cappie Posted July 1, 2008 Posted July 1, 2008 A Minnesota judge has upheld the right of a local priest to exclude an autistic boy from a parish church for his "disruptive conduct." The Minnesota Star-Tribune reports Todd County District Judge Sally Ireland Robertson, upheld a restraining order, saying the parents of 13 year old Adam Race "have been unable to prevent their adult sized minor child from repeated incidents of unwanted and intrusive conduct" at St Joseph Catholic Church in Bertha. Adam's mother, Carol Race, of Eagle Bend, said today that she found Robertson's ruling "very shocking." "What does a judge have to say or not say about what is acceptable in a church service?" she added. "That comes down from the Vatican." She added that St Joseph's priest, Fr Dan Walz, also has no say in such matters. "The Catholic Church takes a strong stand on including people with disabilities," she said. "This isn't a Father Dan church; this is a Catholic church." Race said she is exploring whether to continue challenging the restraining order, either through the courts or within the church hierarchy. Speaking on behalf of the parish this afternoon, Jane Marrin, director of pastoral planning for the St Cloud Diocese, said that St Joseph "is involved in mediation with the family, and it's the parish's hope that we can come to a mutually acceptable solution. That has been the goal all along for the parish, and the judge's ruling doesn't rule out." Judge Robertson noted in her ruling that Adam, who is 188 cm and 102 kg, has "repeatedly, though unintentionally, disrupted church services and intruded on the solemnity, quietude, and privacy of the Mass in several ways." These include making nonverbal noises, flailing his arms, urinating on the floor, hitting a smaller child, bumping into elderly parishioners, running into the church parking lot and starting a vehicle, pulling a teenage girl onto his lap and holding her there for 15 minutes and resisting his parents' efforts to restrain him. [url="http://www.startribune.com/local/22764524.html?location_refer=Most%20Emailed:Homepage:highlightModules:8"]http://www.startribune.com/local/22764524....hlightModules:8[/url]
CatholicCid Posted July 1, 2008 Posted July 1, 2008 (edited) [quote]"What does a judge have to say or not say about what is acceptable in a church service?" she added. "That comes down from the Vatican."[/quote] Am I wrong to assume she was the one who took it to court in the first place? I admit, I had the same thought, but quite opposite her stance. It is the Church's decision, and it seems they made it already. Edited July 1, 2008 by CatholicCid
havok579257 Posted July 1, 2008 Posted July 1, 2008 [quote name='cappie' post='1588513' date='Jul 1 2008, 06:24 PM']A Minnesota judge has upheld the right of a local priest to exclude an autistic boy from a parish church for his "disruptive conduct." The Minnesota Star-Tribune reports Todd County District Judge Sally Ireland Robertson, upheld a restraining order, saying the parents of 13 year old Adam Race "have been unable to prevent their adult sized minor child from repeated incidents of unwanted and intrusive conduct" at St Joseph Catholic Church in Bertha. Adam's mother, Carol Race, of Eagle Bend, said today that she found Robertson's ruling "very shocking." "What does a judge have to say or not say about what is acceptable in a church service?" she added. "That comes down from the Vatican." She added that St Joseph's priest, Fr Dan Walz, also has no say in such matters. "The Catholic Church takes a strong stand on including people with disabilities," she said. "This isn't a Father Dan church; this is a Catholic church." Race said she is exploring whether to continue challenging the restraining order, either through the courts or within the church hierarchy. Speaking on behalf of the parish this afternoon, Jane Marrin, director of pastoral planning for the St Cloud Diocese, said that St Joseph "is involved in mediation with the family, and it's the parish's hope that we can come to a mutually acceptable solution. That has been the goal all along for the parish, and the judge's ruling doesn't rule out." Judge Robertson noted in her ruling that Adam, who is 188 cm and 102 kg, has "repeatedly, though unintentionally, disrupted church services and intruded on the solemnity, quietude, and privacy of the Mass in several ways." These include making nonverbal noises, flailing his arms, urinating on the floor, hitting a smaller child, bumping into elderly parishioners, running into the church parking lot and starting a vehicle, pulling a teenage girl onto his lap and holding her there for 15 minutes and resisting his parents' efforts to restrain him. [url="http://www.startribune.com/local/22764524.html?location_refer=Most%20Emailed:Homepage:highlightModules:8"]http://www.startribune.com/local/22764524....hlightModules:8[/url][/quote] This is a freaking joke. First they kick out the mentally handicapped, next they can kick out the poor. This is absolutly pathetic.
havok579257 Posted July 1, 2008 Posted July 1, 2008 [quote name='CatholicCid' post='1588524' date='Jul 1 2008, 06:42 PM']Am I wrong to assume she was the one who took it to court in the first place? I admit, I had the same thought, but quite opposite her stance. It is the Church's decision, and it seems they made it already.[/quote] Well the church is wrong in their stance.
