Aloysius Posted July 26, 2008 Posted July 26, 2008 Muslims believe God was offended by the image of Mohammad. We believe God Himself in corporeal form was desecrated. if something the Muslims believed was actually God himself was desecrated, the Muslim's level of outrage would be greater than it was over the cartoons. Even a desecration of the Koran would not compare if they believed something to actually be God and it were stolen and desecrated. and nothing, absolutely nothing, would ever justify the level of riots and the damage it caused to innocent people when the muslims were outraged over those cartoons. in addition, the level of respect expected of non-muslims is waay more than the level of respect we are asking the likes of Myers for. they expect non-Muslims not to do satire against them. all we're asking for here is don't take something from our religious service to desecrate it. now, many of the things Bill Donahue campaigns against are the equivalent of the Muslim cartoons; this particular thing is not. our level of outrage ought to be accepted as understandably higher than the muslim's level of outrage... and we didn't riot in the streets and burn down universities and murder professors.
lilac_angel Posted July 26, 2008 Posted July 26, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Hassan' post='1608818' date='Jul 25 2008, 09:47 PM']For Muslims it is not just a cartoon, it was a Blasphemy and a powerful insult to all Muslims. I understand that you believe it to be your God that is fine. However if you minimize and trivialize other people's religious sensibilities, then you are not likely to find much sympathy from others when yours are offended.[/quote] The thing I myself tend to hear most commonly from Catholics is the discontent over the very rampant attacks on Catholicism that are equal to or even, in some cases, greater than the religious attacks on the Muslim community (like the cartoon) and expressing the discontent and frustration that people are allowed to get away with much more when attacking Catholics than they are Muslims in general. It is much more "politically correct" in many countries to denounce Christianity and blaspheme, whereas it's much less permissible to do so to Muslims.. I think this is what people's points are and where their discontent arises. There is a double standard, and I'm not blaming the Muslims for it, simply what society chooses to deem acceptable or inacceptable. [quote]To you it is just a cartoon; to Muslims it is a personal insult that strikes at the very core of their religious faith. You cannot trivialize the pain they feel at seeing their prophet mocked, or their Holy Book desecrated, and then demand that people respect your religious objects. I understand that not all Catholics fall in these categories; however I am talking about a very vocal part of your faith community.[/quote] I think it is wrong as well to trivialize any kind of religious insults. However, we see our religion mocked regularly in movies, pop culture, misrepresented constantly in the media, etc., so I guess sometimes it shows that Catholics feel a bit slighted when the Muslims actually get a response and people respect their wishes, whereas anti-Christian sentiment is only fueled further by our anger and outcry. But on the other hand, we should keep in mind that it's to be expected that the world will hate us. Still, it's our duty to continue to prayerfully defend from outright misrepresentations of our faith and desecrations such as these. [quote]I never said you did not have a right to be angry. Now many of them were not tempered with love and kindness (not here, the Catholic response in general). Calling someone an extremely insulting and misogynistic term and threatening to bash his f-ing head in is not loving. I never said you were not justified in being frustrated of angry, you have every right to be. I said you may want to focus on your own faith community before setting up this false contrast between the peaceful Catholics and the violent Muslims.[/quote] We simply cannot control the actions of a few individuals and people who distort our own faith, just as the Muslim community cannot control everyone in their fold. It is indeed wrong to claim ourselves as peaceful as a whole and another religion as violent, for sure, but I didn't see that in this thread, so I guess I wondered why it was brought up here. [quote]I'm surprised you would admit that the rather vulgar, violent, and threatening response from some Catholics was predictable and to be expected.[/quote] Oh, no, that's not what I meant. I meant that he should have at least expected angry letters when he threatened desecration and should have expected the people who wanted him fired after the desecration. Not the death threats that stemmed from someone very misguided. But there will always be those who don't respond in the proper manner. He was potentially even aware of this possibility himself, and that this would make our entire faith community look bad, too. All the better to support his "cause"! Edited July 26, 2008 by lilac_angel
cmotherofpirl Posted July 26, 2008 Posted July 26, 2008 The man works for a state supported school and should be fired: President Robert H. Bruininks 202 Morrill Hall 100 Church Street S.E. University of Minnesota Minneapolis, MN 55455 Via phone: 612-626-1616 Via fax: 612-625-3875 Via e-mail: upres@umn.edu Chancellor Jacqueline Johnson 309 Behmler Hall 600 East 4th Street Morris, MN 56267 320-589-6020 E-mail: grussing@morris.umn.edu
