itself, not our genes[/quote] How can human nature be transmitted outside of our genetics?
kdewolf2 Posted June 15, 2008 Posted June 15, 2008 (edited) Hmmm.... I'd offer a simpler explanation: 1. Original sin represents the basic animal nature of man, i.e. the basic animal drives and instincts which are inherent in the biological and genetic nature of man, which falls short of the moral demands of religion and tends to militate against them. St. Paul speaks of the war between the "spirit" and the "flesh." I believe the flesh represents animal nature of man in its totality while the "spirit" represents a higher degree of consciousness, a new mode of existence, which man struggles to attain through religion. 2. Divine grace represents the higher plane of existence, in which man becomes freed from the demands of the flesh, and lives for the sake of the spirit, i.e. God, holiness, etc. St. Paul depicts an endless struggle, since the spirit does not re-create the flesh in its image, but a man must struggle against the flesh to rise to the level of the spirit, and will continue to struggle to persevere. God does not change the biological or genetic make-up of man, to enable him to live in that higher plane of consciousness. He surely offers His assistance, through prayer, the sacraments, the Church and its ministers, good Catholic parents, teachers, friends, etc., which form a total support structure to assist man to become a "new being" and not just a craven animal savage. 3. It is then a matter of spiritual initiation (i.e. rebirth) and education which changes man. It doesn't change his biological or genetic make-up, but it changes his beliefs, his values, his priorities, his worldview, his relationships, etc. It changes the spiritual dimensions of man. Since, however, his underlying animal nature remains the same, there will continue to be conflict between the demands of religion and the demands of the flesh. 4. It is also absurd to imagine that the "new being" represented by divine grace could be transmitted through sexual procreation. Sexual procreation gives us the animal body of man, i.e. the flesh. The spiritual life of man must be attained by a process of initiation and education, which enable spiritual growth and development. Baptism is necessary because it is the sacrament of initiation, whereby children are brought into the Church and its total support structure which will enable them to grow spiritually and rise to higher levels of consciousness which transcend the animal nature of man and prevent them from becoming mere savages. It is a first step, not a total solution. Edited June 15, 2008 by kdewolf2
kdewolf2 Posted June 15, 2008 Posted June 15, 2008 Hmmm.... I'd offer a simpler explanation: 1. Original sin represents the basic animal nature of man, i.e. the basic animal drives and instincts which are inherent in the biological and genetic nature of man, which falls short of the moral demands of religion and tends to militate against them. St. Paul speaks of the war between the "spirit" and the "flesh." I believe the flesh represents animal nature of man in its totality while the "spirit" represents a higher degree of consciousness, a new mode of existence, which man struggles to attain through religion. 2. Divine grace represents the higher plane of existence, in which man becomes freed from the demands of the flesh, and lives for the sake of the spirit, i.e. God, holiness, etc. St. Paul depicts an endless struggle, since the spirit does not re-create the flesh in its image, but a man must struggle against the flesh to rise to the level of the spirit, and will continue to struggle to persevere. God does not change the biological or genetic make-up of man, to enable him to live in that higher plane of consciousness. He surely offers His assistance, through prayer, the sacraments, the Church and its ministers, good Catholic parents, teachers, friends, etc., which form a total support structure to assist man to become a "new being" and not just a craven animal savage. 3. It is then a matter of spiritual initiation (i.e. rebirth) and education which changes man. It doesn't change his biological or genetic make-up, but it changes his beliefs, his values, his priorities, his worldview, his relationships, etc. It changes the spiritual dimensions of man. Since, however, his underlying animal nature remains the same, there will continue to be conflict between the demands of religion and the demands of the flesh. 4. It is also absurd to imagine that the "new being" represented by divine grace could be transmitted through sexual procreation. Sexual procreation gives us the animal body of man, i.e. the flesh. The spiritual life of man must be attained by a process of initiation and education, which enable spiritual growth and development. Baptism is necessary because it is the sacrament of initiation, whereby children are brought into the Church and its total support structure which will enable them to grow spiritually and rise to higher levels of consciousness which transcend the animal nature of man and prevent them from becoming mere savages. It is a first step, not a total solution.
