Archaeology cat Posted July 1, 2008 Posted July 1, 2008 [quote name='BG45' post='1588369' date='Jul 1 2008, 07:43 PM']You know, just an outsider's observation or two: 1) Jesus. Mention Jesus more darnit. All I ever hear was "I grew up Catholic, but then I heard about Jesus". The President of the Chi Alpha I attended grew up in Baltimore a Roman Catholic, and he never once was told to have any sort of personal relationship with Christ. His CCD was pretty much as described here, which brings me to point number two.[/quote] Agree. I have to give kudos to the priest that confirmed me, because he definitely did this. [quote name='BG45' post='1588369' date='Jul 1 2008, 07:43 PM']2) CCD stinks in the USA, at least around here. I had to explain what the Apostle's Creed meant to a cradle Catholic once and got the reply, "Wow, our history goes back that far? What does Apostolic mean?"[/quote] Wow. Yeah, I don't think it's that great in some places here, either, though (I'm sure it varies from parish to parish, anywhere you are). Though instead of complaining about it I guess I should offer to help.
BG45 Posted July 1, 2008 Posted July 1, 2008 (edited) Awesome for your priest to have done that AC! Though offer to help with the CCD? Sounds like a good idea...I keep having this fear if I go through RCIA I'll end up teaching at times. Some people on here have mentioned this happening to them, and that I won't seem to get anything out of it. Off to work Edited July 1, 2008 by BG45
LouisvilleFan Posted July 1, 2008 Author Posted July 1, 2008 [quote name='BG45' post='1588369' date='Jul 1 2008, 03:43 PM']You know, just an outsider's observation or two: 1) Jesus. Mention Jesus more darnit. All I ever hear was "I grew up Catholic, but then I heard about Jesus". The President of the Chi Alpha I attended grew up in Baltimore a Roman Catholic, and he never once was told to have any sort of personal relationship with Christ. His CCD was pretty much as described here, which brings me to point number two. 2) CCD stinks in the USA, at least around here. I had to explain what the Apostle's Creed meant to a cradle Catholic once and got the reply, "Wow, our history goes back that far? What does Apostolic mean?"[/quote] Amen, brother! Both of these come back to preaching. We have to get out of this thinking that preaching isn't important because we always have the Eucharist. Without quality preaching and catechesis, it doesn't matter if you have the Eucharist because the ignorant only see a wafer! We have to be able to [i]share[/i] our faith in what the Eucharist really is. You can't just raise it up in front of people and say, "See?! It's obviously Jesus!" No, it's not obvious, especially when parishes put more energy into carrying neighborhood drunken revelries than sharing the Gospel. Granted, much of this is rooted in America's spiritual apathy. I think we're lazy and don't care. Sometimes I wonder if I really care, or if I just enjoy ranting about it from time to time. I feel powerless to do much besides pray, and I guess I'm too impatient to be content with praying for the time being. So that's my little confession...
