dairygirl4u2c Posted September 7, 2008 Posted September 7, 2008 and so when they say 'it's always been taught to be a sin',,,, they're missing hte meat of the issue. it's illustrating that they're not understanding it very well. they shuld be saying "it's currently taught that it's murder and not able to be supported" (and then after that is said,,, all the other stuff can be gotten into,,, ie, about what it means to be ordinary magisterium, andhow teachings like death penalty can evolve (or not), and how and hwne assent is required etc. )
dairygirl4u2c Posted September 7, 2008 Posted September 7, 2008 (edited) i also have some other issues with the CC and it's authority, if you are interested in more. ie, possible contradictions, and other anomalies. i notice that you said in your profile, that you sometimes wonder whether it's true or not, the CC. i don't want to steer you away from it, if it's true,,, so just make sure you get a second opinion. there's plenty of knowledgable folks around here if you want some. i'd been finding myself drifting back to the CC, but i've been drifting more to the idea of orthodox church, or liberal catholic. the idea of a liberal catholic is still knee jerk off to me, and orthodoxy has been instilled as "over there", though i know of the swell orthodox churches locally making me think otherwise, so i guess we will see. i still haven't ruled out being a good obedient catholic. just is looking less and less likely. Edited September 7, 2008 by dairygirl4u2c
littleflower+JMJ Posted September 7, 2008 Posted September 7, 2008 [quote name='eagle_eye222001' post='1649577' date='Sep 6 2008, 11:16 PM']What weaknesses? How does it end? I often find that this issue get horribly misunderstood and therefor is not correctly questioned or scrutinized. On another note, it is good to see the Bishops and Archbishops getting mentioned in the media about questioning Catholic politicians views on important life matters such as abortion. While this confrontation will generate some backlash among these politicians, many non-Catholics, and even some Catholics, it will begin to force those who are in such positions to question why are they Catholic and do they want to be Catholic. We may lose some Catholics this way, however, we will have a stronger church by having members who are truly Catholic and who believe in core Catholic principles and teaching.[/quote] Very true! I agree very much so! I do believe someone (Pope Benedict XVI) stating that the Church will get smaller in size, but stronger in faith because only those truly are faithful to Her teachings will stay through any storm! And it is from there She can truly grow. Welcome to phatmass and I'm glad you found us!
dairygirl4u2c Posted September 7, 2008 Posted September 7, 2008 also this verse from the bible. important, cause catholics like to think that the pope has authority as they claim, when they hear "you are petter" and "whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven". but, in fact, that's a verse that's been applied to everyone, not just peter. Matthew: 15 “If your brother sins, go and show him his fault in private; if he listens to you, you have won your brother. 16 “But if he does not listen to you, take one or two more with you, so that BY THE MOUTH OF TWO OR THREE WITNESSES EVERY FACT MAY BE CONFIRMED. 17 “If he refuses to listen to them, tell it to the church; and if he refuses to listen even to the church, let him be to you as a Gentile and a tax collector. 18 “Truly I say to you, whatever you bind on earth shall have been bound in heaven; and whatever you loose on earth shall have been loosed in heaven.
Norseman82 Posted September 7, 2008 Posted September 7, 2008 (edited) [quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1649891' date='Sep 7 2008, 12:20 PM']also this verse from the bible. important, cause catholics like to think that the pope has authority as they claim, when they hear "you are petter" and "whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven". but, in fact, that's a verse that's been applied to everyone, not just peter. Matthew: 15 “If your brother sins, go and show him his fault in private; if he listens to you, you have won your brother. 16 “But if he does not listen to you, take one or two more with you, so that BY THE MOUTH OF TWO OR THREE WITNESSES EVERY FACT MAY BE CONFIRMED. 17 “If he refuses to listen to them, tell it to the church; and if he refuses to listen even to the church, let him be to you as a Gentile and a tax collector. 18 “Truly I say to you, whatever you bind on earth shall have been bound in heaven; and whatever you loose on earth shall have been loosed in heaven.[/quote] Except that here Jesus did not mention giving the "keys to the kingdom" to everyone in general. Also, did you mean to say "you are better" or "you are Peter"? Edited September 7, 2008 by Norseman82
dairygirl4u2c Posted September 7, 2008 Posted September 7, 2008 not from the bible, but shows how i read it. "What I bind on earth is bound in Heaven, what I free on earth is free in Heaven. Let, then, my dedication be to the eternal, and learn how not to interfere with it and make it slave to time." -cyprian, who says you should be part of the CC,,,, didn't even reconcile to the requests of the then pope, when he got into a disupte, even till his death. catholics say that he was just stubborn. but, if someone who says you must be part of the church, also is willing to defy the pope, maybe "being part of the church" isn't what catholics claim it means. -there were many bishops called "pope" back in the day. the roman bishop wasn't the only one.
