StColette Posted June 16, 2008 Posted June 16, 2008 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1572856' date='Jun 16 2008, 02:20 PM']Clones aren't re-creations of the same people. It's a different person with essentially the same genes. Identitical twins are also clones.[/quote] I'm not saying they are re-creations of the same person. I'm saying that "if" science was able of make an exact copy of someone, it's still going to be a different person, that's my point! If someone wanted a "copy" of their dad, it isn't going to be their dad, because it doesn't have their dad's soul. Anyone cloning isn't the topic here. Back to baptism.
LouisvilleFan Posted June 16, 2008 Posted June 16, 2008 [quote name='mortify' post='1571933' date='Jun 15 2008, 04:21 PM']If original sin is concupiscence, then we are left with the dilemma of why the body continues to desire evil even after baptism. Concupiscence remains even after baptism as means of testing man, God allows each person to go through what they can handle, and if they triumph over their desires they'll gain endurance and merit in heaven which would not have been possible had we never been born in a fallen state.[/quote] I'd be careful with that wording... for one, I'm not sure if you stated it or not, but original sin and concupiscence are two different things. Concupiscence is the result of original sin. Baptism washes away original sin and all actual sins, but not the harm done by them. However, concupiscence doesn't remain for the purpose of us being tested. It remains because our relationship with God is a loving relationship, which means in this life we remain always free to love God or reject him. For God to remove concupiscence through Baptism would not only eradicate the need for any other sacraments, but it would be like a man taking his newlywed bride into his home and locking her up there for as long as they both shall live. God frees us and slowly, if we grow in holiness, we learn to freely choose to love God. Hence, we need the other sacraments to help us along in that journey. Along with that, Christianity isn't about us conquering evil. We are always completely reliant upon God's grace and mercy, whether you're Osama bin Laden or Pope Benedict. Clearly, Benedict is somewhat more aware of his reliance upon God's grace, but neither can gain any merit with God outside of grace.
LouisvilleFan Posted June 16, 2008 Posted June 16, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1572875' date='Jun 16 2008, 03:50 PM']I'm not saying they are re-creations of the same person. I'm saying that "if" science was able of make an exact copy of someone, it's still going to be a different person, that's my point! If someone wanted a "copy" of their dad, it isn't going to be their dad, because it doesn't have their dad's soul. Anyone cloning isn't the topic here.[/quote] Sounds like you answered your own question then.
Veridicus Posted June 29, 2008 Posted June 29, 2008 I leave town for a couple of weeks and someone goes and steals my thunder!!!!
Veridicus Posted June 29, 2008 Posted June 29, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1571828' date='Jun 15 2008, 12:51 PM']Because a human person is both spirit and body. We aren't just genetics. Sin is on a spiritual level, which I stated right before the section of my post you quoted. Because our human nature is composed of both body and soul we are not just our genetics. This is where the idea of cloning would get pretty interesting because would the body just be an empty shell because no soul is there, because we can't clone a soul. The Council of Trent called original sin the death of the soul and that it is the privation of sanctifying grace that a child has at the moment of conception.[/quote] I'm glad this got started in here because I couldn't respond in Q&A... Here is what Trent states in that link you posted in my Q&A topic: 419 "We therefore hold, with the Council of Trent, that original sin is transmitted with human nature, "by propagation, not by imitation" and that it is. . . 'proper to each'" (Paul VI, CPG # 16). Now propagation implies not a spiritual procession but a biological procession. And Biology implies genetics and matter (both the DNA and cellular macromolecules of the parent gametocytes). This is the 'stuff' of human propagation in a physical sense. God creates our souls 'Good' in his image, but at the moment of our conception the spiritual portion of our human nature (which HAD TO HAVE BEEN created good because that is what God does) is immediately stained by the original sin inherent in the flesh and the world. Human parents do NOT beget souls upon their children, only God creates souls. Human parents participate in the creation of the human person by transmitting the physical nature of the whole 'human nature.' I don't think God started created funked out souls after the Fall...the biological part of human nature became broken and the stain of sin is retrogressed upon the sould which is created at the moment of conception. I guess I could be wrong, but it just seems like that has to be the way it is. God creates all things good and 'creates us in His image.' Therefore our spirits must be created good. Therefore the stain on our spiritual nature must proceed as Trent states "by propagation" which implies a biological basis. Please respond...
