Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

Ran across a discussion about this WSJ article [url="http://www.wsj.com/article/SB121331198629268975.html?mod=hpp_us_entrepreneur"]"Inspired by Starbucks"[/url] over on Relevant Magazine (link may take a minute to load).

Thought it would be interesting to hear some perspective from fellow Catholics (or whoever else is here :smokey: ). I don't care to debate about mega-churches since we've done that already and we know most of us aren't big fans of this brand of Christianity (in fact, many people on Relevant's board also have reservations, even those who attend mega-churches). Regardless, mega-churches are growing, they're growing faster than Catholicism, and they're drawing a lot of Catholics both here and overseas. This phenomenon is a reflection of both Christian and secular culture, which is the culture we are all charged with reaching out to.

Ironically, I thought it was interesting that the way they describe these churches modeling themselves after the idea of Starbucks franchising is not much unlike how every Catholic parish is essentially a franchise of St. Peter's with the Bishop of Rome as our common pastor. In fact, every Mass around the world is largely the same except for the homily. The homily also seems to be the weakest part of most Masses, while preaching is the major strong point at mega-churches. Hmm... any wonder they draw so many Catholics???

The article talks about one American church's franchise in Peru that has drawn many young believers away from Catholicism. While we could be quick to criticize them, I think it's clear they're filling a need that isn't met elsewhere. So, the question is, how can Catholic parishes and dioceses respond? How can orthodox Catholicism be presented to this generation?

To throw in my two cents... I think Catholicism is better suited than any mega-church for this style of evangelism. The liturgy and sacraments provide the structure that these places really need to be sustained for generations to come. Just imagine if a charismatic priest at an American parish were able to adopt several overseas sister parishes, with all cooperating with one another to organize outreaches, catechism, mission trips, produce web sites and other multimedia evangelism tools. But at the core of it all would be the Eucharist and fidelity to the Magesterium.

I think that's a pretty cool idea... anyone else got thoughts?

Edited by LouisvilleFan
Posted

I honestly have to give it some thought...I'll respond a bit later.

:think:
Meg

Posted

I have thought about this before. I think some of it has to do with the shortening of our attention spans. We want things quicker, with more flash, and better production values. When there was 2 or 3 channels, and you had to get up and walk across the room to change the channel, you tended to watch what was on longer. Now we are a society of channel surfers. We are constantly looking for the bigger and better deal. The problem with that, is that we just don't realize sometimes that we already have the best deal. That works with marriages and with churches.

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

Guess nobody else found this interesting or concerning...

Television is an ironic example... it wasn't that long ago that television didn't exist at all, but the days of two or three channels and no remote control are looked back on as the "good ol' days" :)

Yesterday I attended the Archdiocese of Louisville's 200th Anniversary Mass held at a local ballpark. I wasn't at Yankee Stadium, and in fact this was probably the only "big event" outdoor Mass I've attended, so I don't have much basis for comparison. But today, thinking about yesterday and viewing the pictures on our newspaper's web site leaves me with one definite thought: events like this reflect the state of the Church and we seriously need an injection of youthful energy and ethusiasm. I mean, you wouldn't think the Catholic Church and the Rolling Stones have much in common, but both sure scream "middle-aged."

Of course, I mean that more in spirit than in truth, to borrow Jesus' words. :)

Edited by LouisvilleFan
Archaeology cat
Posted

Hmm, that is really interesting. I'll have to give it some thought, but my initial comment is that I think this type of set-up could potentially attract more people. On the other hand, I noticed a lot of PoMo people in my area basically wanting what is in a High Mass, and modeling services to include some of those things, but so many of them had so many misconceptions of the Church that they didn't look into it more.

fides quarens intellectum
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1585048' date='Jun 27 2008, 03:29 PM']Ironically, I thought it was interesting that the way they describe these churches modeling themselves after the idea of Starbucks franchising is not much unlike how every Catholic parish is essentially a franchise of St. Peter's with the Bishop of Rome as our common pastor.[/quote]

i was thinking something similar. :)

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1585048' date='Jun 27 2008, 03:29 PM']In fact, every Mass around the world is largely the same except for the homily. The homily also seems to be the weakest part of most Masses, while preaching is the major strong point at mega-churches. Hmm... any wonder they draw so many Catholics???[/quote]

i think they draw so many Catholics because Catholics have dropped the ball in evangelization and catechesis over the past few decades. i personally don't think popcorn sermons are the answer, though - yes, it's great when a homily stirs the heart, but it's asking a bit much from our priests when they often have only 10-15 minutes a week to try to reach everyone in their congregation (i know, some priests go much longer). i think part of the problem in losing Catholics to these faith communities is that we, as a Church, have tended to erroneously assume prior evangelization for most of the people in the pews.


