Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1587591' date='Jun 30 2008, 08:46 PM']For many of the Early Rabbis who explicity rejected Christianity, I would agree. But of those who were in good conscience staying faithful to an assumed continuity with the Old Covenant, there is a level of invincible ignorance that must be recognized with eyes of mercy.[/quote]
This moves into speculative waters, because neither you nor I can know if a person is invincibly ignorant of the true faith, we can only judge according to a man's outward actions. Nevertheless, to accept a belief system that is inherently formulated in order to deny Christian truth is damnable.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1587557' date='Jun 30 2008, 10:35 PM']Anyone who is validly baptized is put into communion (at least to some degree) with the Church.

The main groups would be: (1) the Eastern Orthodox Churches, which are true particular Churches; (2) the ecclesial communities that arose during the Protestant Reformation; and (3) many of the modern non-denominational communities.[/quote]

I was thinking of like, women religious communities that are kind of over-the-top with their modernism, particularly.

Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1587591' date='Jun 30 2008, 08:46 PM']Only the Jews can honestly claim that they didn't get the message that God had "radically" changed the state of the Faith -- moving the Seat of Moses from The Chief Priest to the Pope, fulfilling in one single person all the hopes and prayers of the prophets in one man who was the One God. That kind of change is much harder to accept than what other heretical movements have been faced with. If anyone can be considered our "lost brethren", it must be the Jews first![/quote]
I deny absolutely that the state of the faith was "radically changed," because the faith is immutable. The Old Testament patriarchs and prophets believed in Christ (i.e., in the pre-incarnate Logos), and they worshipped the Holy Trinity.

Posted

[quote name='Alycin' post='1587596' date='Jun 30 2008, 08:51 PM']I was thinking of like, women religious communities that are kind of over-the-top with their modernism, particularly.[/quote]
:bigshock:

Due to their reception of baptism, they would be in communion with the Church, but the level of communion could be imperfect if they have embraced various theological errors.

Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1587591' date='Jun 30 2008, 08:46 PM']But, there is much to be learned from the hoenst faith of our separated brethren (from those who are in fact honest). When researching biblical resources that affirmed the teachings of the Catholic faith on the internet, I found the Catholic resources very much in need. On common matters of faith -- such as the Trinity, the Divinity of Christ, the relationship between the Covenants and Salvation History -- I found that Protestants offer much more by way of studying the Greek text, and the Jews offer much more by way of studying the Hebrew text. And their insite into these common elements of the Faith do in fact inspire me to be a better Catholic. But -- that does require that I understand our differences first so as not to betray them when we work together.[/quote]
I once believed something akin to this, but as an Eastern Christian I no longer hold that faith is a discursive form of knowledge; instead, faith involves an experiential participation in God's uncreated life and glory through grace.

Posted

There is an automatic excommunication for female "priests" so they'd basically have a level of communion similar to that of a Protestant. Maybe a bit greater is they were confirmed as Catholics.

abercius24
Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1587595' date='Jun 30 2008, 10:50 PM']This moves into speculative waters, because neither you nor I can know if a person is invincibly ignorant of the true faith, we can only judge according to a man's outward actions. Nevertheless, to accept a belief system that is inherently formulated in order to deny Christian truth is damnable.[/quote]

But that assumes that all accepted that system for the sake of denial. It is more realistic to assume that most Jews were unaware of the Truths of the Christian Faith than to assume that all were aware and therefore culpable. And the Rabbis were the teachers of the average Jew before the end of the Old Covenant. Even Christ Himself recognized a teaching authority in the Rabbi to some degree by participating at His own synogogue (particularly when He revealed Himself and was subsequently rejected by His own people). A Jew who continued to participate in his/her faith at the synogogue would have been acting in good conscience unless he/she had explicitly rejected the convincing words of a Christian believer beforehand. The burden falls more on us to sufficiently teach the faith to them than it does on them accepting something they as of yet do not understand or have not yet heard.

