Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Church Can Exclude Autistic Boy: Judge Decides


Recommended Posts

havok579257
Posted

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1588613' date='Jul 1 2008, 08:40 PM']Yes; we all realize this. It's a tragedy that he has this condition - no one is arguing that it isn't. Alternatives were offered, the mother didn't like them. I'm sorry, but when I'm worshipping my Lord in the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass, I don't want that desecrated by someone urinating in the House of God, mentally retarded or not. I mean, that's not the same as, say, the tics exhibited by Tourette's sufferers. Not only is his behaviour distracting and (albeit it unintentionally) irreverent, at his size, he is dangerous to other parishioners (and has acted out and injured other church-goers in the past, if I recall correctly). It's not that the Lord doesn't love him as he loves all his flock, but I really don't think it's fair to him nor the other members of the church if his mother puts him in a setting where he's expected to be still, quiet, and orderly for an hour or more. If the alternatives didn't please her, well, that was her choice.
Also, comparing autistic to the poor is fallacious and does not warrant a serious response.

Dear Liberals-At-Large:
You know that "separation of church and state" thing that you're always preaching to us about? Yeah, that goes both ways. Thanks.[/quote]

How does that work? When someone is screaming obsenities because of terrets that is not distracting but someone flayling their arms about is?

The comparison was never a compariosn, it was a statement of saying we ban this, so what do we ban next. Although like someone else pointed out, the article leaves out many facts so the statement went of misguided facts but ones I thought to be true from reading the article.

havok579257
Posted

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1588617' date='Jul 1 2008, 08:44 PM']Yeah, let's put the bull in a china shop. Great idea.
Seriously? Put a 6 foot +, 225 lb guy in a room with a bunch of babies? Get real.

Also, ever heard of extraordinary ministers? They could bring the host to the mother at home or in the fellow ship hall, etc. I'm sure all of these issues could be worked around, but they require something that the mother has implicitly stated she doesn't want: work.[/quote]


Hence the need for one of two ushers and the mom as I stated above. If the two strongest usher can not control one person along with the mother's help then there is a problem. I am referring only to them controlling him hitting other people and not other actions like screaming and throwing his arms about but not hitting anyone.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='havok579257' post='1588602' date='Jul 1 2008, 08:30 PM']Definatly against the home masses or live feeds as with live feeds there is no communion. Which our mass is basically built around.[/quote]

Communion was offered in both situations... unless you mean communion with other parishoners, which is NOT what mass is built around.

Vincent Vega
Posted

[quote name='havok579257' post='1588621' date='Jul 1 2008, 07:50 PM']How does that work? When someone is screaming obsenities because of terrets that is not distracting but someone flayling their arms about is?

The comparison was never a compariosn, it was a statement of saying we ban this, so what do we ban next. Although like someone else pointed out, the article leaves out many facts so the statement went of misguided facts but ones I thought to be true from reading the article.[/quote]
That would be equally distracting; however that's something that's not physically harmful to others and thus could be left in a cry room.

But the thing is - they're not banning all mentally retarded people. They're banning one, [i]dangerous[/i] mentally retarded person. We've got parishioners with Down Syndrome at my parish - they're perfectly accepted as everyone else, because they don't take away from the mass. In fact, there's something very heartwarming about hearing them recite the creed with such faith and heartfeltedness. That's beside the point.

[quote name='havok579257' post='1588623' date='Jul 1 2008, 07:52 PM']Hence the need for one of two ushers and the mom as I stated above. If the two strongest usher can not control one person along with the mother's help then there is a problem. I am referring only to them controlling him hitting other people and not other actions like screaming and throwing his arms about but not hitting anyone.[/quote]
So tell me how restraining a person via the brute force of two others is respecting his dignity? And by your formula, this is what would have to happen, because in one split second and one fell swoop, he could very easily kill one of the babies in the room. Tell me how this would be more advantageous than viewing the mass from an alternate location?

Posted

[quote name='havok579257' post='1588619' date='Jul 1 2008, 08:47 PM']So because he has a mental handicap we should just forfit his salvation. WHat's more important, someone accidently exposing himself and upsetting parishoners or the person's immortal soul?[/quote]

False Dichotomies again?

lol.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='havok579257' post='1588619' date='Jul 1 2008, 08:47 PM']So because he has a mental handicap we should just forfit his salvation. WHat's more important, someone accidently exposing himself and upsetting parishoners or the person's immortal soul?[/quote]
So... masses in one's home are less salvific than masses in church? :unsure:

Posted (edited)

This reminds me a similar incident where a young girl was allergic to wheat, and so her parents requested that the Hosts be made of a different material, something that obviously can't be done. The family made a big deal about it even though there are other options, such as giving her a drop of the precious Blood. The similarity I see in both cases are stubborn parents. The parish priest and the judge both decided there are reasonable reasons to exclude this boy from the Mass, it's not like the community didn't offer alternatives (having a private mass said at home is pretty convenient!) and so the parents should just accept it.