[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1585048' date='Jun 27 2008, 03:29 PM']The article talks about one American church's franchise in Peru that has drawn many young believers away from Catholicism. While we could be quick to criticize them, I think it's clear they're filling a need that isn't met elsewhere. So, the question is, how can Catholic parishes and dioceses respond? How can orthodox Catholicism be presented to this generation?[/quote]

Very good questions that i don't have answers to, as i am not a theologian on the New Evangelization. :) Personally, though, i think we can each do our part on a smaller level by individually striving to lead a life of holiness, and trusting the Holy Spirit to tell us what needs to be done.


[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1585048' date='Jun 27 2008, 03:29 PM']To throw in my two cents... I think Catholicism is better suited than any mega-church for this style of evangelism. The liturgy and sacraments provide the structure that these places really need to be sustained for generations to come. Just imagine if a charismatic priest at an American parish were able to adopt several overseas sister parishes, with all cooperating with one another to organize outreaches, catechism, mission trips, produce web sites and other multimedia evangelism tools. But at the core of it all would be the Eucharist and fidelity to the Magesterium.

I think that's a pretty cool idea... anyone else got thoughts?[/quote]

If that is following God's will, then yes, i think it would be a cool idea.


[quote]Anibal Pinedo, 25, a translator, says he's still not accustomed to watching prerecorded sermons. "I don't like that he's not here," he says. But Mr. Pinedo, who was raised Catholic, says he likes the services, upbeat music and Mr. Gramling's skill at applying biblical teachings to everyday life. "I feel like he's my pastor because of his message," he says. Max Vergara Fowler, 45, another former Catholic, says he started attending a year ago after he heard an ad on the radio. "The Catholic Church is too rigid," he says. "I feel more comfortable here."[/quote]

See, it sounds to me like these two men were not properly evangelized and formed in the Catholic Church before they left it. Flamingo Road would not have been appealing had they really understood what they were turning their backs on. That's just my opinion.

Posted

Great topic and posts...I'll get pack this when I have more time to think about it...going to eat Mexican with my family. Well we aren't eating actual Mexicans...but yeah.

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='fides quarens intellectum' post='1587141' date='Jun 30 2008, 05:57 PM']i was thinking something similar. :)
i think they draw so many Catholics because Catholics have dropped the ball in evangelization and catechesis over the past few decades. i personally don't think popcorn sermons are the answer, though - yes, it's great when a homily stirs the heart, but it's asking a bit much from our priests when they often have only 10-15 minutes a week to try to reach everyone in their congregation (i know, some priests go much longer). i think part of the problem in losing Catholics to these faith communities is that we, as a Church, have tended to erroneously assume prior evangelization for most of the people in the pews.
Very good questions that i don't have answers to, as i am not a theologian on the New Evangelization. :) Personally, though, i think we can each do our part on a smaller level by individually striving to lead a life of holiness, and trusting the Holy Spirit to tell us what needs to be done.
If that is following God's will, then yes, i think it would be a cool idea.
See, it sounds to me like these two men were not properly evangelized and formed in the Catholic Church before they left it. Flamingo Road would not have been appealing had they really understood what they were turning their backs on. That's just my opinion.[/quote]
I'm sure you're right in regards to catechesis when it comes to keeping Catholics in the Church. I guess the question becomes how to attract others into the Church. My answer is perpetual Adoration. ;)

[quote name='Veridicus' post='1587145' date='Jun 30 2008, 06:07 PM']Great topic and posts...I'll get pack this when I have more time to think about it...going to eat Mexican with my family. Well we aren't eating actual Mexicans...but yeah.[/quote]
Los Bravos? That where my roommates & I went a lot. Or sometimes to Don Pablos.

Gal. 5:22,23
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1587085' date='Jun 30 2008, 11:05 AM']Guess nobody else found this interesting or concerning...

