Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

How does a good intention affect mortal sin? Can it make the sin non culpable? And what do people mean when they say an action is objectively a mortal sin but subjectively it's unknown?

Thanks

Posted

I'm really curious about this as well. :)

Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1580430' date='Jun 23 2008, 02:49 PM']And what do people mean when they say an action is objectively a mortal sin but subjectively it's unknown?[/quote]

The sin is a grave matter, but we don't know if the person who commits it has full knowledge or gave deliberate consent (though the latter is easier to tell than the former).

Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1580430' date='Jun 23 2008, 03:49 PM']How does a good intention affect mortal sin? Can it make the sin non culpable?[/quote]

Could you provide an example?

Posted (edited)

[quote name='mortify' post='1580430' date='Jun 23 2008, 04:49 PM']How does a good intention affect mortal sin? Can it make the sin non culpable? And what do people mean when they say an action is objectively a mortal sin but subjectively it's unknown?

Thanks[/quote]


I personally don't think that a good intention counts as a mitigating circumstance, unless you mean that it is a choice between two evils. In war, soldiers must shoot and kill sometimes. Killing is always evil, even if it is sometimes necessary.

If you mean a normal, non-stress (comparatively) situation, like embezzling thousands of dollars to give it to charity, I would still classify that as a mortal sin. It's the whole "end justifying the means" thing.

EDIT: I also agree with STM's post.

Edited by aalpha1989
Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1580430' date='Jun 23 2008, 04:49 PM']How does a good intention affect mortal sin? Can it make the sin non culpable?[/quote]

What do you mean by this?

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

Howdy,

If by good intention you mean using evil means (at the level of a mortal sin) to accomplish something "good," the intention cannot justify the sin. No one may do evil that good may come of it, that is almost directly out of one of St. Paul's letters. Now I am speaking without firm memory, but there are situations where the Church's morality allows for the suggestion of a lesser sin to someone who will not be stopped from committing a greater sin. For instance, in one can advise someone to stop at robbing someone rather than killing and robbing them. There is more to it than that. Hopefully someone can shed more light on that.

For the second one, I would assume they mean the case of someone committing an act that is a grave matter. If done with full knowledge and deliberate consent it is a mortal sin. However, in this case, the person does not have full knowledge of the sinful character of the act, making it impossible for this sin to be mortal. In order to fulfill "full knowledge" for a mortal sin, the person must know that the act constitutes grave matter or clearly acknowledge that it might be. If one commits an evil act that is grave matter and with deliberate consent to doing so, but still only [i]believes[/i] it to be a lighter matter, a venial sin is committed. Such a conscience needs more forming, but it is not possible to commit a mortal sin without knowing it. For the sake of completeness in this post, if one wrongly believes a light matter to be grave matter, and fulfills the other two conditions for a mortal sin, they [i]have[/i] committed a mortal sin. Also, if one decides to commit a mortal sin and performs an act that is not grave matter and does not reflect on whether it is or not, they [i]have[/i] committed a mortal sin.

This is all open to correction from more informed Phatmassers. Pax Christi.

Posted

My first thought was a client who committed murder. He had schizophrenia, and was in a delusional state at the time he committed the act. This was a very grave matter, and I am hopeful that after his execution that Christ took mercy on him.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

[quote name='aalpha1989' post='1580447' date='Jun 23 2008, 05:10 PM']I personally don't think that a good intention counts as a mitigating circumstance, unless you mean that it is a choice between two evils. In war, soldiers must shoot and kill sometimes. Killing is always evil, even if it is sometimes necessary.[/quote]
Just one thing - killing is not an inherent evil. It is permissible under certain circumstances so cannot be said to be [i]always[/i] wrong. A just killing cannot be characterized as an evil act that is somehow justified by mitigating circumstances. Just wanted to clear that up.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1580482' date='Jun 23 2008, 05:36 PM']My first thought was a client who committed murder. He had schizophrenia, and was in a delusional state at the time he committed the act.[/quote]
Here we have an issue of full consent of the will. Only the individual who acted can say for sure if they fully consented. RIP, I hope he's in heaven.

