Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Myers Desecrates The Eucharist


Recommended Posts

CatholicDefender
Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1607953' date='Jul 24 2008, 11:29 PM']+J.M.J.+

Um, no. see below.
+J.M.J.+[/quote]

What I mean is that if you were in the same room as him or anyone else about to do that you wouldn't stop them by force? Hopefully you would. I would NEVER be able to sit there and quitly pray while that was going on near me. Catholics need to act at times as well.

EstoVir_TheWay_4
Posted

Something like this is terrible, but it can really bring out the beauty of the mystery of the Eucharist. Jesus humbles himself so much that he would die on a cross for our sins, but he didn't just die. He gave us his body in the Eucharist, humbling himself so much that his sacred body can be desecrated. He shows us how to endure persecution.

I don't think we should react violently, but if I was in the room, it would require a lot of self control to not punch this guy out.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='CatholicDefender' post='1608126' date='Jul 25 2008, 07:04 AM']What I mean is that if you were in the same room as him or anyone else about to do that you wouldn't stop them by force? Hopefully you would. I would NEVER be able to sit there and quitly pray while that was going on near me. Catholics need to act at times as well.[/quote]

:yes:

I wouldn't kill him but if I were in a room and I saw anyone doing that I would make an attempt to stop the act.

Edited by picchick
Posted

[quote name='CatholicDefender' post='1608126' date='Jul 25 2008, 05:04 AM']What I mean is that if you were in the same room as him or anyone else about to do that you wouldn't stop them by force? Hopefully you would. I would NEVER be able to sit there and quitly pray while that was going on near me. Catholics need to act at times as well.[/quote]
+J.M.J.+
:sweat: i thought you meant that we should go beat him up or something like that! :lol: yeah, i agree that you should stop someone from taking the Eucharist like that. :)

God bless

thessalonian
Posted

I sent an email. Hope his box if full by now.

Posted

Yikes....I actually attend the University of Minnesota.

I will say that at their Student Organizations week where the student organizations across campus sponsored activities for students, there were plenty of liberal, anti-Christian groups such as Students for Choice, Students Atheists and Humanists league, College Democrats etc. that sponsored activities.

How many conservative groups (The St. Lawrence Newman Center, Students for Life, College Republicans, etc.) were represented? NONE.

lilac_angel
Posted

[quote name='zabbazooey' post='1608295' date='Jul 25 2008, 11:40 AM']Yikes....I actually attend the University of Minnesota.

I will say that at their Student Organizations week where the student organizations across campus sponsored activities for students, there were plenty of liberal, anti-Christian groups such as Students for Choice, Students Atheists and Humanists league, College Democrats etc. that sponsored activities.

How many conservative groups (The St. Lawrence Newman Center, Students for Life, College Republicans, etc.) were represented? NONE.[/quote]

Yikes. Quite ironic, too, since Catholics founded the first universities. And I thought Pitt was ultra liberal... at least they had a Newman Center.

Thanks for posting that St. Clare novena, Archeology_cat.

Archaeology cat
Posted (edited)

[quote name='lilac_angel' post='1608337' date='Jul 25 2008, 06:40 PM']Thanks for posting that St. Clare novena, Archeology_cat.[/quote]
No problem. Gotta love Google searches. :))

ETA: If anyone is also interested in a novena to St. Monica instead/in addition, here it is (I :love: St. Monica):

[quote]Exemplary Mother of the Great Augustine,
You perserveringly pursued your wayward son
Not with wild threats
But with prayerful cries to heaven.

Intercede for all mothers in our day
So that they may learn
To draw their children to God.

Teach them how to remain
Close to their children,
Even the prodigal sons and daughters
Who have sadly gone astray.

Dear St Monica, troubled wife and mother,
Many sorrows pierced your heart
During your lifetime.
Yet you never despaired or lost faith.
With confidence, persistence and profound faith,
You prayed daily for the conversion
Of your beloved husband, Patricius
And your beloved son, Augustine.