Television is an ironic example... it wasn't that long ago that television didn't exist at all, but the days of two or three channels and no remote control are looked back on as the "good ol' days" :)

Yesterday I attended the Archdiocese of Louisville's 200th Anniversary Mass held at a local ballpark. I wasn't at Yankee Stadium, and in fact this was probably the only "big event" outdoor Mass I've attended, so I don't have much basis for comparison. But today, thinking about yesterday and viewing the pictures on our newspaper's web site leaves me with one definite thought: events like this reflect the state of the Church and we seriously need an injection of youthful energy and ethusiasm. I mean, you wouldn't think the Catholic Church and the Rolling Stones have much in common, but both sure scream "middle-aged."

Of course, I mean that more in spirit than in truth, to borrow Jesus' words. :)[/quote]

I'm from Louisville, lived there 30+ years. While living there, I belonged to the mega church . My brother and two sisters attended Catholic high schools. What I observed in Louisville was a whole lot of lukewarmness among Catholics. Hundreds of them left the Catholic Church for our mega church. I believe a lot of this boils down to Catholics not living out their faith and not training up their children in the faith. People in the mega church (and others) were on fire for Christ. I never witnessed this among the Catholics I knew. My neighborhood was almost entirely Catholic, yet not once did anyone try to share their faith with us.

I don't believe the answer lies in making our churches more consumer focused (ie Starbucks, etc.). I believe the solution begins in the home. Our children are watching. Are we walking the walk or just talking the talk? I also have found that in parishes where there is a strong devotion to Our Lord in the Eucharist (perpetual Adoration in our parish) there is a level of reverence and devotion to the Catholic faith not found in some other parishes.

Just my opinion as a new convert :)

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1587115' date='Jun 30 2008, 01:33 PM']Hmm, that is really interesting. I'll have to give it some thought, but my initial comment is that I think this type of set-up could potentially attract more people. On the other hand, I noticed a lot of PoMo people in my area basically wanting what is in a High Mass, and modeling services to include some of those things, but so many of them had so many misconceptions of the Church that they didn't look into it more.[/quote]

Hmm... what are PoMo people?

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1587227' date='Jun 30 2008, 07:20 PM']Hmm... what are PoMo people?[/quote]
The Post Modern people that went to my old church in FL. One of the leaders described them as PoMo. :lol: But they wanted to have incense, candles, religious art (the church didn't have a cross because they went over budget on construction), etc. I think many of them would love Adoration, and at least one of them goes to my old parish on some Holy Days because he says he can feel God's Presence there. Maybe someday he'll stay there. ;)

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='fides quarens intellectum' post='1587141' date='Jun 30 2008, 01:57 PM']i think they draw so many Catholics because Catholics have dropped the ball in evangelization and catechesis over the past few decades. i personally don't think popcorn sermons are the answer, though - yes, it's great when a homily stirs the heart, but it's asking a bit much from our priests when they often have only 10-15 minutes a week to try to reach everyone in their congregation (i know, some priests go much longer). i think part of the problem in losing Catholics to these faith communities is that we, as a Church, have tended to erroneously assume prior evangelization for most of the people in the pews.[/quote]

I doubt they are preaching popcorn sermons. The article mentioned some people who appreciated topics like sex and lust being confronted from the pulpit. I don't know how many priests in Peru are doing likewise, but these churches aren't growing there for no reason.

Is it asking too much for a priest to taking preaching seriously?

[quote name='fides quarens intellectum' post='1587141' date='Jun 30 2008, 01:57 PM']Personally, though, i think we can each do our part on a smaller level by individually striving to lead a
life of holiness, and trusting the Holy Spirit to tell us what needs to be done.[/quote]

That is the hard part, I've found. :) Talking about problems is cheap.

[quote name='fides quarens intellectum' post='1587141' date='Jun 30 2008, 01:57 PM']See, it sounds to me like these two men were not properly evangelized and formed in the Catholic Church before they left it. Flamingo Road would not have been appealing had they really understood what they were turning their backs on. That's just my opinion.[/quote]

I'm sure they weren't catechized very well. That's basically the problem... the Catholic Church in Peru apparently isn't doing their job because that article alone mentioned three or four American churches with branches in that country.

