Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Are You Anti-obama Or Pro-mccain


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Didymus' post='1610095' date='Jul 27 2008, 03:53 PM']Congressman Paul was never very pro-life. I don't know why folks couldn't see this. He as well just wanted the issue returned to the states. He's pro-Constitution, not pro-life. He always has been.[/quote]
Yes, he basically holds the position of his former party, i.e., the Libertarian Party, on the issue of abortion.

friendofJPII
Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1610132' date='Jul 27 2008, 06:03 PM']Yes, he basically holds the position of his former party, i.e., the Libertarian Party, on the issue of abortion.[/quote]

in fact he voted against some key pro-life/family legislation because he felt the gov had no right to interfere on the federal level. He voted against the Marriage ammendment.

Posted

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1609969' date='Jul 27 2008, 02:19 PM']I'm not in favor of either. This entire voting year is an utter disaster and no matter which candidate wins America is going to get *delivered a huge package of FAIL.

*Thanks to KoC for that turn of phrase.[/quote]

Agreed. :(

[quote name='toservelove' post='1609996' date='Jul 27 2008, 02:54 PM']What would some of those other reasons be? For my part, I feel he is a lot of empty rhetoric, does not have enough experience, did not do a good job as a Senator in Illinois--for example, one of his low-cost housing projects ended up becoming pretty run down and appears to have been farmed out to supporters/ friends, his arms reduction stance is pure folly--Didn't the iron curtain come down? Why does he keep talking about Russia when the Middle East is of so much greater concern?

Anything else to add?[/quote]



He is also in favor of socialized health care (i.e. huge increases in taxes and reduction in quality and efficiency of care), of pulling the troops out of Iraq right away (I'm personally against the initiation of the war, but now that we're there we can't just leave. we gotta take responsibility for our actions), of catering to environmental groups and supporting anti-global warming legislation (which in my mind is a load of bunk... just another way to control our lives), to name a few. He and I disagree in almost every single issue.

As far as illegal immigrants, though, I think that we should grant them amnesty but not give them some government services (which some people ARE in favor of). That's the only big issue I have with the candidate I am supporting (Chuck Baldwin), but you'll never find the perfect candidate.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='toservelove' post='1609802' date='Jul 27 2008, 09:06 AM']I keep hearing lots of anit-Obama things, some of it bordering on slander and calumniation. Some truth, some empty rhetoric. I see Obama '08 signs in house windows, on t-shirts, hats, bumper stickers--you name it. But, I hardly see anything about McCain. I can't find a bumper sticker. I haven't even seen a billboard or yard sign for him. And, in all this talk about why Obama should NOT be president, I hear very little about why McCain should be president. So, can you give me some positives about McCain--facts that I could use in conversation. I want something like Obama's stance is X, but McCains is Y and it's better because....OR Obama says X and McCain says Y--I think they're both wrong because...Thanks[/quote]

As it went down to the line, from both parties, all I could say, both to myself as well as aloud, "is this the best the US has to offer.." regarding candidates.

As for Obama, what scares me, and I am in the advertising field (creative) is how he is being marketed like a product. Furthermore, I have not seen such propaganda around one person since seeing posters and literature during Hitlers rise to power. Never thought I would see this in my lifetime.

Obama is for everything a Catholic is aganst. His "faith" is grounded in black liberation theology (any of you guys who have ever been to NYC, you will see them screaming in the streets how "whites are the devil." Their belief is that Jesus was black, they are the Israelites and whites must be killed. So his "christian" faith is non-existent. I worry for more than taxes or gay agendas being forwarded, but knowing that late-term abortion will become the norm under him as it did Clinton.

People are looking to the wrong place for something to believe in, as most Obama supporters look at the Bible as a book full of hate speech.

I would love to say that I am Pro-McCain, but the truth is I am Anti-Obama.

Edited by StMichael
Posted

I'm no fan of McCain (he's not a true conservative), and this is the most dreary and depressing presidential campaign of my lifetime, but I definitely believe McCain to be the lesser evil to Obama.

