Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Archbishop Invites Pelosi To Conversation


Recommended Posts

Posted

You haven't provided substance. You've provided vagaries. And you don't seem to grasp what is required of a work to be considered a teaching of the Church.

I am done, respond how you will.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted (edited)

i acknowledge it a respectable position as yours to think i require more citations in the debate. i aknowledge i could have figured out what your position was, with what you said vaguely, but i failed at that and assumed you were saying things that didn't make sense.

i don't see how my knowledge of a teaching of the church being final as infallible is at issue, at least here on the extra nulla debate, at least not at this time. as per the nancy pelosi debate, i am trying to aknowledge in my writing the nuance required to be a final teaching. (said by pope, to church, with intent to be a teaching of faith and morals... it's really not hard. the penal code for abortion etc i concede probably shouldn't rise to the level of final)
i think you're just hung up that i had been insinuating earlier that the teaching was that abortion was allowed early and that it only was a sin- i acknowledge i was careless then.
since i'm checking my words in the pelosi debate,,, and infallibliltiy and my understanding of it doesn't have anything to do with anything at this time, i htink you're just airing bygones irrelvantly.

i have cited in the extra nulla debate,,,, and the quote about papal power,,, very straight forward words of prominent and important people, not vageries. if you're trying to say it's vague, you're trying to avoid the issues.
if you think i'm taking them out of context, then prove me wrong. if not you, then anyone, i welcome them.

Edited by dairygirl4u2c
Posted (edited)

well, i was just posting that link so you could see it, i didn't expect you to respond to it.
at least i'm not verse slinging a bunch of vague bible passages, thinking that quantity makes up for quality, like a typical protestant does.


[quote]I see what you are attempting to argue, however, the NT makes it very plain that Jesus passes on his teaching authority to the Catholic Church and there is a quote about those who do not follow the teaching on the Catholic Church can be considered to be teaching falsehood (1 Timothy 3:15, John 8:32, John 17:22-23, I would list these but they are already posted and ignored by you). The game plan changes when Jesus comes down. That is why you have the OT and NT.[/quote]

so you didn't even respond to my point.
you just
if the people, Jesus included, followed the OT as infallible before Jesus or the christian church.... how did they know it was infallible? according to you, everything that was said back then must have been infallible by the OT church leaders.

i didn't just post scattered thought. i posted quotes from popes like Gregory, saints like ambrose and augustine and cyprian, and other people who flatly rejected the pope being in anyway a final word beyond a unitive and persuasive sense. you did not follorespond them. (i did post a few scattered thoughts on some things, but that was the exception not the rule, and at any rate, there's plenty for you to respond to that was quality)
it's ironic catholics always appeal to the early church, but when it comes to the whole basis of the your church, you won't even go there.
if you won't go there, how can you say the bible is true cause the CC is true if you can't even prove that it's true with nothing else?
the bible quotes you use are not definitive. you're just doing what protestants do: finding some passages that sort of back up what you say and ignoring the rest.

eg. keys. i provided other passages such as the "if your brother sins against you" text, and you simply choose not to follow my interpretation but your own.
i mean really: you quote john 8 "and ye shall know the truth and the truth shall set ye free". how vague is that, as per proving that the CC is true? it's so argumentative, why do you even bother acting like it's a proof? you're just trying to get into a verse slinging game, which anyone can do. look, i know catholics are not ignorant of the bible, i'm not a protestant that thinks that. i appreciate their knowledge etc. but please, get something that's not so flimsy-- stop acting so much like a typical protestant.

