Apotheoun Posted August 18, 2008 Posted August 18, 2008 It is important that we not confuse Catholicity with uniformity.
picchick Posted August 18, 2008 Posted August 18, 2008 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1630216' date='Aug 17 2008, 11:18 PM']It is important that we not confuse Catholicity with uniformity.[/quote] Did I do that? I am sorry if I did. I am sorry, can you explain the difference?
Apotheoun Posted August 18, 2008 Posted August 18, 2008 (edited) [quote name='picchick' post='1630220' date='Aug 17 2008, 09:22 PM'] Did I do that? I am sorry if I did.[/quote] No, you didn't do that, but some people want to say that the particular traditions of the Latin Church are universal, and that they should be adopted by all 23 of the Churches that form the one Catholic Church. [quote name='picchick' post='1630220' date='Aug 17 2008, 09:22 PM']I am sorry, can you explain the difference?[/quote] Catholicity (i.e., what is also called "Sobornicity" in the Slavic Eastern Churches) by its very nature implies multiplicity in unity. Therefore, just as the tri-hypostatic God is one and three at the same time; so too the Church is one and many at the same time. Those who advocate uniformity of rites and usages in the Church could in some sense be called "ecclesiological Sabellians." Edited August 18, 2008 by Apotheoun
picchick Posted August 18, 2008 Posted August 18, 2008 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1630226' date='Aug 17 2008, 11:26 PM']Catholicity (i.e., what is also called "Sobornicity" in the Slavic Eastern Churches) by its very nature implies multiplicity in unity. Just as the tri-hypostatic God is one and three at the same time; so too the Church is one and many at the same time.[/quote] Ahhh, ok. Thanks. One thing I really like about the Eastern Divine Liturgy is the fact that we have so many references to Mary. Also, I like how we are constantly giving God praise. I just love it.
Apotheoun Posted August 18, 2008 Posted August 18, 2008 [quote name='picchick' post='1630228' date='Aug 17 2008, 09:28 PM']Ahhh, ok. Thanks. One thing I really like about the Eastern Divine Liturgy is the fact that we have so many references to Mary. Also, I like how we are constantly giving God praise. I just love it.[/quote] Through the prayers of the Theotokos, O Savior save us!
mortify Posted August 18, 2008 Posted August 18, 2008 [quote name='picchick' post='1630210' date='Aug 17 2008, 11:13 PM']Um...In my humble opinion I have seen the exact opposite. I have seen that people in the Latin rite are arrogant and proud. The attitude of the Eastern Catholics in my area is that they are a part of the Church. Not a better part but a part. However, to go along with your last statement, it is the Latin Rite goers who have the holier than thou attitude. Not all but a majority.[/quote] My experience is different. [quote]The Eastern Catholic Church is in communion with the Pope. Eastern ORTHODOX is not.[/quote] No one denied this. [quote]I love every rite of the Church. I think that we NEED to learn about each other. It is necessary. Totally necessary.[/quote] Considering the current situation in the Roman rite, this is not my priority.
mortify Posted August 18, 2008 Posted August 18, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1630226' date='Aug 17 2008, 11:26 PM']No, you didn't do that, but some people want to say that the particular traditions of the Latin Church are universal, and that they should be adopted by all 23 of the Churches that form the one Catholic Church.[/quote] I did not mean to suggest that every particular church should become identical with the Roman rite, just that there is nothing wrong with eastern churches naturally adopting certain Latin customs, or the Roman church trying to establish some uniformity. The East really only need to accept the Dogmatta proclaimed by the Catholic Church. Edited August 18, 2008 by mortify
TeresaBenedicta Posted August 18, 2008 Posted August 18, 2008 [quote name='mortify' post='1630249' date='Aug 17 2008, 11:53 PM']The East really only need to accept the Dogmatta proclaimed by the Catholic Church.[/quote] I'm not sure what dogma's aren't accepted by the East? I mean... they are in union with the Pope....
Nihil Obstat Posted August 18, 2008 Posted August 18, 2008 That thign you posted about icons was amazing! I had no idea... I'm stunned and awed. Literally.
mortify Posted August 18, 2008 Posted August 18, 2008 [quote name='TeresaBenedicta' post='1630256' date='Aug 18 2008, 12:05 AM']I'm not sure what dogma's aren't accepted by the East? I mean... they are in union with the Pope....[/quote] I'm referring to the Orthodox. In particular the Filioque, Papal primacy of jurisdiction, the Immaculate Conception, etc.
picchick Posted August 18, 2008 Posted August 18, 2008 [quote name='mortify' post='1630263' date='Aug 18 2008, 12:08 AM']I'm referring to the Orthodox. In particular the Filioque, Papal primacy of jurisdiction, the Immaculate Conception, etc.[/quote] Oh, ok, it sounded like you were referring to the whole East.