LouisvilleFan Posted July 1, 2008 Author Posted July 1, 2008 (edited) [quote name='BG45' post='1588378' date='Jul 1 2008, 03:50 PM']Awesome for your priest to have done that AC! Though offer to help with the CCD? Sounds like a good idea...I keep having this fear if I go through RCIA I'll end up teaching at times. Some people on here have mentioned this happening to them, and that I won't seem to get anything out of it. Off to work[/quote] I wasn't in the greatest RCIA class. The instructor was no champion of orthodoxy, but she didn't teach anything heretical, so it wasn't necessary for me to correct anything. We all shared at times and others in the class attested to Catholic beliefs and morals as much as I did, and maybe our instructor knew better than to try teaching anything in opposition. Even though I didn't gain a lot of knowledge, objectively speaking, from RCIA, the experience was well worthwhile because I got to know people whose lives are very different from mine, who journeyed to Catholicism from many different places (one lady had wanted to be Catholic for 50 years!), and none of them were philosphically minded or real interested in theology. I think it was helpful to be around them and see that Catholicism isn't just for us who geek out on Church history, dogmas, and creeds. Plus, it is pretty cool to walk that journey towards Easter Vigil as a community. It wouldn't have been the same entering the Church by myself. And, of course, joining an RCIA class places no obligation upon you to become Catholic. Edited July 1, 2008 by LouisvilleFan
Archaeology cat Posted July 1, 2008 Posted July 1, 2008 (edited) [quote name='BG45' post='1588378' date='Jul 1 2008, 07:50 PM']Awesome for your priest to have done that AC! Though offer to help with the CCD? Sounds like a good idea...I keep having this fear if I go through RCIA I'll end up teaching at times. Some people on here have mentioned this happening to them, and that I won't seem to get anything out of it. Off to work[/quote] Fr. Tom is awesome. He and his brother actually tag-teamed my confirmation; they're Irish, too. But Fr. Tom had changed the time at the last minute to half an hour earlier, and then he ended up showing up at the original time. Not all RCIA classes are bad. From what I can tell, the RCIA classes at my parish in FL were pretty good, and the ones at the Cathedral here aren't bad (I sat in on that one to help a little, because they had quite a few university students converting and Fr. Michael figured they could relate to me. ) Edited July 1, 2008 by Archaeology cat
MissyP89 Posted July 1, 2008 Posted July 1, 2008 To LouisvilleFan, a confession of my own: though I said I think we need to reconsider our music, etc., after some thought I realized I had no idea what that meant. So...my argument was baseless! What I've seen is adults and youth alike that can barely stand to sit and listen to a hymn. It doesn't help that at many parishes, if you listen to the lyrics to the hymns they don't exactly teach Catholic doctrine. Of course, as you said, there are a ton of threads like this and I'm sure you know what I mean. No, I am not the Bread of Life. I don't know, really. I've watched my entire family and most of my friends either leave for a Protestant community or give up faith altogether. Most of them found Mass "stupid" and "boring". To connect to BG's posts and what I said in my original argument--we need to step up the way we teach. He hits the nail on the head when he describes CCD, and the people he mentions are pretty close to identical to my friends. If people knew [i]why[/i] they were there at Mass, and what they were doing, maybe things wouldn't be so "boring".
BG45 Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 LouisvilleFan, amen back at ya. I know that prior to reading Scripture about it, Apologetic works on it, etc. I would have looked at the Eucharist and gone "oh wafer". If that. It's hardly obvious, nor is a lot of what's in a Mass. The first time I went to Mass, I was confused as heck, and I took a friend with me whose mom's family was Catholic (but he was raised Presbyterian) and he could barely follow it either, and couldn't explain a lot of stuff! (Granted this was better than my second Mass in which I nearly contacted the Bishop for the liturgical abuse...seriously even I knew women + Words of Consecration = bad.) That bit on apathy and not knowing, I tend to go through that too. I'll spend more than a month wondering if I care, and then sadly, it's usually anger that brings me into realizing I do. Case in point: I'm currently awaiting an (I'm assured) imminent excommunication from my old Baptist church whom I didn't know even excommunicated people. I would have said I'm apathetic to them...until the news I was one of the people probably next on the list for not tithing to them in over a year. As for RCIA, I'm definitely aware their's no pressure really to join...well there is, but isn't. A mutual friend of Missy and mine's went through 3 times before joining the Church. And yours sounds cool; from what I hear from "Catholic" friends, almost no one goes through it here. I understand at one parish if I did go, I'd be the first in almost a decade. AC, Irish priests rock! Stereotypes FTW, but still awesome! Glad your RCIA classes are nice, and [b]lots of people[/b] sounds so weird to me for some reason. Maybe because of where I am.