lilac_angel Posted July 26, 2008 Posted July 26, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Hassan' post='1608820' date='Jul 25 2008, 09:48 PM']Let's be honest here and not be to clever by half. When someone says the word "Holocaust" in present American culture, what does almost every single American assume they are referring to? What other event is called "holocaust" that one would be referring to when they say, "a new Holocaust"? And what would be another example? There have been, and are, a disturbingly high number of genocidal atrocities in human history. However it is the systematic genocide of the Jewish People (primarily, but many others died as well) during the reign of Adolf Hitler that is called the "Holocaust". Can you honestly say that when Catholics claim abortion is "a new Holocaust" they are not making direct reference to the genocidal campaign of Adolf Hitler?[/quote] When it's termed "a new Holocaust," then yes, it does seem to make that reference. But I don't see that everywhere. I simply see "holocaust" sometimes. Being an English major, I simply see the word for what its meaning is, rather than comparing it to the Jewish Holocaust. Still, I wouldn't compare the two in any case, or make the case of one being greater than the other, because they are both atrocities. Others may not see the murder of millions of babies as serious as another type of mass murder, but Catholics do. We aren't calling it a Holocaust to belittle or offend another religious group; if anything, we are simply drawing public attention to what it is, according to what the word actually means and represents. We are not saying a "new, worse Jewish Holocaust." I've seen, more commonly, "the holocaust of [x] amount of unborn babies each year"... Historically, yes, the Holocaust with a capital H commonly refers to the holocaust of Adolf Hitler. But I have also seen the term, admittedly with a lowercase h (but then it wasn't ever talking about millions of people each year) used for other genocides and atrocities in history books, etc., throughout my schooling. [quote]I never ONCE asked you to do such a thing. I asked you to consider the violent elements of your community, and to take this opportunity to consider how you approach other religions and groups. I never denied that intolerance comes from all sizes. However you all cannot be asked to affect the behavior of Muslim bigots or homosexual bigots, you all as a community can only be asked to affect the behavior of bigots and hateful individuals within your own community, and that is all I am asking.[/quote] As Aloyisuis said, Catholics are not rioting or murdering professors over this heinous act, and that happened in the Muslim community over the cartoon. Death threats are indeed wrong, and we noted that. We are not proud of those in our community who are inappropriately violent or even simply threatening such a thing (which is the case here), and we should probably also be writing letters to them. However, it's less likely that a letter would be as effective to someone who gives extremist death threats than to a learned professor who did a very premeditated act after a long period of time. Edited July 26, 2008 by lilac_angel
RosaMystica Posted July 26, 2008 Posted July 26, 2008 [quote name='doe-jo' post='1607864' date='Jul 24 2008, 10:28 PM']I'm up for another crusade... Agnus Dei, qui tolis peccata mundi, miserere nobis.[/quote] So am I! Anyone up for burning him at the stake?? Just kidding
mortify Posted July 26, 2008 Posted July 26, 2008 Hey Mandy, nice to see another Eastern Catholic, God bless you and wa salaam! As for Myers, he'll understand the implications of what he did after he dies. As for Muhammad cartoons, it's interesting how organized the protests were in the Islamic world over the Danish cartoons, yet after 9-11 there was virtual silence. Guess we see what really offends their religion
Hassan Posted July 26, 2008 Posted July 26, 2008 [quote name='Brother Adam' post='1608876' date='Jul 25 2008, 10:23 PM']For the record, Bill Donahue is not the only member of the Catholic League. He is merely the president so most communications are sent in his name. Here is a list of the board of directors and advisers: Board of Directors [b]Raymond Arroyo[/b] Thomas Brennan Nunzio Cardone Ann Corkery Kathleen Hunt William Lindner Robert Lockwood Marilyn Lundy Jerome McDougal Frank Salas Jodie Thompson, Jr. Kenneth Whitehead Rev. Philip Eichner, Chairman William Donohue, President Bernadette Brady, Vice President David Gregory, General Counsel Board of Advisors Brent Bozell III Gerard Bradley Linda Chavez Robert Destro Dinesh D'Souza Laura Garcia Robert George Mary Ann Glendon Dolores Grier [b]Alan Keyes[/b] Stephen Krason Lawrence Kudlow Thomas Monaghan [b]Michael Novak[/b] Kate O'Beirne Thomas Reeves Patrick Riley Robert Royal Ronald Rychlak [b]Russell Shaw[/b] William Simon, Jr. Joe Varacalli Paul Vitz [b]George Weigel [/b] Some of the most respected princes of the Church praise their work. If you believe their work is "trivial" or "boy who cries wolf" and negatively affects the overall view of society towards Catholics you should contact the League with your grievance.[/quote] I didn't say their work was, without exception, trivial. Just like I have never claimed that there is not anti-Catholic bigotry. I have no interest in contacting the Catholic League. I am simply trying to present an outside point of view and invite you all to look at your relationships with other groups and how the affects the way non-Catholics react to your complaints.
