Justin86 Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 [quote name='mortify' post='1585517' date='Jun 28 2008, 10:17 PM']I guess they want the Pope to repudiate vatican ii and then lift the excommunication on Arch Lefebvre, and then they'll come back.[/quote] If that is what they desire then it is by far too early for Rome to actually condemn the pastoral council (yes, pretty much of all of Vatican II was a pastoral council, and is therefore not infallible). I'm unsure if Rome ever has lifted an excommunication on a deceased person. I'm not sure I see the point really.
XIX Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 [quote name='abercius24' post='1585427' date='Jun 28 2008, 01:59 AM']I think its time to discontinue recognizing the SSPX by the term "SSPX" and call them what they will be known for in Church history to come: "The Lefebvrites". We should not participate in tarnishing Pope St. Pius X's good name in the name of those who have no love for the Papacy.[/quote] Kinda like how Susan B. Anthony had the misfortune of having an abortion chamber named after her.
goldenchild17 Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 don't know if anyone has posted this anywhere. Seems as if the SSPX has chosen not to return to Rome at this time.
Dave Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 [quote name='Justin86' post='1585559' date='Jun 28 2008, 12:35 PM']If that is what they desire then it is by far too early for Rome to actually condemn the pastoral council (yes, pretty much of all of Vatican II was a pastoral council, and is therefore not infallible).[/quote] From a chapter of [i]More Catholic Than the Pope[/i] by Patrick Madrid and Pete Vere: [quote]Many traditionalists argue that the Second Vatican Council was the first general council of the Church to be uniquely convened as a "pastoral" council. Yet the word "pastoral" can be understood (and misunderstood) in different ways. When applied to the Second Vatican Council, as Father de Servigny points out, the word "pastoral" must be understood in the context of what Pope John XXIII intended when he convened the Council. This is a fairly common principle when it comes to the interpretation of the sacred sciences. In fact, one can draw a parallel between Father de Servigny's approach and Canon 17 of the 1983 Code of Canon Law (or, since the 1983 Code of Canon Law was not yet in effect when Pope John XXIII convened the Second Vatican Council, Canon 18 from the 1917 Code of Canon Law). Father de Servigny cites the following paragraph from Pope John XXIII's opening discourse at the Second Vatican Council: "It must come to pass that this certain and immutable doctrine, which must be faithfully respected, is deepened and presented in a way that replies to the demands of our time . . . We must attach more importance to this way and patiently, if need be, towards its elaboration, and we must hasten to a way of presenting it that better corresponds to a teaching whose character is pastoral above all else (2). This is a fairly good summary of how Pope John XXIII understood the word "pastoral" when he convened the Second Vatican Council. "Pastoral" does not mean that the Second Vatican Council merely focused upon the Church's pastoral discipline -- those laws and practices subject to change over time. Nor does "pastoral" mean the Second Vatican Council ignored the Church's teaching, since its pronouncements had to be based on some previous Catholic teaching in order to qualify as one of the Church's general councils. Rather, "pastoral" in this context means taking the Church's existing, immutable teaching -- those matters of faith and morals that we derive from Holy Scripture and Sacred Tradition -- and putting them into practice in a manner that challenges today's society and culture in terms it can comprehend. "While the temptation exists to oppose the Second Vatican Council's pastoral nature with the dogmatic nature of previous ecumenical councils," Father de Servigny warns, "pastoral and dogmatic do not automatically exclude one another. For a pastoral teaching is a theological teaching, albeit not purely intellectual and reserved to theologians. Rahter, it is transmitted to the everyday world in order to spiritually feed Christians and enlighten them about the mystery of God. It is this teaching that enlightens the faithful, telling us what we must believe and what we must do to grow in our relationship with our Lord Jesus Christ." In other words, "pastoral" determines where a doctrine stands among the average Catholic in the pew. We don't study God for God's sake, but for our own. We study the mystery of God to better understand Him, to love Him all the more, and to live His truth more fully. For instance, doctrinal theology teaches us about the great mystery of Christ's redemption, whereas pastoral theology teaches us to put this mystery into practice by frequenting the sacrament of confession. Doctrinal theology teaches us about the mystery of transubstantiation during the holy Sacrifice of the Mass, whereas pastoral theology teaches us when we can and cannot partake of this mystery. Once the reader understands this pastoral orientation of the Second Vatican Council, Father de Servigny introduces the following quotation from Cardinal Yves Congar, O.P. -- one of the many theological experts invited to partake in the Council. "What John XXIII designated by 'pastoral' was doctrine," Cardinal Congar writes, "but expressing itself in history, in the time of the actual world . . . It is doctrinal, but pastoral doctrine, that is to say doctrine that asks to be applied historically" (3). What Congar means is that, as a pastoral council, the Second Vatican Council sought to apply the Church's teaching within the context of current history -- to make the Church's doctrine relevant to today's world. At the incarnation, Christ didn't merely take upon Himself human flesh -- He also took upon Himself our customs, mores, culture, and, as far as creation is concerned, time and space. Thus, doctrine applies here and now, across the expanse of human geography, in an age of modern technology and universal communications. Doctrine is not simply restricted to the Hebrew population gathered in the vicinity of Jerusalem during the era of King Herod and Pontius Pilate.[/quote]
goldenchild17 Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 [quote name='Margaret Clare' post='1584923' date='Jun 27 2008, 01:33 PM']Fr. Z doesn't seem to think this article is the end of the story[/quote] It's not (unless the Vatican doesn't want them back). Bishop Fellay was interviewed soon after the news came out that the reconciliation did not go through, and he said that he still wants to work towards a reunion, but wished to discuss the doctrinal concerns, and believed that Rome was pushing things along a little too quickly.