Posted

[quote name='thedude' post='1580491' date='Jun 23 2008, 05:41 PM']Just one thing - killing is not an inherent evil. It is permissible under certain circumstances so cannot be said to be [i]always[/i] wrong. A just killing cannot be characterized as an evil act that is somehow justified by mitigating circumstances. Just wanted to clear that up.[/quote]


I did not mean that it was always wrong, only that it was never a good. I mean if you had a choice between killing someone or letting them kill a number of people (unjustly, of course...), and these were the only two options, the right choice would be to protect the number. Right? But it still wouldn't be good that you had to take that one person's life. It would be an evil, but a necessary one. Am I wrong?

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted (edited)

You are right that killing isn't a good, but I don't think it should be called an evil either. I don't think there is such thing as a necessary evil act. It's like punishing a misbehaving child, it isn't a good thing but it isn't evil either.

Again, I am quite open to correction. Hopefully someone can enlighten us. I am speaking off my head and from Fr. Jone's [u]Moral Theology[/u].

Edited by thedude
Posted

I was talking to someone who told me they're considering marriage but they might be sterile. I suggested fertility testing but they said it would require committing a mortal sin. I personally thought it wouldn't be a mortal sin since the intention was to determine fertility, which would then influence this person's decision to get married or not.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

Oh ok - I have heard of this situation. The person was correct, a fertility test done in an immoral manner cannot be justified. Apparently there are not any alternatives for an unmarried man but I am not certain. Regarding how this person should approach marriage, it would be best for a good priest to answer or at least someone smarter than I am.

Posted

Well, glad I couldn't convince him

CatholicCid
Posted (edited)

[quote name='thedude' post='1580491' date='Jun 23 2008, 04:41 PM']Just one thing - killing is not an inherent evil. It is permissible under certain circumstances so cannot be said to be [i]always[/i] wrong. A just killing cannot be characterized as an evil act that is somehow justified by mitigating circumstances. Just wanted to clear that up.[/quote]

I've always thought that it was always wrong, however, the circumstances involved could make the person justified in commiting the act and not be culpable. Such as, killing a person in self defense. The person is not culpable for the act as they have a right to defend themselves, however, the act itself is still an evil.

I learned a theological term for this train of thought, but now I cannot remember it. It has to do with seperating the action itself as objective from the person and circumstances involved as subjective (as somewhat stated in the OP). But, I've only had introduction theology classes, so just spouting off my own thoughts on the matter and could quitely easily be horribly wrong.

Edited by CatholicCid
Posted

[quote name='CatholicCid' post='1581092' date='Jun 23 2008, 11:46 PM']I've always thought that it was always wrong, however, the circumstances involved could make the person justified in commiting the act and not be culpable. Such as, killing a person in self defense. The person is not culpable for the act as they have a right to defend themselves, however, the act itself is still an evil.

I learned a theological term for this train of thought, but now I cannot remember it. It has to do with seperating the action itself as objective from the person and circumstances involved as subjective (as somewhat stated in the OP). But, I've only had introduction theology classes, so just spouting off my own thoughts on the matter and could quitely easily be horribly wrong.[/quote]

That's kinda what I thought. *sigh*. More stuff to think/ pray about, I guess.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

I must say I'm pretty confused at this point.

Noel's angel
Posted

[quote name='aalpha1989' post='1580447' date='Jun 23 2008, 11:10 PM']Killing is always evil, even if it is sometimes necessary.[/quote]

I would disagree. Killing isn't always evil. Murder is. Someone could walk out in front of my car and the impact would kill them. It's not an evil act.

Posted

I know for a married man, they can take a sample using a condom with a pin hole in it. It gets the sample needed, but is technically still open to life in the marital act, if marginally so. For a non-married man, I'd say give the sample, go to confession, and let it go. There are a lot of medical procedures that females go through that aren't in my book of chastity, but I don't list them in confession.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...