Veridicus Posted June 29, 2008 Posted June 29, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1571879' date='Jun 15 2008, 01:41 PM']...Just because they are baptized does not mean that the parents are free from the effects of sin. It's still part of our human nature even after our baptism. Our parents have not been completely justified. They have been baptized which gives them the grace to move toward that justification. We can not pass on something that we do not have ourselves. When we are baptized we are washed of original sin but this does not get rid of the tendency that our human nature has to sin....[/quote] That is precisely what I am on about. Our parents are freed from the stain of original sin, not the effects. How can they pass on the stain of Original Sin AFTER their baptism if they no longer have it. I can understand that concupiscience could be passed on after baptism since concupiscience remains, but I cannot understand transmission of Original sin from parents to children on either a biological or spiritual basis. I need to look up what Thomas has to say about this.
Veridicus Posted June 29, 2008 Posted June 29, 2008 (edited) [b]Summa Theologica: Part I Q81; Article I: [i]Whether the first sin of our first parent is contracted by his descendants, by way of origin?[/b] The Apostle says (Rom. 5:12): "By one man sin entered into this world, and by sin death." Nor can this be understood as denoting imitation or suggestion, since it is written (Wis. 2:24): "By the envy of the devil, death came into this world." It follows therefore that through origin from the first man sin entered into the world. I answer that, According to the Catholic Faith we are bound to hold that the first sin of the first man is transmitted to his descendants, by way of origin. For this reason children are taken to be baptized soon after their birth, to show that they have to be washed from some uncleanness. The contrary is part of the Pelagian heresy, as is clear from Augustine in many of his books [*For instance, Retract. i, 9; De Pecc. Merit. et Remiss. ix; Contra Julian. iii, 1; De Dono Persev. xi, xii.] In endeavoring to explain how the sin of our first parent could be transmitted by way of origin to his descendants, various writers have gone about it in various ways. For some, considering that the subject of sin is the rational soul, maintained that the rational soul is transmitted with the semen, so that thus an infected soul would seem to produce other infected souls. Others, rejecting this as erroneous, endeavored to show how the guilt of the parent's soul can be transmitted to the children, even though the soul be not transmitted, from the fact that defects of the body are transmitted from parent to child---thus a leper may beget a leper, or a gouty man may be the father of a gouty son, on account of some seminal corruption, although this corruption is not leprosy or gout. Now since the body is proportionate to the soul, and since the soul's defects redound into the body, and vice versa, in like manner, say they, a culpable defect of the soul is passed on to the child, through the transmission of the semen, albeit the semen itself is not the subject of the guilt. But all these explanations are insufficient. Because, granted that some bodily defects are transmitted by way of origin from parent to child, and granted that even some defects of the soul are transmitted in consequence, on account of a defect in the bodily habit, as in the case of idiots begetting idiots; nevertheless the fact of having a defect by the way of origin seems to exclude the notion of guilt, which is essentially something voluntary. Wherefore granted that the rational soul were transmitted, from the very fact that the stain on the child's soul is not in its will, it would cease to be a guilty stain binding its subject to punishment; for, as the Philosopher says (Ethic. iii, 5), "no one reproaches a man born blind; one rather takes pity on him." Therefore, we must explain the matter otherwise by saying that all men born of Adam may be considered as one man, inasmuch as they have one common nature, which they receive from their first parents; even as in civil matters, all who are members of one community are reputed as one body, and the whole community as one man. Indeed Porphyry says (Praedic., De Specie) that "by sharing the same species, many men are one man." Accordingly the multitude of men born of Adam, are as so many members of one body. Now the action of one member of the body, of the hand for instance, is voluntary not by the will of that hand, but by the will of the soul, the first mover of the members. Wherefore a murder which the hand commits would not be imputed as a sin to the hand, considered by itself as apart from the body, but is imputed to it as something belonging to man and moved by man's first moving principle. In this way, then, the disorder which is in this man born of Adam, is voluntary, not by his will, but by the will of his first parent, who, by the movement of generation, moves all who originate from him, even as the soul's will moves all the members to their actions. Hence the sin which is thus transmitted by the first parent to his descendants is called "original," just as the sin which flows from the soul into the bodily members is called "actual." And just as the actual sin that is committed by a member of the body, is not the sin of that member,except inasmuch as that member is a part of the man, for which reason it is called a "human sin";so original sin is not the sin of this person, except inasmuch as this person receives his nature fromhis first parent, for which reason it is called the "sin of nature," according to Eph. 2:3: "We . . .were by nature children of wrath." Reply to Objection 2: Although the soul is not transmitted, because the power in the semen is not able to cause the rational soul, nevertheless the motion of the semen is a disposition to the transmission of the rational soul: so that the semen by its own power transmits the human nature from parent to child, and with that nature, the stain which infects it: for he that is born is associated with his first parent in his guilt, through the fact that he inherits his nature from him by a kind of movement which is that of generation. Reply to Objection 3: Although the guilt is not actually in the semen, yet human nature is there virtually accompanied by that guilt.