Winchester Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 On my little attyahoo page, there was an article about burning calories and ideal weight and all that croutons. I looked up how many calories I burn during my routine and it's somewhere in the neighborhood of 600. I think that stuff's interesting. However, the BMI and ideal calculator weights are mentally divergent. At 5' 10", my ideal weight tops out at 174. I weigh 196. In the academy at age 24 with the metabolism of a hummingbird on speed, I weighed 192 and could not put weight on when I tried. At 174, I would look like Karen Carpenter circa 2001. My BMI, of course, is way off. I don't power lift or do bodybuilding--I simply stay in shape. What the hell is wrong with these people?
Sarah_JC Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 What do you mean idea weight? I thought BMI was a range.
cathoholic_anonymous Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 It isn't accurate for everybody, as it can't take things like bone structure into account. One of my friends is phenomenally tall but weighs only nine and a half stone, which puts her in the underweight range. Yet she isn't unhealthy and she looks fine. She's just slenderly built. However, BMI serves as a good gauge for most people. I've been at the top and the bottom ends of my ideal weight range for my height, and from how I looked and felt then I know that it's correct where I'm concerned. Remember that no doctor is going to label you as obese or anorexic based on your BMI alone - it's just used as a screening tool to indicate whether a problem [i]might[/i] be present.
Archaeology cat Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 I never pay attention to the BMI. It always tells me I'm really underweight, as it doesn't really take into account my body type. The midwives got upset with me at my booking in appt because they didn't think I'd gained enough weight (this was at 21 weeks, after 8 weeks of morning sickness). So I just ignore it.
picchick Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 [quote name='Winchester' post='1588953' date='Jul 2 2008, 05:56 AM']On my little attyahoo page, there was an article about burning calories and ideal weight and all that croutons. I looked up how many calories I burn during my routine and it's somewhere in the neighborhood of 600. I think that stuff's interesting. However, the BMI and ideal calculator weights are mentally divergent. At 5' 10", my ideal weight tops out at 174. I weigh 196. In the academy at age 24 with the metabolism of a hummingbird on speed, I weighed 192 and could not put weight on when I tried. At 174, I would look like Karen Carpenter circa 2001. My BMI, of course, is way off. I don't power lift or do bodybuilding--I simply stay in shape. What the hell is wrong with these people?[/quote] I totally agree with you...There is something wrong with it. I was on WW and they said that I needed to get to I think like 126. I am 5'6". I would look emaciated if I got down to that weight. I am about 30 lbs off from that so to them I am overweight. Yeah, I guess I could stand to loose another 15 lbs which I am still working at but any more than that and I think it is unhealthy. We all need some fat on our bodies. And what people don't get either is that muscle weighs out too. So I might have a lot of muslce at 130. But anyways, I guess that is our country. They like it skinny lean and thin. My teacher once said that it wasn't like that in the "old days" (ancient times, days of kings and such). At that time being plump was gorgeous because it meant that you could afford to feed yourself. Whereas now a days the healthier food is more expensive. She said that she was waiting for the "fat" fashion statment to come back. Meg
Archaeology cat Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 [quote name='picchick' post='1588985' date='Jul 2 2008, 02:28 PM']We all need some fat on our bodies. And what people don't get either is that muscle weighs out too. So I might have a lot of muslce at 130.[/quote] Exactly! [quote name='picchick' post='1588985' date='Jul 2 2008, 02:28 PM']But anyways, I guess that is our country. They like it skinny lean and thin. My teacher once said that it wasn't like that in the "old days" (ancient times, days of kings and such). At that time being plump was gorgeous because it meant that you could afford to feed yourself. Whereas now a days the healthier food is more expensive. She said that she was waiting for the "fat" fashion statment to come back. Meg[/quote] It's not just the US. I mean, here they keep having these articles about not allowing size 0 models or whatever because they don't want the girls to think they have to be impossibly/unhealthily thin. But then I saw an advert for Special K about a woman being embarrassed to be seen in her swimsuit, and she looked great! She didn't need to lose any weight. Gar.
CatherineM Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 Waist circumference is a much better indicator of healthy weight, unless your pregnant of course.