goldenchild17 Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 [quote name='mortify' post='1585114' date='Jun 27 2008, 05:11 PM']According to recent reports the original leak about the SSPX having to accept the Second Vat Council is false, the five conditions are far milder and thus all the more shocking that they were rejected[/quote] Bishop Fellay doesn't reject the conditions outright. From a very general summary/interpretation of an Italian interview: The interviewer put the first question in terms of the SSPX having rejecting the offer, that on Friday for an ordination, it was announced that the SSPX rejected the ultimatum. But Fellay corrected him saying that that is not quite accurate. Fellay said that it is perhaps false to say that "reject". "Maybe it is false to say so directly that I reject, that I have made a complete refusal. That’s not true. Rather, I see in this ultimate something very vague and confused. But isn’t this the last chance to reunite with Rome, during this favorable time with Pope Benedict XVI? Fellay repeated that this ultimatum makes no sense (non ha senso) because they do, in fact, have a dialogue with Rome,even if it is slow. Rome wants to speed things up. Fellay claims that they want to continue dialogue. SSPX wants to continue the dialogue. For Fellay dialogue might be "chilly" right now but it is not over. The interviewer asked if Rome will lose patience, is the the SSPX at risk, will be it more and more marginalized? Fellay said that more more people are coming to the SSPX. They don’t want to break with the Church. They desire to be accepted into the Church and do good for the Church. They are defenders of tradition.
goldenchild17 Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1585258' date='Jun 27 2008, 07:31 PM']I think that we will get back many of the rank and file because their leader's response has clearly shown that this isn't about theology, this is about power, arrogance, and lack of obedience.[/quote] interesting. not sure which statements of his you've been reading (if any).
goldenchild17 Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 [quote name='abercius24' post='1585427' date='Jun 27 2008, 11:59 PM']I think its time to discontinue recognizing the SSPX by the term "SSPX" and call them what they will be known for in Church history to come: "The Lefebvrites". We should not participate in tarnishing Pope St. Pius X's good name in the name of those who have no love for the Papacy.[/quote] but I would assume you are okay with the Orthodox rites keeping their names, which all correspond to valid Catholic Eastern Rites?
goldenchild17 Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 [quote name='Farsight one' post='1585464' date='Jun 28 2008, 01:51 AM']Ok...I'm a bit confused. They broke off and they claim that they are the true church. Which means they think we are a false one, and, de facto, Benedict the XVI is a false pope. Would not returning to the Church force them to admit that Benedict the XVI is not a false pope, and thus never could have been one? Which would in turn force them to admit that they were wrong all along? Is there something I'm missing here?[/quote] yeah. you're missing the fact that they don't believe that it's a false Church. They believe Benedict is a real pope, who has (along with his recent predecessors) made some very serious (but not infallible) mistakes. They would not be trying to reconcile if they didn't believe that Benedict was a real pope leading the real church. They didn't break away. They were excommunicated (at least the bishops were). There's a difference.
goldenchild17 Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 [quote name='Farsight one' post='1585476' date='Jun 28 2008, 03:57 AM']If he's not a false pope, then he's a real pope. which means his teachings are real. Which means the SSPX is knowingly wrong and should just admit it. See? They're on the wrong end either way. [/quote] Not everything a Pope says is infallible, which is true. This is their premise, and they say the recent popes have made serious mistakes in regards to some non-infallible matters.
