havok579257 Posted July 5, 2008 Posted July 5, 2008 Ok, so I got the info on my marriage and what needs to be done so it can be right in the Catholic church. I plan on doing this ASAP. Now, like priest told me, it was not a mortal sin to take communion because I did not know that the catholic church does not consider other christian marriages valid(we were married in a methodist church). Well my question is, can I not take communion now even though I am going to get this rectified ASAP? If this takes a few weeks, am I not allowed to take communion for a few weeks? It would definatly pain me not to be taking communion for even one service, let alone a few. So can anyone PLEASE shed some light on this before Sunday's service.
Maggyie Posted July 5, 2008 Posted July 5, 2008 (edited) You and your wife can live "as brother and sister" until the situation is taken care of. The main problem is having sex with someone you're not actually married to, at least in the eyes of the Church. You should probably speak to your pastor about this, but if you practice complete abstinence with your wife during this period I think you should be okay to receive Holy Communion. Edited July 5, 2008 by Maggie
CatherineM Posted July 5, 2008 Posted July 5, 2008 We were married civilly at first because of Immigration. Without the marriage, I'd have gotten deported. We went 6 months without communion. We knew that was going to be the consequence, we didn't know it was going to be 6 months though. It was only going to be 6 weeks, but his family got the first church blessing canceled. We had the option of living brother and sister obviously, but #1, we wanted the chance at a child, and at my age, a month of fertility is worth a year's worth to a 20 year old woman, and #2, we had to attest that our relationship was a real marriage, and not just so that I could immigrate to Canada, and I wasn't willing to lie to the government that we were having a normal sex life, if we weren't. And yes, they ask those kind of questions. It was hard going without communion. I was very careful crossing the street in fear that I'd get hit by a car while not in a state of grace. It's one of those hurdles in life that you just hitch it up, and do what you have to do, according to the rules, to make it right.
Fr. Bruno Posted July 5, 2008 Posted July 5, 2008 [quote name='Maggie' post='1591739' date='Jul 5 2008, 07:38 AM']You and your wife can live "as brother and sister" until the situation is taken care of. The main problem is having sex with someone you're not actually married to, at least in the eyes of the Church. You should probably speak to your pastor about this, but if you practice complete abstinence with your wife during this period I think you should be okay to receive Holy Communion.[/quote] I agree with the principle, but this decision also means that your wife accepts and ideally understands it. May need a lot of prayer !
Fr. Bruno Posted July 5, 2008 Posted July 5, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1591808' date='Jul 5 2008, 08:31 AM']We were married civilly at first because of Immigration. Without the marriage, I'd have gotten deported. We went 6 months without communion. We knew that was going to be the consequence, we didn't know it was going to be 6 months though. It was only going to be 6 weeks, but his family got the first church blessing canceled. We had the option of living brother and sister obviously, but #1, we wanted the chance at a child, and at my age, a month of fertility is worth a year's worth to a 20 year old woman, and #2, we had to attest that our relationship was a real marriage, and not just so that I could immigrate to Canada, and I wasn't willing to lie to the government that we were having a normal sex life, if we weren't. And yes, they ask those kind of questions. It was hard going without communion. I was very careful crossing the street in fear that I'd get hit by a car while not in a state of grace. It's one of those hurdles in life that you just hitch it up, and do what you have to do, according to the rules, to make it right.