reyb Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1581308' date='Jun 24 2008, 07:11 AM']I would disagree. Killing isn't always evil. Murder is. Someone could walk out in front of my car and the impact would kill them. It's not an evil act.[/quote] [indent]kill verb 1. he killed three people take someone's life, slay, murder, do away with, do to death, slaughter, butcher, massacre, assassinate, liquidate, wipe out, destroy, erase, eradicate, exterminate, dispatch, put to death, execute, hang, behead, guillotine, send to the electric chair; inf. bump off, do in, knock off, top. (from Oxford Dictionary). Does it mean the word ‘to kill’ is not the same as ‘murder’? [/indent]
CatholicCid Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1581308' date='Jun 24 2008, 06:11 AM']I would disagree. Killing isn't always evil. Murder is. Someone could walk out in front of my car and the impact would kill them. It's not an evil act.[/quote] I would disagree with the disagree (+Checks that off list of things I always wanted to say+ ). That someone was killed would itself be evil and grave. However, the driver would not be culpable as it was unintentional, among several reasons. However, I would dare say the driver in such a situation would be both extremely distressed and grief stricken over the accident, which might also show a glimpse of how the act, though unintentional was still a grave offense. CCC 2269 - Unintentional killing is not morally imputable. [i]But one is not exonerated from grave offense[/i] if, without proportionate reasons, he has acted in a way that brings about someone's death, even without the intention to do so. While the note is about unintentional killing, such as the description described, it still notes the matter as a grave offense in the next sentence. One would not have to be exonerated if the unintentional act was not still a grave offense [Stress mine] Just my (uneducated) thoughts and ponderings on the matter Edited June 24, 2008 by CatholicCid
StColette Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 [quote name='mortify' post='1581024' date='Jun 23 2008, 10:55 PM']I was talking to someone who told me they're considering marriage but they might be sterile. I suggested fertility testing but they said it would require committing a mortal sin. I personally thought it wouldn't be a mortal sin since the intention was to determine fertility, which would then influence this person's decision to get married or not.[/quote] Have this person find a priest who is an awesome moral theologian. Plus one would have to ask this person why he thinks he's sterile, if there is good enough cause to believe such a thing. Also is this person confusing infertility and sterility?
prose Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 I am confused. If he is unmarried and presumably has never had sex, why would he think he is infertile? I am pretty sure that infertility is not a reason that makes a marriage null. Impotency is, but I don't believe infertility is. ESPECIALLY if the person did not know about the infertility.
prose Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 (edited) I found an article that articulates what I am trying to say here: [url="http://jimmyakin.typepad.com/defensor_fidei/2006/02/marriage_after_.html"]http://jimmyakin.typepad.com/defensor_fide...age_after_.html[/url] [quote]It is NOT true that people should only marry if they plan or hope to have children. The Church has NEVER taught this. It has always recognized that it is morally legitimate for infertile people to get married--whether they are infertile due to advanced age or something else. As long as they can perform the marital act, they can marry. Whether the marital act will be fertile or infertile in their case is another issue. ..... Whether you become infertile before or after you get married has nothing to do with whether you and your spouse can engage in the marital act. Sex is not just about procreation. You cannot intentionally thwart the procreative aspect of sex, but if it is infertile for other reasons then you can continue to have it. In fact, it continues to be a debt that the two spouses owe to each other, whether they are fertile or not. If either of them reasonably requests it, the other party is morally obliged to pay the marriage debt in a reasonable manner and time.[/quote] Edited June 24, 2008 by prose
aalpha1989 Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1581308' date='Jun 24 2008, 07:11 AM']I would disagree. Killing isn't always evil. Murder is. Someone could walk out in front of my car and the impact would kill them. It's not an evil act.[/quote] CatholicCid said everything I could have. [quote name='CatherineM' post='1581344' date='Jun 24 2008, 09:12 AM']I know for a married man, they can take a sample using a condom with a pin hole in it. It gets the sample needed, but is technically still open to life in the marital act, if marginally so. For a non-married man, I'd say give the sample, go to confession, and let it go. There are a lot of medical procedures that females go through that aren't in my book of chastity, but I don't list them in confession.[/quote] . Seriously? But... whatever happened to Death Before Sin? If it's a sin you don't do it, and if it's not you don't need to confess it... It's that simple. You don't do something which is a sin just because you can go confess it later...
ardillacid Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 [quote name='prose' post='1581451' date='Jun 24 2008, 12:41 PM']I am confused. If he is unmarried and presumably has never had sex, why would he think he is infertile?[/quote] If he has never masturbated and not had nocturnal emissions, he is infertile, as far as I know.
Noel's angel Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 (edited) What would you define as killing then? Where do you draw the line between accidental death and killing? (Please also note the phrase 'without proportionate reasons' in your quote) Beating an animal to death would be an evil act, but we don't say it is evil when we kill animals to eat. Edited June 24, 2008 by Noel's angel
StColette Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 [quote name='prose' post='1581451' date='Jun 24 2008, 12:41 PM']I am pretty sure that infertility is not a reason that makes a marriage null. Impotency is, but I don't believe infertility is. ESPECIALLY if the person did not know about the infertility.[/quote] You're correct
HisChildForever Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 [quote name='prose' post='1581451' date='Jun 24 2008, 12:41 PM']I am pretty sure that infertility is not a reason that makes a marriage null. Impotency is, but I don't believe infertility is.[/quote] Wait, the Church teaches that if an individual cannot physically have sex (maybe they are paralyzed, i.e., had been in a car accident), then they can't get married?! What if a couple had been engaged (living chastely, of course) for two years, and the man was in a car accident - not his fault at all - and it left him paralyzed from the neck down. He can't marry the woman he loves, and she can't marry the man she loves?