kdewolf2 Posted June 15, 2008 Posted June 15, 2008 (edited) Sorry for repeating myself. I don't know how I did that. Edited June 15, 2008 by kdewolf2
StColette Posted June 15, 2008 Posted June 15, 2008 [quote name='mortify' post='1571743' date='Jun 15 2008, 12:03 PM']How can human nature be transmitted outside of our genetics?[/quote] Because a human person is both spirit and body. We aren't just genetics. Sin is on a spiritual level, which I stated right before the section of my post you quoted. Because our human nature is composed of both body and soul we are not just our genetics. This is where the idea of cloning would get pretty interesting because would the body just be an empty shell because no soul is there, because we can't clone a soul. The Council of Trent called original sin the death of the soul and that it is the privation of sanctifying grace that a child has at the moment of conception.
mortify Posted June 15, 2008 Author Posted June 15, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1571828' date='Jun 15 2008, 12:51 PM']Because a human person is both spirit and body. We aren't just genetics. Sin is on a spiritual level, which I stated right before the section of my post you quoted. Because our human nature is composed of both body and soul we are not just our genetics. This is where the idea of cloning would get pretty interesting because would the body just be an empty shell because no soul is there, because we can't clone a soul. The Council of Trent called original sin the death of the soul and that it is the privation of sanctifying grace that a child has at the moment of conception.[/quote] I guess my difficulty is understanding how original sin is transmitted via generation. The original holiness and justice given to Adam was meant to be passed on via generation as well, if I'm not mistaken, and so I don't understand why the justification baptized parents received wouldn't be passed on to their children.
mortify Posted June 15, 2008 Author Posted June 15, 2008 [quote name='kdewolf2' post='1571783' date='Jun 15 2008, 11:48 AM']1. Original sin represents the basic animal nature of man, i.e. the basic animal drives and instincts which are inherent in the biological and genetic nature of man, which falls short of the moral demands of religion and tends to militate against them.[/quote] That animal instinct you refer to, which desires what is evil, sounds like what a theologian would call concupiscence. Original sin is not concupiscence, though this is how many Protestants understand it. Concupiscence is one of the punishments of original sin that remain even after original sin has been removed. The difference is, in the case of the baptized overcoming concupiscence leads to self mastery and greater merit in heaven, for the unbaptized it remains a punishment. Original sin is the privation of sanctifying grace every human being inherits from Adam.
LouisvilleFan Posted June 15, 2008 Posted June 15, 2008 (edited) [quote name='mortify' post='1571842' date='Jun 15 2008, 03:09 PM']I guess my difficulty is understanding how original sin is transmitted via generation. The original holiness and justice given to Adam was meant to be passed on via generation as well, if I'm not mistaken, and so I don't understand why the justification baptized parents received wouldn't be passed on to their children.[/quote] I think the answer to that would be tied to the distinction between original sin and concupiscence (our tendency to sin). Baptism washes away original sin, but we only rid of concupiscence through earthly death and the resurrection of the dead that we look forward to when Christ returns. I suppose once our souls are harmed by original sin, we can only be completely healed through death. This is why God drove Adam and Eve out of the garden, lest they eat of the tree of eternal life. Even if they could be baptized, they remained in the fallen state and under the curse God had applied to them. That said, their/our curse is also our blessing. The only true curse comes from Satan, given to those souls handed over to him for eternity. Hence, the only way for Mary to be the pure ark of the New Covenant was by the Immaculate Conception so that her soul was never harmed by original sin. If Baptism had the power to restore us to the grace of a perfect relationship with God like Adam and Eve had in the garden, Mary could've simply been baptized, and in fact all of us would be like Mary in this life. As for why we can't be like that... it's a nice thought, but my guess is such a reality would make Christianity more magic than a relationship with the living God. There is no formula or method that makes us holy: only grace. Edited June 15, 2008 by LouisvilleFan
kdewolf2 Posted June 15, 2008 Posted June 15, 2008 [quote]This is where the idea of cloning would get pretty interesting because would the body just be an empty shell because no soul is there, because we can't clone a soul.[/quote] I'd have to disagree. The natural process of sexual reproduction is essentially a bio-mechanical process whereby a sperm fertilizes an ovum and the resultant embryo grows into a living, human being. The procedure for cloning simply enables us to bypass the natural process and to create an embryo through artificial means, which still grows into a living, human being. In either case, I believe we would have a fully developed human body with the latent capacity of reason, consciousness, free will, and genuine emotion. It may be the case that cloning procedures will prove to be faulty, but I'm only speaking of cases that actually work. I do not believe that we would have any basis to claim that a fully developed human body with the latent capacity of reason, consciousness, free will, and genuine emotion would lack a "soul." Granted, the soul is a transcendent principle, but all those faculties that we associate with the soul are embedded in the structure of the brain and the human body and I do not see how they would fail to operate in a fully developed human body/organism, whether it were produced by natural or artificial means. I don't believe that God "endows" souls (i.e. artificially superimposes mysterious substances called "souls" onto human bodies). I believe the soul emerges from the organic structure of a creature with the capacity for genuine thought and emotion. It may be immoral to clone people, but I doubt that God would ultimately reject the soul of a cloned person any more than He would reject the soul of a child borne of rape or incest. We may not "clone" a soul directly, but it's not like we fornicate a soul into existence either. Besides: If the soul were truly this mysterious substance apart from the body, why should the clone be any less entitled to receive a soul than a child borne of rape or incest?
