johnnydigit Posted August 8, 2008 Posted August 8, 2008 [quote name='fides quarens intellectum' post='1620540' date='Aug 7 2008, 03:22 PM']Pope's intentions for the month of August, 2008: Mission: That the answer of the entire people of God to the common calling to holiness and mission may be promoted and fostered by means of careful discernment of charisms and constant commitment to spiritual and cultural formation.[/quote] yowza! is it me or does that sound like a direct address to a certain people? interpreter, please!
Deb Posted August 8, 2008 Posted August 8, 2008 Pope's intentions for the month of August, 2008: Mission: That the answer of the entire people of God to the common calling to holiness and mission may be promoted and fostered by means of careful discernment of charisms and constant commitment to spiritual and cultural formation. yowza! is it me or does that sound like a direct address to a certain people? interpreter, please! Papa really knows best. He pretty much said it all and in very simple terms. I love our Pope!!
fides quarens intellectum Posted August 8, 2008 Posted August 8, 2008 [quote name='abercius24' post='1621138' date='Aug 8 2008, 12:02 AM']One thing to consider in all this is that people who have such gifts find themselves very lonely and confused if they don't find outlets of expression. Our modern day world is very unbelieving of anything spiritual in general. If a conference is the only way one can outwardly explore such gifts, then there is great value in such a conference. I agree that there are a lot of "fake" or "self-deluded" people who believe they have such gifts, but even these people despite their ignorance aid those who actually have such gifts. And yes, in my experience, these gifts are much more tame and subtle than what you normally see. But you gotta admit, even if one person in a group of 50,000 is praying in tongues, that is a very unique and wonderful presence of the Holy Spirit.[/quote] Perhaps many may feel lonely and confused at first, but again, i think spiritual direction is key in discerning charisms. [quote name='johnnydigit' post='1621177' date='Aug 8 2008, 02:19 AM']yowza! is it me or does that sound like a direct address to a certain people? interpreter, please![/quote] [quote name='Deb' post='1621217' date='Aug 8 2008, 07:11 AM']Pope's intentions for the month of August, 2008: Mission: That the answer of the entire people of God to the common calling to holiness and mission may be promoted and fostered by means of careful discernment of charisms and constant commitment to spiritual and cultural formation. yowza! is it me or does that sound like a direct address to a certain people? interpreter, please! Papa really knows best. He pretty much said it all and in very simple terms. I love our Pope!![/quote] Me too, and we should pray for his intentions!!
KOIfriend Posted August 9, 2008 Posted August 9, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Treehugger' post='1615581' date='Aug 2 2008, 12:59 AM']When I was only about twelve years old I went to a Catholic retreat (through my very charismatic church) and the atmosphere was very intense. There was an opportunity to be "prayed over/with" by adult leaders. I witnessed many of the youth start speaking in tongues during this prayer time. Also, there came a point where this one girl in the group was just on her own praying silently when she suddenly started convulsing, but then started to quote scripture. She was quoting different things that Jesus said, but in first person...more scripture than she could probably reference normally. Also, when the shaking and everything stopped, she started singing so angelically. Many of the youth gathered around her with their hands extended in prayer and their eyes wide with curiousity and intrigue. (Who wouldn't be?) Also, some adults were conflicted in their discernment of spirits. Some thought it was all God there, and some thought things were not...of the Holy Spirit. Also, many people had rested in the spirit...having dreams and visions....seeing angels...that sort of thing. Many of the youth did not know what to expect. This was a shock for sure. Also, many people did not know how to respond to what happened. On the bus ride home, the young people swapped testimonies and asked their friends, "So, did you get a gift of the spirit or not." Unfortunately this sort of created and "In the club"/"out of the club division" and put pressure on many of the youth who felt that maybe they had done something wrong in the process. I believe that spiritual gifts do exist, even in the modern context of our faith. But it is easy for personal agendas, indivual motives, and circumstances conducive to producing perhaps a more emotional rather than spiritual experience to get in the way of receiving the authentic gift that the Spirit sends.