Totus Tuus Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 Well, I know on the WW chart I referenced it was for "adults" - as in there was no differentiation between MEN and WOMEN. It was just adult + height = certain weight. I think you have to take your sex into consideration, since women, as far as I know, need more body fat than men do (our hormones balance that out for us)... just my .02
picchick Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 [quote name='mortify' post='1589024' date='Jul 2 2008, 10:30 AM']Ideal body weight is not BMI[/quote] Right but my BMI is overweight as well because my weight is off...in order to get my BMI correct I'd have to get to my ideal body weight. [quote name='Totus Tuus' post='1589064' date='Jul 2 2008, 11:26 AM']Well, I know on the WW chart I referenced it was for "adults" - as in there was no differentiation between MEN and WOMEN. It was just adult + height = certain weight. I think you have to take your sex into consideration, since women, as far as I know, need more body fat than men do (our hormones balance that out for us)... just my .02[/quote] The WW chart that I used years ago (I don't know abou now) had it differentiated. But I agree...we do need fat.
havok579257 Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 BMI and ideal body weights are one of the biggests jokes in the world. They are absolutly wrong in their conception. There biggest problem is it does not account for any muscle mass what so ever. Now I'm not even talking about a huge muscle man or woman(who according to this croutons is considered obese and so far overweight), but just a man or woman who stays in shape. Muscle weighs more than fat inside the human body so the more muscle you have the more you will weigh. The problem with this kind of calculation is it uses 2 components to determine the results, weight and hieght. You can not base anyone's ideal body weight on just those 2 components. There are so many more things to factor in such as muscle mass, % of body fat, what body type a person is and so on and so on. By using only two indicators they are hitting on the most broad of ranges. Which is sad when it can easily factor in these other things. Its also really sad when some doctor's go off of this and consider someone obese because of BMI. A better indicator for health of a person is cholesterol count, blood pressure and aerobic exercise. The waist line is definatly not a good indicator of one being healthy or in shape as someone can be incredible shape and healthy but still have a gut. For men and women, the stomach is usually the last place someone will lose weight. So someone could not be fat andywhere else on their body, but still be fat in the stomach. Although that can also be reverse because just cause someone has a flat stomach does not mean they are healthy at all.
CatherineM Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 The reason that waist circumference over 35 inches for women and 40 inches for men, has to do with the type of fat involved. Fat carried in the hips or butt, is subcutaneous. It is between the skin and muscle. Stomach fat is visceral. In addition to the area just under the skin, it also is under the muscle. It collects around the internal organs and is much more chemically active in the body. Don't take my word for it. Here's a [url="http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/abstract/311/6998/158"]link[/url] to the research. Notice how many prominent researchers have cited the research at the bottom of the page. If blood pressure and cholesterol is all that mattered, I'd be the healthiest person in Edmonton. My last cholesterol level was 57, 50 HDL and 7 LDL. I can assure you I am far from being the weight I should be, but I haven't given up yet.
Andrea348 Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 According to the BMI height and weight deal, I am right on the line of overweight and obese. That system is so bad because while I may need to lose like 10-15 pounds I am by no means near obese! [img]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v479/Tapdancer10/Newman1.jpg[/img] I am the one in the red shirt, khaki pants. This is what they are calling overweight/obese.
Lil Red Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 [quote name='Andrea348' post='1589164' date='Jul 2 2008, 11:12 AM']According to the BMI height and weight deal, I am right on the line of overweight and obese. That system is so bad because while I may need to lose like 10-15 pounds I am by no means near obese! [img]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v479/Tapdancer10/Newman1.jpg[/img] I am the one in the red shirt, khaki pants. This is what they are calling overweight/obese.[/quote] +J.M.J.+ you look amazing! and it's wonderful to see you on the phorums!