Hassan Posted July 26, 2008 Posted July 26, 2008 [quote name='mortify' post='1608991' date='Jul 26 2008, 01:32 AM']As for Muhammad cartoons, it's interesting how organized the protests were in the Islamic world over the Danish cartoons, yet after 9-11 there was virtual silence. Guess we see what really offends their religion [/quote] I don't think is fair, nor do I think you would appreciate that standard being applied to your religion. I do not remember any massive, large scale protests amongst Catholics in response to the IRA bombings of English civilians, or the various authoritarian atrocity wrecking Catholic dictators and military officials in South America. Christian atrocities in Lebanon. I don’t recall any massive protests by Orthodox Catholics during the Serbian led genocides in the Baltic. I don’t think it is fair to draw the conclusion that Catholics get upset when their religious objects get desecrated but say to hell with everyone else.
Hassan Posted July 26, 2008 Posted July 26, 2008 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1608884' date='Jul 25 2008, 10:29 PM']Muslims believe God was offended by the image of Mohammad. We believe God Himself in corporeal form was desecrated. if something the Muslims believed was actually God himself was desecrated, the Muslim's level of outrage would be greater than it was over the cartoons. Even a desecration of the Koran would not compare if they believed something to actually be God and it were stolen and desecrated.[/quote] Why does it matter? If the pain they feel over the Qur'an being desecrated is the same you feel with the Eucharist being desecrated what right do you have to say their outrage is less justified? [quote]and nothing, absolutely nothing, would ever justify the level of riots and the damage it caused to innocent people when the muslims were outraged over those cartoons.[/quote] I agree the murders and destruction was not warranted. [quote]in addition, the level of respect expected of non-Muslims is waay more than the level of respect we are asking the likes of Myers for. they expect non-Muslims not to do satire against them.[/quote] Really, "they" do? I never knew Muslims had come to some set standard of permutable offense. There is plenty of satire of Islam and Muslims. An American congressman went on a little rant when the first Muslims was elected to the House. Let's not pretend no one is allowed to insult Islam, plenty of people can and do to both Muslims and Islam. However this is not just about Muslims. I mentioned other cases. I am not saying all or even most Catholics are guilty of this intolerance, I am simply asking you to look at how some very vocal elements of your community affect your image to non-Catholics. [quote]all we're asking for here is don't take something from our religious service to desecrate it. now, many of the things Bill Donahue campaigns against are the equivalent of the Muslim cartoons; this particular thing is not. our level of outrage ought to be accepted as understandably higher than the Muslim’s level of outrage... and we didn't riot in the streets and burn down universities and murder professors.[/quote] no, you all just call him a c____, threaten to bash his F______ head in, try to get him fired and threaten his children. See? I can generalize too! Godel said a lot of brilliant things in his life, one of the most brilliant was probably, "all generalizations, with the possible exception of this one, are false". This is exactly my point. Some Priests did horrific things. They raped children and used their authority to keep these children in a sick concubine like relationship and did unimaginable psychological and physical damage to them. And some Bishops worked to cover these horrific incidents up and make the matter go away quietly. However not all, or even most Priests and Bishops had anything to do with this. And Catholics get (understandably)upset when comedians and others treat all Priests like pedophiles, or make broad generalizations about all Priests being child predators. So why is it acceptable to do this with Muslims? Most Muslims have never killed anyone, never vandalized property or anything like this. Why do you feel it is acceptable to make these generalizations about Muslims?