princessgianna Posted September 7, 2008 Author Posted September 7, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Norseman82' post='1649900' date='Sep 7 2008, 12:32 PM']Except that here Jesus did not mention giving the "keys to the kingdom" to everyone in general. Also, did you mean to say "you are better" or "you are Peter"?[/quote] though in Isaiah 22 it states[i] 21 I will clothe him with your robe, and gird him with your sash, and give over to him your authority. He shall be a father to the inhabitants of Jerusalem, and to the house of Judah. 22 6 I will place the key of the House of David on his shoulder; [b][i]when he opens, no one shall shut, when he shuts, no one shall open. [/i] [/b] [/i] ~Isaiah 22:21-22 Matthew 16:18-20 [i][i] 18 And so I say to you, you are Peter, and upon this rock I will build my church, 13 and the gates of the netherworld shall not prevail against it. 19 I will give you the keys to the kingdom of heaven. 14 [i]Whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven; and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven." 20[/i][/i][/i] For Christ did not come to abolish the Old but to fulfill the New! And we see Christ give Peter this authority. John 21:15-17 [i]15 When they had finished breakfast, Jesus said to Simon Peter, "Simon, son of John, do you love me more than these?" He said to him, "Yes, Lord, you know that I love you." He said to him, "Feed my lambs." 16 He then said to him a second time, "Simon, son of John, do you love me?" He said to him, "Yes, Lord, you know that I love you." He said to him, "Tend my sheep." 17 He said to him the third time, "Simon, son of John, do you love me?" Peter was distressed that he had said to him a third time, "Do you love me?" and he said to him, "Lord, you know everything; you know that I love you." (Jesus) said to him, "Feed my sheep. [/i] So we see a post-Christ Old Testament prophecy and in the Gospels Christ fulfilling that prophecy! Edited September 7, 2008 by princessgianna
eagle_eye222001 Posted September 7, 2008 Posted September 7, 2008 [quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1649642' date='Sep 7 2008, 12:05 AM']i also have some other issues with the CC and it's authority[/quote] Some interesting notes you have from various people. However, you have next to nothing from the Bible. So I am going to lay the framework for the papacy, by explaining Apostolic succession and the teaching authority of the Church. Before I get to the office of Pope, there are some basic principles that need to be understood. [b]1. Jesus founded one church.[/b] Matthew 16:18 [i]So I now say to you: You are Peter and on this rock I will build my church. And the gates of the underworld can never overpower it. [/i] Jesus starts a "church" and not "churches." It is evident throughout the New Testament that there is one church. [b]2. Jesus established an authoritative church.[/b] John 8:32 [i]you will come to know the truth, and the truth will set you free. [/i] So we need to find the truth. Where do we find the truth? What is the pillar of truth? The Bible? NO! 1 Timothy 3:15 [i]but in case I should be delayed, I want you to know how people ought to behave in God's household -- that is, in the Church of the living God, pillar and support of the truth.[/i] So the Church is the pillar of truth------NOT scripture. Look to the Church for truth. In order to fulfill its role as being the pillar of truth it (the church) needs authority. Matthew 18:15-18 [i]15 'If your brother does something wrong, go and have it out with him alone, between your two selves. If he listens to you, you have won back your brother. 16 If he does not listen, take one or two others along with you: whatever the misdemeanor, the evidence of two or three witnesses is required to sustain the charge. 17 But if he refuses to listen to these, report it to the church; and if he refuses to listen to the church, treat him like a gentile or a tax collector. 18 'In truth I tell you, whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven; whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven.[/i] It does not say to consult scripture to resolve the dispute. It says to go to the church-the final authority. If the person does not listen to the church, then he is caste out (treated as a gentile or tax collector). It has the authority to decide disputes on faith and morals. No, the bind and loose stuff is not going to everyone, it goes to the church. It does not make sense the other way because then it would mean that I could decide that I was right to steal something. And that would be made okay in heaven. It has to be the Church that the "you" refers to. [b]3. The Church is a visible church and one of its characteristics is doctrinal unity in AREAS OF faith and morals[/b] John 17:22-23 [i]I have given them the glory you gave to me, that they may be one as we are one. 23 With me in them and you in me, may they be so perfected in unity that the world will recognize that it was you who sent me and that you have loved them as you have loved me.