Grant me that same fortitude,
Patience and trust in the Lord.
Intercede for me, dear St. Monica,
That God may favorably hear my plea
For

(mention your petition here)

And grant me the grace
To accept his will in all things,
Through Jesus Christ, our Lord,
In the unity of the Holy Spirit,
One God forever and ever. Amen.[/quote]

Edited by Archaeology cat
Spamity Calamity
Posted

This is what I emailed him using that address at the beginning of the thread:

Dear Mr. Meyers
I forgive you for hurting me and other Catholics so much. God will also forgive you if you let him. I hope that you can eventually come to terms with the pain you have caused because of your intolerance for others beliefs and forgive yourself as well. Good luck and much love.

asAlilyAmongThorns
Posted

I think this guy must have a death wish. Doesn't he remember what happened with the Muslim extremists after that dutch [i]cartoon[/i]? I really also can't stand how he just preaches about logic and reason when there is none to this. He also "desecrated" that atheist book by Richard Dawkins. Isn't that his supposed cause? This whole thing just breaks my heart. I will certainly pray for all his "followers" and himself.

Posted

[quote][b]Commentary:[/b]
As often as atheists accuse Christians and other religious groups of irrational hate crimes, here we have a clear act of hate by an avowed atheist professor.[/quote]

It's not a clear act of hate. He has never, that I know of expressed hatred towards Catholics. He was perfectly nice on the interview linked here.

When Atheists mention irrational religious hate crimes they generally mean Muslims killing a Blasphemer, a Pentecostal Christian shooting an abortion doctor, of a Christian tying a gay man to a fence and beating him to death. This was not a hate crime.

It was unbefitting a professor and a strong bit of evidence of the stark nihilism enveloping the Western World.

[quote]His action will gain cheers from his audience of “godless liberals”, and everyone else will simply “not get it” or be angry. In the eyes of Catholics he hasn’t accomplished anything beyond sacrilege[/quote]

Not all the "godless" are liberals.

[quote]and in the eyes of Muslims…well…let’s hope some of the more radical Muslims don’t find out about his hate crime. They very well could call for his death.[/quote]

Donahue (ap?) tried to get CAIR to be involved. He Dr. Myers says he has yet to receive any hate mail from a single Muslim.

This last little tidbit from you is a prime reason many non-Catholics don't have any sympathy for you all in this case. This constant juvenile whining about someone not also offending the Muslims. Guess what? Muslims did not threaten his life, call him a c***, threaten his children, try to get him fired, or call him Satan. Roman Catholics did. A very wise fellow once commanded his followers to remove the logs from their own eyes before removing the spec from their brother’s eyes. I don't mean to say the problems in the Muslim community are a "speck" next to the Catholic "log" or anything like that. My point perhaps you all should make sure that other Catholics won't respond with such sadistic fantasies and death treats before complaining about how no one bothers the violent Muslims fanatics, but only the peace loving Catholics.



[quote]I still have no idea what his point was.[/quote]

He said he got the idea from Church History. Good deals of Jews were violently murdered in Catholic lands by Catholics due to rumors that they stole hosts and drove rusty nails through them. I suppose he found it ironic. Beyond that he said his point was to prove that "nothing is sacred"

I found his decision immature and nihilistic.

[quote]What did he think was going to happen? By committing a hate crime against Christians did he think that Christians would suddenly go “oh, you are right, we should become godless liberals too”? His commentary after desecrating the Eucharist clearly shows that he is completely ignorant of the Christian and Islamic faiths. He is attacking the two largest groups of people in the world and doesn’t have a clue why. Perhaps it is as simple as ignorance of history, perhaps it is some kind of mental illness.[/quote]


?

[quote]The right course of action now would be for the university to fire him as he has committed a hate crime[/quote]

That is not a hate crime.

Let me take a page out of your book. I try to be respectful of religious objects, however I have, on occasion, tossed my Qur'an and/or Bible carelessly on my bed. I also will carry both in my backpack. I have treated the Qur'an disrespectful, is that a hate crime? Of course not. Like Myers this was done on private property and there was no intent to intimidate anyone.