Same goes for John 22 below... how does this prove the CC? it's so vague it's not even funny. it's almost like you post a bunch of verses, just so that you can look like you have an argument. quantify doesn't make up for quality you know.
John: " 22"The (AX)glory which You have given Me I have given to them, that they may be one, just as We are one;
23(AY)I in them and You in Me, that they may be perfected in unity, so that the world may know that (AZ)You sent Me, and (BA)loved them, even as You have loved Me.
24"Father, I desire that (BB)they also, whom You have given Me, (BC)be with Me where I am, so that they may see My (BD)glory which You have given Me, for You loved Me before (BE)the foundation of the world.
25"O (BF)righteous Father, although (BG)the world has not known You, yet I have known You; and these have known that (BH)You sent Me;
26and (BI)I have made Your name known to them, and will make it known, so that (BJ)the love with which You loved Me may be in them, and I in them."

And for the tim quote below. do you really think protestants don't think the church is a pillar of truth? seriously, your verses are just sad the way you're actig they prove anything.
15But if I tarry long, that thou mayest know how thou oughtest to behave thyself in the house of God, which is the church of the living God, the pillar and ground of the truth.



you keep hung up on how anyone knows the bible is true.
i've answered you several times. it all depends on the level of proof you have for the CC. if you can prove it reasonably, then it's not circular reasoning to say that the bible is true bc the CC is true. but you haven't proven it reasonably with the bible, and you're losing hard core with the early church.
as for an alterative to teh CC, that we have it as a one time act of infalliblity through the church, or that we don't know for sure that it's infallible. you never responded to the OT issue above but simply avoided it. the reasoning that made teh OT knowable to Jesus and others before him makes it knowable to christians. it's not "the bible is true bc it says it's true", but that "the bible is true bc the church says it's true" as i said in the sense that it has always been understood.
(plust this is mostly for argument's sake,,, I'd argue personally that the canon isn't ever complete and we never really know,, but just have a good idea what's true from trusting history and the way the early church before the council on the matter, and the council was all the more reason to trust it. but never definitive.)

now,,, i've answered plenty of your quotes. it's your turn to tackle the tough issues, the people i quoted, as i mentioned above. otherwise all you have it "the CC is true because it says it's true and my interpretations of the bible"
catholics always appeal to the early church, it's time to do that now, not just when it's convenient for them.

Edited by dairygirl4u2c
Posted (edited)

i think i showed how ridiculous winchester's position was that wikipeida is bad is. i mean, it's not unreasonable, but it's still ridiculous to expect more than wikipedia.
internet debates are where people get stuff from the random sites and argue it. if it's found to be bad, or baseless, then call the people out on it. wikipedia i don't see as much worse than any random website. (true anyone can edit it, but websites anyone can make and i don't see it wrong anymore than any random website is)
you're fortunate in ths debate only cause you're quoting from the bible--- do you uote from authoritative sources all teh time in internet debates? does anyone here? no. you're just avoiding hte issues.
we're not arging with dissertations, we're on the internet- that i dn't cite wikipedia in a dissertation doesn't have anything to do with this debate.
you're just avoiding the issues.

but regardless,,, here's some quotes from non-wikipedia on that issue:
We declare, say, define, and pronounce that it is absolutely necessary for the salvation of every human creature to be subject to the Roman Pontiff." Pope Boniface VIII, Bull Unam Sanctam 1302
"The most Holy Roman Church firmly believes, professes and preaches that none of those existing outside the Catholic Church, not only pagans, but also Jews and heretics and schismatics, can have a share in life eternal; but that they will go into the "eternal fire which was prepared for the devil and his angels" (Matthew 25:41), unless before death they are joined with Her; and that so important is the unity of this ecclesiastical body that only those remaining within this unity can profit by the sacraments of the Church unto salvation, and they alone can receive an eternal recompense for their fasts, their almsgivings, their other works of Christian piety and the duties of a Christian soldier. No one, let his almsgiving be as great as it may, no one, even if he pour out his blood for the Name of Christ, can be saved, unless he remain within the bosom and the unity of the Catholic Church." Pope Eugene IV Cantate Domino 1441

Fourth Lateran Council "There is but one universal Church of the faithful, outside which no one at all is saved." 1215

and the contradiction:
16 "Those who, through no fault of their own, do not know the Gospel of Christ or his Church, but who nevertheless seek God with a sincere heart, and, moved by grace, try in their actions to do his will as they know it through the dictates of their conscience — those too may achieve eternal salvation" Second Vatican Lumen Gentium

Edited by dairygirl4u2c
Posted (edited)

are you trying to get into more philosohyical arguments about knowing truth, and the basis for it? eg, church, spirit, self etc?

if you want to do that, i'm all game. just don't act like you have some definitive source beyond your own interpretation in the bible.

