Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Some *rumors* of the Pope *considering* changing certain aspects of the Novus Ordo, though *unconfirmed* still very interesting!

===QUOTE===
[b]
Changes in the Liturgy (OF) - All Sacramental Formulae in Latin?[/b]
by Gregor Kollmorgen
Thursday, July 03, 2008
[url="http://thenewliturgicalmovement.blogspot.com/2008/07/changes-in-liturgy-of.html"][u]Link to article[/u][/url]

[color="#0000FF"]Ignazio Ingrao, religion writer of the Italian weekly Panorama, has the following [url="http://dagospia.excite.it/articolo_index_41774.html"][u]article[/u][/url] in this weeks Panorama (NLM translation):

[i]BENEDICT CHANGES THE MASS - THE STUDY OF THE NEW LITURGY ASSIGNED TO THE CONGREGATION FOR WORSHIP

The rite of the Mass could change. According to some indiscretions, Benedict XVI has charged the Congregation for Divine Worship to study some modifications in the liturgy. In particular, the Pope is said to have the intention to restore Latin for the formula for the Eucharistic consecration within the Mass in the "vernacular language", i.e. the one celebrated in the different national languages. The same could happen to the formulae of Baptism, Confirmation, Confession and of the other sacraments. In addition, the exchange of peace among the faithful during the Mass, which today takes place prior to the distribution of the Eucharist, could be anticipated (as in the Ambrosian rite) to the offertory so as not to disturb the recollection that precedes Communion.

These would be changes which would be added to the changes in the liturgy and regarding sacred vestments which the Pope, together with his Master of Ceremonies, Monsignor Guido Marini, has made in recent months, to recover ancient traditions: the restoration of the crucifix at the center of the altar, the distribution of Communion to the faithful in the mouth while kneeling, the recovery of the pastoral staff of Pius IX (the ferula), the changing of the style of pallium (the strip of white wool with red crosses worn by the Pope), the restoration of the papal throne used in the Consistory and the celebration of Mass with the back to the assembly, as happened in January in the Sistine Chapel.[/i]


Evidently if this is accurate, this is huge and wonderful news. However, so far we do well to treat this with great caution and as what it is: a rumour. It should be noted, though, that the moving of the sign of peace to the offertory is something of which Pope Benedict had already indicated in Sacramentum Caritatis that he would let the CDW study it. But the big news would obviously be the recovery of Latin for all the sacramental formulae. This would not only be a recovery of tradition for these themselves, but it would very effectively underscore the importance of Latin for the enitre liturgy of the Roman rite at its core, and might also help to regain a sense for the importance of the sacramental formulae which has been lost or at least blurred in many places. These are some first thoughts right after reading this; perhaps we will post some further considerations later. But keep in mind that this so far is just a rumour, and even the rumour only says that this is being studied.

Posted by Gregor Kollmorgen on 3.7.08 - [/color]

===END QUOTE===

Posted

JMJ
7/5 - Thirteenth Saturday

When Francis Cardinal George addressed the seminarians at Mundelein last fall, a student asked him to speak a little about Summorum Pontificum. The thrust of his thoughts was that Benedict is starting a SLOW process to bring the liturgical rituals together, not into the Ordinary/Extraordinary Form exclusively, but into a [i]tertium quid[/i]. This article seems to substantiate his thoughts.

Posted
:unsure: I have enough trouble confessing in [i]English[/i]...
Archaeology cat
Posted

Interesting. I certainly wouldn't be opposed to this.

Totus Tuus
Posted

It sounds as if he simply wants the Mass of Vatican II to be celebrated according to the original intention of the Council Fathers... As far as I know it was supposed to be the norm for the Canon of the Mass to remain in Latin, with other parts having the option of vernacular.

But I am not arguing that there could be another formula in the making... that sounds possible. It just sounds more like he's bringing the integrity of the original intention of the Mass of Vatican II back into play (if it ever was...)

TeresaBenedicta
Posted

Yay!

Well. The only part that kinda makes me iffy is latin in the confessional. I know I wouldn't have to [i]confess[/i] in latin, but I like hearing that my sins are forgiven in english.