[quote]and for Catholics to pray for him. What he will likely fail to understand is that no matter how much he hates people of faith, we still don’t hate him. As Christians, we love you Professor Myers and will pray for the conversion of your soul before you are judged for your actions.[/quote]


I think you all should see this through a different pair of eyes. Many people have noted "look how offended Muslims got over a cartoon!". The same idea is going on here, "look how offended Catholics got over a piece of unleven bread!". A man threatens to desecrate a piece of bread, which you all claim to be the substance of your lord. This man has been physically threatened (as has his family) and many here are working tirelessly to get him fired from his job, all for something he did in his home, and mentioned on his blog.

People loose interest after a while. I constantly here people talk about "anti-Catholicism" I know about it and I experienced it. I was raised Catholic in the good old south. I have been asked if I was raped by a Priest a number of times and other mocking,vulgar things, however not everything is anti-Catholic bigotry. Acting outraged when Birth Control ads are aired on television, Amnesty International says abortions are a women rights issue, people attack the way the Church handled the abuse scandal etc doesn’t help. When some Catholics claims every little thing that does not conform to their faith is some new wave of "anti-Catholicism" people stop listening after a while and just loose interest, "oh wow, the Catholics are offended over something, what a shock" becomes an internalized response.

When Bill Donahue constantly calls homosexual lifestyles "the homosexual death style" people really stop paying attention when he comes crying that someone hurt his feelings. Believe it of not some Jews get really offended when Catholics constantly call abortion a Holocaust, say it is a "new, larger holocaust" etc. It is really fairly rude to use the near extermination of the Jewish people for your political agenda. Catholics who do this are piggybacking on the emotional impact people experience when the holocaust is mentioned and some Jews really take offense to that. I constantly see Catholic talk about, "just imagine how the MUSLIMS would react if anyone tried that on them" Constantly implying that one religious group is made up of violent savages, unlike the you, the poor morally superior peace loving Catholics can be very offensive to many Muslims. Same thing with claiming their religion is the work of Satan, that their leader was a pedophile, that their Holy text is a violent bloody book that no morally sound person could truly consider divine etc can all be highly offensive.

I am not trying to chastise all Catholics. What I am saying that that, "Charity starts at home" if you yourselves cannot be charitable and accepting of other faiths and lifestyles, then how in the world can you expect other people to be charitable and accecpting to your beliefs? You cannot one the one hand claim to be peaceful and forgiving, and at the same time try to get this man fired. Perhaps it works for you, but others see it as hypocrisy, plain and simple.

The most visible and active element of the American Roman Catholic community has aligned itself with the right wing. The most notable Roman Catholics on television are Laura Ingrahm, Sean Hannity, Bill Donahue, that blond guy on “Fox and Friends” et al. With the exception of Colbert most public Catholics are associated with the national forces of American Exceptionalism and intolerance, and while it is not fair to the average Catholic these people come to reflect on the Catholic community at large.

Posted

[quote name='Spamity Calamity' post='1608482' date='Jul 25 2008, 03:40 PM']This is what I emailed him using that address at the beginning of the thread:

Dear Mr. Meyers
I forgive you for hurting me and other Catholics so much. God will also forgive you if you let him. I hope that you can eventually come to terms with the pain you have caused because of your intolerance for others beliefs and forgive yourself as well. Good luck and much love.[/quote]


I think if all Catholics responded like this there would be a lot more public outcry

lost_in_this_world
Posted

I've been trying to keep up with this story a little bit and I don't care if your an atheist or not. If you personally don't believe that the sacred eucharist is Jesus, then don't worry about it. I view this story as just a disrepectful person looking for attention

lilac_angel
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Hassan' post='1608592' date='Jul 25 2008, 07:09 PM']I think you all should see this through a different pair of eyes. Many people have noted "look how offended Muslims got over a cartoon!". The same idea is going on here, "look how offended Catholics got over a piece of unleven bread!".[/quote]

There is a very large difference between a cartoon and what we believe to be the very Body of God. Remember, we don't believe that it's just bread. If we did, then perhaps that would be a more valid analogy.