homeschoolmom Posted July 1, 2008 Posted July 1, 2008 No, they're not. There was another thread on here that went into further detail on the situation. The mother is unwilling to compromise even a little smidge.
havok579257 Posted July 1, 2008 Posted July 1, 2008 [quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1588528' date='Jul 1 2008, 06:47 PM']No, they're not. There was another thread on here that went into further detail on the situation. The mother is unwilling to compromise even a little smidge.[/quote] Well then all the facts are not presented for us. According to you, this article is only a half truth so we should remove it or put up all the facts about the incident.
MissyP89 Posted July 1, 2008 Posted July 1, 2008 (edited) HSM is right. The mother here was given quite a few other options for having her family participate in Catholic life, and she has refused them. The Church isn't refusing the mentally handicapped. He [i]urinates on the floor[/i], and harasses people. How would you react if someone peed on the floor of your parish during Mass? Noise is excusable. But physically hurting people and doing things like that is unsafe. I'd like to think they would do the same for anyone who acted that way, disabled or not. As there's another thread on this, I'll end my thoughts here. Edited July 1, 2008 by MissyP89
CatholicCid Posted July 1, 2008 Posted July 1, 2008 (edited) [quote name='havok579257' post='1588530' date='Jul 1 2008, 05:52 PM']Well then all the facts are not presented for us. According to you, this article is only a half truth so we should remove it or put up all the facts about the incident.[/quote] Actually, I think this article has a nice, short sum up somewhat of a few incidents: [quote]Judge Robertson noted in her ruling that Adam, who is 188 cm and 102 kg, has "repeatedly, though unintentionally, disrupted church services and intruded on the solemnity, quietude, and privacy of the Mass in several ways." These include making nonverbal noises, flailing his arms, urinating on the floor, hitting a smaller child, bumping into elderly parishioners, running into the church parking lot and starting a vehicle, pulling a teenage girl onto his lap and holding her there for 15 minutes and resisting his parents' efforts to restrain him.[/quote] Edited July 1, 2008 by CatholicCid
havok579257 Posted July 1, 2008 Posted July 1, 2008 [quote name='MissyP89' post='1588531' date='Jul 1 2008, 06:52 PM']HSM is right. The mother here was given quite a few other options for having her family participate in Catholic life, and she has refused them. The Church isn't refusing the mentally handicapped. He [i]urinates on the floor[/i], and harasses people. How would you react if someone peed on the floor of your parish during Mass? Noise is excusable. But physically hurting people and doing things like that is unsafe. I'd like to think they would do the same for anyone who acted that way, disabled or not. As there's another thread on this, I'll end my thoughts here.[/quote] But you can't treat someone handicapped the same as everyone else. If I peed on the floor, then its intentional. If someone who can't control it does, then its not the same. Same with children. We should not treat a 3 y/o the same as a 45 y/o. Note: This does not directly reference the article.
mortify Posted July 1, 2008 Posted July 1, 2008 What were some of the options offered to help this family participate in parish life?
HisChildForever Posted July 1, 2008 Posted July 1, 2008 (edited) [quote]If I peed on the floor, then its intentional. If someone who can't control it does, then its not the same.[/quote] Well, it didn't say that he wet his pants, so I'm thinking that he actually....you know. Edited July 1, 2008 by HisChildForever
IrishSalesian Posted July 1, 2008 Posted July 1, 2008 (edited) [quote name='havok579257' post='1588534' date='Jul 1 2008, 07:55 PM']We should not treat a 3 y/o the same as a 45 y/o.[/quote] If they are mentally handicapped, then yes we should. I think we should have compassion. Edited July 1, 2008 by IrishSalesian
homeschoolmom Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 [quote name='mortify' post='1588541' date='Jul 1 2008, 07:07 PM']What were some of the options offered to help this family participate in parish life?[/quote] Masses in their home and/or a live video feed so that the mother and son could participate in the mass from the fellowship hall to name a couple.
havok579257 Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 [quote name='HisChildForever' post='1588545' date='Jul 1 2008, 07:17 PM']Well, it didn't say that he wet his pants, so I'm thinking that he actually....you know.[/quote] Yeah but he's autistic which if you read up on the condition, it means he exists in his own world. He can't comprehend the world around him. Even if he did pee on the floor, it was not intentional. An example of autism is people with autism can't put together that a smile means someone's happy. It just doesn't connect for them. So even if he dropped his pants and did pee, the likely hood he was doing it knowing not to do it is slim to none.