[/i] Jesus is asking that the Church be as one as he and the Father are one. The unity talked about is not an invisible unity but a visible unity. The church must be a visible unity. 1 Corinthian 1:10 [i]10 Brothers, I urge you, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, not to have factions among yourselves but all to be in agreement in what you profess; so that you are perfectly united in your beliefs and judgments.[/i] Paul is appealing for a tangible unity. A unity to agree on faith and morals and to agree on doctrine. Why is it so important for the Church to have authority? We need an authoritative church so we know what the truth is and we do not have to guess. If the Church does not have authority, then the Bible has no authority as the Church decided on what the Bible would be. As Catholics we believe the Bible is the inerrant word of God in faith and morals. How do we know the Bible comes from God otherwise? How do we know which books should be in it? There is no list in the Bible that says which books should be in and which ones should not. Why is the Book of Thomas not in the Bible? Therefore, because we cannot rely on the Bible, we need another source. What is that source? The Church Jesus set up and in 380 A.D. or so there were councils that decided which books were inspired by God and which ones where not. The Church tells us what the Bible is. How do we know the Bible is true? The church tells us so. Like it or not, that is how you and I and everyone else got the Bible. [b]4. Apostolic authority[/b] The authority comes from God. What type of authority? Apostolic authority given to the apostles by Jesus which was given by the Father. Matthew 28:18-19 [i]18 Jesus came up and spoke to them. He said, 'All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me. 19 Go, therefore, make disciples of all nations; baptize them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, [/i] John 20:21 [i]21 and he said to them again, 'Peace be with you. 'As the Father sent me, so am I sending you.' [/i] Note in Matthew 28:18-19 Jesus is given all authority by God the Father and then Jesus sends the apostles out as the Father has sent him in John 20:21. Luke 10:16 [i]16 'Anyone who listens to you listens to me; anyone who rejects you rejects me, and those who reject me reject the one who sent me.'[/i] Jesus strongly identifies himself with the apostles. What proof do we have that this continues after Jesus goes to heaven? John 14:16-17 [i]16 I shall ask the Father, and he will give you another Paraclete to be with you for ever, 17 the Spirit of truth whom the world can never accept since it neither sees nor knows him; but you know him, because he is with you, he is in you. [/i] The Apostles will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit. John 14:26 [i]26 but the Paraclete, the Holy Spirit, whom the Father will send in my name, will teach you everything and remind you of all I have said to you. [/i] John 16:13 [i] 13 However, when the Spirit of truth comes he will lead you to the complete truth, since he will not be speaking of his own accord, but will say only what he has been told; and he will reveal to you the things to come. [/i] After Jesus ascends into heaven, the holy spirit comes so that the apostles can teach faith and morals without error. A person who is infallible does not mean that they can sin, make a mistake, or teach what they should, it means that God will prevent that person from teaching error in faith and morals. It prevents error from being taught. Acts 8:30-31 [i]30 When Philip ran up, he heard him reading Isaiah the prophet and asked, 'Do you understand what you are reading?' 31 He replied, 'How could I, unless I have someone to guide me?' So he urged Philip to get in and sit by his side. [/i] Scripture plainly says we need a guide to understand scripture correctly and wouldn’t God provide us a means of understanding scripture correctly rather than having us all guess and come up with different interpretations? 1 John 4:6 [i]6 We are from God; whoever recognizes God listens to us; anyone who is not from God refuses to listen to us. This is how we can distinguish the spirit of truth from the spirit of falsehood. [/i] John is saying we can tell who is of God by seeing if they listen to us with us being the church/apostles/successors. 1 Peter 1:12 [i]12 It was revealed to them that it was for your sake and not their own that they were acting as servants delivering the message which has now been announced to you by those who preached to you the gospel through the Holy Spirit sent from heaven.[/i] The apostles preached with the authority of God the Father from what was given to them through Jesus Christ himself and they were aided in using this authority by the Holy Spirit. They taught infallibly. They were not guessing. [b]5. Apostolic Succession.