[/quote] Both joking and serious. The last time I heard someone rolling on the ground in the bible was - KJV - [quote]And when they were come to the multitude, there came to him a certain man, kneeling down to him, and saying, Lord, have mercy on my son: for he is[b] lunatick, and sore vexed: for ofttimes he falleth into the fire, and oft into the water.[/b] And I brought him to thy disciples, and they could not cure him. Then Jesus answered and said, O faithless and perverse generation, how long shall I be with you? how long shall I suffer you? bring him hither to me. [b]And Jesus rebuked the devil; and he departed out of him: and the child was cured from that very hour.[/b] Then came the disciples to Jesus apart, and said, Why could not we cast him out? And Jesus said unto them, Because of your unbelief: for verily I say unto you, If ye have faith as a grain of mustard seed, ye shall say unto this mountain, Remove hence to yonder place; and it shall remove; and nothing shall be impossible unto you.[/quote] or even NIV (I can't believe I am actually using this translation, but it will help) [quote]When they came to the crowd, a man approached Jesus and knelt before him. "Lord, have mercy on my son," he said. "[b]He has seizures and is suffering greatly. He often falls into the fire or into the water[/b]. I brought him to your disciples, but they could not heal him." "O unbelieving and perverse generation," Jesus replied, "how long shall I stay with you? How long shall I put up with you? Bring the boy here to me." [b]Jesus rebuked the demon, and it came out of the boy, and he was healed from that moment.[/b] Then the disciples came to Jesus in private and asked, "Why couldn't we drive it out?" He replied, "Because you have so little faith. I tell you the truth, if you have faith as small as a mustard seed, you can say to this mountain, 'Move from here to there' and it will move. Nothing will be impossible for you."[/quote] The last time I read in the Bible, some was convulsing, and have seizures, they were possessed by a demon! What am I to believe, the testimony of men, saying convulsing is of God, or the Bible? I guess that is the weakness of the Educational system. People seem to forget to think things out before they emotionally say something. I would have been horrified, seeing people squirming on the ground, because my God would never be so cruel to potentially hurt someone! Edited August 9, 2008 by KOIfriend
Nihil Obstat Posted August 9, 2008 Posted August 9, 2008 [quote name='KOIfriend' post='1622302' date='Aug 9 2008, 12:05 AM']Both joking and serious. The last time I heard someone rolling on the ground in the bible was - KJV - or even NIV (I can't believe I am actually using this translation, but it will help) The last time I read in the Bible, some was convulsing, and have seizures, they were possessed by a demon! What am I to believe, the testimony of men, saying convulsing is of God, or the Bible? I guess that is the weakness of the Educational system. People seem to forget to think things out before they emotionally say something. I would have been horrified, seeing people squirming on the ground, because my God would never be so cruel to potentially hurt someone![/quote] I would like to point out that the 'spiritual gifts' we have been discussing are not confined to "rolling on the ground". I think you're trying to look at this issue in an extremely oversimplified way.
Deb Posted August 11, 2008 Posted August 11, 2008 First of all, people do not "roll" on the ground. They kind of just pass out and rest, motionless while the Holy Spirit does his work in them. The power of the Holy Spirit. Second, you need to read more of the bible. [b][i]Daniel 10:8-10 So I was left alone and saw this great vision; yet no strength was left in me, for my natural color turned to a deathly pallor, and I retained no strength. But I heard the sound of his words; and as soon as I heard the sound of his words, I fell into a deep sleep on my face, with my face to the ground. or [/i]<H3>[i]John 18:5-7 )[/i][/b] [i]Whom do you seek?" [/i] [i] They answered Him, "Jesus the Nazarene." He said to them, "I am He." And Judas also, who was betraying Him, was standing with them. So when He said to them, "I am He," they drew back and fell to the ground. [/i] </H3>
Maggyie Posted August 11, 2008 Posted August 11, 2008 I have in fact seen people "roll on the ground." However that was at a very strange Protestant church, not a Catholic one, and there was a whole lot more wrong with them than just that.
fides quarens intellectum Posted August 11, 2008 Posted August 11, 2008 [quote name='Deb' post='1624080' date='Aug 11 2008, 11:11 AM']There ya go. We be Catholics here.[/quote] thanks for that one.