Anecdotal evidence like this gives me good reason to expect Catholicism will not be the faith of most Hispanics in two generations. Unless, of course, something changes... and there can always be a miracle. :)

fides quarens intellectum
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1587244' date='Jun 30 2008, 01:39 PM']I doubt they are preaching popcorn sermons. The article mentioned some people who appreciated topics like sex and lust being confronted from the pulpit. I don't know how many priests in Peru are doing likewise, but these churches aren't growing there for no reason.

Is it asking too much for a priest to taking preaching seriously?[/quote]

i am so sorry - i re-read my post, and i didn't mean to imply preaching doesn't matter. :) Absolutely, priests should take preaching very seriously! It's just that, you'd pointed to preaching as the weakest part of many Masses and the strongest part of many megachurch services, and i was trying (perhaps unsuccessfully) to suggest we should avoid placing the burden for personal faith contentment, for lack of a better word right now, on the short time priests have each week for homilies.

Yes - the kerygma is vital! It does not end there, though - in the long run, to keep Catholics from leaving, so to say, requires strong catechesis and a lived faith (grounded in frequent reception of the Sacraments). With these, it matters less to the practicing Catholic if a priest's homilies are strong or lackluster. Hope this helps clarify my opinion. :)


[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1587244' date='Jun 30 2008, 01:39 PM']That is the hard part, I've found[/quote]

same here. :)

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1587244' date='Jun 30 2008, 01:39 PM']Anecdotal evidence like this gives me good reason to expect Catholicism will not be the faith of most Hispanics in two generations. Unless, of course, something changes... and there can always be a miracle. :)[/quote]

Indeed - Our Lady of Guadalupe, pray for us!

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Gal. 5:22,23' post='1587206' date='Jun 30 2008, 03:00 PM']I'm from Louisville, lived there 30+ years. While living there, I belonged to the mega church . My brother and two sisters attended Catholic high schools. What I observed in Louisville was a whole lot of lukewarmness among Catholics. Hundreds of them left the Catholic Church for our mega church. I believe a lot of this boils down to Catholics not living out their faith and not training up their children in the faith. People in the mega church (and others) were on fire for Christ. I never witnessed this among the Catholics I knew. My neighborhood was almost entirely Catholic, yet not once did anyone try to share their faith with us.[/quote]

Catholics in our country have never been known for evangelizing. A lot of it apparently goes back to the immigrant roots of Catholic families living here with a lot of anti-Catholic sentiment. But our future can be different by emphasizing strong preaching and exercising some creative muscle to engage youth and keep them involved through college and into adulthood. These Protestant churches are growing because they operate with an entepreneurial zeal for spreading the Gospel. They aren't always successful, but they aren't afraid to take risks either. I feel like the Catholic Church is more like a big corporation that inadvertedly stifles creativity and discourages risks, prefering to do things the same every year like we did last year. We still complain about hippies running the show... nobody's stepped up to take their place!

[quote name='Gal. 5:22,23' post='1587206' date='Jun 30 2008, 03:00 PM']I don't believe the answer lies in making our churches more consumer focused (ie Starbucks, etc.). I believe the solution begins in the home. Our children are watching. Are we walking the walk or just talking the talk? I also have found that in parishes where there is a strong devotion to Our Lord in the Eucharist (perpetual Adoration in our parish) there is a level of reverence and devotion to the Catholic faith not found in some other parishes.[/quote]

That's works when the parents are faithful. Often times, I think parents just grow lukewarm or discouraged in the stuggles that come with raising children. Faithful couples who used to spend extra time praying after Mass find that's not an option. They're lucky if they can even sit through Mass and pay attention to the homily. It takes an especially commited couple to not allow years of child-rearing to wear down their devotion.

The consumer-focused approach is definitely not Christian. True Christianity is Christ-focused, and the truest Christianity is Catholicism. Still, people have needs and seek a community to fill them. These mega-churches are providing that community for at least some people. It doesn't work for everyone, but neither does the Tridentine Rite, Charismatic Renewal, or LifeTeen. Each of these has a particular mission or purpose that helps evangelize different types of people.

