Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

friendofJPII
Posted

I was all excited to go see it, because the trailer made it looked cute, but my friend said her mom almost walked out because it was so offensive. Anyone see it?

friendofJPII
Posted

OOps, just realized this should be in the move thread, but I don't know how to move it now.

Sorry! :ohno:

Posted (edited)

I havent seen it but I know I don't want to because the girl has possibly three fathers, and the mother is basically a hooker. The only thing cute about it is the singing and dancing because it's ABBA for goodness' sake. The storyline - BAAAAAAAAAD. :banned:

Edited by pan!c139
Posted

The girl doesn't, for the record, have three fathers.

I saw Mamma Mia! on Broadway last year and loved it. It could have been a lot more sexually charged than it was. I've seen clips from the movie, though, and a couple numbers look nearly explicit.

Use discernment. I would personally go see it, but for those who struggle with lust, it would best be avoided, I think.

Posted

I like musicals, but I can tell from the previews that Mama Mia stinks. Vacant stares, meaningless nordic drivel for the songs, Meryl Streep, a great actress, hamming for the camera.

It's obscene.

friendofJPII
Posted

[quote name='Winchester' post='1614409' date='Jul 31 2008, 05:49 PM']I like musicals, but I can tell from the previews that Mama Mia stinks. Vacant stares, meaningless nordic drivel for the songs, Meryl Streep, a great actress, hamming for the camera.

It's obscene.[/quote]

Darn! I get all excited when I think a movie comes out that I can actually go see! I guess I'll have to stick with Nick at Nite.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

I saw the movie and loved it. Laughed and cried the whole way thru. I will buy in the first day its available for sale.

I would have changed one item of the ending.

Posted

Some musicals may not be for the big screen.

I didn't like it AT ALL.

It was boring IMHO, was that a story? Or just a segment out of "Days of Our Lives"? I didn't find much funny except hearing James Bond sing. Ouch!!!!!

It didn't show anything, just insinuated (sp?) alot. And I got flack from the other teachers (older) for not staying to see the ending number. I just couldn't get into it and wishing I had seen Hancock instead.

Others were REALLY into it. It was almost scary.

IMO, it's overrated.

But it's all how you like your tea. :coffee:

Posted

Aint my cup o tea, dat fa sho. :coffee:

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='jmjtina' post='1614569' date='Jul 31 2008, 11:09 PM']Some musicals may not be for the big screen.

I didn't like it AT ALL.

It was boring IMHO, was that a story? Or just a segment out of "Days of Our Lives"? I didn't find much funny except hearing James Bond sing. Ouch!!!!!

It didn't show anything, just insinuated (sp?) alot. And I got flack from the other teachers (older) for not staying to see the ending number. I just couldn't get into it and wishing I had seen Hancock instead.

Others were REALLY into it. It was almost scary.

IMO, it's overrated.

But it's all how you like your tea. :coffee:[/quote]
You are just not old enough to appreciate it :)

Posted
:lol_roll:

your right cmom!!!!
DemonSlayer
Posted

Musicals are probably my least favourite film genre because they are so annoying.

Anastasia13
Posted

[quote name='DemonSlayer' post='1614875' date='Aug 1 2008, 02:13 AM']Musicals are probably my least favourite film genre because they are so annoying.[/quote]
They are not annoying to everyone.

Posted

[quote name='DemonSlayer' post='1614875' date='Aug 1 2008, 05:13 PM']Musicals are probably my least favourite film genre because they are so annoying.[/quote]

Growing up in the Virginian Boonies my life was a musical. I'd be walking down the street singing and rednecks and hillbillies would pop out of the woods to dance to my lovely voice.

friendofJPII
Posted

I like musicals, actually.

Posted

So do I - just not always in movies.

Posted

I love musicals too.

just not this one. ^_^

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='jmjtina' post='1614569' date='Jul 31 2008, 11:09 PM']Some musicals may not be for the big screen.

I didn't like it AT ALL....

Others were REALLY into it. It was almost scary.

IMO, it's overrated.

But it's all how you like your tea. :coffee:[/quote]
We are into because we can identify with it. Meryl Streep is 59, Pierce Brosnan is 55, and Christine Baranski is 56 - my age group. They are singing the music we remember, and coming to terms with what they have won and what they have lost, and the mistakes and triumphs in the process. And they are having a blast doing it. So yes we are really into it, because we see ourselves reflected in their lives, and it reminds us that happiness or at least enjoyment and contentment doesn't end at 25, as the media would have so many of us women "of a certain age" believe. So yes we love the show because it reminds us we were women before we were mums and grandmas, and til you get to our ages you won't have a clue what that means. :)

Posted (edited)

that might be it cmom. however, some of my friends loved it and were REALLY into it. (my age)

I just didn't like it overall. ;)

Edited by jmjtina
Posted

I thought it was a great movie. It's fun, it's colorful, it's shallow, it's a musical. That's how most musicals are, onstage or on film. If you don't want to get deeply involved in the storyline of a movie, Mamma Mia is a good movie to see.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...