Edited by mortify
HisChildForever
Posted

[quote name='havok579257' post='1588619' date='Jul 1 2008, 08:47 PM']So because he has a mental handicap we should just forfit his salvation. WHat's more important, someone accidently exposing himself and upsetting parishoners or the person's immortal soul?[/quote]

I never, ever said or even implied that we should "forfit his salvation."

In fact, I feel that he should watch Mass at home on the television and then get visited by a Eucharistic Minister.

Posted

[quote name='Alycin' post='1588643' date='Jul 1 2008, 10:14 PM']False Dichotomies again?

lol.[/quote]
Well played.

havok579257
Posted

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1588634' date='Jul 1 2008, 09:04 PM']That would be equally distracting; however that's something that's not physically harmful to others and thus could be left in a cry room.

But the thing is - they're not banning all mentally retarded people. They're banning one, [i]dangerous[/i] mentally retarded person. We've got parishioners with Down Syndrome at my parish - they're perfectly accepted as everyone else, because they don't take away from the mass. In fact, there's something very heartwarming about hearing them recite the creed with such faith and heartfeltedness. That's beside the point.
So tell me how restraining a person via the brute force of two others is respecting his dignity? And by your formula, this is what would have to happen, because in one split second and one fell swoop, he could very easily kill one of the babies in the room. Tell me how this would be more advantageous than viewing the mass from an alternate location?[/quote]


In one second he could fly ACROSS the room and kill a baby? How hard is it for people with babies to not sit by the person in the cry room. Your telling me that 2 men would sit there and watch as the person went across the room and kill the baby. More to the point, why bring up killing babies? He's been in mass before and has not killed anyone yet you jump to this conclusion? WHy?

havok579257
Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1588672' date='Jul 1 2008, 09:36 PM']So... masses in one's home are less salvific than masses in church? :unsure:[/quote]


Did not realize communion was being offered at home and the mass was being held via satallite. Is there a priest at the home doing the communion while the mass is happening?

If something like this is offered and the church helps pay for and set up the via webcam or whatever, then that's fine. As long as communion is offered in this instance.

This is getting hard to go off of since I only have this article. So if someone could please post this article everyone is talking about that the church is offering other options it would help.

Vincent Vega
Posted

[quote name='havok579257' post='1588713' date='Jul 1 2008, 09:27 PM']In one second he could fly ACROSS the room and kill a baby? How hard is it for people with babies to not sit by the person in the cry room. Your telling me that 2 men would sit there and watch as the person went across the room and kill the baby. More to the point, why bring up killing babies? He's been in mass before and has not killed anyone yet you jump to this conclusion? WHy?[/quote]
Most cry rooms are not the size of gymnasiums. In fact, the ones I have experienced are actually rather small. Also, you realize that when people flail and react violently in general, they don't do it slowly and cautiously. Also, in case you haven't noticed, most ushers aren't 18 year old varsity football players. They tend to be older, and as a brash generalization, older men do not move as fast as younger men. Also, in case you didn't know, babies tend to be fragile. Have you ever heard of Shaken Baby Syndrome? Me too. Have you heard of Shaken Full Grown Person Syndrome? Me either. One hit that might bruise an adult or adolescent could kill a baby.
Why bring up killing babies? Well, that's where the highest concentration of babies would be - in the cry room. I'm not saying that it [i]would[/i] happen; just that it could, and might.
I'll tell you this much: if I had an infant, I would not feel comfortable with an adult male, 6 foot something, 220 something, prone to violent outbursts, sitting a few feet away.

CatholicCid
Posted (edited)

Havok, I think you are slightly confusing one of the alternatives HomeSchoolMom offered. I believe the "Mass in their home" would mean that a Priest would come and offer the Holy Sacrafice of the Mass in their home for them.
The other option said would be a livefeed of the Mass said in the 'Fellowship Hall', which I assume would be the Parish Hall adjacent the Church (or Basement of the Church). An Extraordinary Minister of Holy Communion could promptly bring the Eucharist to the family straight from the Church.

That being said, I believe that, though a difficult case, the Pastor in this situation had to put the physical safety of the entire flock over that of the convience of one family. The urination alluded to in the judgement would not worry me as much as the actual physical danger mentioned, including hitting a small child, grabbing a teenage girl and pulling her into his lap, and bumping into the elderly.
I really cannot concieve why the alternatives the Parish seemed to offer would be considered worse then having to use physical force to constrain the child.

I was happy to read though that:
[quote]Speaking on behalf of the parish this afternoon, Jane Marrin, director of pastoral planning for the St Cloud Diocese, said that St Joseph "is involved in mediation with the family, [b]and it's the parish's hope that we can come to a mutually acceptable solution. That has been the goal all along for the parish, and the judge's ruling doesn't rule out."[/b][/quote]
It's nice that, even after being put through all these legal tatics and prevailing, that the Parish is still willing to work out a solution that would be in the best interest for the boy and the Parish.