Edited by dairygirl4u2c
Posted

aquanis, i think it was.... said that he thought an angel would come to inform someone who never heard of the gospel, as away to deal with the harsh rule that all outside the CC are damned. that he'd think that, shows that they taught in a strict sense that rule.

Posted (edited)

so that you don't think i'm providing stattered thoughts:

"[Aquinas] held that, now that the gospel has been promulgated, explicit faith in Christ and partcipation in the sacramental means of salvation are necessary. Those who had heard the gospel but failed to accept it were presumed culpable. As for as those to whom the gospel had not been preached were concerned, Aquinas' opinion appears to have changed over the course of his life. At least for some time, he taught that God would provide in some way, (by an angel, a preacher, or a revelation by inner inspiration) for Thomas seems to have considered the rare case of a person who had heard nothing of Christ. His final treatment of the matter, however, does not mention these possibilities, but points instead to inherited original sin as sufficient reason to justify denial of divine aid to some people. In one particularly strong and historically important formulation, Aquinas even expressed the necessity of belonging to the Church by stating that "being subject to the Roman Pontiff is of necessity for salvation".
The Gift of the Church
Patrick Granfield, Peter C. Phan
(written by a catholic)

if you actually are willing ot debate this issue (hopefully you don't go down in flames on this issue like sparetire did), i have a lot more info scattered in my history here in the archives, and other places i can get for you.

Edited by dairygirl4u2c
Posted (edited)

since cyprian is often pleaded to in the early church, and os you don't think i gave a scattered thought on it:


[quote]The majority of the North African bishops sided with Cyprian; and in the East he had a powerful ally in Firmilian, bishop of Caesarea. But the position of Stephen came to find general acceptance. Stephen in his letters used the claim of superiority of the Roman See over all bishoprics of the Church. To this claim Cyprian answered that the authority of the Roman bishop was coordinate with, not superior to, his own. Stephen broke off communion with Cyprian and Carthage, though perhaps without going as far as a formal excommunication of Cyprian.[/quote]

even if bishops have authority on par with the pope on undefined things,,, the pope is requesting obedience, faith etc on this, and cyprian is refusing.
why should we assume he's just being stubborn to what's obviously true ie the CC?


-i can get you the book quote on cyprianic theory.
-that letter from firmilian which rejected any final papal claims, was to cyprian. i can provide proof if you want. that means they probably were on good terms with each other. that means, if his friend thought final pope as wrong, and cyprian appeared to too,,,, maybe that's the way it was.

again, if the person who claims adherence to the church is necessary, ie cyprian,,, yet this same person refuses to listen to the pope,,, maybe what adherence to the church means, is not what catholics say it means.

(If someone does not hold fast to this unity of Peter, can he imagine that he still holds the faith? If he [should] desert the chair of Peter upon whom the Church was built, can he still be confident that he is in the Church?" (The Unity of the Catholic Church 4; 1st edition [A.D. 251]). Cyprian
-this is the quote etc that i'm referring to. if you look, as i said in my original post to you, at all the quotes at catholic.com, this and the firmilian quotes are the only real ones that might make you think the CC is true.
without them, you can read for hundreds and hundreds, well into 600+ quotes that do not provide a definitive basis in the papacy, beyond a primacy.
supremecy v. primacy

Edited by dairygirl4u2c
Posted (edited)

you might actually have some arguments, as per ordinary v. extraordinary v. other mageristerium arguments, as per whether teh CC contradicted itself, on "extra.. nulla".

apparently, by virtue of the rodinary magisterium, the CC changed its stance on the death penalty etc,,, so maybe that's what occurred here.

the actual papal quotes from the popes on the matters need looked at.

