Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

That's It I"m Becoming Eastern Catholic


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' post='1631035' date='Aug 18 2008, 06:00 PM']I was at a Byzantine-rite Catholic Divine Liturgy yesterday, and the creed did not contain the Filioque, so that should not be as big a stumbling block for Catholic-Orthodox relations as one might expect.[/quote]
Laudate_Dominum posted on this topic some months ago, and his response summarizes the Eastern Christian position quite nicely:

[size=3][quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1445315' date='Jan 13 2008, 01:43 PM']. . .

The problem with the [i]filioque[/i] doctrine as it is expressed in the Roman creed (as far as Orthodoxy is concerned) is that it implies that the Son is cause [[i]aitia[/i]] or co-cause of the [i]hypostasis[/i] of the Holy Spirit. Latin doctrine puts forth an interpretation of [i]procedere[/i] as [i]ekporeusis[/i] which effectively destroys the [i]monarchia[/i] of the Father and results in an understanding of [i]homoousios[/i] that is essentially Sabellian.

According to Orthodox theology the Holy Spirit can be said to proceed from the Father through/and the Son according to the term [i]proienai[/i] which refers to the (eternal and uncreated) energetic manifestation of the Spirit and/or the sending of the Spirit in the [i]oikonomia[/i].[/quote][/size]

Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' post='1631060' date='Aug 18 2008, 08:10 PM']Where do you go? No, I'm not stalking you, but it would have been funny if we were at the same parish yesterday! Plus, one of my friends has a goal to attend Mass or Divine Liturgy at every one of the rites that exists in the Catholic Church, and I think it has rubbed off on me![/quote]


where did you go?

Nihil Obstat
Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1631320' date='Aug 18 2008, 10:36 PM']Laudate_Dominum posted on this topic some months ago, and his response summarizes the Eastern Christian position quite nicely:

[size=3][/size][/quote]
Good Lord, and there are people that understand that??? :|
I can never be a theologian. :(

Posted

[quote name='picchick' post='1631349' date='Aug 19 2008, 12:32 AM']where did you go?[/quote]

Annunciation Byzantine in Homer Glen - Fr. Tom Loya's parish.

Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' post='1631363' date='Aug 19 2008, 01:03 AM']Annunciation Byzantine in Homer Glen - Fr. Tom Loya's parish.[/quote]


Nope, I didn't go there. I went to a Byzantine near me. :)

Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' post='1631363' date='Aug 19 2008, 01:03 AM']Annunciation Byzantine in Homer Glen - Fr. Tom Loya's parish.[/quote]

Fr. Loya just plain rocks.

By the way, did you run into the Northrups? They're pretty cool, too.

princessgianna
Posted

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1627692' date='Aug 14 2008, 11:01 PM']Sometimes I wish I'd been inducted into the Eastern Church so that I could become a priest and still be married, as I feel a strong call to both positions.
But alas, I'd miss the Latin Rite too much, I think. I don't know, though...you know, I've never attended an Eastern rite mass![/quote]
3 things(cool 3, reminds me of the Holy Trinity)
The Latin Rite is coming back! We recently got the Latin Mass at our parish! I LOVE IT!Though i understand your frustration I am disappointed whenever i have to go to a English Mass cause i just like the Latin mass better.HH Pope Benedict XVI is really encouraging it!

I know a guy who wanted to be married and a priest so he came up with this plan to convert to Protestantism become a minister get married and then convert back and then become a priest! Though then his mom pointed out since he was a baptized Catholic-it would not work!

In St Louis we have a Catholic Married Priest Fr. Lockwood!
Long story short!
He was raised Atheist,converted to Lutheranism and then converted to Catholicism.
He is soo smart though he is totally against priest marrying because while he is an awesome priest, like the family has to sacrifice so much so that he can be a priest. And is that really fair for the family to do that???

I ll pray that when the time is right you figure out what you are called to do whatever it is! :marriage: :shield: :starwars: :priest: :farmer: :ninja:
Pax~

Posted

[quote name='peach_cube' post='1630435' date='Aug 18 2008, 11:04 AM']As I understand it in order for the Eastern churches to accept the Filioque they would have to completely change their understanding of the Trinity. I don't think that is even remotely possible.[/quote]

If this were true Eastern Catholicism could not exist.

The "Filioque" was foreign to most Greeks even though it was used by all Latin Fathers and some Eastern Fathers (St Cyril of Alexandria). The fear among the Greeks, as far as I understand, is that it distorts the monarchy of the Father by supposedly creating a double causation of the Spirit. This isn't what the Church teaches. The Spiration of the Spirit proceeds from the Father and Son as one principle, that is, as one spiration. The Son shares in the Father's spiration only because the Son is from the Father and has received all things from Him (John 16:14-15), thus the Father remains the "font of Divinity" and His "monarchy" is preserved.

The spiration of the Spirit is eternal and obviously not visible, so Scripture indicates it's reality through external signs. In John's Gospel Jesus "breaths on the Apostles the Holy Spirit," and explicitly says, "Receive the Holy Spirit." This verse, among others, reveals that the Son shares in the procession of the Spirit. Based on certain philosophical developments after the schism the Greeks will claim only the "energies" of the Spirit proceed from the Son, not His essence. This type of thinking is foreign to the West which affirms the Absolute Simplicity of God.