zealousrap Posted August 12, 2008 Posted August 12, 2008 I haven't really read through this but I want to add a few random scattered tidbits here. Different gifts are given to different people for different reasons. One can never compare what is given to another person to themselves. We are simply too diverse in our state in life, walk with God, gifts and needs, etc. I do not think that the gifts of the spirit are meant for average everyday life...the apostles were not using the gifts at the fishing boats and while collecting taxes...they had left all behind to live a radical life of following Christ and building up the Kingdom of God. It made sense that they were given those gifts for use at the appropriate time according to what Christ called them to do. We are given the gifts as well, for use at the appropriate time according to what God calls us to do. The Apostles were all Charismatic. Jesus promised He wouldn't leave them alone and He sent forth His Spirit. Living a Charismatic life means living a life in the Holy Spirit that Jesus left for us. It is the most traditional way of living. It doesn't mean you have to have all the Charismatic gifts like tongues, words, prophecy, etc. It just means you're open to the Holy Spirit, and are willing to be used by Him for the uplifting of the rest of the body (of the Catholic Church). Many people don't read what the Charismatic renewal really is; its about the Church encounter with the Holy Spirit as described in Sacred Scripture. And when did the Organ (which is a good thing) come into the Church? Later... So Charismatic tradition is older in the Church as compared to the organ, Gregorian chant, etc. Pentecost is key...it was the birthplace of the Catholic Church. Its also been Approved by JP2 and Pope Paul VI, The USCCb etc... So basically charismatic spirituality is a spirituality that simply calls us to be open to the Spirit and His gifts, as those in the upper room at Pentecost. Papal preacher Rev. Raniero Cantalamessa said the Charismatic Renewal “is a grace meant for all the baptized. The external things can be different, but in its essence, it is an experience meant for all the baptized". Cardinal Leo Jozef Suenens said that “to interpret the Renewal as a ‘movement’ among other movements is to misunderstand its nature; it is a movement of the Spirit offered to the entire Church and destined to rejuvenate every face of the Church’s life". Pope John Paul II himself in his first meeting with Catholic charismatics in 1979 said that he had “always belonged to this renewal in the Holy Spirit … I am convinced that this movement is a sign of His action".
zealousrap Posted August 12, 2008 Posted August 12, 2008 Also, one of the most obvious ways of discerning whether a person's spiritual gift is from the Lord is by the fruits that are present in their lives. If a person is truly living a life of virtue and holiness, it's more likely than if they were retreat junkies who got caught up in a crowd and then went back to a life with God in the background. We are called to use our gifts with humility and reverence, discerning at all times why we have them and when we should use them.
fides quarens intellectum Posted August 12, 2008 Posted August 12, 2008 [quote name='zealousrap' post='1624702' date='Aug 11 2008, 07:50 PM']So basically charismatic spirituality is a spirituality that simply calls us to be open to the Spirit and His gifts, as those in the upper room at Pentecost. Papal preacher Rev. Raniero Cantalamessa said the Charismatic Renewal “is a grace meant for all the baptized. The external things can be different, but in its essence, it is an experience meant for all the baptized". Cardinal Leo Jozef Suenens said that “to interpret the Renewal as a ‘movement’ among other movements is to misunderstand its nature; it is a movement of the Spirit offered to the entire Church and destined to rejuvenate every face of the Church’s life". Pope John Paul II himself in his first meeting with Catholic charismatics in 1979 said that he had “always belonged to this renewal in the Holy Spirit … I am convinced that this movement is a sign of His action".[/quote] YES! You brought in Cantalamessa and Suenens!! You - you i like. Where exactly are your Cantalamessa and Suenens quotes from? Thanks so much.
fides quarens intellectum Posted August 12, 2008 Posted August 12, 2008 [quote name='zealousrap' post='1624726' date='Aug 11 2008, 08:05 PM']Also, one of the most obvious ways of discerning whether a person's spiritual gift is from the Lord is by the fruits that are present in their lives. If a person is truly living a life of virtue and holiness, it's more likely than if they were retreat junkies who got caught up in a crowd and then went back to a life with God in the background. We are called to use our gifts with humility and reverence, discerning at all times why we have them and when we should use them.[/quote] Amen, amen. Well said. Like i've said a few times in here - this is why spiritual direction is so important.