[quote name='Didymus' post='1610095' date='Jul 27 2008, 04:53 PM']McCain's stance on abortion is that he wants the issue back to the states. I have never heard what he says about the state's power over partial birth abortion, but until we do hear something about it, then how can we say he actually has [i]more[/i] respect for life?[/quote]

[quote]Congressman Paul was never very pro-life. I don't know why folks couldn't see this. He as well just wanted the issue returned to the states. He's pro-Constitution, not pro-life. He always has been.[/quote]
While I'd certainly be in favor of a Human Life Amendment, I definitely think overturning the judicial monstrosity that is Roe v. Wade, and returning the power to the states would be a huge step in the right direction (as well as probably the only politically feasible choice right now).

As shown by his endorsement of the "Freedom of Choice Act" (which would essentially bar any state restrictions on abortion) and his pro-infanticide votes against the partial-birth abortion ban and against the Infants Born Alive Protection Act in the Illinois state senate, Obama has made it clear that he opposes any restrictions whatever on baby-killing.

Certainly returning the rights to the states, and having the possibility of unborn infants being protected in some states is preferable to perpetuating abortion-on-demand as the universal law of the land as Obama would do.

Didy, you've repeatedly made your opposition to anything and everything conservative, Republican, or libertarian quite clear this year, yet you've never really made it clear what you would actually advocate that voters do. You've given a lot of negativism with no direction for positive action.

Posted

I definitely believe that returning the issue to the states is a huge step in our favor. We need to overturn Roe v. Wade, and we will.

But what I had been responding to was the comment that McCain actually [i]respects[/i] life more than Obama, and I have yet to see any evidence for that. We as pro-lifers can benefit from him being in office for sure, but that doesn't necessarily mean he has a respect for life in the womb.

In these days of strong central government, most any conservative/libertarian candidate can help the pro-life movement to an extent. But let's take them for what they're worth. Most libertarians don't seem too in favor of a human life amendment (btw, does Paul support one?)

I am not pro-McCain by any means (obviously) but I will most probably end up voting for him or a third party candidate (depending on who the veep is), and I would expect anyone serious about the pro-life movement to do the same, especially with the justices that the next pres will most probably be replacing.

In response to my supposed lack of suggesting 'positive action,' I have done it quite a few times on different sites and only been received with hostility.

I really really support the efforts of the [url="http://www.democratsforlife.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=48&Itemid=45"]95-10 Initiative[/url], but I unfortunately haven't heard any news on it lately. Till it starts being put into work, I believe we must still hold onto our pro-life values first and foremost while within the voting booth.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='aalpha1989' post='1610226' date='Jul 27 2008, 08:05 PM']As far as illegal immigrants, though, I think that we should grant them amnesty[/quote]

Without knowing who they are? Can you imagine finger-printing and doing background checks on 12 million illegal aliens? I don't know HOW that is ever going to happen. But one thing is for sure, we CANNOT grant auto-amnesty to 12 million illegals without knowing who they are.

Posted

what do you suggest would be a good first step?

Posted

Anti-Obama - yes.

Pro-McCain - on budgetary matters, yes.

Posted

[quote name='Didymus' post='1610383' date='Jul 27 2008, 11:24 PM']In response to my supposed lack of suggesting 'positive action,' I have done it quite a few times on different sites and only been received with hostility.[/quote]
Have you suggested it on Phatmass?

[quote]I really really support the efforts of the [url="http://www.democratsforlife.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=48&Itemid=45"]95-10 Initiative[/url], but I unfortunately haven't heard any news on it lately. Till it starts being put into work, I believe we must still hold onto our pro-life values first and foremost while within the voting booth.[/quote]
That looks like generally a good initiative (at least a better spending of our tax dollars than many other things). I'm afraid pro-life Dems are going to face a long uphill battle, though, especially with their own party in power (whose leaders are determined to keep it the Party of Death).

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1613486' date='Jul 30 2008, 10:18 PM']Have you suggested it on Phatmass?[/quote]

I believe I've brought up my thoughts on using the term "pro-choice" rather than always referring to those against us (on the abortion issue) as being pro-abortion or pro-death. I personally think my whole take on the issue to be quite positive.

I can definitely start bringing more of it to phatmass if you are interested. I know that I appear to be a very negative person at times, and I apologize for that.

[quote name='Socrates' post='1613486' date='Jul 30 2008, 10:18 PM']That looks like generally a good initiative (at least a better spending of our tax dollars than many other things). I'm afraid pro-life Dems are going to face a long uphill battle, though, especially with their own party in power (whose leaders are determined to keep it the Party of Death).[/quote]

True that. I think the most important role pro-life democrat legislators play right now is the fact that they will always give pro-choice liberals a false sense of security when it comes to Congress.