[/b] The Apostles passed the authority given to them by Jesus to others. Matthew 28:19-20 [i]19 Go, therefore, make disciples of all nations; baptize them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, 20 and teach them to observe all the commands I gave you. And look, I am with you always; yes, to the end of time.' [/i] Make disciples of all nations. But they would not make it every nation in their lifetime, so Jesus must have also meant for them to pass their authority to someone else. So they can go out to all nations by Apostolic succession. How could Jesus be with them until the end of the age? They died about 30 years or so after Jesus. But their successors lived and will be alive at the end of time. So Jesus will be with the successors at the end of time. Also note that the Apostles are on a teaching mission. Therefore the mission of the church is teaching. Jesus says nothing about reading scripture and deciding for oneself. 1 Corinthians 12:38. [i]28 And those whom God has appointed in the Church are, first apostles, secondly prophets, thirdly teachers; after them, miraculous powers, then gifts of healing, helpful acts, guidance, various kinds of tongues. [/i] So we still have the Church, and the Apostolic authority from the original 12. Acts 1:15-26 [i]15 One day Peter stood up to speak to the brothers -- there were about a hundred and twenty people in the congregation, 16 'Brothers,' he said, 'the passage of scripture had to be fulfilled in which the Holy Spirit, speaking through David, foretells the fate of Judas, who acted as guide to the men who arrested Jesus- 17 after being one of our number and sharing our ministry. 18 As you know, he bought a plot of land with the money he was paid for his crime. He fell headlong and burst open, and all his entrails poured out. 19 Everybody in Jerusalem heard about it and the plot came to be called "Bloody Acre", in their language Hakeldama. 20 Now in the Book of Psalms it says: Reduce his encampment to ruin and leave his tent unoccupied. And again: Let someone else take over his office. 21 'Out of the men who have been with us the whole time that the Lord Jesus was living with us, 22 from the time when John was baptising until the day when he was taken up from us, one must be appointed to serve with us as a witness to his resurrection.' 23 Having nominated two candidates, Joseph known as Barsabbas, whose surname was Justus, and Matthias, 24 they prayed, 'Lord, you can read everyone's heart; show us therefore which of these two you have chosen 25 to take over this ministry and apostolate, which Judas abandoned to go to his proper place.' 26 They then drew lots for them, and as the lot fell to Matthias, he was listed as one of the twelve apostles. [/i] Peter is the leader here. Note that an office was vacated and Peter states necessity of filling the office (office of bishop). They pray and decide. 1 Timothy 3:1 1 Here is a saying that you can rely on: to want to be a presiding elder is to desire a noble task. Cannot have an vacant office. The vacant office are to be filled. As the church grew, they increased the number of offices. Paul’s letter to Timothy and Titus show Apostolic Succession 1 Timothy 1:18 [i]18 I entrust this charge to you, Timothy, my child, in accordance with the prophetic words once spoken about you. Through them may you fight a good fight.[/i] This language of passing on authority as a father passing authority to his son. A father passing his inheritance. Titus 1:4 [i]4 To Titus, true child of mine in the faith that we share. Grace and peace from God the Father and from Christ Jesus our Savior. [/i] Similar language, same explanation as above. The authority that was passed to Paul is passed to Titus and Timothy. Apostolic succession is alive. 2 Timothy 1:13-14 [i] 13 Keep as your pattern the sound teaching you have heard from me, in the faith and love that are in Christ Jesus. 14 With the help of the Holy Spirit who dwells in us, look after that precious thing given in trust. [/i] Paul was entrusting the truth to Timothy. How authoritative was the passing on? He identifies it with the Holy Spirit. The infallible truth. Remember that the truth that sets you free is from the Church and not scripture. 2 Timothy 2:2 [i]And what you heard from me through many witnesses entrust to faithful people who will have the ability to teach others as well.[/i] Timothy is to appoint others as he himself as been ordained. Jesus did not just leave and let the church fend for itself. He started apostolic succession. We hear 4 generations of this in this passage [i]And what you (Timothy 2) heard from me (Paul 1) through many witnesses entrust to faithful people (3) who will have the ability to teach others (4) as well.[/i] Titus 1:7 [i]The reason I left you behind in Crete was for you to organize everything that still had to be done and appoint elders in every town, in the way that I told you,[/i] What kind of position is he appointing them to? Bishops. 1 Timothy 1:3 [i]3 When I was setting out for Macedonia I urged you to stay on in Ephesus to instruct certain people not to spread wrong teaching [/i] 1 Timothy 4:11-15 [i]11 This is what you are to instruct and teach. 12 Let no one disregard you because you are young, but be an example to all the believers in the way you speak and behave, and in your love, your faith and your purity. 13 Until I arrive, devote yourself to reading to the people, encouraging and teaching. 