Hassan Posted July 26, 2008 Posted July 26, 2008 [quote name='lilac_angel' post='1608890' date='Jul 25 2008, 10:33 PM']The thing I myself tend to hear most commonly from Catholics is the discontent over the very rampant attacks on Catholicism that are equal to or even, in some cases, greater than the religious attacks on the Muslim community (like the cartoon) and expressing the discontent and frustration that people are allowed to get away with much more when attacking Catholics than they are Muslims in general. It is much more "politically correct" in many countries to denounce Christianity and blaspheme, whereas it's much less permissible to do so to Muslims.. I think this is what people's points are and where their discontent arises. There is a double standard, and I'm not blaming the Muslims for it, simply what society chooses to deem acceptable or inacceptable.[/quote] I think this double standard is something of an illusion (though I understand who this perception can cause frustration). [quote]I think it is wrong as well to trivialize any kind of religious insults. However, we see our religion mocked regularly in movies, pop culture, misrepresented constantly in the media, etc., so I guess sometimes it shows that Catholics feel a bit slighted when the Muslims actually get a response and people respect their wishes, whereas anti-Christian sentiment is only fueled further by our anger and outcry. But on the other hand, we should keep in mind that it's to be expected that the world will hate us. Still, it's our duty to continue to prayerfully defend from outright misrepresentations of our faith and desecrations such as these.[/quote] Yes, and in most movies (particularly in the 90's) if there was a Catholic Priest you could be sure he would be somehow corrupt, a hypocrite, a pedophile, or some other horrid portrayal. However I think Catholics tend not to notice when the same thing happens to Muslims. Think of all the Hollywood movies you have seen. I myself cannot think of a single occasion where a religious, faithful Muslims was portrayed as a hero, and certainly not the main character. Most portrayals of Muslims are overtly raciest and bigoted. Either the submissive empty headed servant like Muslim woman who looks to her husband for approval before speaking, or a ski mask wearing Mujahidin screaming in incoherent Arabic and waving a gun at the poor western woman before the hero kills him and saved the hostage from the dangerous fanatic. Look at news coverage. Please compare and contrast how many times a peaceful Muslims simply going about their lives is put up as opposed to a masked fanatic wavering a Qur'an in one hand and a SAW machine gun in the other. I understand that you all also get a lot of bad press, but look at the other side. You have dozens of representatives in Congress, your President’s brother and sister in law are Catholics, you have a great deal of very politically powerful Catholics in the United States, and you had over a week of highly laudatory coverage when Pope John Paul the Great died. My point is that while I understand that you feel frustrated at the response Muslims got when some of their community reacted with violence, you must also admit that the Catholic community has much more power, particularly in the United States then the Muslim community. While many Catholics didn't like John Kerry he didn’t have to defend his Catholicism. Obama has constantly had to respond to rumors he is a Muslim. How do you think Muslims feel that a Presidential candidate has to treat being called a Muslim like a smear? I think things have gotten exponentially better for Catholics in recent years. When my friends mother was growing up she and her family had to lock up their home and hide when the farm next to their hosted a Klan rally (they were Catholics), not to long ago Catholics were viewed with suspicion and it was a matter of great controversy weather a Catholic could be trusted with public office. And this hasn’t totally gone away. I know a man who is a Judge. He is an extraordinary man who truly represents everything good and decent in Catholicism (he’s still a role model for me to this very day). During his election I was furious to see political pamphlets referring to his non-Catholic opponent as "a True Christian" and other disgusting slurs. Yet how many Catholics are on the Supreme Court? So. I can understand this frustration, however do not see it as totally justified. Catholics have made great leaps in these last few decades and now are an extremely powerful force in the United States. And this power is only growing as more and more Catholic immigrants arrive from Mexico and South America. Oppi and Anthoney had a couple perform a sex act in St. Patrick’s Cathedral, however a Radio Host in New Jersey not to long ago, satirically, called for all American Muslims to be marked with a crescent tattoo on their wrist and was horrified to have caller after caller support the idea and suggest event further measures. [quote]We simply cannot control the actions of a few individuals and people who distort our own faith, just as the Muslim community cannot control everyone in their fold. It is indeed wrong to claim ourselves as peaceful as a whole and another religion as violent, for sure, but I didn't see that in this thread, so I guess I wondered why it was brought up here.