goldenchild17 Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 [quote name='Justin86' post='1585489' date='Jun 28 2008, 04:45 AM']Those conditions, if they were what the Vatican actually wants, are so vague they could mean anything. While I disagree strongly with the SSPX, I could understand not wanting to rejoin under these requirements. They could be tricked into accepting anything.[/quote] And that is exactly what Bishop Fellay's reasoning is. He says so in the italian interview.
abercius24 Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 (edited) There is a lot of confusion about Vatican II and its infallibility. Yes, the Council as a whole is not infallible, particularly because its contents dealt mostly with elements of religious practice and general disciplinary methods. BUT, there are dogmatic decrees admist all the documents of Vatican II that ARE infallible. When a particular doctrine (regarding faith and morals) is laid out with solemn language stating that such truths are proclaimed by the Council Fathers and must be binding upon the consciences of all the faithful, then that doctrine is now elevated to the level of dogma. And there are in fact such statements in the documents of Vatican II. So, the Council as a whole may not be dogmatic, but it certainly does contain dogma that the Lefebvrites must accept. Vatican II Dogmas include: --The State's Duty to Protect Religious Freedom (not the same as an Individual's Moral Right to Freedom of Religious Concscience) --The Incomplete, yet Substantial Brotherhood the Church Holds with Jews and Moslems and the Immoral Character of Discrimination based on Race, Color, Condition of Life, or Religion. --An Individual's Moral Right to Education, particularly Education in the Faith Edited June 28, 2008 by abercius24
goldenchild17 Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 If those are the infallible teachings, then I amend my initial thoughts about the reunion. I hope they never do, if they are bound to some of those teachings.
abercius24 Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 There is a substantial anti-semitism that exists in the Lefebvrite movement that lead them to not accept the Decrees of Vatican II. They adopt as their own the personal issues many of the Church Fathers had with the Jewish people. We have no legitimate claim to the same feelings of persecution the Early Church had at the hands of the Jews given our current relationship with the Jewish people. And despite the Early Church Father's poor choice of words when speaking of their Jewish persecutors, they still recognized the Jewish people as their older brothers of the Faith.
mortify Posted June 28, 2008 Author Posted June 28, 2008 Speaking of the "dogmaticness" of Vatican II, I keep finding conflicting information. On one hand there are quotes from the Popes and commentators that Vatican II was not and did not intend to be dogmatic, that is they did not intend to introduce any dogma, and if they were to do so it would be clearly indicated. The problem however is that some documents contain the word "dogma," as in example the Dogmatic Constitutions of Lumen Gentium, which suggests the points therein are dogmatic, but then this would contradict the previous statements. Ultimately the point is Vatican II is binding on us even though it is not set in stone, i.e. the pastoral changes it brought can be changed in the future. Lastly, I do hope the SSPX return to full union with Rome, many of them are good hearted Catholics even if they be on the wrong side of the fence and they're devotion can surely be used to reform the Church. Pax Christi
jeffpugh Posted June 29, 2008 Posted June 29, 2008 [quote name='Margaret Clare' post='1584923' date='Jun 27 2008, 02:33 PM']Fr. Z doesn't seem to think this article is the end of the story, [url="http://wdtprs.com/blog/2008/06/reuters-bp-fellay-says-no-story-is-not-the-end-of-the-story/"]http://wdtprs.com/blog/2008/06/reuters-bp-...d-of-the-story/[/url] [url="http://wdtprs.com/blog/2008/06/pray-pray-now-2/"]http://wdtprs.com/blog/2008/06/pray-pray-now-2/[/url] [url="http://wdtprs.com/blog/2008/06/sleepless-at-the-moment-pray/"]http://wdtprs.com/blog/2008/06/sleepless-at-the-moment-pray/[/url] [url="http://wdtprs.com/blog/2008/06/pray-pray-now-3/"]http://wdtprs.com/blog/2008/06/pray-pray-now-3/[/url] Although it does look very unlikely at this point that this agreement will take place within the next couple of days. And this is disturbing from Bishop Williamson - [url="http://wdtprs.com/blog/2008/06/musings-of-excommd-sspx-bp-williamson/"]http://wdtprs.com/blog/2008/06/musings-of-...