havok579257 Posted July 3, 2008 Posted July 3, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1589535' date='Jul 2 2008, 07:36 PM']Oh, my body was pretty beat up. Strangulation injured my thyroid, plus I went from being very active to being in a wheelchair, and the depression of my injuries and loss of career, and the medication I was prescribed for PTSD causes huge weight gains. So I put on incredible hulk type weight. I've lost a couple of hundred pounds now, but am not yet where I want to be. My inside is healthy, but my outside isn't. I think obesity is too complicated an issue to try to label with any type of stock grading system. Each person is so different. I actually consider myself a strange science experiment.[/quote] Well it sounds like you are quite healthy which means your not obese. Although it sounds like you have a personal goal to slim down more. Although that does not mean you are obese, overweight or fat. It means you are quite healthy but you have bigger goals.
CatherineM Posted July 3, 2008 Posted July 3, 2008 I promise that I am still classified as morbidly obese. That's my point that those guidelines don't work for most people.
Socrates Posted July 3, 2008 Posted July 3, 2008 BMI is balogna, like most bureaucratic government "guidelines." It's all built on the assumption that everybody is a weakling with no muscle. If you are even moderately muscular, you will be considered "overweight." I think I rated "borderline obese" or something last I checked - which is laughable if you've ever seen me.
Graciela Posted July 3, 2008 Posted July 3, 2008 [quote name='Andrea348' post='1589164' date='Jul 2 2008, 01:12 PM']According to the BMI height and weight deal, I am right on the line of overweight and obese. That system is so bad because while I may need to lose like 10-15 pounds I am by no means near obese! [img]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v479/Tapdancer10/Newman1.jpg[/img] I am the one in the red shirt, khaki pants. This is what they are calling overweight/obese.[/quote] Thanks for sharing- you look fabulous! This helps me know how to use the BMI chart when thinking about an "ideal" weight- I'll pick something on the overweight side of the overwgt/obese cusp. I don't fancy looking like Kate Moss Grace & peace! Graciela
Alycin Posted July 3, 2008 Posted July 3, 2008 Yeah.... I'm pretty sure that like 3 or 4 [b][i]years[/i][/b] ago they made fun of the BMI calculator in a really funny article listing all the male celebs that were "overweight" or "obese" by its standards... So I wonder why it is still used?
XIX Posted July 3, 2008 Posted July 3, 2008 Oddly enough, it says my ideal weight is 150. Which is actually dead on for me. Huh. In general it still seems pretty useless.
IrishSalesian Posted July 3, 2008 Posted July 3, 2008 BMI is BS. Granted, I know that if I went to a doctor he would tell me that I am obese. But I am comfortable with who I am. I can run, and play sports without getting too winded. I can run pretty fast for someone who weighs 330. A doctor once, told me that i needed to get in shape, I retorted back, that round was a shape.
Sarah_JC Posted July 3, 2008 Posted July 3, 2008 According to the BMI I'm underweight. When I found out I actually got quite upset and went to my doctor. He checked my vitals, told me I was healthy. Apparently I'm just small. My future husband, when I mentioned BMI, said "Oh, BMI, that's accurate for about 50% of the population."
Archaeology cat Posted July 3, 2008 Posted July 3, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Sarah_JC' post='1589765' date='Jul 3 2008, 04:52 AM']According to the BMI I'm underweight. When I found out I actually got quite upset and went to my doctor. He checked my vitals, told me I was healthy. Apparently I'm just small. My future husband, when I mentioned BMI, said "Oh, BMI, that's accurate for about 50% of the population."[/quote] Yeah, I'm always listed as underweight, but like I said, it doesn't take into account that I have a small frame. I eat all the time, and try to eat healthily and just don't worry about it. ETA: I had to laugh when the midwives initially weighed me, because they didn't check to see what my weight was prior to being pregnant, and they just told me I wasn't gaining enough. How they could know that without a baseline comparison is beyond me. Edited July 3, 2008 by Archaeology cat
XIX Posted July 3, 2008 Posted July 3, 2008 "Kinda like saying "what's the score of the baseball game?" "Red Sox 1" "Wow the Red Sox are really getting blown out today!!"
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now