[/quote] . Perhaps not in this thread but I have seen plenty of Catholics write things with that implication. [quote]Oh, no, that's not what I meant. I meant that he should have at least expected angry letters when he threatened desecration and should have expected the people who wanted him fired after the desecration. Not the death threats that stemmed from someone very misguided. But there will always be those who don't respond in the proper manner. He was potentially even aware of this possibility himself, and that this would make our entire faith community look bad, too. All the better to support his "cause"![/quote] Sure, sure, I didn't think you meant it like that. I didn't see any of this on the News, I really don't think he got much attention. Perhaps he got some slaps on the back from people who think just like him. Others like myself, simply lost all respect for him. I really would like to stress that. I don't support what he did. I have no respect for him what so ever. He didn't do anything to advance tolerance, understanding, or even freedom of expression. He just did a stupid stunt that was enormously offensive to a great many Catholics. I don't think it's fair to call it a "temper tantrum" I'm really not sure what to call it. A grown man and Professor acted with an extraordinary amount of stupidity and showed a total lack of respect for the beliefs of other people. There is room for someone to get hurt over this, by people trying to imitate him. By either a Catholic who decides to respond violently, someone who breaks in a Church to desecrate the Hosts, or trying to run off with a Host during communion, and I think he will be morally responsible for that and will have that weighing on him for the rest of his life. I hope that doesn’t happen but he was very irresponsible
Aloysius Posted July 26, 2008 Posted July 26, 2008 it is less justified because they have no right to expect non-muslim cartoonists to follow their religious belief that mohammad should not have images made of him; whereas we have every right to expect non-Catholics not to invade our religious services and take something from them for their own purposes. but aside from that, it ISN'T the same level of pain caused. To Muslims, it offended God and offended them, yes. To us, God Himself has been desecrated. Not just the word of God, not just a symbol of God or of a prophet of His, but indeed God Himself. If there were something in the Muslim religion which they believed to be God and that were desecrated, they would have a higher level of outrage, right? I'm looking at it from their standards and comparing it to our standards and this particular act is clearly not equal. the only thing I can think of in Islam that would compare to this is if Mecca, the place above which they believe Allah's presence dwells, were bombed. That would be like God Himself being attacked to them the way this is God being attacked to us. satirical comics about Catholicism sometimes bother me as well... so I do understand that Muslims would be offended by the Danish cartoons and I understand that it's one degree further because their religion teaches that no image should be made of the prophet. however, the level that rule has in their religion compared to the level the idea of the Eucharist has in our religion AS WELL AS the way in which the two acts are done (one being done completely apart from muslim acts in a newspaper in a country that allows free speech while another has part of its act include the invasion of our worship service) makes this act clearly justify more outrage. I don't go around calling for the end of Family Guy though it makes some annoying satire of Catholicism... nor rioting in the street when South Park makes blasphemous cartoons. I know the Catholic Leage has petitioned against South Park before... and that's fine, Muslims can petition against cartoons that depict Mohammad if they wish. None of this stuff justifies the violence they perpetrated against innocent people in their outrage over cartoons.
Aloysius Posted July 26, 2008 Posted July 26, 2008 I think the cartoon controversy can be compared to people using Jesus' name in vain. I can't really expect non-Catholics to treat Jesus' name with the level of respect I wish it would be treated with, but I can ask people to respect my beliefs and not use the name of Jesus vainly... but I can't really expect it of them and I sure as heck can't go around rioting if they don't. This is an entirely different thing, it involves the invasion of our worship service to take the object of our worship and desecrate it. Way more than a cartoon, even by their standards.