Archaeology cat Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 [quote name='Andrea348' post='1589164' date='Jul 2 2008, 06:12 PM']According to the BMI height and weight deal, I am right on the line of overweight and obese. That system is so bad because while I may need to lose like 10-15 pounds I am by no means near obese! [img]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v479/Tapdancer10/Newman1.jpg[/img] I am the one in the red shirt, khaki pants. This is what they are calling overweight/obese.[/quote] Yeah, definitely not obese - you look great!
havok579257 Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1589133' date='Jul 2 2008, 12:49 PM']The reason that waist circumference over 35 inches for women and 40 inches for men, has to do with the type of fat involved. Fat carried in the hips or butt, is subcutaneous. It is between the skin and muscle. Stomach fat is visceral. In addition to the area just under the skin, it also is under the muscle. It collects around the internal organs and is much more chemically active in the body. Don't take my word for it. Here's a [url="http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/abstract/311/6998/158"]link[/url] to the research. Notice how many prominent researchers have cited the research at the bottom of the page. If blood pressure and cholesterol is all that mattered, I'd be the healthiest person in Edmonton. My last cholesterol level was 57, 50 HDL and 7 LDL. I can assure you I am far from being the weight I should be, but I haven't given up yet.[/quote] Blood pressure, cholesterol level and aerobic endurance is what I wrote.
CatherineM Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 My blood pressure is 120/60, I take water aerobics 3 times a week, and outlast the instructor. We don't own a car, so I walk everywhere, to the library, to church, even to the grocery store with a 75L expedition backpack to bring the purchases home. I'm not old enough for a pull around grocery carts like the little old ladies use. My last blood work showed 80 glucose, and 72 triglycerides. I had an angiogram in March because they thought I was having a heart attack when it was just food poisoning. See a big woman with abdominal pain, and that is their first worry, and rightly so. The angiogram showed my arteries complete clear and free of any narrowing or plaque, with an ejecta rate of 75%. That's the highest the cardiologist had ever seen, granted he probably doesn't get a lot of marathon runners on his table, so I was being compared to people having heart attacks. It's a pretty invasive test to have just to see how your heart is doing in middle age, but it is nice knowing my heart is strong even if the rest of my anatomy is screwed up. Sure scared my husband though, I think he woke up every priest he knew, and it was 2am.
zabbazooey Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 [quote name='Andrea348' post='1589164' date='Jul 2 2008, 11:12 AM']According to the BMI height and weight deal, I am right on the line of overweight and obese. That system is so bad because while I may need to lose like 10-15 pounds I am by no means near obese! [img]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v479/Tapdancer10/Newman1.jpg[/img] I am the one in the red shirt, khaki pants. This is what they are calling overweight/obese.[/quote] You...obese? No way...
havok579257 Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1589307' date='Jul 2 2008, 03:36 PM']My blood pressure is 120/60, I take water aerobics 3 times a week, and outlast the instructor. We don't own a car, so I walk everywhere, to the library, to church, even to the grocery store with a 75L expedition backpack to bring the purchases home. I'm not old enough for a pull around grocery carts like the little old ladies use. My last blood work showed 80 glucose, and 72 triglycerides. I had an angiogram in March because they thought I was having a heart attack when it was just food poisoning. See a big woman with abdominal pain, and that is their first worry, and rightly so. The angiogram showed my arteries complete clear and free of any narrowing or plaque, with an ejecta rate of 75%. That's the highest the cardiologist had ever seen, granted he probably doesn't get a lot of marathon runners on his table, so I was being compared to people having heart attacks. It's a pretty invasive test to have just to see how your heart is doing in middle age, but it is nice knowing my heart is strong even if the rest of my anatomy is screwed up. Sure scared my husband though, I think he woke up every priest he knew, and it was 2am.[/quote] Sounds like your quite healthy. What seems to be the problem?
CatherineM Posted July 2, 2008 Posted July 2, 2008 Oh, my body was pretty beat up. Strangulation injured my thyroid, plus I went from being very active to being in a wheelchair, and the depression of my injuries and loss of career, and the medication I was prescribed for PTSD causes huge weight gains. So I put on incredible hulk type weight. I've lost a couple of hundred pounds now, but am not yet where I want to be. My inside is healthy, but my outside isn't. I think obesity is too complicated an issue to try to label with any type of stock grading system. Each person is so different. I actually consider myself a strange science experiment.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now