[quote]A man threatens to desecrate a piece of bread, which you all claim to be the substance of your lord. This man has been physically threatened (as has his family) and many here are working tirelessly to get him fired from his job, all for something he did in his home, and mentioned on his blog.[/quote]

He threatened to desecrate and did desecrate Christ's Body. Those who are angry are justified, those who respond with sadness are justified, as long as the responses are tempered with Christian forgiveness and love.

He obviously knew how much attention this would get him - he obviously knew that what he did was a very controversial thing that would anger many. What did he expect? Anyone with half a brain would know that the act would have repercussions, and he's a professor, so I'm pretty sure he has half a brain.

[quote]When some Catholics claims every little thing that does not conform to their faith is some new wave of "anti-Catholicism" people stop listening after a while and just loose interest, "oh wow, the Catholics are offended over something, what a shock" becomes an internalized response.[/quote]

This wasn't just something that didn't "conform to" our "faith." It was a very overt act of desecration. And to deny the existence of a very real wave of anti-Catholicism is simply illogical. It's not even all that subtle most of the time. To expect us not to be saddened or angered by it is a little unreasonable and not a proper understanding of human nature. However, we shouldn't stoop to his level, we should respond as Christians. We don't have to be happy about it (Jesus wasn't happy about everything that went on around him), but we still must act as Christ taught us.

[quote]When Bill Donahue constantly calls homosexual lifestyles "the homosexual death style" people really stop paying attention when he comes crying that someone hurt his feelings. Believe it of not some Jews get really offended when Catholics constantly call abortion a Holocaust, say it is a "new, larger holocaust" etc. It is really fairly rude to use the near extermination of the Jewish people for your political agenda.[/quote]

Actually, the first definition of "holocaust" in the dictionary is: "Great destruction resulting in the extensive loss of life"... we don't base it on the Jewish holocaust. The Jewish holocaust was called such a thing because it was one example of the above definition.

[quote]if you yourselves cannot be charitable and accepting of other faiths and lifestyles, then how in the world can you expect other people to be charitable and accecpting to your beliefs? You cannot one the one hand claim to be peaceful and forgiving, and at the same time try to get this man fired. Perhaps it works for you, but others see it as hypocrisy, plain and simple.[/quote]

Many of us are praying and/or fasting as reparations and not focused or even interested in getting him fired. Most responses on this thread have been quite charitable, and I'm sure that a great many Catholic blogs are focused on praying for the man's conversion. To expect us to sit back and say "that's fine, maan, whatever floats his boat" that he drove a nail through the body of Christ and continue about our day as if nothing happened, though, is a little unreasonable to ask of someone who believes in the Real Presence.

[quote]The most visible and active element of the American Roman Catholic community has aligned itself with the right wing. The most notable Roman Catholics on television are Laura Ingrahm, Sean Hannity, Bill Donahue, that blond guy on “Fox and Friends” et al. With the exception of Colbert most public Catholics are associated with the national forces of American Exceptionalism and intolerance, and while it is not fair to the average Catholic these people come to reflect on the Catholic community at large.[/quote]

"The average Catholic" is generally misinformed and not at all passionate about their faith and many do not even believe that Christ is truly present in the Eucharist, even though that's what the Church has taught since the beginning. So of course those people would not be as offended as more devout Catholics. Not to imply that all right wing people are more devoutly Catholic. Intolerance comes in all shapes and sizes. Homosexuals in Brazil are working on a law that will imprison Christians for showing their differences in beliefs.

Edited by lilac_angel
Posted

[quote name='lilac_angel' post='1608607' date='Jul 25 2008, 07:29 PM']There is a very large difference between a cartoon and what we believe to be the very Body of God.[/quote]

For Muslims it is not just a cartoon, it was a Blasphemy and a powerful insult to all Muslims. I understand that you believe it to be your God that is fine. However if you minimize and trivialize other people's religious sensibilities, then you are not likely to find much sympathy from others when yours are offended.