Posted

[quote name='XIX' post='1587620' date='Jun 30 2008, 09:03 PM']There is an automatic excommunication for female "priests" so they'd basically have a level of communion similar to that of a Protestant. Maybe a bit greater is they were confirmed as Catholics.[/quote]
A person who is excommunicated is not even imperfectly in communion with the Church. Thus, Protestants living today are closer to the Church than someone who tries to simulate the sacrament of orders.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='abercius24' post='1587627' date='Jun 30 2008, 09:05 PM']But that assumes that all accepted that system for the sake of denial. It is more realistic to assume that most Jews were unaware of the Truths of the Christian Faith than to assume that all were aware and therefore culpable. And the Rabbis were the teachers of the average Jew before the end of the Old Covenant. Even Christ Himself recognized a teaching authority in the Rabbi to some degree by participating at His own synogogue (particularly when He revealed Himself and was subsequently rejected by His own people). A Jew who continued to participate in his/her faith at the synogogue would have been acting in good conscience unless he/she had explicitly rejected the convincing words of a Christian believer beforehand. The burden falls more on us to sufficiently teach the faith to them than it does on them accepting something they as of yet do not understand or have not yet heard.[/quote]
You and I cannot know what is in another person's mind, but if they embrace a theological system that is inherently anti-Christian, then it follows that we must see them as cut off from the true faith. Whether they are damned or not is up to God.

Edited by Apotheoun
abercius24
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1587619' date='Jun 30 2008, 11:02 PM']I once believed something akin to this, but as an Eastern Christian I no longer hold that faith is a discursive form of knowledge; instead, faith involves an experiential participation in God's uncreated life and glory through grace.[/quote]

I agree, but because it is intangible and can at best be personally sensed I used an intellectual example to demonstrate. But nonetheless, what good is recognizing the baptism of non-Catholics if we are not at least willing to recognize their participation in grace to some extent -- and their relationship to us by virtue of our sharing in that grace (which yes, is nothing less than a participation in God's uncreated life and glory).

And we cannot deny that God would lovingly appreciate the geniune worship shown by a faithful Jew of the Rabbinnic era despite his/her ignorance of the faith. Is that love shown between the two not a participation in grace to some extent? Perhaps not sanctifying grace (as we would call it in the West), but certainly a relationshp that we would have in common with him/her.

Edited by abercius24
Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1587605' date='Jun 30 2008, 09:53 PM']I deny absolutely that the state of the faith was "radically changed," because the faith is immutable. The Old Testament patriarchs and prophets believed in Christ (i.e., in the pre-incarnate Logos), and they worshipped the Holy Trinity.[/quote]

Dude then help me out in my discussion with ReyB in the Debate Table...PLEASE...

[url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=71169&st=120&start=120"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...0&start=120[/url]

Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1587647' date='Jun 30 2008, 09:11 PM']I agree, but because it is intangible and can at best be personally sensed I used an intellectual example to demonstrate. But nonetheless, what good is recognizing the baptism of non-Catholics if we are not at least willing to recognize their participation in grace to some extent -- and their relationship to us by virtue of our sharing in that grace (which yes, is nothing less than a participation in God's uncreated life and glory).[/quote]
Intellectual activity is important, but faith involves an intuitive gift of grace. Thus, neither you nor I can cause someone else to have faith.

What you have done in this conversation is to move from talking about the Rabbinic theological system, which is an objective thing, to the subjective belief of individuals. You and I can judge the former, but the latter can only be judged by God.

Thus, I stand by what I said earlier, Rabbinic Judaism is a false religion.

abercius24
Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1587662' date='Jun 30 2008, 11:18 PM']Intellectual activity is important, but faith involves an intuitive gift of grace. Thus, neither you nor I can cause someone else to have faith.

What you have done in this conversation is to move from talking about the Rabbinic theological system, which is an objective thing, to the subjective belief of individuals. You and I can judge the former, but the latter can only be judged by God.

Thus, I stand by what I said earlier, Rabbinic Judaism is a false religion.[/quote]

My point is that the likelihood of that subjective situation is very real and must be taken into consideration if we are to be honest and respectful of the Jews. Yes, objectively Rabbinical Judaism is a religion holding to significant error. I disagree that is has completely cut itself off from a relationship with the Old Covenant, and therefore should be recognized as completely cut off from us. Is Rabbinal Judiasm sufficient for salvation? No. Do they worship the same God as we? Yes, absolutely. Is that a substantial tie that should be recognized, especially in those who have not explicitly rejected the Catholic faith? Absolutely. Anything less is simply dishonest.

But my good friend, I believe we must agree to disagree at this point. We have already ridden this dead horse beyond the intended scope of this thread and further risk the need to dodge tomatos from our fellow phatmassers. I must admit, I enjoy talking about such deep topics with you again!