As for Perpetual Adoration, that's wonderful, but the parishes that decide to have it are orthodox and faithful to begin with. Although, I've heard one local priest testify about how Adoration (not perpetual) at one of his parishes (and telling the people that if they cared about their parish staying open, they would show up) put an end to bickering among parishioners and brought a renewed enthusiasm. It also helped that the kids loved Adoration, so sometimes it's the kids who evangelize the parents. :)

[quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1587233' date='Jun 30 2008, 03:29 PM']The Post Modern people that went to my old church in FL. One of the leaders described them as PoMo. :lol: But they wanted to have incense, candles, religious art (the church didn't have a cross because they went over budget on construction), etc. I think many of them would love Adoration, and at least one of them goes to my old parish on some Holy Days because he says he can feel God's Presence there. Maybe someday he'll stay there. ;)[/quote]

I see... actually, traditionalism is seeing a resurgance among non-Catholics too. My old Baptist church has weekly Communion, does responsory prayer and psalms, and sometimes even recites the Apostle's Creed. Art and music are also very important to them. People are drawn in through the experience and the senses.

Now, I'm reading an article "Is Google Making Us Stupid?" from The Atlantic about how advancing technology is shortening our attention spans to the point that many people struggle to read literature that requires heavy concentration. Towards the end of [url="http://www.theatlantic.com/doc/200807/google"]this page[/url], it says in the 15th century some people argued against the printing press saying "that cheaply printed books and broadsheets would undermine religious authority, demean the work of scholars and scribes, and spread sedition and debauchery."

Isn't that something? Somebody (no specific reference given) essentially predicted the undermining of the Catholic Church's authority due to the printing press. Of course, around that time St. Francis de Sales brought 70,000 Calvinists back to the Church by printing religious tracts, so the Church was able to use the technology it her favor too.

Edited by LouisvilleFan
Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1587315' date='Jun 30 2008, 09:38 PM']I see... actually, traditionalism is seeing a resurgance among non-Catholics too. My old Baptist church has weekly Communion, does responsory prayer and psalms, and sometimes even recites the Apostle's Creed. Art and music are also very important to them. People are drawn in through the experience and the senses.[/quote]
My Baptist church did the occasional responsorial Psalm, now that you mention it. But not the other things. Though I will say that, shortly before I left there, the music director (who was not raised as a Baptist) brought in an Advent wreath. Not sure if they still do that or not.

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1587315' date='Jun 30 2008, 09:38 PM']Now, I'm reading an article "Is Google Making Us Stupid?" from The Atlantic about how advancing technology is shortening our attention spans to the point that many people struggle to read literature that requires heavy concentration. Towards the end of [url="http://www.theatlantic.com/doc/200807/google"]this page[/url], it says in the 15th century some people argued against the printing press saying "that cheaply printed books and broadsheets would undermine religious authority, demean the work of scholars and scribes, and spread sedition and debauchery."

Isn't that something? Somebody (no specific reference given) essentially predicted the undermining of the Catholic Church's authority due to the printing press. Of course, around that time St. Francis de Sales brought 70,000 Calvinists back to the Church by printing religious tracts, so the Church was able to use the technology it her favor too.[/quote]
Hmm, quite interesting. I agree about the attention span - it's horrible! I mean, I'm just as guilty as anyone else. But when I was teaching, we were told to give 10 minute max mini-lessons, and then have the kids rotate to stations for 10 minutes each in order to keep their attention.

Posted

Personally, I tend to be skeptical of any church community that has ", Inc." in its name, but moving on to the question at hand:

[quote]So, the question is, how can Catholic parishes and dioceses respond? How can orthodox Catholicism be presented to this generation?[/quote]

I think we need to take a more media-centric approach to the way we teach our faith. I would say that media should also have a place in the Mass, but I know the Church's stance on that and while I disagree, I submit out of obedience.

People get bored so easily anymore--it's our culture. They want lights and sounds and smells and pretty colors, more than just words and monotone preaching, no matter how true it is. They want to express awe to God in whatever ways they can--and for many people that is a "big" thing. Dance, song, etc. (Note: I'm not saying prancing around the tabernacle is what should happen. God forbid. *shudder*) Again, this isn't what proper worship requires in the Church. People find what the Church says to be proper boring, and its movements and gestures mere calisthenics.

So...(and I know a lot of people are going to disagree with me over this. I love you. Please don't eat me!)

We might want to consider our music. There are ways of presenting Truth in a way conductive to the right worship of God, while still appealing to what people are seeking aesthetically. (Mind you, I think polyphony is pretty awesome. But I'm a choir geek. Many people just can't handle that kind of music, just like many people hate rap.)