LouisvilleFan Posted July 2, 2008 Author Posted July 2, 2008 [quote name='MissyP89' post='1588553' date='Jul 1 2008, 08:35 PM']To LouisvilleFan, a confession of my own: though I said I think we need to reconsider our music, etc., after some thought I realized I had no idea what that meant. So...my argument was baseless! What I've seen is adults and youth alike that can barely stand to sit and listen to a hymn. It doesn't help that at many parishes, if you listen to the lyrics to the hymns they don't exactly teach Catholic doctrine. Of course, as you said, there are a ton of threads like this and I'm sure you know what I mean. No, I am not the Bread of Life. [/quote] Nor are we building the City of God. However, I can see how that one serves a good purpose: if I'm ever persecuted, I'll sing that song in my head and then tell myself, "If you remain faithful, you'll never have to hear this song again." Of course, I'll get to Heaven and Jesus will be singing, "Let me buu-iild the ci-ty of Go-d..." Hmm... that's a weird tangent... I've been drinking Starbucks. Go figure. Back to earthy... music usually is a problem. An older Catholic guy I talk to on another forum has explained to me how music is a relatively new experience for American Catholics because it was rarely incorporated into Mass before Vatican II. Usually there was an opening hymn and closing hymn, both sung with the enthusiasm of Stephen Hawking on an anesthetic, and not much of anything in between. Following Vatican II, there was a lot of new music that came out, but obviously it was influenced too much by the popular culture of that time and the ignorance of Church teaching manifests itself in many lyrics. I wish I had the talent for writing music. When was the last time a new hymnal was published? Is there even a source for parishes to get new Catholic music? I don't even know if any Catholics are writing liturgical music. My old Baptist church does a great job with hymns. They're usually played to electric guitar, drums, and keyboard, but it's no less reverent. Of course, they turn the volume up, and the quality is excellent, so you really can immerse yourself into the song and pray the lyrics in worship to God. In contrast to the experience of singing the same hymn at a Catholic church, the arguments against modern instrumentation just aren't making sense. The Baptist church produces a more heavenly sound than the lazy effort at most Catholic parishes. [quote name='BG45' post='1588814' date='Jul 2 2008, 12:55 AM']The first time I went to Mass, I was confused as heck, and I took a friend with me whose mom's family was Catholic (but he was raised Presbyterian) and he could barely follow it either, and couldn't explain a lot of stuff! (Granted this was better than my second Mass in which I nearly contacted the Bishop for the liturgical abuse...seriously even I knew women + Words of Consecration = bad.)[/quote] An idea I've tossed around in my head is hosting a Mass specifically for teaching people about it, promoting it in the community like a Protestant church would promote one of their evangelistic events. Maybe even incorporate it into the parish picnic, since you've got hundreds of people there anyway, many of whom probably have a passing interest in learning about Catholicism. As much of an abomination as parish picnics are (well, maybe they aren't that bad... hard to forget seeing an old lady stumble across railroad tracks while on the way to Louisville's biggest Catholic picnic), they also have a lot of potential. A local Orthodox church uses their ethnic festival to introduce people to their faith (25% of their members are converts). Catholic parishes should be doing the same thing... would it hurt to have a booth devoted to prayer? Maybe even a confessional right there at the picnic Or host short 15-minute teachings in the church about a few parts of the Mass, their Scriptural basis, and what they mean for us on a practical level. And, of course, give people something to take home so they'll actually remember it (the same should be done for homilies... maybe that would get priests to preach about something worth taking home). Heck, use those picnics to get the word out about other things too, like authentic Church teaching on Theology of the Body and NFP. Being too forward might start to scare people away from Catholic picnics, which would defeat the purpose of evangelizing, but even small measures would be a good step forward and at least start eliminating mass ignorance on those topics. [quote name='BG45' post='1588814' date='Jul 2 2008, 12:55 AM']As for RCIA, I'm definitely aware their's no pressure really to join...well there is, but isn't. A mutual friend of Missy and mine's went through 3 times before joining the Church. And yours sounds cool; from what I hear from "Catholic" friends, almost no one goes through it here. I understand at one parish if I did go, I'd be the first in almost a decade.[/quote] Yeah, there may be some people who will pressure you a bit, but the instructors of RCIA shouldn't. They know that the sacrament of Confirmation includes your oath that you are entering the Church of your own free will. But, you know, it's only six or seven months... even a bad class is well worth the reward. I'm surprised the parishes in your area see so few RCIA participants. Usually they'll at least get some folks who are marrying a Catholic. Where do you live?