Many pro-choicers might see a Democratic majority in congress and may believe that they have the upper hand, until Congress perhaps votes on a bill that a pro-life Republican might present and find that it could very well pass.

This might be wishful thinking, but I think it's something we all wish for when we are left with a Democratic majority in Congress. I guess with the current congress though nothing seems to ever get done.

Posted

[quote name='Didymus' post='1613587' date='Jul 30 2008, 10:21 PM']I believe I've brought up my thoughts on using the term "pro-choice" rather than always referring to those against us (on the abortion issue) as being pro-abortion or pro-death. I personally think my whole take on the issue to be quite positive.

I can definitely start bringing more of it to phatmass if you are interested. I know that I appear to be a very negative person at times, and I apologize for that.[/quote]
I would be interested in hearing your ideas, but there is no guarantee, of course, that I will agree with any of them.

I think I missed that about using the term "pro-choice," but I'll have to strongly disagree with you there.
Some years back I heard a speech by one of the leaders of the pro-life movement, who said it was very important that pro-lifers do not adopt the language of the enemy by using the term "pro-choice." Once we start using their language to refer to the abortion issue, we allow the debate to be on their terms, rather than ours.
She said it actually took the pro-abortion side many years to come up with the term "pro-choice" to refer to their position, and it was a brilliant propaganda move, as it allowed them to shift emphasis away from abortion itself, and allowed them to support legalized abortion while claiming to not really be "for" it.

The term "pro-choice" is an Orwellian euphemism based on a lie.
It deliberately shifts the emphasis, and the debate, away from the facts of abortion itself, and towards a pleasant sounding abstraction ("choice"). After all, who could possibly be against the right to choose? If you oppose "choice," you are portrayed as some kind of enemy of human free-will.

Heck, I'm pro-choice! I believe we should have the freedom to choose where to live, who to vote for, what career to pursue, whom to date or marry, which brand of goods to buy, what movies to watch, where to go to school, etc., etc. And I'm sure on a number of issues I'm more for freedom of choice than most in the "pro-choice" crowd.
The truth remains though that some actions are not legitimate choices to make. I have no "right to choose" to murder, rob, or rape my neighbor. I have no right to choose to kill an innocent unborn child!

The fact is that the "pro-choice" crowd does not stand for "choice" as some generic general principle, but specifically with regards to [b]abortion[/b].
And oftentimes "pro-choicers" are far from pro-choice when it comes to things that oppose abortion - such as the freedom of the people of the states to choose to have restrictions of abortion, or the choice of taxpayers not to pay for abortions with their tax money, or the choice of pro-lifers to protest at abortion mills.

The truth is that "pro-choice" does indeed in reality mean "pro-abortion," and we should be honest and truthful in our language. Bowing to dishonest euphemistic language to be politically-correct in reality does no one a favor, and will do absolutely zilch to further the pro-life cause.

And if you're going to insist we use the enemy's language with regards to "pro-choice," what of their other euphemisms must we adopt? Should we start calling abortion mills "reproductive health clinics"? Unborn children "fetal tissue"?

We should be respectful of persons with wrong and mistaken opinions regarding abortion, but this does not mean we should adopt their euphemistic and propagandistic slogans when discussing and debating abortion.
Our language should always reflect truth, not political correctness.

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1614554' date='Jul 31 2008, 09:59 PM']I would be interested in hearing your ideas, but there is no guarantee, of course, that I will agree with any of them.

I think I missed that about using the term "pro-choice," but I'll have to strongly disagree with you there.
Some years back I heard a speech by one of the leaders of the pro-life movement, who said it was very important that pro-lifers do not adopt the language of the enemy by using the term "pro-choice." Once we start using their language to refer to the abortion issue, we allow the debate to be on their terms, rather than ours.
She said it actually took the pro-abortion side many years to come up with the term "pro-choice" to refer to their position, and it was a brilliant propaganda move, as it allowed them to shift emphasis away from abortion itself, and allowed them to support legalized abortion while claiming to not really be "for" it.

The term "pro-choice" is an Orwellian euphemism based on a lie.
It deliberately shifts the emphasis, and the debate, away from the facts of abortion itself, and towards a pleasant sounding abstraction ("choice"). After all, who could possibly be against the right to choose? If you oppose "choice," you are portrayed as some kind of enemy of human free-will.