We might want to reconsider our media, too. How we as a Church reach out to the world...in more than just picking up a Bible or a Catechism and trying to pick it apart. We need to inject life into things that can frankly be intellectually difficult to wrap our heads around. The video podcast [url="http://thatcatholicshow.sqpn.com/"]That Catholic Show[/url] has done a wonderful job of this.

Overall, this leads me to my main point: catechesis. We need people to know the faith, to live it, and most importantly, be able to [i]teach it[/i]. I was raised Catholic, and you know what I learned in CCD? Jesus loves me. Mary was conceived without sin. Pre-marital sex, and sex acts, are wrong. That was the gist of it...and people wonder why every last one of the 25 of us have fallen away? Very few have come back. I had to become a Protestant to come back.

We want to understand, and be understood. That should be the Church's priority.

/end rant

fides quarens intellectum
Posted

[quote name='MissyP89' post='1587333' date='Jun 30 2008, 04:22 PM']Personally, I tend to be skeptical of any church community that has ", Inc." in its name, but moving on to the question at hand:
I think we need to take a more media-centric approach to the way we teach our faith. I would say that media should also have a place in the Mass, but I know the Church's stance on that and while I disagree, I submit out of obedience.

People get bored so easily anymore--it's our culture. They want lights and sounds and smells and pretty colors, more than just words and monotone preaching, no matter how true it is. They want to express awe to God in whatever ways they can--and for many people that is a "big" thing. Dance, song, etc. (Note: I'm not saying prancing around the tabernacle is what should happen. God forbid. *shudder*) Again, this isn't what proper worship requires in the Church. People find what the Church says to be proper boring, and its movements and gestures mere calisthenics.

So...(and I know a lot of people are going to disagree with me over this. I love you. Please don't eat me!)

We might want to consider our music. There are ways of presenting Truth in a way conductive to the right worship of God, while still appealing to what people are seeking aesthetically. (Mind you, I think polyphony is pretty awesome. But I'm a choir geek. Many people just can't handle that kind of music, just like many people hate rap.)

We might want to reconsider our media, too. How we as a Church reach out to the world...in more than just picking up a Bible or a Catechism and trying to pick it apart. We need to inject life into things that can frankly be intellectually difficult to wrap our heads around. The video podcast [url="http://thatcatholicshow.sqpn.com/"]That Catholic Show[/url] has done a wonderful job of this.

Overall, this leads me to my main point: catechesis. We need people to know the faith, to live it, and most importantly, be able to [i]teach it[/i]. I was raised Catholic, and you know what I learned in CCD? Jesus loves me. Mary was conceived without sin. Pre-marital sex, and sex acts, are wrong. That was the gist of it...and people wonder why every last one of the 25 of us have fallen away? Very few have come back. I had to become a Protestant to come back.

We want to understand, and be understood. That should be the Church's priority.

/end rant[/quote]


Yes, i disagree with what you were saying about the Mass, but i have no intent to "eat you." :) Yes, our culture is consumeristic and ADD. Yet, rather than bringing the media they are used to into the Mass, personally, i think we should be trying to get people to turn off their TVs for a change, and i don't know - go for a walk outside, read a book, play a board game as a family... i don't think we need to make the Mass more media-centric - i think we need to loosen the grip mass media has on the majority of Americans. The Mass is everything it needs to be - if we find it boring, it's not the Mass - it is us. We don't need fancy lights and music to move the ambiance of Mass - Jesus the King is present in what appears as mere bread - talk about being low-key!

I totally agree with you on the catechesis part, though! Yes! Use podcasts, radio, EWTN, Catholic movies, etc to preach and teach the Good News! Infiltrate the culture! Absolutely! But see, that's because i think our faith is more than just Sunday Mass...

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

[quote name='MissyP89' post='1587333' date='Jun 30 2008, 06:22 PM']I think we need to take a more media-centric approach to the way we teach our faith. I would say that media should also have a place in the Mass, but I know the Church's stance on that and while I disagree, I submit out of obedience.[/quote]

Seems like this was discussed in one of the several hundred praise-and-worship-in-the-mass threads that have been rehashed around here since time eternal, but been too long for me to remember. What exactly is the Church's teaching on using media in the Mass?

For example, one thing that helps worshipers at most Protestant services to participate is projecting lyrics on a screen so people can look up instead of looking down, and focus on worship instead of thumbing through pages (assuming the person flippin' the slides is paying attention... sometimes that's a problem). It also gives the church a lot more flexibility in song selection and saves a lot of money on books. Sermon notes can be posted and often they show artwork and icons in between all the practical things.