-bp-williamson/[/url] Also, there's a little podcast audio there with an interview. It starts around 27 minutes, where he is being interviewed about the current situation with the SSPX [url="http://www.wdtprs.com/podcazt/08_06_26.mp3"]http://www.wdtprs.com/podcazt/08_06_26.mp3[/url][/quote] [quote name='Margaret Clare' post='1584954' date='Jun 27 2008, 02:58 PM']New blog post from FR. Z - [url="http://wdtprs.com/blog/2008/06/afp-lefebvrites-no-intention-of-responding-to-vatican-ultimatum/"]http://wdtprs.com/blog/2008/06/afp-lefebvr...ican-ultimatum/[/url][/quote] Poor Fr Z. He's really concerned about this. Heck, so am I. May God unite what evil has broken. [quote name='abercius24' post='1585427' date='Jun 28 2008, 12:59 AM']I think its time to discontinue recognizing the SSPX by the term "SSPX" and call them what they will be known for in Church history to come: "The Lefebvrites". We should not participate in tarnishing Pope St. Pius X's good name in the name of those who have no love for the Papacy.[/quote] Interesting way of putting it. I agreed with you the first time I read this, but now I think we're jumping the gun a bit... [quote name='goldenchild17' post='1585679' date='Jun 28 2008, 02:46 PM']but I would assume you are okay with the Orthodox rites keeping their names, which all correspond to valid Catholic Eastern Rites?[/quote] I'd have to say that's a different context all together. [quote name='abercius24' post='1585691' date='Jun 28 2008, 02:54 PM']There is a lot of confusion about Vatican II and its infallibility. Yes, the Council as a whole is not infallible, particularly because its contents dealt mostly with elements of religious practice and general disciplinary methods. BUT, there are dogmatic decrees admist all the documents of Vatican II that ARE infallible. When a particular doctrine (regarding faith and morals) is laid out with solemn language stating that such truths are proclaimed by the Council Fathers and must be binding upon the consciences of all the faithful, then that doctrine is now elevated to the level of dogma. And there are in fact such statements in the documents of Vatican II. So, the Council as a whole may not be dogmatic, but it certainly does contain dogma that the Lefebvrites must accept. Vatican II Dogmas include: --The State's Duty to Protect Religious Freedom (not the same as an Individual's Moral Right to Freedom of Religious Concscience) --The Incomplete, yet Substantial Brotherhood the Church Holds with Jews and Moslems and the Immoral Character of Discrimination based on Race, Color, Condition of Life, or Religion. --An Individual's Moral Right to Education, particularly Education in the Faith[/quote] Surely not the muslims? Their understand of God is quite interesting... and can they really back up their claims to ties w/ "Ishmael"?
abercius24 Posted June 29, 2008 Posted June 29, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1586002' date='Jun 29 2008, 12:00 AM']Interesting way of putting it. I agreed with you the first time I read this, but now I think we're jumping the gun a bit...[/quote] I do hope so! [quote name='mortify' post='1585822' date='Jun 28 2008, 06:03 PM']Lastly, I do hope the SSPX return to full union with Rome, many of them are good hearted Catholics even if they be on the wrong side of the fence and they're devotion can surely be used to reform the Church. Pax Christi[/quote] You are right, there are very many good people caught up in the movement for genuine emotional reasons. When I did door-to-door work, they were the hardest people to leave behind after speaking with them. They were one of us, but they simply loved the Tridentine Rite too much to abandone it. Thanks to Benedict XVI, they have no reason to anymore. [quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1586002' date='Jun 29 2008, 12:00 AM']Surely not the muslims? Their understand of God is quite interesting... and can they really back up their claims to ties w/ "Ishmael"?[/quote] No, they really can't back up their claims to ties with Ishamel. In fact we know that isn't true. And they do have a skewed understanding of Salvation and our relationship with God. Regardless, they do have the genuine and informed intention of worshiping the God of Abraham. They worship the God of our Fathers even though they misunderstand a great number of other things. That means we do share the same spiritual Father -- God -- and are therefore brothers in Faith. Edited June 29, 2008 by abercius24
mortify Posted June 29, 2008 Author Posted June 29, 2008 The vagueness of the five conditions isn't a reason to reject the ultimatum. They all more or less call for respect and obedience to the Magesterium, which the SSPX already claims to be doing. The "hastiness" Fellay complains of is balanced with the fact the Pope is not requiring them to openly pledge fidelity to the Second Vatican Council, but only the baby step of respecting the Papal Office.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted June 30, 2008 Posted June 30, 2008 Well, just more proof that pride is the whole reason behind the schism...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now