I am not condemning the Catholic community at large, I am asking you to look at how many in your community treat other religious, and see how this may affect the lack of sympathy others feel towards Catholics. When I first heard of this act I myself was offended that he would do something like this. However after seeing enough condescending/insulting allusions towards Muslims and other is became less distressing.

I am not trying to insult you, I am simply giving an outsider point of view.

[quote]Remember, we don't believe that it's just bread. If we did, then perhaps that would be a more valid analogy.[/quote]

I understand what you believe. And when I attend Mass I do not receive the Eucharist because I feel it would be disrespectful to the faithful, I simply receive a blessing.

To you it is just a cartoon; to Muslims it is a personal insult that strikes at the very core of their religious faith. You cannot trivialize the pain they feel at seeing their prophet mocked, or their Holy Book desecrated, and then demand that people respect your religious objects. I understand that not all Catholics fall in these categories; however I am talking about a very vocal part of your faith community.

[quote]He threatened to desecrate and did desecrate Christ's Body. Those who are angry are justified, those who respond with sadness are justified, as long as the responses are tempered with Christian forgiveness and love.[/quote]

I never said you did not have a right to be angry. Now many of them were not tempered with love and kindness (not here, the Catholic response in general). Calling someone an extremely insulting and misogynistic term and threatening to bash his f-ing head in is not loving. I never said you were not justified in being frustrated of angry, you have every right to be. I said you may want to focus on your own faith community before setting up this false contrast between the peaceful Catholics and the violent Muslims.


[quote]He obviously knew how much attention this would get him - he obviously knew that what he did was a very controversial thing that would anger many. What did he expect? Anyone with half a brain would know that the act would have repercussions, and he's a professor, so I'm pretty sure he has half a brain.[/quote]

I'm surprised you would admit that the rather vulgar, violent, and threatening response from some Catholics was predictable and to be expected.

Posted

[quote]This wasn't just something that didn't "conform to" our "faith." It was a very overt act of desecration.[/quote]

I was obviously not referring to the desecration given my reference to Birth Control and other things. When you have Bill Donahue calling so many trivial things anti-Catholicism then people ignore genuine complaints, like this one, of someone committing a highly vulgar and insulting act with the intention of offending Catholics.

[quote]And to deny the existence of a very real wave of anti-Catholicism is simply illogical.[/quote]

It wouldn’t be illogical, logical deductions has nothing to do with this. I never denied anti-Catholic bigotry exists. I mentioned that I have experienced plenty of it, and still se it from street preachers. However I have seen the most trivial things labeled anti-Catholic, I have also seen valid criticisms labeled anti-Catholic.

My point is the same one the protagonist in "the boy who cried wolf" learned. When Bill and others continually cry wolf over silly and trivial things, then when the real wolf comes, people likely won't pay attention.

[quote]It's not even all that subtle most of the time. To expect us not to be saddened or angered by it is a little unreasonable and not a proper understanding of human nature.[/quote]

Again, I never claimed you shouldn’t be saddened

[quote]However, we shouldn't stoop to his level, we should respond as Christians.[/quote]

I agree.

In his interview he showed willingness to compromise. I think he said he would consider some deal where a Church leader would renounce threats of violence and intimidation by Catholics in return for the Hosts being returned. I think perhaps Bill Donahue should have spent less time trying to get him fired and more time trying to work with him. He didn’t (so far as I can tell) and now no one has won. The Hosts have been desecrated, and per the wishes of so many Catholics the Qur’an has also been desecrated and now Muslims will have the opportunity to feel the same pain you feel for these Hosts (perhaps next Mr. Donahue can dare him to rub some pork on a Torah roll and toss that away, no reason anyone needs to escape without feeling like the very soul of their religion has been desecrated I suppose). Myers looks (deservedly so) like a bit of a looser with nothing better to do then type in his blog and offend Catholics and Muslims, and everyone is still upset. No good has come out of trying to bully respect

[quote]We don't have to be happy about it (Jesus wasn't happy about everything that went on around him), but we still must act as Christ taught us.[/quote]

And I think if the more high profile members of the Catholic Community in America followed this you may have had a better response.