[/quote] [size=3][font="Times New Roman"]Catherine, I understand your situation, but for me (and for many other people, I guess) it would be unacceptable to say: " Ok, I just spend some time without living in the state of grace, for whatever reason ". Please understand this : I do not want to blame or to judge you, but for the sake of other people who read your post, I want to add a clarification. The purpose of the Church's discipline in this area (and of Church law in general) is not to accomplish a human law, but to love God and our neighbor. God never puts us in a situation where we are obliged to sin, or to live in a situation of sin. On the other hand, I think many people tend to focus more on "respecting the law" rather then to focus on loving God and his children. Choosing a situation where you are not allowed to go to communion, and accepting the consequences, reveals this kind of attitude. The right thing to do would be to avoid sin and repent if you have sinned, go to confession if necessary and take the resolution not to offend God anymore. There are two things I'd like to clarify. The first is that Christians should trust God in all situations, also for the question of having children. There are a couple of examples in the Bible… In other words : a Christian should never say: " Ok I accept doing something that is against God's will and just won't go to communion for some time, hoping that I won't have a mortal accident and go to hell…". Why ? Because either what you do is wrong and offensive to God, whom we should love above all, or it's right, but then there is no reason not to go to communion. I can understand the fertility question, but I'd rather recommend Christians in this case to trust God. A second clarification concerns your attitude towards the officials. Civil authorities cannot oblige you to have sex ! If a married couple chooses abstinence, civil authorities have no right to investigate in what's happening. In other words, if they do so, there is no obligation to tell them the truth. According to the Catechism, it's not a lie to answer "yes", if the right answer would be "no". Once again, Catherine, I hope this does not trouble you. Obviously, it was a hard situation for you, and I have the impression that other people go thru similar difficulties. So I just thought it was necessary to clarify this question. [/font][/size]
homeschoolmom Posted July 5, 2008 Posted July 5, 2008 [quote name='havok579257' post='1591732' date='Jul 5 2008, 12:30 AM']I did not know that the catholic church does not consider other christian marriages valid(we were married in a methodist church).[/quote] I just wanted to clarify something.... The Church does consider other Christian marriages vaild-- maybe just not the circumstances of yours.
Madame Vengier Posted July 5, 2008 Posted July 5, 2008 (edited) [quote name='havok579257' post='1591732' date='Jul 4 2008, 11:30 PM']Ok, so I got the info on my marriage and what needs to be done so it can be right in the Catholic church. I plan on doing this ASAP. Now, like priest told me, it was not a mortal sin to take communion because I did not know that the catholic church does not consider other christian marriages valid(we were married in a methodist church). Well my question is, can I not take communion now even though I am going to get this rectified ASAP? If this takes a few weeks, am I not allowed to take communion for a few weeks? It would definatly pain me not to be taking communion for even one service, let alone a few. So can anyone PLEASE shed some light on this before Sunday's service.[/quote] You shouldn't take communion if you can't abstain from marital relations. Instead you should remain in a spirit of prayer and pray for unity among all Christians. Also, sorry to nitpick, but we Catholics do not call it "a service". It's called "the Mass" as in "Holy Sacrifice of the Mass". Protestants use the term "service". Edited July 5, 2008 by Madame Vengier
Fr. Bruno Posted July 5, 2008 Posted July 5, 2008 [quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1591833' date='Jul 5 2008, 12:51 PM']I just wanted to clarify something.... The Church does consider other Christian marriages vaild-- maybe just not the circumstances of yours.[/quote] The Church considers religious marriages of non-catholic christians valid ; but not marriages of catholics who are not married under the canonically required form (presence of a priest or his delegate, and 2 witnesses), UNLESS there is a canonical dispense. For people not familiar with Canon Law, this might sound odd... but there are pastoral reasons for all this.
homeschoolmom Posted July 5, 2008 Posted July 5, 2008 Right. But unless we are privy to all the details of the original posters marriage, I think it's not right to let the statement "the Church does not consider other Christian marriages valid" go unqualified. We have had that issue come up here several times and people get unnecessarily hurt by blanket statements. Thanks for the details.