aalpha1989 Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 [quote name='HisChildForever' post='1581568' date='Jun 24 2008, 02:49 PM']Wait, the Church teaches that if an individual cannot physically have sex (maybe they are paralyzed, i.e., had been in a car accident), then they can't get married?! What if a couple had been engaged (living chastely, of course) for two years, and the man was in a car accident - not his fault at all - and it left him paralyzed from the neck down. He can't marry the woman he loves, and she can't marry the man she loves?[/quote] [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=81420&hl="]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...c=81420&hl=[/url]
Brigid Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 [quote name='thedude' post='1580471' date='Jun 23 2008, 05:27 PM']if one wrongly believes a light matter to be grave matter, and fulfills the other two conditions for a mortal sin, they [i]have[/i] committed a mortal sin.[/quote] okay, so... you're saying that if a person commits a sin that's not grave matter, has full knowledge of that sin and has deliberately consented to committing it, but believes it to be grave matter, that sin IS mortal? I'm just trying to make sure I understand what you're saying. [quote name='thedude' post='1580471' date='Jun 23 2008, 05:27 PM']Also, if one decides to commit a mortal sin and performs an act that is not grave matter and does not reflect on whether it is or not, they [i]have[/i] committed a mortal sin.[/quote] so if someone (with full knowledge/consent) commits a sin that's not grave, but doesn't bother to think about whether it's grave or not, they're committing a mortal sin, too? still just trying to understand...
prose Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 [quote name='notardillacid' post='1581547' date='Jun 24 2008, 01:36 PM']If he has never masturbated and not had nocturnal emissions, he is infertile, as far as I know.[/quote] Um... You aren't being serious are you?
prose Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 [quote name='notardillacid' post='1581547' date='Jun 24 2008, 01:36 PM']If he has never masturbated and not had nocturnal emissions, he is infertile, as far as I know.[/quote] Um... You aren't being serious are you?
CatholicCid Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1581549' date='Jun 24 2008, 01:36 PM']*What would you define as killing then? Where do you draw the line between accidental death and killing? **(Please also note the phrase 'without proportionate reasons' in your quote) ***Beating an animal to death would be an evil act, but we don't say it is evil when we kill animals to eat.[/quote] *I suppose I would have to define 'killing' as the taking of a life through unnatural means, whether accidental or not. I would propose that an 'accidental death' would still be a form of 'killing', though the person(s) involved would most likely not be culpable of the action(s) (depending on the circumstances). **My use of the CCC quote was more so to stress the "grave offense" part, as I see that as the CCC stating that causing the death of another is a grave offense, whether intentional or not. If I may summarize the 2nd sentence from my previous quote of the CCC, I believe it is saying that one is culpable of grave offense if one's reckless actions leads to another's death, even if it was not intended. However, if one accidently brings about the death of another [i]with proportionate reason[/i], I believe it would be reasonable to say that they are then "exonerated from grave offense". The point I was trying to make then was that, whether one is culpable or not, the unnatural death of another is still a 'grave offense'. The act itself would be 'evil' (objectively), however, one's culpability in the matter can vary (subjectively) depending on the circumstances. ***I would think that the situation changes when discussing animals, and humans. All my discussion was directed soley toward humans. My quick thought on it would be that the situation is different as the Lord entrusted the care of animals to us as stewards of the earth. Slaughtering animals for use as food and such is legitimate in our roles as stewards. You have, but again, just my (insane) thoughts and ramblings
Noel's angel Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 Was it evil for David to kill Goliath? Would it have been evil if Abraham had killed his son?
reyb Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1581549' date='Jun 24 2008, 02:36 PM']What would you define as killing then? Where do you draw the line between accidental death and killing? (Please also note the phrase 'without proportionate reasons' in your quote) Beating an animal to death would be an evil act, but we don't say it is evil when we kill animals to eat.[/quote] [indent]Of course, there is a difference between accidental 'killing' and intentional 'murder'. That is why in the justice system there are different verdict/sentences on these two different cases. But here, in our discussion, we are talking in spiritual level because the word 'evil' was mentioned. [/indent] [indent]It is written in Matt 19:18-19 [color="#FF0000"]Jesus replied, "'Do not murder , do not commit adultery, do not steal, do not give false testimony, 19 honor your father and mother,' and 'love your neighbor as yourself.'" [/color]NIV Is there any condition whether it is intentional or accidental in committing this 'murder'in the above verse? [/indent]
CatholicCid Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1581790' date='Jun 24 2008, 04:44 PM']Was it evil for David to kill Goliath? Would it have been evil if Abraham had killed his son?[/quote] My initial response would be that what David did and Abraham was going to do were the will of the Lord. As the Lord is the Creator and Author of Life, He alone has the right to destroy any human being. If the Lord wills that a person might die, then that would be a natural end to the person's life written by the Author of Life himself. As I haven't yet re-read David and Goliath to refresh myself on all details, another possibility appears as an option if it was not directly the Lord's will. At the time, I believe, the countries were at war. David fought Goliath as a warrior, to defeat him and save his people. If the Lord had not willed it, then yes, the death of Goliath would have been evil soley as the unnatural death of a person. However, David, fighting necessarily as a soldier in war, would not be culpable of that evil, he would have no sin in that case. When time is available, however, I would like to take time to reflect and expand/correct my thoughts on this matter due to a few portions of the CCC that caught my eye, specifically 2261 & 2263. You have once again my (uneducated and inane) thoughts
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now