StColette Posted June 15, 2008 Posted June 15, 2008 [quote name='mortify' post='1571842' date='Jun 15 2008, 02:09 PM']I guess my difficulty is understanding how original sin is transmitted via generation. The original holiness and justice given to Adam was meant to be passed on via generation as well, if I'm not mistaken, and so I don't understand why the justification baptized parents received wouldn't be passed on to their children.[/quote] Micah and I are having a conversation on this right now. Justification is a work in progress. Just because they are baptized does not mean that the parents are free from the effects of sin. It's still part of our human nature even after our baptism. Our parents have not been completely justified. They have been baptized which gives them the grace to move toward that justification. We can not pass on something that we do not have ourselves. When we are baptized we are washed of original sin but this does not get rid of the tendency that our human nature has to sin. As Micah said to me, Unless a couple in Heaven had a child (while in Heaven) then a child cannot be born already justified (except for the exceptions we already know). That couple in Heaven is completely justified and therefore any child of theirs would inherit their state, which is a state of justification. Because couples here on earth are not completely justified, their state is still one that is fallen, until they die and enter into Heaven, then they are fully justified. Our parents, because they are still in a fallen state while on earth, cannot conceive and bring forth a justified child, because that child would inherit their state, which is fallen. Things are inherited both spiritually and physically.
StColette Posted June 15, 2008 Posted June 15, 2008 [quote name='kdewolf2' post='1571860' date='Jun 15 2008, 02:29 PM']I don't believe that God "endows" souls (i.e. artificially superimposes mysterious substances called "souls" onto human bodies). I believe the soul emerges from the organic structure of a creature with the capacity for genuine thought and emotion.[/quote] CCC 366 The Church teaches that every spiritual soul is created immediately by God - it is not "produced" by the parents - and also that it is immortal: it does not perish when it separates from the body at death, and it will be reunited with the body at the final Resurrection. CCC 382 "Man, though made of body and soul, is a unity" (GS 14 § 1). The doctrine of the faith affirms that the spiritual and immortal soul is created immediately by God. I wanted to address this to make it clear as to what the Church teaches in regards to the creation of a person's soul. Back to the topic of original sin.
kdewolf2 Posted June 15, 2008 Posted June 15, 2008 [quote]That animal instinct you refer to, which desires what is evil, sounds like what a theologian would call concupiscence. Original sin is not concupiscence, though this is how many Protestants understand it. Concupiscence is one of the punishments of original sin that remain even after original sin has been removed. The difference is, in the case of the baptized overcoming concupiscence leads to self mastery and greater merit in heaven, for the unbaptized it remains a punishment. Original sin is the privation of sanctifying grace every human being inherits from Adam.[/quote] Alright, I'm about to quit, I promise. Does it really make sense for God to punish Adam for his sin by giving him an even greater proclivity to sin which can never be removed, even after he has been forgiven? Does it really make sense for God to punish all of Adam's children by allowing them to fall into this same proclivity to sin and refuse to remove it even after they too have been forgiven? I am thinking way outside the orthodox box here. Does it even make sense to ontologize the concepts of sin and grace and to make them into these abstract entities or forces that exist outside the concrete world of form and matter that we inhabit? I fail to see in what original sin consists, unless it is the imputation of the guilt of Adam's sin to his children, which does not make sense to me either. So, I would in fact conflate concupiscence with original sin, and I would posit that it consists of natural desires common to men and animals, which only becomes sin in men due to the presence/consciousness of the higher demands of religion, and the resultant conflicts between them. Otherwise, why would St. Paul suggest that Gentiles who do not know the law become law unto themselves, or that we were not sinners until we gained knowledge of the law and that the law is what made us sinners? In other words, man is born with natural desires that he shares with animals, and were he not conscious of a higher mode of existence, to which he is called, would not be sinful. The function of religion is to help us regulate and govern those impulses so that we can live in a higher mode of existence, which is proper to man and not to animals. Religion is the basis of human culture, and it is the life of civilized man in culture that religion fosters when it cracks down on "sin." The prevalence of sin leads to a breakdown of culture, in which man becomes progressively more animalistic, which is what we have observed in recent generations. There is a constant struggle between the animal nature of man and the higher life toward which he aspires. The story of Adam and Eve is essentially a myth of the origin of evil. I would not take it literally at all.