TeresaBenedicta Posted July 26, 2008 Posted July 26, 2008 Wow. When did this turn into a Muslim vs. Catholic thing? Seriously. It's immature and childish. We should be focusing on the fact that Our Lord was crucified all over again. Not arguing over which group of people have been more offended. "Forgive them Father, for they know not what they do." Obviously Myers doesn't know what he did anymore than those who condemned Jesus to the cross knew what they were doing. We should be outraged. We should turn to prayer and fasting. We should write letters. We should let out lamenting and wailing. Yes. But as Jesus told Peter to put aside his sword when the soldiers came for Him in the garden, so too should we put away our swords-- which includes all threats and acts of violence.
lilac_angel Posted July 26, 2008 Posted July 26, 2008 (edited) [quote name='TeresaBenedicta' post='1609278' date='Jul 26 2008, 02:27 PM']Wow. When did this turn into a Muslim vs. Catholic thing? Seriously. It's immature and childish. We should be focusing on the fact that Our Lord was crucified all over again. Not arguing over which group of people have been more offended. "Forgive them Father, for they know not what they do."[/quote] Please try to be less judgmental. The desecration has been on my mind pretty much day and night, and I've been praying, reading spiritual readings focused on the Eucharist, and offering up all my sufferings for it. Just because I responded to someone in this forum thread defending my faith and the [u]Eucharist[/u] does not make me petty and childish. My responses were filled with charity and never once immature or childish. Host desecrations have unfortunately happened throughout Christian history many, many times. Christ has been recrucified throughout history by unbelievers. One way of preventing that from happening is (charitably!) trying to enlighten others about our faith, perspective, or beliefs. Edited July 26, 2008 by lilac_angel
TeresaBenedicta Posted July 26, 2008 Posted July 26, 2008 (edited) [quote name='lilac_angel' post='1609291' date='Jul 26 2008, 04:44 PM']Please try to be less judgmental. The desecration has been on my mind pretty much day and night, and I've been praying, reading spiritual readings focused on the Eucharist, and offering up all my sufferings for it. Just because I responded to someone in this forum thread defending my faith and the [u]Eucharist[/u] does not make me petty and childish. My responses were filled with charity and never once immature or childish. Host desecrations have unfortunately happened throughout Christian history many, many times. Christ has been recrucified throughout history by unbelievers. One way of preventing that from happening is trying to enlighten others about our faith, perspective, or beliefs.[/quote] I apologize if I sounded as if I were judging, that's not how I intended to come across. I did not mean to imply that those participating or what they had said was immature or childish. I think the argument itself is immature and childish and I do not see how it is related to this topic in general. This is not a Muslim vs. Catholic issue. And it is petty to argue over who was most hurt by this or that action. Again, I'm sorry if it seemed that I was slighting you at all. I wasn't even thinking or considering any persons in particular when I responded. In fact, my comments of immaturity are directed only at the argument occuring itself, not to be directed towards any persons. Edit: And looking back now, I realize that my quoting "Forgive them Father, for they know not what they do" looked as though I were directin those words towards those in this thread. I'm sorry, bad context. That was meant to be directed towards Myers and his actions. Looks like I really screwed up trying to get what I was thinking across. Edited July 26, 2008 by TeresaBenedicta
Hassan Posted July 26, 2008 Posted July 26, 2008 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1609189' date='Jul 26 2008, 11:14 AM']it is less justified because they have no right to expect non-muslim cartoonists to follow their religious belief that mohammad should not have images made of him; whereas we have every right to expect non-Catholics not to invade our religious services and take something from them for their own purposes.[/quote] Are you talking about a moral right or a legal right? [quote]but aside from that, it ISN'T the same level of pain caused.[/quote] Who in God's name do you think you are that you have any moral right what so ever to say that? [quote]To Muslims, it offended God and offended them, yes. To us, God Himself has been desecrated. Not just the word of God, not just a symbol of God or of a prophet of His, but indeed God Himself.