[quote]The Immaculate Conception makes little sense in the framework of Eastern thought, since we are all conceived without the stain of original sin. This is because all sin is a personal choice, not the result of a fallen nature.[/quote]

The inherited "stain" of original sin is being born deprived of sanctifying grace and the preternatural gifts possessed by our first parents. It is this absence of something necessary for our eternal end that constitutes the "guilt" or "stain" of original sin. This is why we are all condemned (Romans 5:18) and in need of Redemption. If certain Easterners reject this concept then the West can enrich them with this development as well.

Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' post='1631035' date='Aug 18 2008, 08:00 PM']I was at a Byzantine-rite Catholic Divine Liturgy yesterday, and the creed did not contain the Filioque, so that should not be as big a stumbling block for Catholic-Orthodox relations as one might expect.[/quote]

I personally don't understand it's removal. We should all be reciting the same Creed as it reflects our oneness in Faith.

Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1631031' date='Aug 18 2008, 07:57 PM']But the real truth is found when you can see how both perspectives are teaching the same thing. That's why the East and West are so valuable -- they are legitimate testimonies of the Deposit of Faith that infallibly teach the SAME Truth. Neither can truly exist without the other. Either both are right, or one is heretical; and we can't truly be in union if one is heretical.[/quote]

The Holy Spirit worked throughout Christendom until the various schisms. It does not necessarily mean He totally abandoned the schismatics, but certainly any development of theres after the fact needs to be re examined.

[quote]The East must FIRST be able to secure its own tradition before it can hope to understand it in light of the West. And frankly, if the East abandons too much of their own tradition, we in the West won't have an Eastern counterpart to study and learn from. And that would be the loss of a great, God-given window into the mysteries of the Faith.[/quote]

I just don't understand why people can't see it's the Roman rite that's threatened by a complete loss of its traditions and not the East.

We are in far more need of securing our rite than the East is.

Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1632219' date='Aug 20 2008, 03:56 AM']We are in far more need of securing our rite than the East is.[/quote]
true.

Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1632207' date='Aug 19 2008, 07:47 PM']I personally don't understand it's removal. We should all be reciting the same Creed as it reflects our oneness in Faith.[/quote]
The Eastern Churches (both Catholic and Orthodox) recite the Niceno-Constantinopolitan creed as it was originally written (i.e., without the [i]filioque[/i]), because our theology makes a real distinction between the Spirit's procession ([i]ekporeusis[/i]) of origin as person, which is from the Father alone, and His progression ([i]proienai[/i]) or manifestation ([i]phanerosis[/i]) as energy, which is from the Father through the Son.

Posted

Peace be with you Apotheoun,

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1633179' date='Aug 20 2008, 08:02 PM']The Eastern Churches (both Catholic and Orthodox) recite the Niceno-Constantinopolitan creed as it was originally written (i.e., without the [i]filioque[/i]), because our theology makes a real distinction between the Spirit's procession ([i]ekporeusis[/i]) of origin as person, which is from the Father alone, and His progression ([i]proienai[/i]) or manifestation ([i]phanerosis[/i]) as energy, which is from the Father through the Son.[/quote]

The distinction between God's essence and energies is a post-schism Greek development revolving around the Hesychast controversy. It's foreign to the West and those not influenced by the Greeks. The West condemned the concept in 1148 at the Synod of Rheims.

It seems incomplete to say there are relations between Father and Son, Father and Spirit, but not Spirit and Son. It fractures the essence of God. God is one in essence and there is no absolute distinction between any of the Three Persons, only Their relation to each Other can distinguish Them. The only way we can distinguish the "Spirit of Christ" from the Son of God, is to recognize a relative opposition between the two, and by this I mean the procession of the Spirit from Christ.


But God knows best.

Posted

[quote]Lebanese girls are very attractive[/quote]

Oh, you think so :D (I'm Lebanese, lol)

Posted (edited)

[quote name='mortify' post='1633230' date='Aug 20 2008, 08:43 PM']The distinction between God's essence and energies is a post-schism Greek development revolving around the Hesychast controversy. It's foreign to the West and those not influenced by the Greeks. The West condemned the concept in 1148 at the Synod of Rheims.[/quote]
The essence / energy distinction is made by the Cappadocians, by Clement of Alexandria, by Cyril of Alexandria, by St. Maximos the Confessor, by St. John Damascene, and many others; so it is hardly a "post-schism" development. In fact, anyone who has read the Eastern Fathers knows that the triadological and christological dogmas require this ineffable distinction.