zealousrap Posted August 12, 2008 Posted August 12, 2008 [quote name='fides quarens intellectum' post='1624782' date='Aug 11 2008, 09:41 PM']YES! You brought in Cantalamessa and Suenens!! You - you i like. Where exactly are your Cantalamessa and Suenens quotes from? Thanks so much.[/quote] perhaps these 2 links can bring this discussion and thread a lot of help Cantalamessa [url="http://www.ntucsacharismatic.org/articles.php?p=0&id=17"]http://www.ntucsacharismatic.org/articles.php?p=0&id=17[/url] Suenens [url="http://www.ccr.org.uk/crnature.htm"]http://www.ccr.org.uk/crnature.htm[/url]
Maggyie Posted August 12, 2008 Posted August 12, 2008 [quote name='zealousrap' post='1624702' date='Aug 11 2008, 09:50 PM']Papal preacher Rev. Raniero Cantalamessa said the Charismatic Renewal “is a grace meant for all the baptized. The external things can be different, but in its essence, it is an experience meant for all the baptized". Cardinal Leo Jozef Suenens said that “to interpret the Renewal as a ‘movement’ among other movements is to misunderstand its nature; it is a movement of the Spirit offered to the entire Church and destined to rejuvenate every face of the Church’s life".[/quote] But do you see, the above is one reason why some people are very "turned off" by the charismatic renewal. There is this feeling that there is an assumption that if you are not a part of the movement, you are a second-rate Catholic, do not have a relationship with the Holy Spirit, etc. etc. I am sure when Fr. Cantalamessa says it is "meant for all the baptized" he doesn't mean to imply that if you aren't a Charismatic you aren't living your baptism in full, but that is what it sounds like to outsiders. This actually came up in a Fan into Flame retreat I went on, we were reading a passage from Cantalamessa himself and several of the people in my group were very uncomfortable with his formulations. They were actually long-time members of the movement but they weren't happy with how he "put" things. I also think Cardinal Suenens is wrong to say it can not be categorized as a movement. Like all movements the Charismatic Renewal has gone through periods of growth and periods of decline. Currently the movement is graying, for instance.
Deb Posted August 12, 2008 Posted August 12, 2008 [quote name='Maggie' post='1624969' date='Aug 12 2008, 12:52 AM']But do you see, the above is one reason why some people are very "turned off" by the charismatic renewal. There is this feeling that there is an assumption that if you are not a part of the movement, you are a second-rate Catholic, do not have a relationship with the Holy Spirit, etc. etc. I am sure when Fr. Cantalamessa says it is "meant for all the baptized" he doesn't mean to imply that if you aren't a Charismatic you aren't living your baptism in full, but that is what it sounds like to outsiders. This actually came up in a Fan into Flame retreat I went on, we were reading a passage from Cantalamessa himself and several of the people in my group were very uncomfortable with his formulations. They were actually long-time members of the movement but they weren't happy with how he "put" things. I also think Cardinal Suenens is wrong to say it can not be categorized as a movement. Like all movements the Charismatic Renewal has gone through periods of growth and periods of decline. Currently the movement is graying, for instance.[/quote] He is not saying that one has to go to charismatic retreats or charistmatic churches. One has to be open to the Holy Spirit and the gifts of the Holy Spirit. God graces all with gifts. To return them unopened or to not see them because you don't want to believe in them or use them for God's glory does not make you a second class Catholic, just one who is not receiving the fullness of the faith that is there for them. We are all called to spread the word of the Lord and to build up God's kingdom on earth. That is required of us when we are confirmed. That is why we are given the gifts of the spirit, to be used outward for the Church. (see the catechism) If you are not doing this then no, you are not living out your baptism or your confirmation promises. You do not have to be doing anything in a "Charismatic" style, you just have to renew yourself in the Holy Spirit, ask for the grace to know your gifts and to use them. You may think the movement is graying, the reality is so many people have embraced it and our living to the fullness of the faith. They don't have to do it in a flashy manner.