Edited by dairygirl4u2c
Posted

more as per the keys.

as to the isaiah verse that's supposedly preluding to peter, notice that most stop before verse 24, where it's clear the peg is not fixed, and so if it applies to Peter, negates the CC position:


[quote]22 And I will lay the key of the house of David upon his shoulder: and he shall open, and none shall shut: and he shall shut, and none shall open. 23 And I will fasten him as a peg in a sure place, and he shall be for a throne of glory to the house of his father. 24 And they shall hang upon him all the glory of his father's house, divers kinds of vessels, every little vessel, from the vessels of cups even to every instrument of music. 25 In that day, saith the Lord of hosts, shall the peg be removed, that was fastened in the sure place: and it shall be broken and shall fall: and that which hung thereon, shall perish, because the Lord hath spoken it.[/quote]

even if it applied to Peter, that only means Peter was the first one who got the keys. he was the rock, the first to confess faith. the one who in front of the line would open the gate.

since you don't have isaiah, you have only Matthew 16. and i've shown other interpretation in "if your brother sins against you".

Posted (edited)

also, since i have orthodox leaning, i wouldn't rule out John where Jesus gives the power to forgive sins.
as of now, i just take it as the power to spread the gospel, or to hold and close people from yourself, like happened in Maththew 18 "if your brother sins against you" verse.


but even the CC encyclopedia, based on the early church fathers, doesn't say the keys means infallible, but that it means power to forgive sins.

[quote](1) In the Fathers the references to the promise of Matthew 16:19, are of frequent occurrence. Almost invariably the words of Christ are cited in proof of the Church's power to forgive sins. The application is a natural one, for the promise of the keys is immediately followed by the words: "Whatsoever thou shalt bind upon earth", etc.[/quote]
[url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08631b.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08631b.htm[/url]
[quote]It is comparatively seldom that the Fathers, when speaking of the power of the keys, make any reference to the supremacy of St. Peter. When they deal with that question, they ordinarily appeal not to the gift of the keys but to his office as the rock[/quote]

i wouldn't rule that out, but whatever the case, it's not what the CC teaches.

Edited by dairygirl4u2c
Posted

i do not want or you expect you to respond to this. he wrote it kinda weird, so i will get back to it. i want to post it here for archival purposes though.

[quote]Quote:
Revelation 3:7 proves Christ is the one who holds the key of David, not Peter. Isaiah 22 prophesies Christ's coming and his authority rather than Peter's. Matthew 16:18 has nothing to do with either.

As the royal son of David, Christ is the owner of the key of David, but this doesn't mean he can't give it to Peter, as his "prime minister," the keys to his heavenly kingdom.

In the passage to which Revelation 3:7 alludes, Isaiah 22:20-23, Eliakim is made master of the palace, a post roughly equivalent to prime minister. As the king's right-hand man, the master of the palace is given the "key of the House of David."

Keys symbolize authority, so bestowing the key to the House of David upon Eliakim is equivalent to giving him, as the king's duly appointed representative, authority over the kingdom.

Revelation 3:7 speaks of Jesus as "the holder of the key of David." Some argue this means he fulfills the role Eliakim foreshadowed in Isaiah 22:20-23. They claim this excludes a prophetic application of this text to Peter by Christ in Matthew 16:18-19.

There's a problem with this argument. In Isaiah 22 Eliakim is master of the palace--the king isn't. Eliakim possesses the key of the kingdom not as its owner, but as one deputed to oversee the king's affairs. If we apply this to Christ, Then we must conclude he's not the true messianic king, merely his prime minister, the Messiah's chief representative!