Heck, I'm pro-choice! I believe we should have the freedom to choose where to live, who to vote for, what career to pursue, whom to date or marry, which brand of goods to buy, what movies to watch, where to go to school, etc., etc. And I'm sure on a number of issues I'm more for freedom of choice than most in the "pro-choice" crowd.
The truth remains though that some actions are not legitimate choices to make. I have no "right to choose" to murder, rob, or rape my neighbor. I have no right to choose to kill an innocent unborn child!

The fact is that the "pro-choice" crowd does not stand for "choice" as some generic general principle, but specifically with regards to [b]abortion[/b].
And oftentimes "pro-choicers" are far from pro-choice when it comes to things that oppose abortion - such as the freedom of the people of the states to choose to have restrictions of abortion, or the choice of taxpayers not to pay for abortions with their tax money, or the choice of pro-lifers to protest at abortion mills.

The truth is that "pro-choice" does indeed in reality mean "pro-abortion," and we should be honest and truthful in our language. Bowing to dishonest euphemistic language to be politically-correct in reality does no one a favor, and will do absolutely zilch to further the pro-life cause.

And if you're going to insist we use the enemy's language with regards to "pro-choice," what of their other euphemisms must we adopt? Should we start calling abortion mills "reproductive health clinics"? Unborn children "fetal tissue"?

We should be respectful of persons with wrong and mistaken opinions regarding abortion, but this does not mean we should adopt their euphemistic and propagandistic slogans when discussing and debating abortion.
Our language should always reflect truth, not political correctness.[/quote]

you make very good arguments, and I would definitely like to pick your brain on them. I will start a new thread and lay out in more detail my thoughts on the language we use as pro-lifers

Posted (edited)

I don't like Obama because he's pro-abortion (obviously) but also he doesn't support the principle of subsidiarity. I would say that McCain is more pro-life and and subsidiarity than Obama... but I can't vote anyway. If I could I don't know what I'd do.

Edited by StThomasMore
Posted

I thought McCain was pro-life? "At its core, abortion is a human tragedy. To effect meaningful change, we must engage the debate at a human level."

Posted

[quote name='Fixxxer' post='1615655' date='Aug 2 2008, 07:43 PM']I thought McCain was pro-life? "At its core, abortion is a human tragedy. To effect meaningful change, we must engage the debate at a human level."[/quote]

McCain supported embryonic stem cell research. That's really his only sin against the pro-life movement. It is just one issue and Obama is way more pro-choice than McCain. I honestly don't know if its even going to come up this election cycle as I've heard they've pretty much proven the only stem cells that have medical benefits are those from adults anyway.

ilovechrist
Posted

[quote name='toservelove' post='1609996' date='Jul 27 2008, 01:54 PM']What would some of those other reasons be? For my part, I feel he is a lot of empty rhetoric, does not have enough experience, did not do a good job as a Senator in Illinois--for example, one of his low-cost housing projects ended up becoming pretty run down and appears to have been farmed out to supporters/ friends, his arms reduction stance is pure folly--Didn't the iron curtain come down? Why does he keep talking about Russia when the Middle East is of so much greater concern?

Anything else to add?[/quote]

he talks about Russia so much--BECAUSE--the principles and approach of his campaign are both strongly similar in comparison to the principles and foundation of Communism in Russia.

and that my friends, is creepy as can be.

i am anti-Obama. am i more of the latter than of being pro-McCain? the jury's still out on that one, because i still have some reading up to do on McCain's history. but as for now, being in a targeted swing state, i plan on voting for the lesser of two evils, John McCain.

geetarplayer
Posted

I'm more anti-Obama than I am anti-McCain. McCain is pro-war, yes, but at least he has honor. He was offered an early release by his North Vietnamese captors, but he refused it because they would not release his fellow prisoners. He ought to know what it is like to be tortured, and he has been committed to treating prisoners humanely. He also seems opposed to military intervention in Iran, which is more than I can say for Obama.

That being said, he is nominally opposed to abortion, but he supports embryonic stem cell research and the death penalty.

-Mark

Posted

I am anti-abortion and anti-infanticide.

'Nuff said.

dominicansoul
Posted (edited)

[quote]I am anti-abortion and anti-infanticide.

'Nuff said.[/quote]

ditto

Edited by dominicansoul

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...