TeresaBenedicta Posted August 18, 2008 Posted August 18, 2008 [quote name='mortify' post='1630263' date='Aug 18 2008, 12:08 AM']I'm referring to the Orthodox. In particular the Filioque, Papal primacy of jurisdiction, the Immaculate Conception, etc.[/quote] Okay. So, I'm confused when you're making statements about 'the East', then. Do you think the Eastern Rites need to accept more Latinization?
mortify Posted August 18, 2008 Posted August 18, 2008 [quote name='TeresaBenedicta' post='1630270' date='Aug 18 2008, 12:14 AM']Okay. So, I'm confused when you're making statements about 'the East', then. Do you think the Eastern Rites need to accept more Latinization?[/quote] Teresa, I just don't find "Latinization" to be a bad thing. There's nothing bad about Eastern Catholics adopting some Latin customs or the Pope wanting to establish *some* uniformity. This doesn't mean that the Eastern rites should accept more Latinization, it's something that should occur naturally unless the Church deems it necessary to initiate on its own accord.
qfnol31 Posted August 18, 2008 Posted August 18, 2008 You have to be careful how far you take such reasoning...Otherwise I could say that too much Greek theology influenced Western Christology and so I can and probably should reject all Eastern Christology because it isn't Latin...
abercius24 Posted August 18, 2008 Posted August 18, 2008 [quote name='mortify' post='1629998' date='Aug 17 2008, 07:24 PM']We have already abandoned most of our traditions, we are more vulnerable than ever. The East is too proud of its ways to ever completely abandon their traditions.[/quote] The threat we face is from the influences of materialism, not the Eastern Rite.
peach_cube Posted August 18, 2008 Posted August 18, 2008 [quote name='mortify' post='1630263' date='Aug 18 2008, 01:08 AM']I'm referring to the Orthodox. In particular the Filioque, Papal primacy of jurisdiction, the Immaculate Conception, etc.[/quote] As I understand it in order for the Eastern churches to accept the Filioque they would have to completely change their understanding of the Trinity. I don't think that is even remotely possible. The Immaculate Conception makes little sense in the framework of Eastern thought, since we are all conceived without the stain of original sin. This is because all sin is a personal choice, not the result of a fallen nature.
abercius24 Posted August 18, 2008 Posted August 18, 2008 (edited) But the real truth is found when you can see how both perspectives are teaching the same thing. That's why the East and West are so valuable -- they are legitimate testimonies of the Deposit of Faith that infallibly teach the SAME Truth. Neither can truly exist without the other. Either both are right, or one is heretical; and we can't truly be in union if one is heretical. But I have found that the Truth that both testify to is MUCH deeper than any theologians had previously considered. And that is where the Great Adventure in studying the Faith really begins! I think this challenge to understand the cohesion between East and West is something the West is ready to begin. I DO NOT believe the East is ready for it, though, given the overwhealming and eroding influence Western tradition is having on the East. The East must FIRST be able to secure its own tradition before it can hope to understand it in light of the West. And frankly, if the East abandons too much of their own tradition, we in the West won't have an Eastern counterpart to study and learn from. And that would be the loss of a great, God-given window into the mysteries of the Faith. Edited August 19, 2008 by abercius24
Norseman82 Posted August 19, 2008 Posted August 19, 2008 [quote name='mortify' post='1630263' date='Aug 18 2008, 12:08 AM']I'm referring to the Orthodox. In particular the Filioque, Papal primacy of jurisdiction, the Immaculate Conception, etc.[/quote] I was at a Byzantine-rite Catholic Divine Liturgy yesterday, and the creed did not contain the Filioque, so that should not be as big a stumbling block for Catholic-Orthodox relations as one might expect.
Winchester Posted August 19, 2008 Posted August 19, 2008 [img]http://cliffordcoonan.dreamhosters.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/03/bjork_07.jpg[/img]
Norseman82 Posted August 19, 2008 Posted August 19, 2008 [quote name='picchick' post='1628379' date='Aug 15 2008, 08:21 PM']I go to an Eastern Mass. I don't think that I will switch jurisdictions but I still love going.[/quote] Where do you go? No, I'm not stalking you, but it would have been funny if we were at the same parish yesterday! Plus, one of my friends has a goal to attend Mass or Divine Liturgy at every one of the rites that exists in the Catholic Church, and I think it has rubbed off on me!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now