zealousrap Posted August 12, 2008 Posted August 12, 2008 [quote name='Maggie' post='1624969' date='Aug 12 2008, 12:52 AM']But do you see, the above is one reason why some people are very "turned off" by the charismatic renewal. There is this feeling that there is an assumption that if you are not a part of the movement, you are a second-rate Catholic, do not have a relationship with the Holy Spirit, etc. etc. I am sure when Fr. Cantalamessa says it is "meant for all the baptized" he doesn't mean to imply that if you aren't a Charismatic you aren't living your baptism in full, but that is what it sounds like to outsiders. This actually came up in a Fan into Flame retreat I went on, we were reading a passage from Cantalamessa himself and several of the people in my group were very uncomfortable with his formulations. They were actually long-time members of the movement but they weren't happy with how he "put" things. I also think Cardinal Suenens is wrong to say it can not be categorized as a movement. Like all movements the Charismatic Renewal has gone through periods of growth and periods of decline. Currently the movement is graying, for instance.[/quote] I think you missed the point. "Living a Charismatic life means living a life in the Holy Spirit that Jesus left for us. It is the most traditional way of living. It doesn't mean you have to have all the Charismatic gifts like tongues, words, prophecy, etc. It just means you're open to the Holy Spirit, and are willing to be used by Him for the uplifting of the rest of the body (of the Catholic Church)." You don't need to have charismatic gifts to live a charismatic life abandoned to the Holy Spirit. What exactly do you classify as being "part of the movement"? If you disagree with Cardinal Suenens, then whose school of thought do you base this off of? this is from the second link I provided on Suenens: "All of these diverse characteristics in expressions and in leadership are the experience in most countries, and they mark out the Catholic Charismatic Renewal as different from other ecclesial movements. This can be both a strength and a weakness, but it does draw attention to the fact that the Renewal is not man-made and humanly ordered." The Charismatic Renewal is NOT one among many man made movements. The fact that it gone through periods of growth and decline are on us alone. The Holy Spirit hasn't changed. It's the same Holy Spirit that came at Pentacost, and that moved Peter to proclaim to Jesus who He was when no person on earth would have known by human knowledge. It's on us to call upon the Holy Spirit. Eph 5:8, Luke 11:9-15 we have to ask and seek Him out, and that is a call for all of the Church.
Maggyie Posted August 12, 2008 Posted August 12, 2008 Oh no I agree with y'all, I am just pointing out that to people who are not members of the Renewal alot of the things Fr. Cantalamessa/others say come off as somewhat offensive, rather like a member of the traditionalist movement saying that Masses without Latin are inferior. I think the Charismatic Renewal would be classified as a "movement" by any ordinary standard of examination. Within the Catholic Church it has a definable modern start date (the Duquesne Weekend) and it has national organizations dedicated to spreading the word and explaining the renewal to other people. To most people that would probably be called a movement, much like the Liturgical Movement or Cursillo etc. It is absolutely true that everyone is called to be open to the Holy Spirit, but if you are trying to do that are you automatically a "member of the Renewal" even if you have no interest in prayer meetings or healing Masses and quite deliberately do not call yourself Charismatic? This is where the Cardinal and a lot of people part ways, I believe. I think a lot of people would resent being being "gerrymandered" into the group based on the criteria that if you are trying to live your baptismal vows you are participating in the Charismatic Renewal. They would view membership as something more concrete, like going to prayer meetings or conferences. As to the Charismatic Renewal graying that is a fact that has been acknowledged by the Renewal leadership. That does not mean anything bad either. Movements grow only to the extent that God needs them to accomplish His will. Maybe 10 years from now the Renewal will look a lot younger because they will fill a greater need at that time, just as they did 30 years ago. There was an interesting article on this in The Christian Century, which I finally managed to find online, [url="http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1058/is_5_123/ai_n26692927/pg_1?tag=artBody;col1"]http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m105...ag=artBody;col1[/url] although the title says "Charismatic and mainline" it does deal briefly with Catholic and non-mainline experiences with the renewal. The phrase it uses, "rise, fall, and diffusion" is I think an accurate description of what has happened in the Charismatic movement over the years.