[quote]Actually, the first definition of "holocaust" in the dictionary is: "Great destruction resulting in the extensive loss of life"... we don't base it on the Jewish holocaust.[/quote]

Let's be honest here and not be to clever by half. When someone says the word "Holocaust" in present American culture, what does almost every single American assume they are referring to?

What other event is called "holocaust" that one would be referring to when they say, "a new Holocaust"?



[quote]The Jewish holocaust was called such a thing because it was one example of the above definition.[/quote]
And what would be another example?

There have been, and are, a disturbingly high number of genocidal atrocities in human history. However it is the systematic genocide of the Jewish People (primarily, but many others died as well) during the reign of Adolf Hitler that is called the "Holocaust".

Can you honestly say that when Catholics claim abortion is "a new Holocaust" they are not making direct reference to the genocidal campaign of Adolf Hitler?


[quote]Many of us are praying and/or fasting as reparations and not focused or even interested in getting him fired. Most responses on this thread have been quite charitable, and I'm sure that a great many Catholic blogs are focused on praying for the man's conversion. To expect us to sit back and say "that's fine, maan, whatever floats his boat" that he drove a nail through the body of Christ and continue about our day as if nothing happened, though, is a little unreasonable to ask of someone who believes in the Real Presence.[/quote]

I never ONCE asked you to do such a thing. I asked you to consider the violent elements of your community, and to take this opportunity to consider how you approach other religions and groups.


[quote]"The average Catholic" is generally misinformed and not at all passionate about their faith and many do not even believe that Christ is truly present in the Eucharist, even though that's what the Church has taught since the beginning. So of course those people would not be as offended as more devout Catholics. Not to imply that all right wing people are more devoutly Catholic. Intolerance comes in all shapes and sizes. Homosexuals in Brazil are working on a law that will imprison Christians for showing their differences in beliefs.[/quote]

I never denied that intolerance comes from all sizes. However you all cannot be asked to affect the behavior of Muslim bigots or homosexual bigots, you all as a community can only be asked to affect the behavior of bigots and hateful individuals within your own community, and that is all I am asking.

Posted (edited)

Lord have mercy on him, some Catholics might...but if a cartoon can set off some overseas Muslims, this will make a frenzy from that margin.

Edited by BG45
Posted

[quote name='BG45' post='1608844' date='Jul 25 2008, 09:58 PM']Lord have mercy on him, Catholics might...but if a cartoon can set off some overseas Muslims, this will make a frenzy.[/quote]


point in case

Brother Adam
Posted

For the record, Bill Donahue is not the only member of the Catholic League. He is merely the president so most communications are sent in his name. Here is a list of the board of directors and advisers:

Board of Directors

[b]Raymond Arroyo[/b]
Thomas Brennan
Nunzio Cardone
Ann Corkery
Kathleen Hunt
William Lindner
Robert Lockwood
Marilyn Lundy
Jerome McDougal
Frank Salas
Jodie Thompson, Jr.
Kenneth Whitehead

Rev. Philip Eichner, Chairman
William Donohue, President
Bernadette Brady, Vice President

David Gregory, General Counsel
Board of Advisors

Brent Bozell III
Gerard Bradley
Linda Chavez
Robert Destro
Dinesh D'Souza
Laura Garcia
Robert George
Mary Ann Glendon
Dolores Grier
[b]Alan Keyes[/b]
Stephen Krason
Lawrence Kudlow
Thomas Monaghan
[b]Michael Novak[/b]
Kate O'Beirne
Thomas Reeves
Patrick Riley
Robert Royal
Ronald Rychlak
[b]Russell Shaw[/b]
William Simon, Jr.
Joe Varacalli
Paul Vitz
[b]George Weigel [/b]

Some of the most respected princes of the Church praise their work. If you believe their work is "trivial" or "boy who cries wolf" and negatively affects the overall view of society towards Catholics you should contact the League with your grievance.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...