Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Please Help, Communion Question Before Sunday


Recommended Posts

CatherineM
Posted

When I did work in the tribunal, we had many cases of Catholics who were married civilly or in other Christian churches without going through the steps to have the marriage recognized by the church. These are quick, easy annulments because the marriage wasn't valid on it's face. Catholics are required to say their vows before a priest/deacon, in a Catholic church, unless they have specific permission to do otherwise. The hard annulments are the ones for Protestants who want to marry a Catholic, or who want to convert. Since they aren't required to be married before a priest, their annulments are longer and more complicated. The most complicated are those where Catholics went through all the proper procedures, and pre-Cana classes, and still ended up divorced. A lot of those are simply not awarded annulments, and for obviously good reason.

The most interesting case was one where a Protestant had married a fallen away Catholic. His first marriage was eventually granted an annulment, and he completed RCIA with their two kids. He had no obstacle to being baptized except his marriage. He was now free to marry in the church, but the question was, was she, as a non-practicing Catholic. We bucked that one all the way up to the Archbishop. What finally happened, is she started attending mass so that her husband and kids could get baptized. She figured she'd come just long enough for them, and then stop again. Once she started coming though, she didn't stop, and they are one of the most active families in the parish.

Posted

[quote name='havok579257' post='1592554' date='Jul 6 2008, 07:42 AM']but how can they not since according to what everyone says, the person is not considered married. see this seems weird to me. the church recognizes non-catholic marriages but not catholic marriages outside the church. i mean what's the deal really? as long as its a christian marriage and it was done in front of the father, son and the holy spirit, how is this not a valiad marriage? what difference is there that makes it valid? is it only because a catholic priest does it? which seems weird to me since as i understood it, the marriage is the only sacrament the preist does not bestow on anyone, rather the couples do it themselfs. really, why is it an invalid marriage?[/quote]

Somehow, I can understand your reaction... because for many Catholics indeed this is not so easy to grasp. I think you have to distinguish between theological arguments (based on Revelation) and those who are related to Church discipline (which has historical reasons). There are conditions for a valid marriage which concern all Christians, based on divine Revelation.
There are other conditions which concern only Catholics, and these are a matter of Church discipline. One of these conditions is the presence of the parish priest (or a minister delegated by him) and two witnesses. The Church cannot impose these conditions on non-Catholics. But, you may ask, why then does she impose them on Catholics ? The answer is : history has shown often times that disciplinary rules are necessary for pastoral reasons. When the bishops decided (at the Council of Trent) to impose certain rules for a marriage to be recognized, their reason for doing so was that there were to many abuses (people living together for a limited time, changing partners, or whatever you can imagine). Church discipline may sometimes be looked at as a burden, but ultimately, it's for the good of the people, and therefore the Church cannot renounce on it. Does this make sense ?

havok579257
Posted

Well I just don't get why.... I mean I have been to numerous catholic masses and other christian marriages. Looking back at my marriage, the only thing it did not have was a mass and a catholic preist doing the service. The service was very similar to catholic marriage services.

Ok, so is the church saying that God does not recognize our marriga eor just the catholic church due to their rules?" Cause to me it would make no sense why they would say our marriage is not right in God's eyes. We were married in front of the father, son and the holy spirit. The preist specifically said those words. The marriage services were so simliar to what I have seen in catholic masses, except for the mass and it was a sacrement me and my wife bestowed on each other in front of God with the intent to love one another and love God through our marriage. So how could that not be ok to God.

and if it is ok in God's eyes, how can something be ok in God's eyes but not the catholic church's eyes? this to me makes no sense.

also the communion in other christian churches and marriage are 2 different things entirely. they caqn not be compared.