14 You have in you a spiritual gift which was given to you when the prophets spoke and the body of elders laid their hands on you; do not neglect it. 15 Let this be your care and your occupation, and everyone will be able to see your progress. [/i] Timothy and Titus are being told to command and teach. 2 Timothy 1:6 [i]6 That is why I am reminding you now to fan into a flame the gift of God that you possess through the laying on of my hands. [/i] 1 Timothy 4:14 [i]15 Let this be your care and your occupation, and everyone will be able to see your progress. 16 Be conscientious about what you do and what you teach; persevere in this, and in this way you will save both yourself and those who listen to you. [/i] Both passages above give us the laying on of hands The authority is passed on in a formal ceremony in the laying on of hands which the Catholic Church still does today. They are passing not only teaching, but teaching authority. Apostles not only pass down teaching, but teaching authority. Where did they get authority? From Jesus. “What the Father sent me so I send you” What was sent to Jesus? See Matthew 28:18-20 [i]18 Jesus came up and spoke to them. He said, 'All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me. 19 Go, therefore, make disciples of all nations; baptise them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, 20 and teach them to observe all the commands I gave you. And look, I am with you always; yes, to the end of time.' [/i] I will deal with the Pope in the next post. I know it was slightly long but it is important to lay the framework for the office of Pope as the Catholic Church did not just contrive it out of thin air as many non-Catholics mistakenly believe.
SpareTime Posted September 7, 2008 Posted September 7, 2008 [quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1649617' date='Sep 6 2008, 11:54 PM']also the bottom line with the bishop statement stuff.... is that yes it's always been taught to be a sin. but it hasn't always been taught to be murder, and in fact has been hinted at that it's not. there is a compelling argument, that there's no teachings that it's not murder from the past,,,, and even if this teaching currently, that it is murder, is subject to change, one doens't have any contra authority to follow, and so for this reason is different than the death penalty issue. my main point is just how sad it'd be for those death penalty followers on either side of the issue to feel compelled to take a stand, only to be later told they were wrong. and likewise, how it'd be bad if the current teaching on abortion is murder at all stages could change.[/quote] It was not always taught that it was specifically HOMICIDE, but it has always been taught that it was a mortal sin.
eagle_eye222001 Posted September 7, 2008 Posted September 7, 2008 part 2 So someone did beat me to it slightly. I am still going to finish though with what I have looked up. Matthew 16:16-19 [i]'But you,' he said, 'who do you say I am?' 16 Then Simon Peter spoke up and said, 'You are the Christ, the Son of the living God.' 17 Jesus replied, 'Simon son of Jonah, you are a blessed man! Because it was no human agency that revealed this to you but my Father in heaven. 18 So I now say to you: You are Peter and on this rock I will build my community. And the gates of the underworld can never overpower it. 19 I will give you the keys of the kingdom of Heaven: whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven; whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven.' [/i] Not that the Gates of hell cannot prevail, Why? Because error will not be taught. Jesus would have been speaking in Aramaic, and in Aramaic the translation runs like this "you are keitha, and on this kietha you will build my church" So Jesus gives the keys to Peter. Now keys symbolize power and succession. Keys also show authority over a house. The person who had kings would decide who saw the king and who would not. The key person was like the number 2 guy around the castle. Isaiah 22:15-25 [i]15 The Lord Yahweh Sabaoth says this: Go and find that steward, Shebna, the master of the palace: 16 'What do you own here, who gave you the right for you to hew yourself a tomb here?' He is hewing himself a tomb, is digging a resting-place for himself in the rock. 17 But Yahweh will throw you away, strong as you are, will grasp you in his grip, 18 will screw you up into a ball, a ball thrown into a vast space. There you will die, with your splendid chariots, disgrace to your master's palace! 19 I shall hound you from your office, I shall snatch you from your post 20 and, when that day comes, I shall summon my servant Eliakim son of Hilkiah. 21 I shall dress him in your tunic, I shall put your sash round his waist, I shall invest him with your authority; and he will be a father to the inhabitants of Jerusalem and to the House of Judah. 22 I shall place the key of David's palace on his shoulder; when he opens, no one will close, when he closes, no one will open. 23 I shall drive him like a nail into a firm place; and he will become a throne of glory for his family. 