Although Jesus is called the "holder of the key of David" in Revelation 3:7, he doesn't hold it as Eliakim did. As the son of David, Jesus is the heir to the throne of his ancestor (Luke 1:32-33). He really is the king, not the master of the king's palace, as was Eliakim. As king, Jesus is free to bestow the keys of his kingdom on whomever he wishes--without losing the authority those keys represent.

It's the Catholic position that this is precisely what Jesus does in Matthew 16:18-19. Peter identifies Jesus as the Messiah, which means, among other things, acknowledging his kingship. Christ then shows his kingly authority by bestowing on Peter something only the king could give--the keys of the kingdom of heaven--thus making Peter the messianic equivalent of Eliakim.
[url="http://www.newadvent.org/library/almanac_thisrock91.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/library/almanac_thisrock91.htm[/url][/quote]

Posted (edited)

[quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1652191' date='Sep 10 2008, 10:10 AM']you might actually have some arguments, as per ordinary v. extraordinary v. other mageristerium arguments, as per whether teh CC contradicted itself, on "extra.. nulla".

apparently, by virtue of the rodinary magisterium, the CC changed its stance on the death penalty etc,,, so maybe that's what occurred here.

the actual papal quotes from the popes on the matters need looked at.[/quote]

or, traditionalist catholics might actually be right in their arguments
i suppose all the consistency arguments i have,,, i've just recently been coming to realize, are what many traditionalists have against the CC...
hmm

Edited by dairygirl4u2c
Posted (edited)

this is just for archival purposes, you do not need to respond to it.
[url="http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-religion/2048575/posts"]http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-religion/2048575/posts[/url]

i incidentally always thought that the CC must've been right on the canon, but given that link, am second guessing it, given what people have said soon after the canon was finalized. i could see both arguments, but would as of now give deference to the protestant canon.


aside from that link, there were two schools of jews who followed different canons. that the churches then separated on the canon, is like the idea that the churches now separated on the canon.
or would you be claiming that the strand of Jesus was the true judaism? (and the pharisees of that strand were infallible?)


note,,, i might have misinterpreted you. when you said "i see what you're saying" as per the OT church, you might have been arguing that that's a decent argument, and might theoretically have merit, but regardless, the CC is true bc of your bible arguments and so my arguments couldn't be appliable necessarily. so essentially it all comes down to your arguments from the bible.
i just wanted to note this in case i misunderstood what i thought was you avoiding the issue.

Edited by dairygirl4u2c
Posted (edited)

look at the idea that abraham received that name after God called him. peter got rock, and abraham got his. that catholics would claim infallibility would be like the leaders after abraham claiming infallibility.

it could be argued either way (catholics would argue start of new era,,,, and then for some reason throw in infallibility too). since it and the bible stuff can go either way, i think that the point is that we should go to the early church, to figure out what was beleived. if you can't make yoru claim beyond a proponderance of hte evidence from there either, you've lost your case.

Edited by dairygirl4u2c
Posted (edited)

[quote]"I follow no leader but Christ and join in communion with none but your blessedness [Pope Damasus I], that is, with the chair of Peter. I know that this is the rock on which the Church has been built. Whoever eats the Lamb outside this house is profane. Anyone who is not in the ark of Noah will perish when the flood prevails" (Letters 15:2 [A.D. 396]).[/quote]

-this has been said to be from the false decretals of the late first millenium. (the same decretals, btw, that supported a lot of aquanis' ideas that the papacy was "supreme")
-if this is true, this takes away yet another source that teh CC can claim in its quasi early list of decently strng quotes at catholic.com
-http://www.newadvent.org/fathers/0835.htm this link doesn't include it that i see. perhaps giving argument that we should be weary of what we read on the internet. though, it's surely bias as it's the catholic encyclopedia.
-i will look into seeing if i can find a good source on it or not
-it's not that strong of a quote anyway, so if i don't find anything, it's not the end of the world. you don't have to respond to this.