Edited by Apotheoun
Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1633230' date='Aug 20 2008, 08:43 PM']It seems incomplete to say there are relations between Father and Son, Father and Spirit, but not Spirit and Son. It fractures the essence of God. God is one in essence and there is no absolute distinction between any of the Three Persons, only Their relation to each Other can distinguish Them. The only way we can distinguish the "Spirit of Christ" from the Son of God, is to recognize a relative opposition between the two, and by this I mean the procession of the Spirit from Christ.[/quote]
The persons of the Trinity are not reducible to their relations, nor can it be said that there are "relations of opposition" within the Godhead, because God is beyond any form of opposition. God is adiastemic (i.e., beyond any kind of "intervals" or "oppositions"). Pagan philosophy must not be confused with Christian theology.

Posted

[quote name='Selah' post='1633234' date='Aug 20 2008, 10:51 PM']Oh, you think so :D (I'm Lebanese, lol)[/quote]

Ah, Lebnania? mash'allah mash'allah

Posted (edited)

[quote name='mortify' post='1633230' date='Aug 20 2008, 08:43 PM']The only way we can distinguish the "Spirit of Christ" from the Son of God, is to recognize a relative opposition between the two, and by this I mean the procession of the Spirit from Christ.[/quote]
This statement is false, for as St. John Damascene said, ". . . we do [b]not[/b] speak of the Spirit as from the Son: but yet we call Him the Spirit of the Son." That the Holy Spirit is the Spirit of the Son does not mean that He takes His origin from the Son. There is only one cause, one principle of origin within the Godhead, and that is the person of the Father.

Finally, as I have already said, there is absolutely no opposition in God, not between the persons of the Trinity, nor between the persons and the divine essence. Thus, there is no place in Christian theology for the metaphysics of Aristotle.

Edited by Apotheoun
Posted

Peace be with you Apotheoun,

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1633248' date='Aug 20 2008, 11:07 PM']The essence / energy distinction is made by the Cappadocians, by Clement of Alexandria, by Cyril of Alexandria, by St. Maximos the Confessor, by St. John Damascene, and many others; so it is hardly a "post-schism" development. In fact, anyone who has read the Eastern Fathers knows that the triadological and christological dogmas require this ineffable distinction.[/quote]

There is no real distinction between God's Essence and attributes because God is what He has. Scripture notes this when it says "God is Love." Certain Eastern Fathers such as the Cappadocians emphasized the distinction between God's essence and attributes because the heretic Eunomius claimed an immediate cognition of God even in this world. Our finite minds are incapable of comprehending God, so we know Him solely through a multiplicity of concepts revealed through His attributes.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='mortify' post='1633274' date='Aug 20 2008, 09:31 PM']Peace be with you Apotheoun,



There is no real distinction between God's Essence and attributes because God is what He has. Scripture notes this when it says "God is Love." Certain Eastern Fathers such as the Cappadocians emphasized the distinction between God's essence and attributes because the heretic Eunomius claimed an immediate cognition of God even in this world. Our finite minds are incapable of comprehending God, so we know Him solely through a multiplicity of concepts revealed through His attributes.[/quote]
There is a real distinction, without a separation, between God's essence and His energies, and your position is not supported by the Eastern Fathers, because it is a pagan notion adopted from the metaphysics of Aristotle.

Below is a quotation from one of St. Gregory of Nyssa's writings that touches on this topic:


The Divine Nature, whatever It may be in Itself, surpasses every mental concept. For It is altogether inaccessible to reasoning and conjecture, nor has there been found any human faculty capable of perceiving the incomprehensible; for we cannot devise a means of understanding inconceivable things. Therefore, the great Apostle calls His ways unsearchable, meaning by this that the way that leads to knowledge of the Divine Essence is inaccessible to thought. That is to say, none of those who have passed through life before us has made known to the intelligence so much as a trace by which might be known what is above knowledge.

Since such is He whose nature is above every nature, the Invisible and Incomprehensible is seen and apprehended in another manner. Many are the modes of such perception. For it is possible to see Him who has made all things in wisdom by way of inference through the wisdom that appears in the universe. It is the same as with human works of art where, in a way, the mind can perceive the maker of the product that is before it, because he has left on his work the stamp of his art. [i]In this, however, is seen not the nature of the artist, but only his artistic skill which he has left impressed on his handiwork.[/i] Thus also, when we look at the order of creation, we form in our mind an image [i][b]not of the essence[/b], but of the wisdom of Him who has made all things wisely[/i]. And if we consider the cause of our life, that He came to create man not from necessity, but from the free decision of his goodness, we say that we have contemplated God by this way, [i]that we have apprehended his goodness – [b]so again, not his essence[/b], but his goodness[/i]. It is the same with all other things that raised the mind to transcendent goodness, all these we can term apprehensions of God, since each one of these sublime meditations places God within our sight. For power, purity, constancy, freedom from contrariety – all these engrave on the soul the impress of the divine and transcendent mind. Hence it is clear through what has just been said that the Lord speaks the truth when he promises that God will be seen by those who have a pure heart; nor does Paul deceive when he asserts in his letters that no one has seen God, nor can he see him. [i]For he is invisible by nature, [b]but becomes visible in his energies[/b], for he may be contemplated in the things that are referred to him.[/i]

[St. Gregory of Nyssa, [u]Sixth Sermon on the Beatitudes[/u]]

Edited by Apotheoun

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...