24 'On him will depend all the glory of his family, the descendants and offspring, all the vessels of small capacity too, from cups to pitchers. 25 That day, declares Yahweh Sabaoth, the nail driven into a firm place will give way, will be torn out and fall. And the whole load hanging on it will be lost. For Yahweh has spoken.' [/i] Lord talking to Shebna, he is the holder of the keys of the kings household. Authority is symbolized by key house of David. The Kings #1 man acted on kings behalf and he had the keys. The new David house is the church. Peter is God's #1 guy on earth after Jesus ascends. John 21:15 [i]15 When they had eaten, Jesus said to Simon Peter, 'Simon son of John, do you love me more than these others do?' He answered, 'Yes, Lord, you know I love you.' Jesus said to him, 'Feed my lambs.' [/i] Why is Jesus asking Peter to feed his lambs? Maybe because he will be a shepherd! Read the first half of Apostle Acts of Apostle, Peter starts pretty much everything and gets mentioned tons more than anyone else. Why? Because Jesus put him in charge of the church on earth with his teaching authority. Luke 22:31-32 [i]31 'Simon, Simon! Look, Satan has got his wish to sift you all like wheat; 32 but I have prayed for you, Simon, that your faith may not fail, and once you have recovered, you in your turn must strengthen your brothers.' [/i] The "you" refers to Peter and the Apostles as Satan will want to snuff out the early church apostolic leaders. Why is Jesus talking to Peter? Because he will be in charge when Christ leaves. John 21: 15-17 [i]15 When they had eaten, Jesus said to Simon Peter, 'Simon son of John, do you love me more than these others do?' He answered, 'Yes, Lord, you know I love you.' Jesus said to him, 'Feed my lambs.' 16 A second time he said to him, 'Simon son of John, do you love me?' He replied, 'Yes, Lord, you know I love you.' Jesus said to him, 'Look after my sheep.' 17 Then he said to him a third time, 'Simon son of John, do you love me?' Peter was hurt that he asked him a third time, 'Do you love me?' and said, 'Lord, you know everything; you know I love you.' Jesus said to him, 'Feed my sheep. [/i] Jesus is really stressing this shepherd thing. 2 peter 1:12-15 [i]12 That is why I will always go on recalling the same truths to you, even though you already know them and are firmly fixed in these truths. 13 I am sure it is my duty, as long as I am in this tent, to keep stirring you up with reminders, 14 since I know the time for me to lay aside this tent is coming soon, as our Lord Jesus Christ made clear to me. 15 And I shall take great care that after my own departure you will still have a means to recall these things to mind. [/i] Peter is getting ready to pass on the succession. Pretty much the entire New Testament is about Apostolic Succession and the Church as the teaching authority. Remember that the Bible will not exist until 380 A.D. or so. And what happens in the meantime? Christians do not know what is God-inspired doctrine and what is not. Some Christian areas accept book A and other will not know it exists until 30 years later. With all these disagreements on what is inspired by God and what is not who will decide that? When you are in a group and you encounter a problem or a disagreement, how do you resolve it and how do you know if you resolved it correctly? God did not just pick Jesus up and then dropped the ball on the Apostles on what to do. They had specific instructions on teaching the truth that would set them free. What I find interesting is that all churches (except the real one) have to discount a large portion of the New Testament. They take a book that was put together by the teaching authority of the Catholic Church. The Catholic Church decided that the Bible as it is is inerrant when understood correctly on faith and morals. Now when you have Martin Luther in 1500 or so just take several books out and edit at least one word in Romans.....on what authority does he do that? He does not have infallible teaching. He is fallible just as I am fallible. However, I look to the Church, the pillar of truth on matter of faith and teaching because that is what brought me the faith, the Bible, and Jesus. What does your church do when they need to make a decision on a teaching? On what authority do they make such teaching and is there a leader and can the leader make a mistake? That is the reason why there are so many Christian denominations. They have no teaching authority and it is a free ride on what you want to believe. The problem is that someone is right and someone is wrong. We are not all right. Through the Apostolic authority of the Catholic CHurch, given to us from God the Father to Jesus to Peter and the Apostles to our Pope Benedict XVI and the bishops today. I know this was a lot, however, if you want to understand why the Catholic Church has this teaching authority and why we have a pope with papal infallibility when teaching on matters of faith and morals and when in communion with the church, you need to see the Apostolic Succession from the Gospels through the New Testament.