[/quote] I understand this. However simply because you claim that a piece of bread becomes your God after a Priest has said some words over it does not mean that no other religious group can possibly feel your level of pain at the desecration of something from their religion. [quote]If there were something in the Muslim religion which they believed to be God and that were desecrated, they would have a higher level of outrage, right?[/quote] It has been. I doubt it. Perhaps more Muslims would be outraged then were due to the cartoon controversy. Many Muslims feel extremely close and have an extremely loving attitude towards their prophet. There is no scientific basis for measuring individual subjective qualia. You cannot compare and contrast in such a legalistic way. Yes, from a purely rational point of view stabbing a rust nail from God is probably worse than blaspheming God. However we are not talking about a rational category, there is not rational reason to believe that that little wafer is Jesus body, blood, soul, and divinity. Many people find is insane that Catholics would insist a little wafer is God, however simply because it is not a rationally founded belief doesn’t give anyone the right to dismiss the pain you feel when the Eucharist is desecrated. Similarly this idea you seem to have that you can set up some tightly categorized level of religious offenses, and there is a certain rational level of grief an individual can feel in elation to a given level of offense is just silly. We are not talking about rational categories here. Let's say Myers desecrated two Hosts at once, your pain be double what it was when he desecrated one? Qualitative Experience isn’t something that fits into strict scientific categories, sorry. [quote]I'm looking at it from their standards and comparing it to our standards and this particular act is clearly not equal.[/quote] See above [quote]the only thing I can think of in Islam that would compare to this is if Mecca, the place above which they believe Allah's presence dwells, were bombed. That would be like God Himself being attacked to them the way this is God being attacked to us.[/quote] Firstly it's not Mecca, Mecca is a city. That is the Ka'ba. No, the Ka'ba is not at all like what you mean with the Eucharist. [quote]satirical comics about Catholicism sometimes bother me as well... so I do understand that Muslims would be offended by the Danish cartoons and I understand that it's one degree further because their religion teaches that no image should be made of the prophet. however, the level that rule has in their religion compared to the level the idea of the Eucharist has in our religion AS WELL AS the way in which the two acts are done (one being done completely apart from muslim acts in a newspaper in a country that allows free speech while another has part of its act include the invasion of our worship service) makes this act clearly justify more outrage.[/quote] No, see above, that is silly. [ [quote]None of this stuff justifies the violence they perpetrated against innocent people in their outrage over cartoons.[/quote] Again, you cannot expect people to measure their outrage by some scientific metric of perceived offense. No, it was not justified to kill innocent people.
Hassan Posted July 26, 2008 Posted July 26, 2008 [quote name='TeresaBenedicta' post='1609278' date='Jul 26 2008, 02:27 PM']Wow. When did this turn into a Muslim vs. Catholic thing? Seriously. It's immature and childish. We should be focusing on the fact that Our Lord was crucified all over again. Not arguing over which group of people have been more offended. "Forgive them Father, for they know not what they do." Obviously Myers doesn't know what he did anymore than those who condemned Jesus to the cross knew what they were doing. We should be outraged. We should turn to prayer and fasting. We should write letters. We should let out lamenting and wailing. Yes. But as Jesus told Peter to put aside his sword when the soldiers came for Him in the garden, so too should we put away our swords-- which includes all threats and acts of violence.[/quote] I agree that such an argument would be childish, and that really wasn’t the point I was trying to get across. I was simply trying to give a perspective on this and why perhaps Catholics got less sympathetic responses then I feel were due for the situation. It got side tracked when I mentioned Catholics seeming to set up a distinction of the peaceful Catholics with the violent Muslims and suggested that perhaps you all would have more sympathy if some of the more vocal elements of your community didn’t appear to insensitive to other beliefs. Part of that also happened, I think, when I complained that rather than trying to peacefully resolve the situation Donahue seemed to try and bully a resolution and now has allowed the Muslims to get dragged in as well.