CatherineM Posted July 5, 2008 Posted July 5, 2008 Fr. Bruno-No I don't take offense. I didn't feel obligated to sin, and didn't feel any hard feelings towards the church. I used to work in the Tribunal for the Defender of the Bond, so I'm certainly aware of the rules, and agree with them completely. We were in a difficult position. For people who haven't gone through an immigration process, it is hard to explain. Most people here thought that I would automatically become a Canadian citizen when we married. I wish. Immigration here delves into every personal aspect of our life to prove that I am not paying him to marry me temporarily so that I can immigrate to Canada. Some of my immigration friends have been separated for 5 years because their husbands haven't been allowed visas to enter the country yet. They've even missed out on having their husbands be allowed to be with them at the birth of their children. At the interview, they asked me all kinds of personal, and sexual questions alone, and then asked my husband the same, to see if they could find inconsistencies to prove we weren't in an authentic marriage. They were incredibly invasive, personal and practically pornographic, but we had been warned that they would be. That is their job, and unfortunately some of them enjoy it a bit too much. At the time, my mother in law was doing everything she could to get me deported. Had she been successful, it might have taken 5 years to re-apply, go through an appeal process, and pay several more thousand dollars in fees to be together. I wish we could have done everything the right way. I had saved myself for marriage, and had dreamed of doing all the right things, and that just wasn't to be. We had to make difficult choices, and made them in consultation with our pastor. I also believe that things work out the way they are supposed to. Our marriage came out stronger for the struggle, and going without communion just made me appreciate it more deeply.
Fr. Bruno Posted July 5, 2008 Posted July 5, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1592009' date='Jul 5 2008, 07:54 PM']Fr. Bruno-No I don't take offense. I didn't feel obligated to sin, and didn't feel any hard feelings towards the church. I used to work in the Tribunal for the Defender of the Bond, so I'm certainly aware of the rules, and agree with them completely. We were in a difficult position. For people who haven't gone through an immigration process, it is hard to explain. Most people here thought that I would automatically become a Canadian citizen when we married. I wish. Immigration here delves into every personal aspect of our life to prove that I am not paying him to marry me temporarily so that I can immigrate to Canada. Some of my immigration friends have been separated for 5 years because their husbands haven't been allowed visas to enter the country yet. They've even missed out on having their husbands be allowed to be with them at the birth of their children.[/quote] It's hard to believe this would happen in a democratic country. Sorry, Catherine, my intention was not to lecture you on your personal situation and choice. However, I wanted to clarify one thing which I realized is not always clear for everybody, even here on this forum. My point is this : if we do God's will (which we should seek in all circumstances), then our heart should be in peace. So why not going to communion or being afraid of " what might happen in case I die " ? Some people might encounter similar situations (like in this topic). The first question is to ask oneself : what does God want us to do in this situation ? In some cases, the solution for couples who can't wait might be just to celebrate the marriage in private (which, according to the circumstances, may require permission from the local ordinary). One final remark : since I happen to be confronted to this kind of situation once in a while, I'm always trying to learn from these experiences. So I'm always grateful for people's input to this kind of questions. Thanks !
CatherineM Posted July 5, 2008 Posted July 5, 2008 Our pastor had never dealt with anything like this before as well. To prevent the wedding, my sister in law called him, and said that my husband had gone off his medication, had gotten violent, and was beating me. That's why our first church wedding was canceled two days before the scheduled date. He hadn't known me long enough at the time to know whether to believe me that I wasn't being beaten. He had to cancel the wedding to do more due diligence. After talking to just about everyone who has ever known us, and with letters from both of our doctors attesting to our competence to marry in the church, and months more of pre-marriage counseling, he realized he'd been lied to. When we finally had the service, he held it early on Sunday morning, and locked the doors after we went in with the wedding party and a few friends. Some people who came late, were left outside banging on the door to get in. He wasn't about to have any more interference.
havok579257 Posted July 6, 2008 Author Posted July 6, 2008 ok so then a catholic who is married outside the catholic church is not considered a valiad marriage. then that would mean they could get a divorce to their spouse and the church would not recognize that either? If they would recoginze the divorce, then they would be in a contradiction cause that would mean the marriage only becomes valid in divorce. is this right?