Edited by dairygirl4u2c
eagle_eye222001
Posted (edited)

[quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1652160' date='Sep 10 2008, 09:01 AM'][/quote]


[quote]well, i was just posting that link so you could see it, i didn't expect you to respond to it.
at least i'm not verse slinging a bunch of vague bible passages, thinking that quantity makes up for quality, like a typical protestant does.[/quote]

If you did not expect me to view the link then why did you put it up? You were making a point backed by the link and if I was to argue against you I needed to read the link. I read the link, I responded.

I do not think that quantity makes up for quality however your 15 posts in a row seem to suggest you think that quantity will overrun my argument. You have yet to show me how the passages I cited are vague. You claim they are vague. but you offer no other reasonable explanation that would work as well as what I provided. I want to respond, but you keep posting so much that it will take me hours to read through and respond to everything. When I do respond to something you argue I am ignoring something else, which I did not do intentionally but I have a life and responding to spammer-like posts is not productive for you, me, or anyone else.

You have not gone through what I said and offered a compelling counterargument so if you are not going to go through my posts and respond in a debating manner then, then I do not need to waste my time responding to tens of posts that differ in their point and ignore vast amount of past posts that explain it.

If you want to continue to debate in a debating manner, I will continue. However, I do not have 3-4 hours a day to repeat what I have already said or respond to all the possible attacks on Catholicism. Please state your counterpoint or counterargument, with evidence and I will do my best to respond in a timely manner.

Edited by eagle_eye222001
Posted (edited)

there is no hurry. you can take as much time as you need.


[quote]When I do respond to something you argue I am ignoring something else, which I did not do intentionally but I have a life and responding to spammer-like posts is not productive for you, me, or anyone else.

You have not gone through what I said and offered a compelling counterargument so if you are not going to go through my posts and respond in a debating manner then, then I do not need to waste my time responding to tens of posts that differ in their point and ignore vast amount of past posts that explain it.[/quote]

apparently we think we're doing the same thing to each other.

length,,, you block texted and give super long walls of text (and you accuse me of block texting, and the many posts)

quality,,,, "the truth shall set you free",,,, why do you post these sorts of verses? most of your whole list of initial posting to me was just as bad.

your length and quality is just like you see protestants do with long lists of questionable quotes. the keys verse is decent, those types.

i think what i post for your reponse is quality. if you simply dismiss it based on it not being infallible,,, what exactly is your basis in the early church? just that the bishop of rome was considered a leader?

i don't know what i'm not responding to to you. things i don't respond to are things that appear to me to be "the truth shall set you free" type verses.

there may just be ultimatley a difference of opinion, and if that's the case, there's not much mroe to be said. i always find it odd most arguments can't be ended with people defining where the disagreements are etc. i think because it's jsut practically difficult to convey thoughts many times. so if we did that, it'd be cool. if not, we can just agree to disagree.

Edited by dairygirl4u2c
Posted (edited)

if you don't think my responses so far are adequate, i think what you may be wanting is more philsophical talk.

how can the church be a "pillar of truth", if there's many different churches? etc. philosophically, there's a lot to be said about it.
but that you'd assume that protestants don't believe that or don't have some arugment for it is ridiculous. that you'd even post that is just a waste of time. the philoosphy behind the fundamental catholic/protestant disagreements might be fun and informative to discuss more though if that's what you're getting at.

i mean, maybe it's not a waste of time in that you're adding extra icing to your cake so to speak. but you shouldn't expect me to respond to those types of quotes.

Edited by dairygirl4u2c
Posted

[url="http://www.nationmaster.com/encyclopedia/Pope-Damasus"]http://www.nationmaster.com/encyclopedia/Pope-Damasus[/url]

as to the earlier mention of the jerome quote, this says it was false, from the false decretals. it looks like an authoritative encylopedia, sort of. but then again, sort of not. so i don't know.
(if wonder if just a portion of it was surely false, and the rest of it is simply clouded and disputed, or something)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...