[/i] [b]Summa Theologica Part I: Q81: Article III: [i]Whether the sin of the first parent is transmitted, by the way of origin, to all men?[/b] On the contrary, The Apostle says (Rom. 5:12): "Death passed upon all men in whom all have sinned." I answer that, According to the Catholic Faith we must firmly believe that, Christ alone excepted, all men descended from Adam contract original sin from him; else all would not need redemption [*Cf. Translator's note inserted before TP, Q[27]] which is through Christ; and this is erroneous. The reason for this may be gathered from what has been stated (A[1]), viz. that original sin, in virtue of the sin of our first parent, is transmitted to his posterity, just as, from the soul's will, actual sin is transmitted to the members of the body, through their being moved by the will. Now it is evident that actual sin can be transmitted to all such members as have an inborn aptitude to be moved by the will. Therefore original sin is transmitted to all those who are moved by Adam by the movement of generation.[/i] While Thomas' understanding of biological generation is antiquated by our current understanding, it appears that he does recognize human nature is transmitted by the gamete (for the sake of argument I would say in modern terms it is sperm and egg together that accomplish this transmission). But since the gametes themselves do not have the capacity to transmit soul or its faculties (only the capacity to potentiate with God the creation of the soul at conception), it must be conceded that human nature is transmitted via the physical process of generation. So...hmm...not sure where I'm going anymore...Thomas always does this to me...Okay...So the semen (gametes) through propagation transmit the broken human nature complete with the stain of original sin. It seems that 'human nature' is something that supercedes biological existence, but in some way it subsists in it. So my "Original Question" remains: are the gametes somehow not cleansed by baptism in the sense that the rest of the flesh is cleansed of the stain and guilt of original sin (even though concupiscience remains)? Since gametes are what transmit a broken human nature...it would appear so. I would desist from speculating about genetics, etc....beyond to say that it seems that transmission of original sin occurs through physical propagation and that original sin is imparted on the soul by the flesh. Edited June 29, 2008 by Veridicus
mortify Posted June 29, 2008 Author Posted June 29, 2008 (edited) Veridicus, Fr. Spirago in _The Catechism Explained_ uses an excellent analogy which I'll build on. He says, "Even the children of Christians are born in sin. [u]Not only the seed of the wild olive, but also of the cultivated olive comes up as a wild plant.[/u] So is it with the children of Christian as well as of heathen parents." God's "cultivating care" was given to Adam and meant to be applied to all his future children. When Adam displeased God, God ceased this "care" and Adam and his future posterity were abandoned to themselves. When Christ came, He came as the Second Adam, but this time the cultivating care would not be applied to all but only to the Tree of Christ, and therefore all would need to be grafted (read Baptism!) onto It. Therefore even the seeds that come about through the grafted branches fall apart from the Tree and still require to be grafted. Fr Spirago's explanation was sufficient, but typing it all out helped me understand it better. I guess it all depends on the idea of original justice originally being transmitted to all through Adam, this being lost, and now the only way to be justified is to be become a member of Christ's Body via baptism. Edited June 29, 2008 by mortify
Veridicus Posted June 30, 2008 Posted June 30, 2008 [quote name='mortify' post='1586589' date='Jun 29 2008, 05:20 PM']Veridicus, Fr. Spirago in _The Catechism Explained_ uses an excellent analogy which I'll build on. He says, "Even the children of Christians are born in sin. [u]Not only the seed of the wild olive, but also of the cultivated olive comes up as a wild plant.[/u] So is it with the children of Christian as well as of heathen parents." God's "cultivating care" was given to Adam and meant to be applied to all his future children. When Adam displeased God, God ceased this "care" and Adam and his future posterity were abandoned to themselves. When Christ came, He came as the Second Adam, but this time the cultivating care would not be applied to all but only to the Tree of Christ, and therefore all would need to be grafted (read Baptism!) onto It. Therefore even the seeds that come about through the grafted branches fall apart from the Tree and still require to be grafted. Fr Spirago's explanation was sufficient, but typing it all out helped me understand it better. I guess it all depends on the idea of original justice originally being transmitted to all through Adam, this being lost, and now the only way to be justified is to be become a member of Christ's Body via baptism.[/quote] I do appreciate the analogical insight! I really think I am going to have to keep digging into this one though. I'll have to read more Thomas and keep running thoughts by my friends. I probably just think to much for my own good.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now