Lil Red Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 +J.M.J.+ one thing you've brought up, is parish picnics. i don't know why we (here, i mean) don't use it as an evangelization tool. that would be amazing! or why my city doesn't do a city-wide parish picnic, with a big Mass.
jeffpugh Posted July 4, 2008 Posted July 4, 2008 [quote name='MissyP89' post='1588553' date='Jul 1 2008, 07:35 PM']To LouisvilleFan, a confession of my own: though I said I think we need to reconsider our music, etc., after some thought I realized I had no idea what that meant. So...my argument was baseless! What I've seen is adults and youth alike that can barely stand to sit and listen to a hymn. It doesn't help that at many parishes, if you listen to the lyrics to the hymns they don't exactly teach Catholic doctrine. Of course, as you said, there are a ton of threads like this and I'm sure you know what I mean. No, I am not the Bread of Life. I don't know, really. I've watched my entire family and most of my friends either leave for a Protestant community or give up faith altogether. Most of them found Mass "stupid" and "boring". To connect to BG's posts and what I said in my original argument--we need to step up the way we teach. He hits the nail on the head when he describes CCD, and the people he mentions are pretty close to identical to my friends. If people knew [i]why[/i] they were there at Mass, and what they were doing, maybe things wouldn't be so "boring".[/quote] A saint once said that if you really really understood/knew what was happening at mass, you'd die from happiness. It's that profound of a happening!
BG45 Posted July 4, 2008 Posted July 4, 2008 I was about to say that our parishes don't do outdoor picnics as far as I know, but that would be wrong. The Italian Heritage Festival is one giant outdoor picnic of drunken revelry. It finishes with a giant outdoor Mass -sometimes with thousands of people- and then everyone there gets absolutely drunken and debacuherized with the exception of the priests. But yes, it would be nice to have some sort of "Mass for Dummies" to show everyone what everything is for. Scott Hahn's cleared it up some for me, but that's about all I've heard. I have a better working knowledge of the Mass than almost every Catholic I know in real life, if not all...that is not pride; that is unfortunate fact. As for the Orthodox festivals...baklava. I eat lots of baklava when Saint Spyridon (sp?) holds the Greek Heritage Festival. Yes, we do lots of heritage festivals here. <.< As to where I live, North Central WV. My aunt, for one, did marry a Catholic and had never gone to RCIA. She raised the kids Baptist. In fact she's probably the most frightened that "I'll turn papist" of the family.
MissyP89 Posted July 4, 2008 Posted July 4, 2008 [quote name='BG45']But yes, it would be nice to have some sort of "Mass for Dummies" to show everyone what everything is for.[/quote] A few of my Protestant friends said to me once, half joking but still trying to convey a point, that we need to put Post-It notes on things. Mary, the tabernacle, the altar, holy water, even the priest--with Scripture and Catechism quotes that explain the what and why of our liturgy. Hmmm...
BG45 Posted July 4, 2008 Posted July 4, 2008 [quote name='MissyP89' post='1590875' date='Jul 4 2008, 02:26 AM']A few of my Protestant friends said to me once, half joking but still trying to convey a point, that we need to put Post-It notes on things. Mary, the tabernacle, the altar, holy water, even the priest--with Scripture and Catechism quotes that explain the what and why of our liturgy. Hmmm...[/quote] It is true though...