dairygirl4u2c Posted September 7, 2008 Posted September 7, 2008 the reason i quoted the early church as per infallibility, was because i assumed all would agree that the bible is debatable. early history is also debatable,,, but you'd think if the CC was true, that it'd settle it. it does not, but gives opposite impressions. [quote name='SpareTime' post='1649993' date='Sep 7 2008, 01:39 PM']It was not always taught that it was specifically HOMICIDE, but it has always been taught that it was a mortal sin.[/quote] where do you get mortal sin from? i concede it's always been a sin. just wondering. it was just a sin, whatever type of sin it is doesn't really matter, as long as it's not murder or something that's typically outlawed. we don't go around banning every mortal sin, either.
dairygirl4u2c Posted September 7, 2008 Posted September 7, 2008 peter had a primary role in the bible. he also had a primary role in the early church. this doesn't preclude what the orthodox say "first among equals". note what i said in my last post. as for everything else,,,, i'm not a typical protestant, and i don't assume that the bible is complete or final or even perfect or whatever. but even if i were a typical protestant,,,, it doesn't preclude me from believing hte bible. they can legitimately believe that the church got together to make the book,,, but that that's all the church was infallibly inspired to do. the importance of scipture has always been foundational,,, and so even in the old testament days,,, the leaders didn't have ot be infallible in everything to put together an infallible complialtion. unless you assume they were infallible in the compiling..... and everything else too. that's what would have to be concluded with yoru reasoning. these discussions we are having seem like apologetics and christian debate 101, since i've heard it all. i jsut wanted to let you know of the quotes i have etc cause i realize that it and early church stuff largely goes beyond christian debate 101 (except who wrote the bible seems like christian debate 101). you apparently do not find what i posted compelling enough to dissaude you,,,, or at least enough that you want to respond to it, so there's not much more to be said.
dairygirl4u2c Posted September 7, 2008 Posted September 7, 2008 that's an impressive compilation though, thanks. i especially like that verse about peter taking care to ensure all adhere to the faith after his departure. from his "tent".
SpareTime Posted September 7, 2008 Posted September 7, 2008 [quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1650110' date='Sep 7 2008, 03:20 PM']the reason i quoted the early church as per infallibility, was because i assumed all would agree that the bible is debatable. early history is also debatable,,, but you'd think if the CC was true, that it'd settle it. it does not, but gives opposite impressions. where do you get mortal sin from? i concede it's always been a sin. just wondering. it was just a sin, whatever type of sin it is doesn't really matter, as long as it's not murder or something that's typically outlawed. we don't go around banning every mortal sin, either.[/quote] My professor (who has a doctorate in theology) said that the church never ever ever ever said that abortion was "okay" as Nancy Pelosi implied when she said the church didn't always teach that it was homicide. The CHURCH has always declared that it is a MORTAL SIN to kill a child in the womb. And yeah I do believe that it really matters if a sin is mortal or not.
dairygirl4u2c Posted September 8, 2008 Posted September 8, 2008 where do you get that it was a mortal sin is what i'm asking. i don't think she was implying that they thought it was okay. i think all you should impute to her saying is that it hasn't always been taught ot be murder. i might be wrong,,, but you might be wrong too, in hat she's implying: i tend to give people the benefit of the doubt, and see opponents with their best possible argument.
dairygirl4u2c Posted September 8, 2008 Posted September 8, 2008 also.. remember the dinction i brought up which you did not answer.... namely, that we don't outlaw all mortal sins. so what's your reasoning that if it was a mortal sin, that it translates into something that a polititcian can allow? it's not like she's proactively endorsing the sin, much like other sins aren't proactively endorsed.