However, my guess is this isn't allowed in the Mass according to the GIRM. My question would be, though, what difference there is between using an electronic projector versus books, microphones, and any other technology to assist the faithful in participating? (Or maybe my assumption is wrong :) ) Technology must always be incorporated tastefully and in a manner that promotes Eucharistic worship, which would be especially difficult when it comes to putting up a screen in most Catholic churches.

Stage lights and any kind of theatrical effects are obviously out of the question... can't argue with that. :)

[quote name='MissyP89' post='1587333' date='Jun 30 2008, 06:22 PM']People get bored so easily anymore--it's our culture. They want lights and sounds and smells and pretty colors, more than just words and monotone preaching, no matter how true it is. They want to express awe to God in whatever ways they can--and for many people that is a "big" thing. Dance, song, etc. (Note: I'm not saying prancing around the tabernacle is what should happen. God forbid. *shudder*) Again, this isn't what proper worship requires in the Church. People find what the Church says to be proper boring, and its movements and gestures mere calisthenics.[/quote]

The cool thing is that a proper liturgy, especially a high Mass, does appeal to all the senses. However, the faithful need to be taught what's happening for these elements to become meaningful. Otherwise it's easy to think it's all a big religious show (which is the impression some Protestants got from the papal Masses in DC and NYC). If technology is used in the Mass, it needs to be done in a way that people aren't consciously thinking about the technology. This is basically the premise behind Apple's approach to innovation.

[quote name='MissyP89' post='1587333' date='Jun 30 2008, 06:22 PM']We might want to reconsider our media, too. How we as a Church reach out to the world...in more than just picking up a Bible or a Catechism and trying to pick it apart. We need to inject life into things that can frankly be intellectually difficult to wrap our heads around. The video podcast [url="http://thatcatholicshow.sqpn.com/"]That Catholic Show[/url] has done a wonderful job of this.[/quote]

I've never watched That Catholic Show, but SQPN is pretty sweet. Definitely doing a lot of good things that go in the right direction there.

A lot of ideas pop into my head and I have trouble knowing what's worth persuing and what isn't, much more so because I'm hardly in any position to put them to work. Maybe none of my ideas would work, but we can't be afraid to try new things (that are orthodox, of course). More than anything, I think the Church needs to foster a stronger sense of innovation and entrepreneurship. Laypeople need to feel empowered to take an idea and run with it. They won't all be good ideas, and some may be totally wrong, but having the Church with our priests and bishops to hold us steady frees us to at least do something different, for a change!

Edited by LouisvilleFan
Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='fides quarens intellectum' post='1588220' date='Jul 1 2008, 04:38 PM']Yes, i disagree with what you were saying about the Mass, but i have no intent to "eat you." :) Yes, our culture is consumeristic and ADD. Yet, rather than bringing the media they are used to into the Mass, personally, i think we should be trying to get people to turn off their TVs for a change, and i don't know - go for a walk outside, read a book, play a board game as a family... i don't think we need to make the Mass more media-centric - i think we need to loosen the grip mass media has on the majority of Americans. The Mass is everything it needs to be - if we find it boring, it's not the Mass - it is us. We don't need fancy lights and music to move the ambiance of Mass - Jesus the King is present in what appears as mere bread - talk about being low-key!

I totally agree with you on the catechesis part, though! Yes! Use podcasts, radio, EWTN, Catholic movies, etc to preach and teach the Good News! Infiltrate the culture! Absolutely! But see, that's because i think our faith is more than just Sunday Mass...[/quote]
I agree with you. And I'm just as bad as others about the attention span sometimes (depends on whether I have a book or not).

Posted

You know, just an outsider's observation or two:

1) Jesus. Mention Jesus more darnit. All I ever hear was "I grew up Catholic, but then I heard about Jesus". The President of the Chi Alpha I attended grew up in Baltimore a Roman Catholic, and he never once was told to have any sort of personal relationship with Christ. His CCD was pretty much as described here, which brings me to point number two.

2) CCD stinks in the USA, at least around here. I had to explain what the Apostle's Creed meant to a cradle Catholic once and got the reply, "Wow, our history goes back that far? What does Apostolic mean?"

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...