fides quarens intellectum Posted August 13, 2008 Posted August 13, 2008 [quote name='Maggie' post='1625403' date='Aug 12 2008, 01:54 PM']Oh no I agree with y'all, I am just pointing out that to people who are not members of the Renewal alot of the things Fr. Cantalamessa/others say come off as somewhat offensive, rather like a member of the traditionalist movement saying that Masses without Latin are inferior. I think the Charismatic Renewal would be classified as a "movement" by any ordinary standard of examination. Within the Catholic Church it has a definable modern start date (the Duquesne Weekend) and it has national organizations dedicated to spreading the word and explaining the renewal to other people. To most people that would probably be called a movement, much like the Liturgical Movement or Cursillo etc. It is absolutely true that everyone is called to be open to the Holy Spirit, but if you are trying to do that are you automatically a "member of the Renewal" even if you have no interest in prayer meetings or healing Masses and quite deliberately do not call yourself Charismatic? This is where the Cardinal and a lot of people part ways, I believe. I think a lot of people would resent being being "gerrymandered" into the group based on the criteria that if you are trying to live your baptismal vows you are participating in the Charismatic Renewal. They would view membership as something more concrete, like going to prayer meetings or conferences. As to the Charismatic Renewal graying that is a fact that has been acknowledged by the Renewal leadership. That does not mean anything bad either. Movements grow only to the extent that God needs them to accomplish His will. Maybe 10 years from now the Renewal will look a lot younger because they will fill a greater need at that time, just as they did 30 years ago. There was an interesting article on this in The Christian Century, which I finally managed to find online, [url="http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1058/is_5_123/ai_n26692927/pg_1?tag=artBody;col1"]http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m105...ag=artBody;col1[/url] although the title says "Charismatic and mainline" it does deal briefly with Catholic and non-mainline experiences with the renewal. The phrase it uses, "rise, fall, and diffusion" is I think an accurate description of what has happened in the Charismatic movement over the years.[/quote] Okay - i read the article - thanks for sharing it. i think i can see some of teh frustrations you are trying to voice. Personally, though, i respectfully disagree with you. i think i've already said i do not consider myself a "Charismatic Catholic," and i do not belong to the CCR. i do love Suenens and Cantalamessa, though, and do not at all feel "offended" by their words - they were calling us to embrace the inheritance we were given in our baptisms - i find that exciting! i've read much more Cantalamessa than Suenens (and have heard Cantalamessa in person), and have never felt he considered other Catholics inferior in any way, nor have i found him to be condescending. But, that's just me. Actually, i sense in him a deep respect for skeptics, which is understandable in light of the fact that he used to be one of them. (Maggie - please know i am not directing the following venting to you - thanks.) i really wish people would stop lumping spiritual gifts/charisms with the "Charismatic movement," like it is some ominous entity or something. Plain and simple, charisms, or spiritual gifts, are for ALL the baptized - they are the means through which the Holy Spirit allows us to humbly work with Him in building up the Church. Again, see CCC #2003. thanks. /end rant.
Deb Posted August 13, 2008 Posted August 13, 2008 [quote name='fides quarens intellectum' post='1625761' date='Aug 12 2008, 10:24 PM']Okay - i read the article - thanks for sharing it. i think i can see some of teh frustrations you are trying to voice. Personally, though, i respectfully disagree with you. i think i've already said i do not consider myself a "Charismatic Catholic," and i do not belong to the CCR. i do love Suenens and Cantalamessa, though, and do not at all feel "offended" by their words - they were calling us to embrace the inheritance we were given in our baptisms - i find that exciting! i've read much more Cantalamessa than Suenens (and have heard Cantalamessa in person), and have never felt he considered other Catholics inferior in any way, nor have i found him to be condescending. But, that's just me. Actually, i sense in him a deep respect for skeptics, which is understandable in light of the fact that he used to be one of them. (Maggie - please know i am not directing the following venting to you - thanks.) i really wish people would stop lumping spiritual gifts/charisms with the "Charismatic movement," like it is some ominous entity or something. Plain and simple, charisms, or spiritual gifts, are for ALL the baptized - they are the means through which the Holy Spirit allows us to humbly work with Him in building up the Church. Again, see CCC #2003. thanks. /end rant.[/quote] Great statement. That is what I was trying to get across. One does not have to belong to any movement or group or special thing to experience or receive or find their spiritual gift or charism. The gift or charism is to be used for the build up of the Church and that goes for all Catholic Churches, not just ones that are labeled Charismatic.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now