Posted (edited)

Indeed, your marriage was celebrated in the presence of God, the Father, Son and Holy Spirit.
Now, if this were just a matter between you and your wife and God, there would be no problem.
However, as Catholics, we are not just individuals; we are members of a body (See Ephesians 4-5 for this). And in a body, the different members cannot just function as they feel like : there needs to be harmony, rules which make function the whole thing in a balanced way, lest the body become sick. However, it is for the good of all members (also for your's) that the body functions well and in a healthy way. The more complex the body is, the more rules (laws) there must be (for a natural body : biological laws; for a social body: human laws; and for the Body of Christ: the Law of God AND Church law). Now, the Catholic Church is the largest Christian Community in the world ; therefore it needs more rules then others (there are other reasons, too). I live in a country where a lot of ministers sometimes do their own thing, without caring much about Canon law, liturgical rules, and so on. Believe me, it's a mess that weakens and divides the Church, and a lot of people just keep away from her. So please, for the sake of the Body of Christ, and for your own sake, accept those rules, even if sometimes they seem like a burden to you. There can be exceptions to many of these rules, especially in the way marriages are celebrated. But these can only be made with the permission of the Bishop or his vicar. Therefore I recommend you just take the necessary step to have your marriage recognized. Otherwise, other people who know your case could just go to any minister to get there marriage blessed in a, maybe " simpler way ", without getting the necessary preparation and protection that the Church offers, especially in particular cases where people most times don't think about, especially when they are in love. Feelings not necessarily last for ever. However, the Church has a lot of experience (particularly in tnis area), so I think we should all trust her and accept to follow her rules, even if it's not always easy.

Edited by Fr. Bruno
Posted

[quote]If this takes a few weeks, am I not allowed to take communion for a few weeks? It would definatly pain me not to be taking communion for even one service, let alone a few.[/quote]

If there is no way for you and your wife to live as brother and sister until the marriage has been blessed by the Church, then no you should not receive Holy Communion. You now have full knowledge that it is wrong. If you did receive Holy Communion and were still living as man and wife before the marriage has been blessed then you would be committing sacrilege. It might pain you to stay away from Holy Communion for a few weeks or even one service, but it will and does pain Christ to a much greater extent when people receive the Eucharist in an unworthy fashion.

I'm sorry if this sounds too harsh or too blunt. My parents went through a similar situation and they both stayed away from the Eucharist. The Eucharist isn't there for you just to take. It's there for you to receive and that reception is two fold. Christ is brought into you and you are brought into Christ.

Posted

[quote name='havok579257' post='1593428' date='Jul 7 2008, 01:04 AM']Ok, so is the church saying that God does not recognize our marriga eor just the catholic church due to their rules?" Cause to me it would make no sense why they would say our marriage is not right in God's eyes. We were married in front of the father, son and the holy spirit. The preist specifically said those words. The marriage services were so simliar to what I have seen in catholic masses, except for the mass and it was a sacrement me and my wife bestowed on each other in front of God with the intent to love one another and love God through our marriage.[/quote]


Okay, I'm a little confused. In this paragraph you mention that "The priest specifically said those words." Did a Roman Catholic Priest celebrate the wedding with you as a witness or are you calling the Methodist minister a priest? I'm a little confused and want a little clarification.

The rules regarding the Sacrament of Marriage are there for a very good purpose. The Church requires couples to go through a time of counseling with a priest or deacon before a marriage will even take place. This is to ensure that the couple are prepared as well as able to be married, able meaning that one or both of the espoused are not Sacramentally bound to someone else. The Churches "rules" are there to protect the sanctity of the Sacrament. The only time a Catholic or two Catholics can be married outside of a Catholic Church is if special dispensation comes from the Bishop. The Priest or Deacon at a Catholic wedding acts as an ordained witness of the Church to the marriage between the couple. They ask them the all important question of "are they free to marry", meaning that they are for certain not Sacramentally bound to someone else. The guidelines of the Church when it comes to the Sacrament of Marriage are again put there for a purpose, and not just because the Church likes making up rules. They are there in order to protect the Sacrament. Just like there are rules and guidelines about the reception of the Most Holy Eucharist. I mean not just anyone can receive the Eucharist. We would not allow an athiest to receive the Holy Eucharist, would we? The guidelines are there to protect the Sacrament, not there to make things difficult.