MissyP89 Posted July 4, 2008 Posted July 4, 2008 (edited) A thought BG and I just had discussing this on the phone: What if we were to put these notes in the missal or missalettes? Not only what is said, but why. BG said that it would take away from the experience as people are reading, but to compare, you'll often find Catholics doing the same thing at their first few Traditional Latin Masses. Thoughts? Edited July 4, 2008 by MissyP89
Archaeology cat Posted July 4, 2008 Posted July 4, 2008 [quote name='BG45' post='1590831' date='Jul 4 2008, 06:01 AM']But yes, it would be nice to have some sort of "Mass for Dummies" to show everyone what everything is for. Scott Hahn's cleared it up some for me, but that's about all I've heard. I have a better working knowledge of the Mass than almost every Catholic I know in real life, if not all...that is not pride; that is unfortunate fact.[/quote] You should meet the priest who married my husband & me, Fr. Anand. He does an awesome teaching Mass, and did a teaching Adoration, too. He just explains what everything is while he's going, and why things are done when. He's awesome. So if you're ever in JAX, go to Holy Spirit parish in the Arlington area and you can meet him. [quote name='MissyP89' post='1590884' date='Jul 4 2008, 06:31 AM']A thought BG and I just had discussing this on the phone: What if we were to put these notes in the missal or missalettes? Not only what is said, but why. BG said that it would take away from the experience as people are reading, but to compare, you'll often find Catholics doing the same thing at their first few Traditional Latin Masses. Thoughts?[/quote] I think that sounds like a pretty good idea. I ended up doing that for my non-Catholic friends/family (the majority of them) who were coming to our wedding so they would know where everything came from, and what to do and when.
Norseman82 Posted July 4, 2008 Posted July 4, 2008 (edited) Someone who went to my grade school once told me about how he "never heard about Jesus" from the nuns there. My thought was that he must not have been paying attention, because I heard plenty of it. Anyway, I think at some point we need to confront Catholics who leave the church for the "evangelical variety show", as my friend refers to megachurches, by asking them "Is this worth leaving the truth for?" and start from there. I mean, how are they going to fulfill their Easter duty? Who do they go to for absolution when they commit a mortal sin by using artificial birth control? That's not something you can get at the food court at Willow Creek. Edited July 4, 2008 by Norseman82
LouisvilleFan Posted July 8, 2008 Author Posted July 8, 2008 (edited) [quote name='MissyP89' post='1590884' date='Jul 4 2008, 02:31 AM']A thought BG and I just had discussing this on the phone: What if we were to put these notes in the missal or missalettes? Not only what is said, but why. BG said that it would take away from the experience as people are reading, but to compare, you'll often find Catholics doing the same thing at their first few Traditional Latin Masses. Thoughts?[/quote] That sounds like a really cool web site! Imagine something like a virtual world (which I suppose could be programmed in Java, which I know nothing about) where you would go and experience a simulated Mass from beginning to end and be able to click on everything you commonly see in a Catholic church or Mass to find out what it means and some of the Scripture and Tradition behind it. In other words, it's like adding a GUI to the PhatMass Defense Directory! (that's totally a geek comment ) That's something any Catholic could visit to learn about the faith themselves and then direct people to when they ask questions. All it needs is a catchy, memorable URL and you could tell anyone, "Check out this web site..." and in ten minutes they could learn all the essentials about Catholicism and have a fun doing it! Best of all, it would be completely non-threatening and able to meet people who are curious right where they're at. Hmm... if only I knew how to do something like that. Edited July 8, 2008 by LouisvilleFan
Archaeology cat Posted July 8, 2008 Posted July 8, 2008 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1595243' date='Jul 8 2008, 07:49 PM']That sounds like a really cool web site! Imagine something like a virtual world (which I suppose could be programmed in Java, which I know nothing about) where you would go and experience a simulated Mass from beginning to end and be able to click on everything you commonly see in a Catholic church or Mass to find out what it means and some of the Scripture and Tradition behind it. In other words, it's like adding a GUI to the PhatMass Defense Directory! (that's totally a geek comment ) That's something any Catholic could visit to learn about the faith themselves and then direct people to when they ask questions. All it needs is a catchy, memorable URL and you could tell anyone, "Check out this web site..." and in ten minutes they could learn all the essentials about Catholicism and have a fun doing it! Best of all, it would be completely non-threatening and able to meet people who are curious right where they're at. Hmm... if only I knew how to do something like that.[/quote] That sounds pretty cool!
socalscout Posted July 8, 2008 Posted July 8, 2008 I apologize for nitpicking but Starbucks is not franchised unless it is a licensed store in Barnes&Nobles, Target or Von's/Randalls/Safeway. They are all corporate owned and managed from the headquarters in the Seattle. Now Subway's are franchised.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now