KnightofChrist
Posted

There is no practicing Jew alive today.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='abercius24' post='1587683' date='Jun 30 2008, 09:29 PM']My point is that the likelihood of that subjective situation is very real and must be taken into consideration if we are to be honest and respectful of the Jews. Yes, objectively Rabbinical Judaism is a religion holding to significant error. I disagree that is has completely cut itself off from a relationship with the Old Covenant, and therefore should be recognized as completely cut off from us. Is Rabbinal Judiasm sufficient for salvation? No. Do they worship the same God as we? Yes, absolutely. Is that a substantial tie that should be recognized, especially in those who have not explicitly rejected the Catholic faith? Absolutely. Anything less is simply dishonest.

But my good friend, I believe we must agree to disagree at this point. We have already ridden this dead horse beyond the intended scope of this thread and further risk the need to dodge tomatos from our fellow phatmassers. I must admit, I enjoy talking about such deep topics with you again![/quote]
Rabbinic Judaism is simply a man made system, so I have no qualms in saying that it is cut off from the true faith.

You are right about one thing; we will have to agree to disagree.

Edited by Apotheoun
Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1587619' date='Jul 1 2008, 09:32 AM']I once believed something akin to this, but as an Eastern Christian I no longer hold that faith is a discursive form of knowledge; instead, faith involves an experiential participation in God's uncreated life and glory through grace.[/quote]

Sorry for the hijack, but that's a beautiful definition of faith. I never thought of faith that way. Thanks for sharing this. Can you recommend any writings on the net where the Eastern Christian view of faith is explained in more detail? Thanks.

Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1587683' date='Jun 30 2008, 10:29 PM']...We have already ridden this dead horse beyond the intended scope of this thread and further risk the need to dodge tomatos from our fellow phatmassers....[/quote]

Watch out! :tomato:

abercius24
Posted

[quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1587687' date='Jun 30 2008, 11:30 PM']There is no practicing Jew alive today.[/quote]

That is a nice and tiddy academic statement, but not a practical one at all.

At what point did the Jews no longer be Jews? What is the coming of Christ? No, because we recognize that Christ Himself was a Jew who followed all prescriptions of the law perfectly throughout His life. Was it after Jesus gave the Keys of the Kingdom to Peter? No, because Jesus recognized the Seat of Moses in Caiphas when He adjured Him to testify at His trial, thereby recognizing Caiphas' authority as High Priest. Was it after Pentecost? No, because the Early Church struggled with questions as to whether or not Gentile converts needed to follow the Jewish prescriptions of the Old Covenant as did the Jewish Christians. Was it after the Romans assissinated all members of the Jewish priesthood and destroyed the Temple? Perhaps for those Jews who participated in Temple worship amidst the priests. But what about the regular "Joe Schmo" Jew who lived too far from Jerusalem and never made enough money to travel and make an offering at the Temple? The only place of worship that formed their daily lives was the synogogue. And the synogogues never disappeared. Was it when the Rabbis joined at the Council of Jamnia and rejected many elements of the Christian faith -- possibly recognizing many Anti-Catholic elements of the Talmud? Yes, maybe for the high ranking Rabbis at Jamnia. But not for the poor, local rabbi and his congregation whose lives were completely unchanged by Jamnia. To them the decisions of the council would have been little more than interesting news. THEIR SPIRITUAL LIVES WERE UNCHANGED OTHERWISE.

So yes, academically speaking, Rabbinical Judaism has rejected Catholicism and may have a history of anti-Catholic doctrine. Academically speaking, the Jews as a whole have lessened their ties to the Historical Church. But doctrines, beliefs and practices are no more than theoretical concepts if they are not understood from the perspective where they ultimately matter -- at the level of the average believer. As far as the average Jew is concerned, they are attending the same synogogue worship and seder meals as did the Patriarchs. They read of the same Pentateuch as those who descended from Moses. And they have a bloodline and heritage that traces back to the heros that we only read about in the Bible. On a macro level, Judaism has changed substantially. On the individual level, the Jews are practicing the same faith as they did in the time of Christ. And I am offended by those who can be so cavalier as to disregard the relationship they continue to have with the Lord despite their ignorance of the Christian Faith. We gotta keep things in perspective and remember that people matter more than academic postulations.

Posted

I am completely uneducated on all of this information about Judaism...I've got some homework to do...

Chiquitunga
Posted

[url="http://wdtprs.com/blog/2008/06/behind-the-scenes-sspx-things-are-brighter-than-they-may-seem/"]http://wdtprs.com/blog/2008/06/behind-the-...-they-may-seem/[/url]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...