[quote]So how could that not be ok to God.[/quote]

God entrusted the care of the Sacraments into the hands of the Church. The Church does not contradict God and God does not contradict the Holy Mother Church.

Bottom line, it's all about humility. We must stop trying to make the Church conform to our wants and instead conform ourselves to the Church, who is the Spotless Bride of Christ.

havok579257
Posted

i'm not trying to get the church to conform to my wants and wills, I just can not fathom how God would see my marriage as something wrong.

Some one also said unless me and my wife don't physically stay apart from each other the entire time then i am committing a mortal sin? if i don't take communion then i am not in a state of grace? That just because I have not got the marriage approved through the church yet, I am living in a state of mortal sin?

So basically it seems like i am dead in the water if i happen to die before the preist approves my marriage? It seems like I would have been better not finding this aspect out about the catholic church because until this is fixed (at least 2 weeks because our preist out of town for that long and then we need to talk to him so it could be a month) I am in a state a mortal sin and nothing I can do until this is fixed can take away my mortal sins. So now do I need lock my self in a padded room for a month for my soul salvation? please help me on this, cause i don't know what to think here?

CatherineM
Posted

You can't expect to have your priest marry you quickly. Every diocese has different rules for pre-wedding classes, procedures, and waiting periods. Because we were both over the age of 35, we only had to take a weekend long pre-Cana class. Younger people in this diocese have to go to classes one evening a week for 3 months, in addition to taking NFP classes. Plus, individual pastors often have their own requirements. My pastor in Florida required a 9 month wait on top of the diocese's requirements, and my pastor in Oklahoma, when dealing with a couple where one was not a Catholic, made them attend basically RCIA even if the non-Catholic spouse had no intention of converting. He wanted the non-Catholic partner to understand what their spouses' responsibilities as a Catholic would be.

We were both Catholics, free to marry in the church, fulfilled the Archdiocese's pre-Cana classes and waiting period, and our pastor still required additional pre-marriage counseling and an additional 6 months wait. This is something that takes time for a reason because marriage shouldn't be jumped into lightly because we believe it is permanent, so it is important that both individuals are prepared, mature, and sure. When I helped with pre-Cana classes in Oklahoma, I saw many couples go through the process and realize that they weren't meant to marry. It's the church's way of protecting us.

havok579257
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1594650' date='Jul 7 2008, 10:51 PM']You can't expect to have your priest marry you quickly. Every diocese has different rules for pre-wedding classes, procedures, and waiting periods. Because we were both over the age of 35, we only had to take a weekend long pre-Cana class. Younger people in this diocese have to go to classes one evening a week for 3 months, in addition to taking NFP classes. Plus, individual pastors often have their own requirements. My pastor in Florida required a 9 month wait on top of the diocese's requirements, and my pastor in Oklahoma, when dealing with a couple where one was not a Catholic, made them attend basically RCIA even if the non-Catholic spouse had no intention of converting. He wanted the non-Catholic partner to understand what their spouses' responsibilities as a Catholic would be.

We were both Catholics, free to marry in the church, fulfilled the Archdiocese's pre-Cana classes and waiting period, and our pastor still required additional pre-marriage counseling and an additional 6 months wait. This is something that takes time for a reason because marriage shouldn't be jumped into lightly because we believe it is permanent, so it is important that both individuals are prepared, mature, and sure. When I helped with pre-Cana classes in Oklahoma, I saw many couples go through the process and realize that they weren't meant to marry. It's the church's way of protecting us.[/quote]

I completly understand all that stuff for new couples, but we have been married for 2 years. Its not like we are a new couple yet to be married, we already have been married. I understand the not jumping into it, but my case is different because I am already IN marriage. I am not going to seperate from my wife, so all that seems over the top for this situation to me. I mean would a couple married 50 years be expected to go through all that stuff again.