jeffpugh Posted July 6, 2008 Posted July 6, 2008 (edited) double post Edited July 6, 2008 by Sacred Music Man
jeffpugh Posted July 6, 2008 Posted July 6, 2008 The Church doesn't "recognise" divorce (divorce, being knowing that there was a marriage, but it was split for some reason). So the question at hand would not make sense without the recognising of the marriage But again, the Church doesn't recognise divorce. It's forbidden to separate what God has united.
havok579257 Posted July 6, 2008 Author Posted July 6, 2008 [quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1592544' date='Jul 6 2008, 12:31 AM']The Church doesn't "recognise" divorce (divorce, being knowing that there was a marriage, but it was split for some reason). So the question at hand would not make sense without the recognising of the marriage But again, the Church doesn't recognise divorce. It's forbidden to separate what God has united.[/quote] so essentially some catholic could marry outside of the church, seperate from his wife and then get married in the church and the chruch would recognize only his current marrigae and not his precvious one?
jeffpugh Posted July 6, 2008 Posted July 6, 2008 technically... Church might not let that happen though if one is being licentious about it. Im no expert though.
havok579257 Posted July 6, 2008 Author Posted July 6, 2008 [quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1592551' date='Jul 6 2008, 12:38 AM']technically... Church might not let that happen though if one is being licentious about it. Im no expert though.[/quote] but how can they not since according to what everyone says, the person is not considered married. see this seems weird to me. the church recognizes non-catholic marriages but not catholic marriages outside the church. i mean what's the deal really? as long as its a christian marriage and it was done in front of the father, son and the holy spirit, how is this not a valiad marriage? what difference is there that makes it valid? is it only because a catholic priest does it? which seems weird to me since as i understood it, the marriage is the only sacrament the preist does not bestow on anyone, rather the couples do it themselfs. really, why is it an invalid marriage?
Alycin Posted July 6, 2008 Posted July 6, 2008 [quote name='havok579257' post='1592554' date='Jul 6 2008, 12:42 AM']but how can they not since according to what everyone says, the person is not considered married. see this seems weird to me. the church recognizes non-catholic marriages but not catholic marriages outside the church. i mean what's the deal really? as long as its a christian marriage and it was done in front of the father, son and the holy spirit, how is this not a valiad marriage? what difference is there that makes it valid? is it only because a catholic priest does it? which seems weird to me since as i understood it, the marriage is the only sacrament the preist does not bestow on anyone, rather the couples do it themselfs. really, why is it an invalid marriage?[/quote] The same reason that Catholics cannot receive communion at non-Catholic churches, I would assume. I don't know for sure.
mommas_boy Posted July 6, 2008 Posted July 6, 2008 [quote name='havok579257' post='1592554' date='Jul 6 2008, 12:42 AM']but how can they not since according to what everyone says, the person is not considered married. see this seems weird to me. the church recognizes non-catholic marriages but not catholic marriages outside the church. i mean what's the deal really? as long as its a christian marriage and it was done in front of the father, son and the holy spirit, how is this not a valiad marriage? what difference is there that makes it valid? is it only because a catholic priest does it? which seems weird to me since as i understood it, the marriage is the only sacrament the preist does not bestow on anyone, rather the couples do it themselfs. really, why is it an invalid marriage?[/quote] I don't know enough of the specifics about your situation to really be able to comment. I would assume that you have already been in conversation with your pastor, and am certain that there is some sort of good reason. The Catholic Church DOES accept the validity of marriages performed in other Christian traditions. However, these marriages must conform to the specifications held by the Catholic Church. A similar situation occurs with baptism; the Catholic Church recognizes baptisms by other traditions so long as it is in the "name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit" with the proper matter (water) in triple immersion. Any deviation from that formula results in an invalid sacrament. Bearing this in mind, I have a quick question for you: did you and your wife write your own vows when you were married in the Methodist church? This is a common enough practice nowadays, and many times these written vows don't contain the words that the Church is looking for in a sacramental marriage. [url="http://www.marysadvocates.org/syllabus/RiteMarriage.html"]Have a look here for the Rite of Catholic Marriage[/url]. Just a thought; it may not be the hangup.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now