eagle_eye222001 Posted September 8, 2008 Posted September 8, 2008 [quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1650120' date='Sep 7 2008, 04:30 PM'][quote]quotepeter had a primary role in the bible. he also had a primary role in the early church. this doesn't preclude what the orthodox say "first among equals". note what i said in my last post.[/quote] as for everything else,,,, i'm not a typical protestant, and i don't assume that the bible is complete or final or even perfect or whatever. [/quote] Say you don't assume the Bible as it is. Then what do you think of the Bible and how do you know which books are God-inspired? Do you guess? Do you just take what you want? How do you know what you are studying is true? [quote]but even if i were a typical protestant,,,, it doesn't preclude me from believing hte bible. they can legitimately believe that the church got together to make the book,,, but that that's all the church was infallibly inspired to do.[/quote] How do you know that was all the church was infallibly inspired to do? [quote]the importance of scipture has always been foundational,,, and so even in the old testament days,,, the leaders didn't have ot be infallible in everything to put together an infallible complialtion.[/quote] Scripture is important, but who decides what scripture is and what it isn't? You say though that the leaders did not have to be infallible to put together an infallible compilation. how could they tell what was infallible and what was not? Why is the Gospel of Thomas not in the Bible? [quote]unless you assume they were infallible in the compiling..... and everything else too. that's what would have to be concluded with yoru reasoning.[/quote] I know that the church leaders who decided on what the Bible was going to be acted infallibly because of something called Apostolic Succession. I have already explained that and backed it up. [quote]these discussions we are having seem like apologetics and christian debate 101, since i've heard it all. i jsut wanted to let you know of the quotes i have etc cause i realize that it and early church stuff largely goes beyond christian debate 101 (except who wrote the bible seems like christian debate 101). you apparently do not find what i posted compelling enough to dissaude you,,,, or at least enough that you want to respond to it, so there's not much more to be said.[/quote] The notes you brought up were interesting, however, you have mere notes from here and here whereas I have nearly exhaustively explained what happens in the New Testament----that Jesus sets up his church along with Apostlolic Sucession, Apostolic Authority etc. I mean, if there is not Apostolic Succession or authority, then what is a large portion of the New Testament about? We have to delete nearly 80% of the New Testament to get rid of this "church" Jesus set up. When Jesus left, did he just say that we were on our own? Did he just ascend the coup leaving no instructions? And then Bible randomly came together, right? Did Jesus say you have Apostolic Authority only to collaborate on what is scripture? Bottom line, if there is not Apostolic Sucession or authority or the one church Jesus set up, then there are a lot of extra words in the New Testament
SpareTime Posted September 9, 2008 Posted September 9, 2008 [quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1650358' date='Sep 7 2008, 09:13 PM']also.. remember the dinction i brought up which you did not answer.... namely, that we don't outlaw all mortal sins. so what's your reasoning that if it was a mortal sin, that it translates into something that a polititcian can allow? it's not like she's proactively endorsing the sin, much like other sins aren't proactively endorsed.[/quote] I didn't mention outlawing sins in my first post because I am not interested in debating that--and you asked me where I heard it was mortal sin so I told you. I just thought it important to correct any misunderstanding that the church hasn't always taught abortion to be wrong. It has always taught abortion is a GRAVE MORAL EVIL. Mortal sin.
dairygirl4u2c Posted September 9, 2008 Posted September 9, 2008 i don't see how you can ay what i provided is just some quotes. you could argue that they're just some men who were wrong, not infallible like hte bible, like i'd imagine you'd argue. but that the CC hadn't taught itself to be definitive for hundreds of years,,, and then adding those quotes, makes the orthodox position the better one. i'd argue what you provided was just some quotes that showed peter had a primary role, that's all. if anything is not definitive, it's what you showed. early history even catholics would claim is where to go for illumination on some things... but that's not the case with papal supremecy. "I know that the church leaders who decided on what the Bible was going to be acted infallibly because of something called Apostolic Succession. I have already explained that and backed it up." i wasn't referring to the early christian church. if you look, i was referring to the old testament church in the statement you responded to with the above quote. how do you know the books they compiled were infallible? they didn't have an infallible church in everything else,,, just how to compile that book. also, asking a rhetorical question "if infallible in one instance, why not more" isn't answering it. it could be just that it's infallible in only one instance,,,, why not? if we took your stance, doesn't that mean the old testament church was infallible in the OT,,,, and in their teachigns too? rhetocial question, as if i'm answering it, though i'm not. not that i answered my question, but it can be argued either way. not that you're saying that it can't be argued either way, but i'm just fyi making the comment. also, if you research the doctrine of extra... nulla, "outside the catholic church,,, no salvation", i think you'll find a contradiction in teaching. not necessarily, once you get into the semantics. but the face value,,,, as you would see on wikipedia if you look up, "extra... nulla",,,, it's apparently a contradiction.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now