-Edit-

Havok, I believe that Apotheoun was kind enough to search for and repost the original article and discussion that was had on here in his post on Page 1 of this topic.

Edited by CatholicCid
Vincent Vega
Posted

[quote name='havok579257' post='1588716' date='Jul 1 2008, 09:30 PM']Did not realize communion was being offered at home and the mass was being held via satallite. Is there a priest at the home doing the communion while the mass is happening?[/quote]
Are you fawning ignorance, or have you really never heard of things like EWTN?

[quote]This is getting hard to go off of since I only have this article. So if someone could please post this article everyone is talking about that the church is offering other options it would help.[/quote]
There's this lovely thing called...oh, forget it. Here:
[url="http://abcnews.go.com/TheLaw/story?id=4885322"]http://abcnews.go.com/TheLaw/story?id=4885322[/url]
[url="http://www.huliq.com/60382/pope-benedict-xvi-urged-provide-guidelines-after-autism-church-ban"]http://www.huliq.com/60382/pope-benedict-x...tism-church-ban[/url]
[url="http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/24920240/"]http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/24920240/[/url]
Result of a 15 second google search.
By the way, you can see from the picture in the last article that the mother would probably not be able to constrain him much, if at all.

havok579257
Posted

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1588733' date='Jul 1 2008, 10:43 PM']Are you fawning ignorance, or have you really never heard of things like EWTN?
There's this lovely thing called...oh, forget it. Here:
[url="http://abcnews.go.com/TheLaw/story?id=4885322"]http://abcnews.go.com/TheLaw/story?id=4885322[/url]
[url="http://www.huliq.com/60382/pope-benedict-xvi-urged-provide-guidelines-after-autism-church-ban"]http://www.huliq.com/60382/pope-benedict-x...tism-church-ban[/url]
[url="http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/24920240/"]http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/24920240/[/url]
Result of a 15 second google search.
By the way, you can see from the picture in the last article that the mother would probably not be able to constrain him much, if at all.[/quote]


No need to be a jerk. I am just coming back to the church and am still learning many things about it. I had never heard of this before. Also I am trying to learn about as much as I can but it does take time.

Posted

[quote name='havok579257' post='1588619' date='Jul 1 2008, 08:47 PM']So because he has a mental handicap we should just forfit his salvation. WHat's more important, someone accidently exposing himself and upsetting parishoners or the person's immortal soul?[/quote]

I don't know about you, Havok, but the God I worship is a God of mercy...

Posted

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1588733' date='Jul 1 2008, 08:43 PM']Are you fawning ignorance, or have you really never heard of things like EWTN?
There's this lovely thing called...oh, forget it. Here:
[url="http://abcnews.go.com/TheLaw/story?id=4885322"]http://abcnews.go.com/TheLaw/story?id=4885322[/url]
[url="http://www.huliq.com/60382/pope-benedict-xvi-urged-provide-guidelines-after-autism-church-ban"]http://www.huliq.com/60382/pope-benedict-x...tism-church-ban[/url]
[url="http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/24920240/"]http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/24920240/[/url]
Result of a 15 second google search.
By the way, you can see from the picture in the last article that the mother would probably not be able to constrain him much, if at all.[/quote]
+J.M.J.+
CHARITY
The infused supernatural virtue by which a person loves God above all things for his own sake, and [b]loves others for God's sake.[/b]

so havok is having a hard time understanding this. so what? why don't we be charitable in our attitudes please? :) thanks.

Posted

[quote name='havok579257' post='1588716' date='Jul 1 2008, 11:30 PM']Did not realize communion was being offered at home and the mass was being held via satallite. Is there a priest at the home doing the communion while the mass is happening?

If something like this is offered and the church helps pay for and set up the via webcam or whatever, then that's fine. As long as communion is offered in this instance.

This is getting hard to go off of since I only have this article. So if someone could please post this article everyone is talking about that the church is offering other options it would help.[/quote]
a mass at home would involve the priest coming to the home and saying mass... the whole mass, right there, not by satelite or webcam. if the mass was being offered by webcam or whatever, I am sure they would have a priest or an extraordinary minister come to offer communion also... but if they're offering mass at home the priest actually comes and prays the whole mass. a private mass like that would probably take no more than a half hour.

Posted

The Mass at home idea was a good one, and I really do not see why the family rejected that option.

Posted

[quote name='havok579257' post='1588534' date='Jul 1 2008, 05:55 PM']But you can't treat someone handicapped the same as everyone else. If I peed on the floor, then its intentional. If someone who can't control it does, then its not the same. Same with children. We should not treat a 3 y/o the same as a 45 y/o.

Note: This does not directly reference the article.[/quote]

+

The problem with your argument is that it rests on a notion of "intentionality" equalling acceptability.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...