havok579257 Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 [quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1588575' date='Jul 1 2008, 08:04 PM']Masses in their home and/or a live video feed so that the mother and son could participate in the mass from the fellowship hall to name a couple.[/quote] Definatly against the home masses or live feeds as with live feeds there is no communion. Which our mass is basically built around. I'm not saying there are not other options, just saying I am not for either of those. Many churches have cry rooms that no matter what happens in them, you can not hear outside the rooms. They could easily go in there and come out for communion. Cause you can hear stuff inside the prayer room, just not outside of it. Also inside the cry rooms there are a limited number of mom's with their babies in it, so it would be much easier for the mom and say an usher to control the childs abusive actions to others. The flayling arms and scream is fine, but an usher could be there to make sure the child does not strike other people inside the cry rooms.
HisChildForever Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 [quote]So even if he dropped his pants and did pee, the likely hood he was doing it knowing not to do it is slim to none.[/quote] Even if he didn't know how inappropriate the gesture was, do you think it's appropriate to allow him to continually come into the Church and expose himself (possibly every week) like that? Do you think that's "fair" for the other parishoners? Whether he knows what he's doing or not, if there was someone at my parish like that, I would no longer attend. It is a very sad situation but it's just not acceptable. He grabbed a teenage girl and forced her on his lap? He should not be in the Church. I mean, are you saying that the entire parish should just deal with it?
Apotheoun Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 Here is the older thread on this topic: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=80376&hl"][u]Autistic Child Banned From Catholic Church[/u][/url]
Vincent Vega Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 [quote name='havok579257' post='1588598' date='Jul 1 2008, 07:26 PM']Yeah but he's autistic which if you read up on the condition, it means he exists in his own world. He can't comprehend the world around him. Even if he did pee on the floor, it was not intentional. An example of autism is people with autism can't put together that a smile means someone's happy. It just doesn't connect for them. So even if he dropped his pants and did pee, the likely hood he was doing it knowing not to do it is slim to none.[/quote] Yes; we all realize this. It's a tragedy that he has this condition - no one is arguing that it isn't. Alternatives were offered, the mother didn't like them. I'm sorry, but when I'm worshipping my Lord in the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass, I don't want that desecrated by someone urinating in the House of God, mentally retarded or not. I mean, that's not the same as, say, the tics exhibited by Tourette's sufferers. Not only is his behaviour distracting and (albeit it unintentionally) irreverent, at his size, he is dangerous to other parishioners (and has acted out and injured other church-goers in the past, if I recall correctly). It's not that the Lord doesn't love him as he loves all his flock, but I really don't think it's fair to him nor the other members of the church if his mother puts him in a setting where he's expected to be still, quiet, and orderly for an hour or more. If the alternatives didn't please her, well, that was her choice. Also, comparing autistic to the poor is fallacious and does not warrant a serious response. Dear Liberals-At-Large: You know that "separation of church and state" thing that you're always preaching to us about? Yeah, that goes both ways. Thanks.
Vincent Vega Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 [quote name='havok579257' post='1588602' date='Jul 1 2008, 07:30 PM']Definatly against the home masses or live feeds as with live feeds there is no communion. Which our mass is basically built around. I'm not saying there are not other options, just saying I am not for either of those. Many churches have cry rooms that no matter what happens in them, you can not hear outside the rooms. They could easily go in there and come out for communion. Cause you can hear stuff inside the prayer room, just not outside of it. Also inside the cry rooms there are a limited number of mom's with their babies in it, so it would be much easier for the mom and say an usher to control the childs abusive actions to others. The flayling arms and scream is fine, but an usher could be there to make sure the child does not strike other people inside the cry rooms.[/quote] Yeah, let's put the bull in a china shop. Great idea. Seriously? Put a 6 foot +, 225 lb guy in a room with a bunch of babies? Get real. Also, ever heard of extraordinary ministers? They could bring the host to the mother at home or in the fellow ship hall, etc. I'm sure all of these issues could be worked around, but they require something that the mother has implicitly stated she doesn't want: work.
havok579257 Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 [quote name='HisChildForever' post='1588607' date='Jul 1 2008, 08:33 PM']Even if he didn't know how inappropriate the gesture was, do you think it's appropriate to allow him to continually come into the Church and expose himself (possibly every week) like that? Do you think that's "fair" for the other parishoners? Whether he knows what he's doing or not, if there was someone at my parish like that, I would no longer attend. It is a very sad situation but it's just not acceptable. He grabbed a teenage girl and forced her on his lap? He should not be in the Church. I mean, are you saying that the entire parish should just deal with it?[/quote] So because he has a mental handicap we should just forfit his salvation. WHat's more important, someone accidently exposing himself and upsetting parishoners or the person's immortal soul?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now