CatholicCid
Posted

[quote name='Totus Tuus' post='1592027' date='Jul 5 2008, 12:16 PM']It sounds as if he simply wants the Mass of Vatican II to be celebrated according to the original intention of the Council Fathers... As far as I know it was supposed to be the norm for the Canon of the Mass to remain in Latin, with other parts having the option of vernacular.

But I am not arguing that there could be another formula in the making... that sounds possible. It just sounds more like he's bringing the integrity of the original intention of the Mass of Vatican II back into play (if it ever was...)[/quote]

That's what I was thinking as well. Trying to put the norms into more regular use.

Posted (edited)

I think bringing back the old Roman Canon in Latin would be a great idea.

Edited by mortify
Totus Tuus
Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1592047' date='Jul 5 2008, 01:42 PM']I think bringing back the old Roman Canon in Latin would be a great idea.[/quote]

It really is beautiful. It's very similar to the NO Canon in Latin, but there are differences.

Posted

definately some good rumors Mortify!!!!

Posted

You all would not have to confess in Latin, the priest would simply absolve you in Latin.

dominicansoul
Posted

HIP HIP HOORAY!@!!!!!


:yahoo:

Posted

[quote name='TeresaBenedicta' post='1592041' date='Jul 5 2008, 01:35 PM']Yay!

Well. The only part that kinda makes me iffy is latin in the confessional. I know I wouldn't have to [i]confess[/i] in latin, but I like hearing that my sins are forgiven in english.[/quote]


i was thinking the same thing.....those words of absolution bring so much peace to my soul. i can't really imagine hearing something different (i know its the same, just a different language). i guess i could grow accustomed to it...but i do think i would prefer that part in english.

Posted

Nice rumour. I believe what they described was how the masses were performed at the Eucharistic Congress... except, maybe the consecration wasn't in Latin. But there were a lot of Latin parts so we could worship together as an international community ^_^ ex Pater Noster...

Posted

I wonder if any Novus Ordo priest can just say the Canon, or at least the Consecration, in Latin without permission. Seems like this would be in line with the Second Vatican Council and rubrics of the mass, right?

Posted

JM + JT

[quote name='mortify' post='1592129' date='Jul 5 2008, 02:33 PM']I wonder if any Novus Ordo priest can just say the Canon, or at least the Consecration, in Latin without permission. Seems like this would be in line with the Second Vatican Council and rubrics of the mass, right?[/quote]
The daily Masses on EWTN sometimes do so. I was watching it yesterday and a lot was in Latin. Didn't catch the consecration part, though.

CatholicCid
Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1592129' date='Jul 5 2008, 01:33 PM']I wonder if any Novus Ordo priest can just say the Canon, or at least the Consecration, in Latin without permission. Seems like this would be in line with the Second Vatican Council and rubrics of the mass, right?[/quote]

I believe Latin would be the norm, but that the vernacular is a valid option? Could be wrong though.

I think there was a thread a while back about a Priest changing a few words of the Consecration in the English that were badly translated, however, he made the change without permission. The response was that he should not make any unapproved changes and could just revert to the Latin so he would not have to say what he considered to be poorly translated.

Posted

Bring back the Latin! :woot:

Posted

The New Liturgical Movement web site, which brought the Italian report to the attention of English-speaking readers, cautioned that the Panorama report should be treated "with great caution." The Panorama story itself suggests only that the Pope has asked for a study of the proposals-- not that he is prepared to implement the changes.

According to the Italian weekly, the Pope is weighing the use of Latin for the formula of Consecration at Mass. He may also be leaning toward the use of Latin in other sacraments.

Pope Benedict has often expressed a desire to enrich the post-conciliar liturgy by incorporating some aspects of older liturgical practices. The proposed changes could be seen as part of that process.
[url="http://www.cwnews.com/news/viewstory.cfm?recnum=59474"]http://www.cwnews.com/news/viewstory.cfm?recnum=59474[/url]

Paddington
Posted

Absolution in Latin could keep a priest from using synonyms that break the rule.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...