Hassan Posted July 26, 2008 Posted July 26, 2008 [quote name='TeresaBenedicta' post='1609293' date='Jul 26 2008, 02:50 PM']I apologize if I sounded as if I were judging, that's not how I intended to come across. I did not mean to imply that those participating or what they had said was immature or childish. I think the argument itself is immature and childish and I do not see how it is related to this topic in general. This is not a Muslim vs. Catholic issue. And it is petty to argue over who was most hurt by this or that action. Again, I'm sorry if it seemed that I was slighting you at all. I wasn't even thinking or considering any persons in particular when I responded. In fact, my comments of immaturity are directed only at the argument occuring itself, not to be directed towards any persons. Edit: And looking back now, I realize that my quoting "Forgive them Father, for they know not what they do" looked as though I were directin those words towards those in this thread. I'm sorry, bad context. That was meant to be directed towards Myers and his actions. Looks like I really screwed up trying to get what I was thinking across.[/quote] I don't think that is how it looked, and I never felt it was directed at anyone in particular. I am sorry that this has caused a disruption. I will abandon this topic so the argument will stop and you all can grieve in peace.
lilac_angel Posted July 26, 2008 Posted July 26, 2008 (edited) [quote name='TeresaBenedicta' post='1609293' date='Jul 26 2008, 02:50 PM']I apologize if I sounded as if I were judging, that's not how I intended to come across. I did not mean to imply that those participating or what they had said was immature or childish. I think the argument itself is immature and childish and I do not see how it is related to this topic in general. This is not a Muslim vs. Catholic issue. And it is petty to argue over who was most hurt by this or that action. Again, I'm sorry if it seemed that I was slighting you at all. I wasn't even thinking or considering any persons in particular when I responded. In fact, my comments of immaturity are directed only at the argument occuring itself, not to be directed towards any persons. Edit: And looking back now, I realize that my quoting "Forgive them Father, for they know not what they do" looked as though I were directin those words towards those in this thread. I'm sorry, bad context. That was meant to be directed towards Myers and his actions. Looks like I really screwed up trying to get what I was thinking across.[/quote] Ah, sorry. I did think that the "forgive them father" was directed at those who were arguing in this thread. Woops. I apologize anyway for being defensive. I think that an argument in this particular topic definitely does not come across as ideal, but I find it hard sometimes not to come to the Church's (and the Real Presence's) defense, so that's why I responded to a couple of posts. It's a forum for people with varying perspectives, and arguments are bound to crop up if even one person has a very different idea of something. In this case, it is someone who doesn't believe in the Real Presence. Nobody individually was arguing for childish reasons, at least I hope not, so I would conclude from that information that the larger argument itself was not childish or immature. However, even if it is childish in a way, it is somewhat appropriate, as we are all children in God's eyes, just aiming to please him. Sometimes we stink at it, and sometimes we all go about it in completely different ways, but we are all His children. Let's just pray that we can return His love in the best way that we each individually can in our lives, and hopefully that will reflect in how we interact with each other in the future. God bless, all! I will refrain from arguing about smaller points in this thread. I do think that a new thread should probably be created for something that is off-topic, but I personally have found that one or two things said helped increase my understanding and willingness to see others, including those with a differing perspective, in a more Christlike manner. Other things said made me grieve, but I won't dwell on it. Edited July 26, 2008 by lilac_angel
johnnydigit Posted July 26, 2008 Posted July 26, 2008 [quote name='Fleurdelys7' post='1607712' date='Jul 24 2008, 05:10 PM']I'd recommend lots of prayer and Blessed Bartolo Longo and our Lady as special intercessors for this spiritually barren man's case. What if Catholics sent him love notes, lots of love notes on behalf of Jesus. "I love you, Jesus." "You did not know what you did, I forgive you, Jesus" and so on. Imagine thousands of postcards for the rest of his life reminding him that the Jesus he persecutes died for him so that he might have life and have it abundantly. Other famous atheists have converted...let's pray for yet another conversion! Put his name right next to Hitchens on your prayer lists[/quote] i agree. instead of the hate mail he will expect and receive (thus fueling his fire), what if he was bombarded with loving notes, especially from children? i have seen countless hardened hearts and shells broken in this way. i am one of them.. i like the mention of converted saints. imagine, a man filled with so much hate and confusion that he announces it to the world, only for God to take special notice and baptize his soul with 100 times the intensity. the tears from his soul being crushed into powder will flood the world. we pray for Divine Mercy on him..
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now