mortify Posted June 15, 2008 Author Posted June 15, 2008 (edited) [quote name='kdewolf2' post='1571909' date='Jun 15 2008, 02:02 PM']Alright, I'm about to quit, I promise. Does it really make sense for God to punish Adam for his sin by giving him an even greater proclivity to sin which can never be removed, even after he has been forgiven?[/quote] It's not something God gave to Adam, it's the consequence of Adam's sin. In the state of original holiness, the body is in complete conformity to the intellect and the intellect is in full conformity with the spirit, which is in full conformity to God. When Adam sinned, man rebelled against God and the very being of man began to rebel within itself. So now even though the intellect can recognize the evil in something, the body still desires it, etc. This rebellion between the spirit, intellect, and body is what constitutes concupiscence as far as I understand. If original sin is concupiscence, then we are left with the dilemma of why the body continues to desire evil even after baptism. Concupiscence remains even after baptism as means of testing man, God allows each person to go through what they can handle, and if they triumph over their desires they'll gain endurance and merit in heaven which would not have been possible had we never been born in a fallen state. [quote]Does it really make sense for God to punish all of Adam's children by allowing them to fall into this same proclivity to sin and refuse to remove it even after they too have been forgiven?[/quote] It makes sense because God originally gave Adam a nature not inclined towards sin, and it was meant to be passed down. Since Adam was like a person receiving land and titles from a King, upsetting the king made him and his descendents lose the title that was given as a gift by the King. [quote]I fail to see in what original sin consists, unless it is the imputation of the guilt of Adam's sin to his children, which does not make sense to me either.[/quote] It consists in the privation of sanctifying grace and the preternatural gift of integrity. We share in the "guilt" of Adam because we are born missing the sanctifying grace which is necessary for communion with God in heaven. Edited June 15, 2008 by mortify
LouisvilleFan Posted June 15, 2008 Posted June 15, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1571828' date='Jun 15 2008, 02:51 PM']This is where the idea of cloning would get pretty interesting because would the body just be an empty shell because no soul is there, because we can't clone a soul.[/quote] The soul is received at conception, which must happen for human life to be created regardless of the method. Now, if scientists somehow developed a way to create embryos without using a sperm and egg, that would be interesting. I imagine, though, it would still have a soul because it is human and God would grant its soul at whatever point in the biological process it becomes human. Just like in the theoretical process of evolution, it can be accepted by a Christian on the basis that at the point in that process when homo sapiens (and thus humans) came into being, God granted the soul to those first humans.
StColette Posted June 15, 2008 Posted June 15, 2008 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1571967' date='Jun 15 2008, 03:34 PM']The soul is received at conception, which must happen for human life to be created regardless of the method. Now, if scientists somehow developed a way to create embryos without using a sperm and egg, that would be interesting.[/quote] That's what I'm talking about, not the creation of embryo with sperm and egg. Say if someone's father died and they wanted to clone him, they couldn't clone his soul, it would not be their "dad" it might look like him but it doesn't have his soul. I should have been clearer in that statement.
cmotherofpirl Posted June 16, 2008 Posted June 16, 2008 [quote name='kdewolf2' post='1571909' date='Jun 15 2008, 04:02 PM']There is a constant struggle between the animal nature of man and the higher life toward which he aspires. The story of Adam and Eve is essentially a myth of the origin of evil. I would not take it literally at all.[/quote] If you claim to be Catholic you accept it as fact that we have two original parents, given souls by God. Last I checked dogma isn't optional.
CatherineM Posted June 16, 2008 Posted June 16, 2008 I think a cloned human would have a soul, just not the same soul as the person that was cloned. If we start creating life like that, I'm sure God will create a soul in them, I'm just hoping that God prevents us from being successful with the cloning in the first place.
LouisvilleFan Posted June 16, 2008 Posted June 16, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1571987' date='Jun 15 2008, 04:42 PM']That's what I'm talking about, not the creation of embryo with sperm and egg. Say if someone's father died and they wanted to clone him, they couldn't clone his soul, it would not be their "dad" it might look like him but it doesn't have his soul. I should have been clearer in that statement.[/quote] Clones aren't re-creations of the same people. It's a different person with essentially the same genes. Identitical twins are also clones.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now