Also any help with my questions in the previous post since it seems you dealt with something similar. What does the church say should happen between me and my wife until this is rectified and I am to understand that until this is fixed I am living in mortal sin and there is no way I can be free of mortal sin because of my marriage, so if it takes 9 months I will be living in mortal sin for 9 months?

CatherineM
Posted

I knew a couple once through my tribunal work, that the husband's first marriage was deemed to be a valid bond, and he was not granted an annulment. They had been married 10 years and had 3 kids. All this came up when their oldest was getting ready for first communion, and their pastor discovered that they hadn't been married in the church. There are some pastors that deal with these kinds of cases with compassion through the confessional. There are people who go to confession on Saturday night so they can receive communion on Sunday morning, and then go right back to their boyfriend's bed. Not the way it is supposed to work. It is a major pain at times to know the truth, and be held to a higher standard.

How we handled our 6 months was frequent confession, and not receiving communion. What you have to understand is that the sacrament of marriage is the only sacrament not actually conferred by a clergy. The sacrament itself is conferred on the couple, by each other, with the priest or deacon as a witness. That's why our church ceremony was called a marriage blessing, and not a wedding. Our pastor was very compassionate with us, he knew the difficult position we were in, and I might joke that I worried about getting hit by a car, but I really didn't. I knew that our marriage was sacramental, and would eventually be recognized by the church, but in the meantime, we were not "in communion" with the church. That didn't mean we weren't Catholic, it didn't mean we could skip mass, it just meant we couldn't receive communion. That was pretty weird at daily masses, I'll admit.

What you need to do is calm down, and ask the Lord to give you the perseverance to endure whatever your pastor requires of you. Take it one step at a time, together. You will find in the long run that your marriage will be stronger for having gone through it. The first time we received communion together as husband and wife will live with me forever. It was worth the wait.

havok579257
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1594709' date='Jul 8 2008, 12:09 AM']I knew a couple once through my tribunal work, that the husband's first marriage was deemed to be a valid bond, and he was not granted an annulment. They had been married 10 years and had 3 kids. All this came up when their oldest was getting ready for first communion, and their pastor discovered that they hadn't been married in the church. There are some pastors that deal with these kinds of cases with compassion through the confessional. There are people who go to confession on Saturday night so they can receive communion on Sunday morning, and then go right back to their boyfriend's bed. Not the way it is supposed to work. It is a major pain at times to know the truth, and be held to a higher standard.

How we handled our 6 months was frequent confession, and not receiving communion. What you have to understand is that the sacrament of marriage is the only sacrament not actually conferred by a clergy. The sacrament itself is conferred on the couple, by each other, with the priest or deacon as a witness. That's why our church ceremony was called a marriage blessing, and not a wedding. Our pastor was very compassionate with us, he knew the difficult position we were in, and I might joke that I worried about getting hit by a car, but I really didn't. I knew that our marriage was sacramental, and would eventually be recognized by the church, but in the meantime, we were not "in communion" with the church. That didn't mean we weren't Catholic, it didn't mean we could skip mass, it just meant we couldn't receive communion. That was pretty weird at daily masses, I'll admit.

What you need to do is calm down, and ask the Lord to give you the perseverance to endure whatever your pastor requires of you. Take it one step at a time, together. You will find in the long run that your marriage will be stronger for having gone through it. The first time we received communion together as husband and wife will live with me forever. It was worth the wait.[/quote]

I guess I misunderstood your getting hit by a car line because i thought you were saying until you were offical in the church you were technically living in mortal sin.

havok579257
Posted

so any answer on what the church expects a married couple to do in this situation until the marriage is offical?

  • 4 weeks later...
Posted

Hi,
I am the unofficial poster child for this situation.
Baptised Catholic.
Never raised Catholic.
Married to a divorced Catholic in a Presbyterian Church where I was a member, married to him for 10 years.
Decided at-one-ment with the Catholic Church,
went through RCIA,
hubby applied for an annulment,
lived as brother and sister,
and finally married in the Church.

Any questions?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...